New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

it's time to close GITMO

I Think Something Has To Be Done BUT

This is from the very end of 2011


CNN World









Editor's Note: Carol Rosenberg is a reporter for The Miami Herald who covers the U.S. Navy base at Guantánamo Bay, Cuba.

By Carol Rosenberg, Foreign Affairs

The last two prisoners to leave the U.S. detention center at Guantánamo Bay were dead. On February 1, Awal Gul, a 48-year-old Afghan, collapsed in the shower and died of an apparent heart attack after working out on an exercise machine. Then, at dawn one morning in May, Haji Nassim, a 37-year-old man also from Afghanistan, was found hanging from bed linen in a prison camp recreation yard.

In both cases, the Pentagon conducted swift autopsies and the U.S. military sent the bodies back to Afghanistan for traditional Muslim burials. These voyages were something the Pentagon had not planned for either man: each was an "indefinite detainee," categorized by the Obama administration's 2009 Guantánamo Review Task Force as someone against whom the United States had no evidence to convict of a war crime but had concluded was too dangerous to let go. Today, this category of detainees makes up 46 of the last 171 captives held at Guantánamo. The only guaranteed route out of Guantánamo these days for a detainee, it seems, is in a body bag.

The responsibility lies not so much with the White House but with Congress, which has thwarted President Barack Obama's plans to close the detention center, which the Bush administration opened on January 11, 2002 with 20 captives.

Congress has used its spending oversight authority both to forbid the White House from financing trials of Guantánamo captives on U.S. soil and to block the acquisition of a state prison in Illinois to hold captives currently held in Cuba who would not be put on trial - a sort of Guantánamo North. The current defense bill now before Congress not only reinforces these restrictions but moves to mandate military detention for most future al Qaeda cases unless the president signs a waiver. The White House withdrew a veto threat on the eve of likely passage Wednesday, saying the latest language gives the executive enough wiggle room to avoid military custody.

On paper, at least, the Obama administration would be set to release almost half the current captives at Guantánamo. The 2009 Task Force Review concluded that about 80 of the 171 detainees now held at Guantánamo could be let go if their home country was stable enough to help resettle them or if a foreign country could safely give them a new start.

How Pakistan Negotiates With the United States: Riding the Roller Coaster

But Congress has made it nearly impossible to transfer captives elsewhere. Legislation passed since Obama took office has created a series of roadblocks that mean that only a federal court order or a national security waiver issued by Secretary of Defense Leon Panetta could trump Congress and permit the release of a detainee to another country.

Neither is likely: U.S. District Court judges are not ruling in favor of captives in the dozens of unlawful detention suits winding their way from Cuba to the federal court in Washington. And on the occasions when those judges have ruled for detainees, the U.S. Court of Appeals has consistently overruled them in an ever-widening definition of who can be held as an affiliate of al Qaeda or the Taliban.

Meanwhile, Defense Department General Counsel Jeh Johnson, the Pentagon's top lawyer, believes that Congress crafted the transfer waivers a year ago in such a way that Panetta (and Robert Gates before him) would be ill-advised to sign them. (In essence, the Secretary of Defense is supposed to guarantee that the detainee would never in the future engage in violence against any American citizen or U.S. interest.)

A Shift in the Afghanistan Strategy

In a strange twist of history, Congress, through its control of government funds, is now imposing curbs on the very executive powers that the Bush administration invoked to establish the camps at Guantánamo in the first place. Much of its intransigence is driven by the politics of fear: what if, for example, a captive is acquitted in a civilian trial because the judge bars evidence obtained by the military without benefit of counsel? When will another freed Guantánamo detainee attack a U.S. target or interest, such as when Abdullah al Ajami, who was transferred to Kuwait in 2005, blew himself up in a truck bomb attack in Iraq in 2008?

In the face of such public and political pressure - especially from Congress - Obama administration officials have waffled at several key moments. For example, Holder changed his mind on where to try five alleged 9/11 plotters at Guantánamo, including Khalid Sheikh Mohammed. In November 2009, Holder announced that the trial would be held in a civilian courtroom in Manhattan; then, in April 2011, following strong resistance from congressional representatives and New York politicians, the White House abandoned this plan and instead announced that Pentagon prosecutors would bring a trial by military commission.

Resettling in the United States those captives cleared for release has also become taboo. Soon after taking over in 2009, the Obama administration was considering resettling Guantánamo captives from China's Uighur Muslim minority, whom the Bush administration had readied for release. (They were to be hosted by Uighur-Americans in Virginia.) But then, in the face of congressional objections, the White House lost its nerve. The United States instead scattered the Uighurs to Bermuda, Switzerland, and even the Pacific island nation of Palau; five more Uighurs remain at Guantánamo.

