New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

it's time to close GITMO

JuliefromOhio

President
Supporting Member
actually, it's past time. when Pres Obama first issued the order to close Gitmo, repubs and dems alike got all wobbly and stopped him from proceeding with the plan.

there's no reason to be afraid to close GITMO and bring the detainees stateside.

"The original premise for opening GTMO – that detainees would not be able to challenge their detention – was found unconstitutional five years ago. In the meantime, GTMO has become a symbol around the world for an America that flouts the rule of law. Our allies won’t cooperate with us if they think a terrorist will end up at GTMO. During a time of budget cuts, we spend $150 million each year to imprison 166 people –almost $1 million per prisoner. And the Department of Defense estimates that we must spend another $200 million to keep GTMO open at a time when we are cutting investments in education and research here at home." --- Pres Obama
 
I agree, and it should have never been open in the first place...

What I disagree is bringing them to the states... Unless they were caught here or are U.S. citizens then no they should not be brought here...

They should have been kept in the country they were caught like Afghanistan and put on trial there...

Just my opinion and I do not blame Obama for what Bush did but Obama need to close GITMO...
 
I agree, and it should have never been open in the first place...

What I disagree is bringing them to the states... Unless they were caught here or are U.S. citizens then no they should not be brought here...

They should have been kept in the country they were caught like Afghanistan and put on trial there...

Just my opinion and I do not blame Obama for what Bush did but Obama need to close GITMO...

Pres Obama can't close Gitmo until congress agrees. it's cheaper to bring the detainees stateside and confine them in our prisons till they are adjudicated.

contact your senators and congressman and ask them to cooperate.

thanks for replying.
 
Pres Obama can't close Gitmo until congress agrees. it's cheaper to bring the detainees stateside and confine them in our prisons till they are adjudicated.

contact your senators and congressman and ask them to cooperate.

thanks for replying.

probably room for them in Ohio. I missed the hedge in Obama's statement when he told the world that he'd close Guantanemo 'if he could convince congress'.

Glad to see all this courtesy being extended to foreigners with whom we're at war that ignore all conventions - Geneva and otherwise.

If only the Tea Party could be treated with the same respect by leftists
 
It they're not U.S. citizens they have no business here and should return back to their country of origin...

Why would you bring enemy combatants to our soil when they have no business here???

I would agree if they attacked the U.S., were caught here within our borders, and then you have a case but not if they were caught in Afghanistan...

A Terroristic rebel has no purpose here and keeping them in a Prison within our borders is STUPID!!!

So contact Obama and tell him to keep the U.S. citizens enemy combatants and the rest should be sent back to their pathetic shit can dwelling hell hole they call a country...

Thank you for responding...
 
actually, it's past time. when Pres Obama first issued the order to close Gitmo, repubs and dems alike got all wobbly and stopped him from proceeding with the plan.

there's no reason to be afraid to close GITMO and bring the detainees stateside.

"The original premise for opening GTMO – that detainees would not be able to challenge their detention – was found unconstitutional five years ago. In the meantime, GTMO has become a symbol around the world for an America that flouts the rule of law. Our allies won’t cooperate with us if they think a terrorist will end up at GTMO. During a time of budget cuts, we spend $150 million each year to imprison 166 people –almost $1 million per prisoner. And the Department of Defense estimates that we must spend another $200 million to keep GTMO open at a time when we are cutting investments in education and research here at home." --- Pres Obama

not that I don't trust every syllable out of this president's mouth but could you link to this statement and specifically his claim that "that detainees would not be able to challenge their detention – was found unconstitutional five years ago. "

and I have to ask, could you not be comfortable with foreign enemy combatants being held indefinitely outside America's borders? what sense of constitutional patriotism is riled within you that I'm guessing might not also apply to, for instance, the Justice Department's violation of a Fox News reporters 1st amendment protections?
 
It they're not U.S. citizens they have no business here and should return back to their country of origin...

Why would you bring enemy combatants to our soil when they have no business here???

