New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Job Creation

Arkady

President
May employment numbers are in and it was another strong month -- 280,000 jobs created, which is more than enough to keep boosting the employment-population ratio. That's over the 220,000 jobs projected (which was already optimistic), and brings the 2015 total to over a million. As most mainstream analysts predicted, the rough report in March (only 119,000 jobs created) was a weather-related blip. 280,000 is over the pace for last year, which was the best year for job creation since 1999. Job creation has been decent-to-outstanding every month since July 2012.

Unfortunately, unemployment picked up, as previously discouraged workers restarted their job hunts.
 
May employment numbers are in and it was another strong month -- 280,000 jobs created, which is more than enough to keep boosting the employment-population ratio. That's over the 220,000 jobs projected (which was already optimistic), and brings the 2015 total to over a million. As most mainstream analysts predicted, the rough report in March (only 119,000 jobs created) was a weather-related blip. 280,000 is over the pace for last year, which was the best year for job creation since 1999. Job creation has been decent-to-outstanding every month since July 2012.

Unfortunately, unemployment picked up, as previously discouraged workers restarted their job hunts.

Oh, but we all know that these people are only working 2 minutes per week and all these people have 20 jobs to make ends meet and it is all Obama's fault because he made 40 hour work weeks illegal.....
 
my neighbors kid (he's 21) was let go from his job as cashier in january. he finally was hired last week: dishwasher at the restaurant around the corner, 30 hours a week, no benefits.

of course, he's thrilled, because he worked so hard to get his high school diploma.

this of course aligns with the link below: 6.6 million americans who fomerly had full time jobs are now involuntarily working part time.

http://cnsnews.com/news/article/ali-meyer/6652000-more-americans-working-part-time-not-choice
 
my neighbors kid (he's 21) was let go from his job as cashier in january. he finally was hired last week: dishwasher at the restaurant around the corner, 30 hours a week, no benefits.

of course, he's thrilled, because he worked so hard to get his high school diploma.

this of course aligns with the link below: 6.6 million americans who fomerly had full time jobs are now involuntarily working part time.

http://cnsnews.com/news/article/ali-meyer/6652000-more-americans-working-part-time-not-choice
The BLS keeps track of how many people are working full-time and how many part-time. Since Obama took office, the ratio of full-time workers to part-time workers has risen. Of course, don't expect CNS News to mention that. They're a right-wing propaganda site and only tell you the partial truths they think help the conservative movement.

Specifically, in Obama's first month, 115,818,000 people were employed who usually worked 35 hours per week or more. Today it's 121,402,000. In the same period, those usually working less than 35 hours per week have gone from 26,377,000 to 27,593,000. Thus, the ratio went from 4.39 to 4.40.
 
It's unfortunate people started looking for jobs???

No, it's unfortunate for those who are looking for work that the increase in labor participation exceeded the increase in employment, such that people are still going to have a hard time finding work, because they're up against more competitors than in prior months. It's unfortunate that it'll take a while to work through that "discouraged worker" backlog, before there's finally a tighter correlation between job creation and declining unemployment. Only when unemployment declines more will there be enough gain of worker bargaining power, allowing for significantly improving incomes and benefits. Unemployment rates in the mid-5s mean wages will barely exceed inflation. Only when the pool of job seekers dries up some more, with unemployment in the high-4s, will there be big gains for working people.
 
Yea, job gains in the 200,000's is very poor historically.

We all know Arkady's gig, PJ's 2012 David Axelrod, but it's hard to be crazy enthused by the numbers.

However, Arkady? Just after he saw the BLS report?

0.jpg

is that what you do in front of your computer, too, all by your lonesome?
 
Only to the exotic video you made with Sarah Palin sweety ;)

Now, let's cut the personal stuff and get back to the job creation subject. Your thoughts?

do us all a favor and delete that image from your post. all it shows is your hostility towards Arkady....in a vulgar way.
 
Only to the exotic video you made with Sarah Palin sweety ;)

Now, let's cut the personal stuff and get back to the job creation subject. Your thoughts?
You appear to long for the Days of W Bush in 2008....How was the "job creation" then?
 
Hell that's nothing compared to the 873,000 reported in September, 2012 just before the election.
I thought I'd cleared you up on this issue in the past. No? Maybe it was someone else who didn't know how jobs reports work. Fair enough. I'm happy to educate you, too:

For September 2012, the current employment statistics survey (the one that provides the 280,000 figure for May 2015) shows job creation of 144,000, not 873,000:

http://data.bls.gov/timeseries/CES0000000001

The 144,000 figure is an upward adjustment -- back when the report first came out they actually underestimated job creation, and reported that only 114,000 jobs had been created:

http://www.bls.gov/news.release/archives/empsit_10052012.htm

You're thinking of a completely different report -- the household survey, which showed 873,000 more jobs in September 2012 than the prior month. Because of the statistical sampling method used for the household survey, it is subject to a great deal more statistical "noise" from month to month than the establishment survey, and so isn't the one people reference when reporting what job creation was in a particular month. As you can see, it's the 114,000 figure that got the lede:

http://www.nytimes.com/2012/10/06/b...jobs-in-september-rate-drops-to-7-8.html?_r=0

Also, this wasn't the job report "just before the election." The October job report came out on November 2, 2012. The 2012 election was held four days after that.
 
Last edited:
Yea, job gains in the 200,000's is very poor historically.