Vladimir Putin's Cyber Warriors

Factors besides Congress also contributed to the current Guantánamo stalemate. First, the Defense Intelligence Agency concluded that at least a fourth of the detainees the United States has released from Guantánamo were confirmed or suspected of later engaging in terrorism or insurgent activity. Opponents of closing Guantánamo immediately seized on these figures. (For its part, the Obama administration noted that most of those on the recidivist list were transferred before Obama took office, when the Bush-era Pentagon approved some 500 releases. Officials took fault with these big-batch transfers and claimed that the Obama administration's individually fashioned, case-by-case system for release would yield better results.)

Second, over the past couple years a powerful al Qaeda offshoot has taken hold in Yemen, the very country where the Obama administration had planned to transfer many detainees. Sending dozens of suspected terrorists back to a country besieged by a growing terrorist threat is hardly good politics or security policy.{end quote}

Our security is greatly at risk and if someone here can solve this complicated question I would surely like to hear it. It surely is a disgrace.
 
I'm curious. Do Americans believe in justice as a universal and inalienable right (moral value) for all human beings or just a special few?

I'm also curious as to why foreign terrorists are somehow more dangerous than people like Timothy McVeigh, an American who thought he was justified in killing 168 and wounded over 600 of his fellow Americans, including small children, in an act of revenge for a wrong he thought should be taken up outside the law. Since 9/11/2013 how many Americans have been killed by foreign terrorists? In that same period, how many Americans have killed other Americans?

We might not see ourselves, but those who are not Americans and we ask to trust us and believe in our interest in justice, don't see us through our sometimes vain and self-interested eyes. If one is to lead or be a leader in the world, one must have strong credibilty. Saying or claiming one thing and doing the opposite, does not provide credibilty or trust. Claiming an interest in justice, then holding people against their will without a chance to prove their innocence or have their guilt proven, does not add to our credibilty or proof we have an interest in justice, it takes away from it.

Some people keep claiming that others should be more accountable for their actions, yet when it comes to being accountable for picking people out of their own nation and whisking them off to secret or non-secret detention and holding them for a decade without a chance to seek justice for themselves and denying them that right (if we believe in it, the same way we would like Americans to be treated by any others in the world), the same people that are all about personal responsibility and accountability, want to wash their hands of such when it comes to GITMO and actually living according to what they claim is of ultimate importance to them, while denying the same for others.
 
How often we do this and only look at our side of the story.

This is a mess we never should have been in and with the state of the world right now, I do think Obama has an obligation to protect all of us.
 
Hi there lilly!
Yes, security is greatly at risk, but ironically perhaps as much or more because while we seemed to have no hesitation to pick people up and whisk them away from wherever we took them from, we have refused to accord them the very basic values we hold dear for human beings, that of justice and a chance to be proven guilty of something or let go for lack of evidence of their guilt. I find it interesting to hear all the assumptions of guilt about people who have not yet had a chance to have their guilt proven, even after years and years. If Americans were similarly held, they would be and have been called hostages to evil empires and terrorists, yet when we do it, we seem to feel we can give ourselves a pass and no one will notice or try to do anything about it.

The irony is, GITMO feeds the fires of our hypocrisy and those calling us on our acting according to our own values. Once again, it's like a law enforcement officer puffing on a cigarette in a no smoking zone while issuing a violation to someone for smoking in a non-smoking zone, then when confronted, totally ignoring it or acting as if there is nothing out of place or even absurd about it, whatsoever.

Hope you're having a great weekend!
 
Hi Knot, I remember your mention of the 'Do Unto Others' quote that we saw on a ruler in our childhood and it still stands true. So we have our security and no respect what kind of a nation does that make us.

Yep, I can find every excuse in the book but it still comes down to this. Like I said before it is a disgrace.
 
How often we do this and only look at our side of the story.

This is a mess we never should have been in and with the state of the world right now, I do think Obama has an obligation to protect all of us.

I would be interested to know just how much power the President has without Congressional approval to do anything about GITMO, but to do what he has done and continually point out how this reflects on our nation and adds, not reduces our risk of danger to our security, simpoly because it gives fodder to those who point to our hypocrisy.