I would agree if they attacked the U.S., were caught here within our borders, and then you have a case but not if they were caught in Afghanistan...

A Terroristic rebel has no purpose here and keeping them in a Prison within our borders is STUPID!!!

So contact Obama and tell him to keep the U.S. citizens enemy combatants and the rest should be sent back to their pathetic shit can dwelling hell hole they call a country...

Thank you for responding...

congress won't let Pres Obama release the detainees to their home countries. DUH.
 
ah, now I understand your replies.

tea partiers are generally uninformed. as your replies indicate, you don't understand the separation of powers, nor have you paid attention to Supreme Court rulings during the Bush years on the Gitmo detainees.

get yourself up to speed.
 
ah, now I understand your replies.

tea partiers are generally uninformed. as your replies indicate, you don't understand the separation of powers, nor have you paid attention to Supreme Court rulings during the Bush years on the Gitmo detainees.

get yourself up to speed.

'tea partiers are generally uninformed'

you conducted / financed your own study or this is based on the soundness of the balance of the hyper-partisan rantings of yours that seem typical, given the sample I've had the pleasure of reading?

Maybe what you mean is that they're not suitably indoctrinated... but I don't want to put words in your mouth.

you must be referring to specific content in my head full of ignorance. you refer to 'supreme court rulings during the Bush years on Gitmo detainees'.

since there might have been two (rulings), can you do me the courtesy of citing the one in particular that supports your point. assuming you have one in your head that wasn't evident in your post.

and please be quick so I can 'get myself up to speed'
 
I'd vote for letting them go in Cuba, then closing the prison. They could shove them out the gate and shoot them if they tried to get back in.

actually, it's past time. when Pres Obama first issued the order to close Gitmo, repubs and dems alike got all wobbly and stopped him from proceeding with the plan.

there's no reason to be afraid to close GITMO and bring the detainees stateside.

"The original premise for opening GTMO – that detainees would not be able to challenge their detention – was found unconstitutional five years ago. In the meantime, GTMO has become a symbol around the world for an America that flouts the rule of law. Our allies won’t cooperate with us if they think a terrorist will end up at GTMO. During a time of budget cuts, we spend $150 million each year to imprison 166 people –almost $1 million per prisoner. And the Department of Defense estimates that we must spend another $200 million to keep GTMO open at a time when we are cutting investments in education and research here at home." --- Pres Obama
 
Yes Julie, and I am sure you want them brought here because Obama said so...

Why not release them to Cuba just for payback???
 
'tea partiers are generally uninformed'

you conducted / financed your own study or this is based on the soundness of the balance of the hyper-partisan rantings of yours that seem typical, given the sample I've had the pleasure of reading?

Maybe what you mean is that they're not suitably indoctrinated... but I don't want to put words in your mouth.

you must be referring to specific content in my head full of ignorance. you refer to 'supreme court rulings during the Bush years on Gitmo detainees'.

since there might have been two (rulings), can you do me the courtesy of citing the one in particular that supports your point. assuming you have one in your head that wasn't evident in your post.

and please be quick so I can 'get myself up to speed'

yes, 'tea partiers are generally uninformed.' that's obvious from your reply.

you're asking ME to tell YOU about the "Supreme Court rulings during the Bush years on Gitmo detainees".........supports my claim.

if you were informed, you wouldn't need to ask.
 
Obama's very first act as president was signing an executive order closing GITMO by the end of '09.

of course '09 came and went as well as 10,11,12.

What happened?
 
Obama's very first act as president was signing an executive order closing GITMO by the end of '09.

of course '09 came and went as well as 10,11,12.

What happened?

People like you happened.

The GOP latched on to the closing of GITMO and used it to launch yet another fear mongering anti muslim campaign. Fox Noise and the AM radio screamers had terrorists under everyone's bed.

The GOP Congress refused to close it.

For any right winger to complain about Obama not closing Gitmo yet is abject hypocricy.
 
Back
Top