What makes you think that, exactly? Your statement is clearly and demonstrably untrue and I'm quite surprised you could be so ignorant of the facts that you'd say such a thing. Since the BLS started tracking job creation numbers, in 1939, the monthly average is 122,000. Last month's job creation of 280,000 jobs is the 184th best out of 916 months on record. That makes it better than 4 out of 5 months on record.

Even that understates how good it was, since earlier eras had a massive influx of women into the workforce, with higher average job creation numbers because of it. If you only look since the start of the Bush years, it's the 19th best month out of 173 months. That makes it better than almost 9 out of 10 months. Even if it had come in much lower, at around 200,000, it would have beaten nearly 3 out of 4 months in this century.

So, out of curiosity, what made you falsely assume job gains in the 200,000's were very poor historically? Was that something some right-wing propaganda site told you, or just something you thought you remembered hearing somewhere, or what? Really, that's not a rhetorical question; I'd honestly like to know. Right-wingers are so frequently convinced of things that are so obviously wrong, and it fascinates me. Where do you get your wrong ideas? How do the lies enter into circulation, and what is it that convinces you to just swallow and then regurgitate them, without ever thinking to check your facts? I think it's important to understand this pathology, so any assistance you can provide would be greatly appreciated. Thanks.
 
Last edited:
I thought I'd cleared you up on this issue in the past. No? Maybe it was someone else who didn't know how jobs reports work. Fair enough. I'm happy to educate you, too:

In September 2012, the current employment statistics survey (the one that provides the 280,000 figure for May 2015) shows job creation of 144,000, not 873,000:

You're thinking of a completely different report -- the household survey, which showed 873,000 more jobs in September 2012 than the prior month.

Spare me your condescending bullshit Mr. Shill. I know the difference between the household survey and the payroll report, or the current employment statistics survey, or whatever you want to call it to confuse people. Whatever you want to call it's a survey of actual businesses! 125,000 businesses I think?

And, contrary to your assertion that May, 2015 numbers were from - whatever term you want to use - the survey of actual businesses, it was not!!!! It was from the Household Survey! The same 65,000 Household Survey that in 2012 reported 873,000 jobs.

Yes there's volatility in the Household Survey. Not noise, but volatility. (You may want to refresh yourself on statistical terms before foisting them on us to impress.)

The amazing thing about statistical volatility with this Administration though is the exquisite timing involved to achieve the desired statistical result.

Which reminds me....you never responded to my post on this very subject, that out of 65,000 households it only takes about 350 positive responses of a new job found, to lower the unemployment rate estimate of 150,000,00o households a measly 0.2%. Which in the fall of 2012 before the election was very, very important..... to get below that 8% bogeyman.
 
Last edited:
And, contrary to your assertion that May, 2015 numbers were from - whatever term you want to use - the survey of actual businesses, it was not!!!! It was from the Household Survey! The same 65,000 Household Survey that in 2012 reported 873,000 jobs.

Incorrect. The household survey says employment went from 148,523,000 to 148,795,000. That's 272,000 jobs created. The establishment survey says it rose from 141,399,000 to 141,679,000. That's the 280,000 figure I quoted in the top post, and that the financial press reported.

So, where did you get the false idea that the May 2015 number was from the Household Survey? I've got this little personal project I'm working on where I try to track down where the lies that the right-wingers push here come from, originally. Was this one of your own invention, or did it come from a blog, Fox News, or some similar source? I'm genuinely curious about how these disinformation memes get generated and propagated, so any information you could provide would be appreciated. Thanks.

Not noise, but volatility.

In this case, it's noise. It's not that household employment really is jumping up and down wildly like you'd think it was if you took the monthly household numbers as gospel. It's that the household survey has a larger margin of error, making the data noisier. Where did you get the false idea that it was actual volatility, rather than noise? Again, it would help me out on my little project if you could let me know if that's a lie you invented, or something you just credulously passed on from some other source. Thanks again.

Anyway, here's the official explanation:

"The establishment survey employment series has a smaller margin of error on the measurement of month-to- month change than the household survey because of its much larger sample size. An over-the-month employment change of about 100,000 is statistically significant in the establishment survey, while the threshold for a statistically significant change in the household survey is about 400,000."

http://www.bls.gov/news.release/empsit.faq.htm

One of the things I enjoy about this forum is the opportunity to make ignorant people somewhat less ignorant. You came in here knowing nothing about the larger margin of error of the household survey, but now you know a change needs to be four times as large in the household survey to be meaningful. Aren't you pleased with your new-found knowledge?

Which reminds me....you never responded to my post on this very subject, that out of 65,000 households it only takes about 350 positive responses of a new job found, to lower the unemployment rate estimate of 150,000,00o households a measly 0.2%. Which in the fall of 2012 before the election was very, very important..... to get below that 8% bogeyman.

I've discussed this at length, here:

https://www.politicaljack.com/threads/a-fascinating-economic-fact.81469/page-3#post-1325758

The nutshell version is that in order to skew jobs numbers meaningfully enough to make a political difference in a month, you'd need a whole team of pollsters cooperating in the fraud, or you'd need a way for someone higher up the chain to invent numbers that didn't agree with the raw data from the pollsters without getting caught. And, as I pointed out, even if someone had that access and daring, it would be weird to go after the jobs numbers in the household survey, when the media treats the establishment survey as the lede. It would be a very big risk for very little pay-off.
 
Back
Top