Mr. Obama does not get a free pass with regard to the use of drones, but there is room for discussion there regarding the dilemma or conundrum of the issue of lowering the risk of loss and injury of American service men and women's lives and the use of technology that surely would terrorize Americans as much as anyone else were drones to be used over America, whether by some foreign enemy or the U.S. government, even as a means to go after suspected criminals, but where innocent people become "collateral" victims. Then there is that tricky question of where allowances for war and a need for justice and proof of some level of guilt begin and end.

Our interest in justice is all about protecting innocent people from being falsely accused and then judged and sentenced to some fate, especially when it is death, without their having a chance to defend their actions or having their actions proven to be worthy of their judgment and sentencing. In otherwords, where would such an atmosphere stop? Could anyone of us call in a drone strike on a neighbor down the street because we either have a beef with them or we saw them doing something we thought looked illegal, even if we weren't sure about it?
 
what should be done about Gitmo, Knot?

same question for lilly.

Be accountable for what we did. Bring the detainees here for trial or let them go. It cannot be any worse than holding them for another 5 or 10 years in limbo and at least it will send the message that at least some Americans recognize the injustice and our hypocrisy and want to do something to make amends for it and live up to our claims of what we stand for?

What would you suggest? Delaying closure on the whole sorry affair longer? If people begin to die in GITMO because of our delay in living up to our beliefs about justice and being accountable for our own actions, what do people believe that will do to our security? I am most certain it will not improve it, nor increase trust or belief in the U.S. as a champion of justice and freedom and likely those that die will become martyrs of sorts and held up for a long time as reminders of the mess GITMO has become for our credibility and interest in justice and living up to our beliefs.
 
Hi Knot, I remember your mention of the 'Do Unto Others' quote that we saw on a ruler in our childhood and it still stands true. So we have our security and no respect what kind of a nation does that make us.

Yep, I can find every excuse in the book but it still comes down to this. Like I said before it is a disgrace.

It sure is not helping to keep us safer or offering proof of our claimed interest in "justice for all".
 
I would be interested to know just how much power the President has without Congressional approval to do anything about GITMO, but to do what he has done and continually point out how this reflects on our nation and adds, not reduces our risk of danger to our security, simpoly because it gives fodder to those who point to our hypocrisy.

Mr. Obama does not get a free pass with regard to the use of drones, but there is room for discussion there regarding the dilemma or conundrum of the issue of lowering the risk of loss and injury of American service men and women's lives and the use of technology that surely would terrorize Americans as much as anyone else were drones to be used over America, whether by some foreign enemy or the U.S. government, even as a means to go after suspected criminals, but where innocent people become "collateral" victims. Then there is that tricky question of where allowances for war and a need for justice and proof of some level of guilt begin and end.

Our interest in justice is all about protecting innocent people from being falsely accused and then judged and sentenced to some fate, especially when it is death, without their having a chance to defend their actions or having their actions proven to be worthy of their judgment and sentencing. In otherwords, where would such an atmosphere stop? Could anyone of us call in a drone strike on a neighbor down the street because we either have a beef with them or we saw them doing something we thought looked illegal, even if we weren't sure about it?

As far as the first paragraph, I agree. But on the second I do not. If in protecting our soldiers we can take on any kind of warfare then we are right back at the 'Do unto Me' quote.
 
Be accountable for what we did. Bring the detainees here for trial or let them go. It cannot be any worse than holding them for another 5 or 10 years in limbo and at least it will send the message that at least some Americans recognize the injustice and our hypocrisy and want to do something to make amends for it and live up to our claims of what we stand for?

What would you suggest? Delaying closure on the whole sorry affair longer? If people begin to die in GITMO because of our delay in living up to our beliefs about justice and being accountable for our own actions, what do people believe that will do to our security? I am most certain it will not improve it, nor increase trust or belief in the U.S. as a champion of justice and freedom and likely those that die will become martyrs of sorts and held up for a long time as reminders of the mess GITMO has become for our credibility and interest in justice and living up to our beliefs.

Yes we really do have to man up.
 
I'll leave that up to Knot but I would say first steps have to be taken.

I'm for closing Gitmo immediately and bringing the detainees to the states as a first step.

what say you?

of course, we'll have to pressure congress to allow this to happen.
 
Be accountable for what we did. Bring the detainees here for trial or let them go. It cannot be any worse than holding them for another 5 or 10 years in limbo and at least it will send the message that at least some Americans recognize the injustice and our hypocrisy and want to do something to make amends for it and live up to our claims of what we stand for?

What would you suggest? Delaying closure on the whole sorry affair longer? If people begin to die in GITMO because of our delay in living up to our beliefs about justice and being accountable for our own actions, what do people believe that will do to our security? I am most certain it will not improve it, nor increase trust or belief in the U.S. as a champion of justice and freedom and likely those that die will become martyrs of sorts and held up for a long time as reminders of the mess GITMO has become for our credibility and interest in justice and living up to our beliefs.

I've stated my position throughout this thread.
 
As far as the first paragraph, I agree. But on the second I do not. If in protecting our soldiers we can take on any kind of warfare then we are right back at the 'Do unto Me' quote.

Actually I don't disagree with you lilly. War presents conundrums and dilemmas and it is why, just as in cases for individuals, some serious thought needs to be undertaken before entering into war and the differences between "war" with other nations and "war" against "groups" which have no specific national interest or accommodation for diplomacy or negotiation, but have simply decided to take "justice" into their own hands.

A "war on terror" seems more closely matched with a "war against crime" or a "war against organized crime" or some specific organized crime group. How does a nation prosecute a "war" on what amount to great crimes, but not necessarily conventional wars against people who represent a nation? We don't think of men and women in uniform as criminals, murderers or terrorists because what they do is in our interest, yet from the perspective of the "other side" their "warriors" are seen in no different a view than our "warriors".

There is difficulting in sorting out some moral high ground when it comes to war since war includes all manner of actions which otherwise would be considered immoral if done outside the realm of war. For soldiers, were it not for all the training to help remove conflicting thoughts about their religious or personal beliefs and what they may be doing on the field of battle, there would be for all, the question of conflicts of interest when it comes to war. In addition, there is the question of what constitutes a "defensive" action versus an aggressive one? Certainly if someone comes up to you and begins slapping you, you're initial instinct is to fend off their actions by raising your arms to shield yourself from their blows and then thoughts turn to how to get them to stop. You may kick them in the shins, (the balls if a male) or begin slapping them back, hoping to make them see the error of their ways by doing unto them, what they are doing unto you or you could try to retreat from their blows. In all cases, as long as you weren't the one that initiated the blows, you could claim you were acting in defense and those attacking you, because they initiated the aggressiveness, could not claim defense or damages and harm against them from your fending them off, because they entered into and initiiated the action.

Their initiating the action is still not a license for those fending them off to use more force than is necessary to get them to stop. That produces a gray area and allows speculation to enter into the equation, but there is still room for allowance on the part of the defender to spontaneously react to a perceived threat. The tricky part is what triggered their perception of the level of threat to them. If someone is flathanded slapping someone with light blows, blowing them away with a S&W 500 magnum or a P-Z 600 nitro express magnum, is clearly disproportional to the threat of harm one should be feeling, yet there is a risk that the light blows could turn harder at the same time they could also lighten up. This is why cases of "defense" are difficult to deal with.

With regard to defending a nation, where the lines are between defenseive acts and pre-emptive acts before any warlike actions have yet occurred are tough to establish and judge, thus a reason why entering into anything that looks like war, officially declared or not, needs some serious thought before committing to.

In war, where the bar is lowered to people killing one another either offensively or defensively, the question is, how does any thought of moral high ground enter into the actions at all and how does one adhere to their own beliefs in a moral highground or superiority when others may not care about such things, seeing war as the base of all base acts humans can engage in. By claiming a higher moral ground and a level of civility and attention to justice, we trap ourselves in dilemmas of our own making. If we refuse to hold ourselves to higher humane or moral values, we can't claim to any less evil than those we call enemies based on their actions. We can't call them evil for killing us, if we're killing them since if "killing" is the determining factor and the evil, if we engage in it also, we're no less evil than anyone else engaging in the same.

Drones might protect our personnel from risk and harm in the short term, but do they in the longer term? Is such an "advantage" in terms of keeping our personnel out of harm while inflicting as much or more damage than we might if our personnel were manning such crafts a long term advantage or will others eventually have what we have and not only negate our "advantage", but perhaps use the "advantage" we once had to their own advantage and to the greater harm to not just American military personnel, but to all American citizens. If we worry about such nations as Irna obtaining nuclear or other WMD, why do we create or even use such weapons in the first place, then somehow think no one else can or will develop and use what we have used? Why not devote our resources to keeping wmd weaponry from being developed rather than be the leaders in the development of things that come back to haunt us when people follow our lead?

It's the same with GITMO and American citizens or military personnel. What leg do we have to stand on when other nations take American military personnel or citizens to their versions of GITMO? What leg do we have to stand on when other nations or groups begin using drones to attack Americans?

The ethics of reciprocity are intended as a test of our actions upon ourselves before we enact them against others. Chances are if we wouldn't like what we are about to do to others done to us, others would be the same as us and not like it anymore than we would. That is intended to be a self deterrent amongst all to doing bad things to one another on the premise of mutual respect for ourselves and for others.
 
Yes we really do have to man up.

It's an example of why pride and vanity do not fall under the column "human virtues" and are listed amongst, if not the deadlist of the deadly of the opposite.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seven_deadly_sins
http://web.cn.edu/kwheeler/documents/Seven_Deadly_Sins.pdf


George Washington may not have actually cut down one of his father's cherry trees and admitted to it, but the story provides somewhat of a parable for not just young human beings who can relate to the age of a young George Washington, but to all humans when it comes fo fessing up to being accountable for our acts.

America seems to have taken on a wider spread attitude that it's somehow okay to live in lots of denial and alternative realities or the idea that if we don't admit to what we do or did, it just goes away and never happened. Unfortunately, it is the biggest stumbling block to people with substance abuse problems who refuse to be held accountable for their own actions and simply live in denial of their part in their own actions. The thing is, they aren't fooling anyone, but themselves because everyone else can see what's happening. This is not to say that all have the personal ability to overcome their susceptability to addiction or their ability to chose what seems more harmful and discomforting to them (reality) than the escape from it, even if that escape is responsible for making their reality MORE difficult and discomforting rather than less.

It is quite curious to see the people who harp on the idea of being more personally responsible and accountable, be the ones who exhibit, display and illustrate the biggest avoidance of doing so. GITMO was a mistake this nation made and pride/vanity or fear of admitting to imperfections in the actions of our nations is not going to raise up our reputation, but make us look like fools who place their pride before reality and being a nation reflective of human beings, all of which who are imperfect. It does no good to call for anyone, including ourselves, to be accountable for our own actions, then run away from doing so when faced with having to do so.

I'll be the first to admit, it is a very very difficult thing to do at times, but refusal to do so, seems to get us into more trouble and hot water than admitting to our imperfections and that seems to be why refusing to do so has long and almost universally considered to be harmful to us, whether regarding our entry in to a heaven or having things run more smoothly and heavenly here on earth, regardless of whether one believes in a heaven or god or not.
 
Knot, you make so much sense. I really only have these two problems with Obama but of course they are big ones.

Your quote "With regard to defending a nation, where the lines are between defenseive acts and pre-emptive acts before any warlike actions have yet occurred are tough to establish and judge, thus a reason why entering into anything that looks like war, officially declared or not, needs some serious thought before committing to{end quote}

I think this is where Obama shines in my opinion, many a president would have had us in a war years ago. He doesn't want that and I don't either.....others do want to go to war or act like they do and call him weak but I call him smart.
 
Knot, you make so much sense. I really only have these two problems with Obama but of course they are big ones.

Your quote "With regard to defending a nation, where the lines are between defenseive acts and pre-emptive acts before any warlike actions have yet occurred are tough to establish and judge, thus a reason why entering into anything that looks like war, officially declared or not, needs some serious thought before committing to{end quote}

I think this is where Obama shines in my opinion, many a president would have had us in a war years ago. He doesn't want that and I don't either.....others do want to go to war or act like they do and call him weak but I call him smart.

I think you're right lilly. It seems some want war to be the first thing they resort to and the older, wiser and more experienced (although Mr. Obama is not that old or with firsthand combat experience (GWB either)) see war as a last resort when all other avenues have been exhausted or when there has been a clear aggression and attack against us by something that is truly discernable to go to war with.

Timothy McVeigh, until 9/11, killed more Americans in an act of terrorism than any other single incident on U.S. soil, yet his act was treated as the act it was, a criminal act by someone or a small group of someones who did something horrific and terrible.

We didn't invade our own country under the premise that we harbor terrorists and while we monitor hate groups and para-military groups that like Timothy McVeigh may think their representative government has turned tyrannical and the majority of the nation also believes the same (even when they do not), we haven't declared war on any groups that Timothy McVeigh was affiliated with and try to take out "operatives" with drones.

McVeigh as well as alleged conspirators were found and their innocence and guilt were tried, an establishment of guilt made and sentencing according to current laws, carried out. An example of carrying out our claimed beliefs and standards of justice, the question of the death penalty another discussion for many and another dilemma or conundrum with regard to those who believe this nation may have been founded on Christian values that don't exactly offer a huge level of support the idea of an eye for an eye, a tooth for a tooth sort of "justice".

I'm going to cut away here, weather is clearing and lots of things to do outside! Have an incredible day!
Very best, Knot
 
Back
Top