New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Language in the Classroom

In schools with high non-English speaking students, what method should be used?

  • Bilingual Classroom

    Votes: 22 33.8%
  • English Speaking Classroom

    Votes: 43 66.2%

  • Total voters
    65

Chris

Council Member
In schools with a large number of non-English speaking students, do you believe they should be taught in a bilingual education classroom or be taught through immersion in all English speaking classes?
 
In Texas the bilingual approach is still in effect and still mostly failing to do what it was designed to do, to ease Hispanic children toward learning English. But once such a program is installed it becomes an inviolate fixture of public policy and is nearly impossible to eliminate afterwards.
 
If you want hispanic children to grow up poor like their immigrant parents, then by all means, teach them in spanish. If you want them to become productive members of society in the US, then teach them in english.
Even the instructions for a leaf blower are printed in english.
 
I honestly don't know which is best but I would think that where there is a large non English speaking population you need to have truly bilingual teachers in the immersion classes and intensive language instruction, not just leave non English speaking children adrift.
 
A 5-6 year old child from a predominately spanish speaking home, shouldn't be dissuaded from their "native" language and estranged from their family and relatives. There are ESL (English as a second language) classes available now, and their use should be propagated. A bilingual person is always an asset for any job. And here in Corpus Christi, there are many bilingual people who I encounter every day. Learning a language opens up areas of your brain that many of us english-speakers are unfamiliar with. There is NO offical language of this country, and you need to face the fact that things change and will keep on changing.
 
...excellent post. I could not agree more...

...the "curmudgeon" factor is getting a bit too large in our country...
 
This is a tough one, and shouldn't be decided by the absolutists. When I first started going on mission to Honduras, the cultural do-gooder in my head, told me that I was obliged to do my best to speak to the kids in THEIR native tongue. I subsequently learned that I had it backwards. These kids already have plenty of people speaking Spanish to them. The best thing I could do for them, is encourage them to communicate with me in English, and help them learn English.

On the OTHER hand - consider a subject like "math". ALL kids need to start learning math at the youngest possible age. It's silly, counterproductive, and just a little bit nativist/nasty to make them put off learning math, until they've mastered English.
 
In schools with a large number of non-English speaking students, do you believe they should be taught in a bilingual education classroom or be taught through immersion in all English speaking classes?

I vote for only English speaking in the class room. I believe there should be a program where the non-English speaking students should be required to attend either before or after school classes to help them transition to English speaking.

When I was in Junior High a Vietnamese student registered at our school...this was about the time the Vietnam war was raging. He could not even speak enough English to carry on a conversation. However, after about a month he was getting up in front of the class giving an oral report and we could understand him. He was highly intelligent and had a gift for languages for a 14 year old. I remember he wore a starched military uniform with medals, ribbons and braids every day to school. I'm sure he thought American teenagers were the laziest most indulged group he'd ever seen.
 
In schools with a large number of non-English speaking students, do you believe they should be taught in a bilingual education classroom or be taught through immersion in all English speaking classes?

Great question, but I am not knowledgeable enough to make a real opinion on the matter. That said (LOL!), on the one hand I have HEARD, that it is easier to learn a language with total immersion, BUT, at the same time, it would be kind of silly to expect a child to understand "Algebra..." AS he is learning the language....(That's a heap of learnin on one plate!)

That said, I am of the opinion, that Americans should do more to become BI-Lingual, with ENGLISH as the main tongue.

Many Europeans can speak and understand multiple languages.
 
A 5-6 year old child from a predominately spanish speaking home, shouldn't be dissuaded from their "native" language and estranged from their family and relatives. There are ESL (English as a second language) classes available now, and their use should be propagated. A bilingual person is always an asset for any job. And here in Corpus Christi, there are many bilingual people who I encounter every day. Learning a language opens up areas of your brain that many of us english-speakers are unfamiliar with. There is NO offical language of this country, and you need to face the fact that things change and will keep on changing.

A 5-6 year old Spanish speaking child isn't going to be estranged from their family if they're taught only English in the classroom. Unless you're thinking to sieze the child from the parents, and give it to a nice English-speaking couple. After all, if the kid is 5-6 years old and Spanish speaking, they already know about as much Spanish as your average high schooler taking Spanish.

That being said, they should go multi-lingual. I'm talking aiming at English-Spanish-French-German-Italian-Chinese-Russian speaking students by the time they graduate.
 
In Texas the bilingual approach is still in effect and still mostly failing to do what it was designed to do, to ease Hispanic children toward learning English. But once such a program is installed it becomes an inviolate fixture of public policy and is nearly impossible to eliminate afterwards.

Why is it failing in your opinion? What do you suggest...I mean, besides building a wall.

Where I live in Texas it is working great. Most Mexican parents depend on their children learning English so they can translate for them. They strongly encourage their children to learn English. Many times when a Mexican family needs our services we end up talking to the children.

When I was a kid my Mexican friends always translated for their non-English speaking parents even though their parents had top paying jobs here in Texas. My friends were never allowed to mix English and Spanish together when speaking, you either spoke one or the other. The parents felt only low class people mixed languages.
 
Things change.

Of course they do.

I have only believed that America would fall after my lifetime. With ideas and opinions like yours, I'm not so sure it won't happen before I pass on.

Our borders, language and culture are under constant assault from outside as well as being chiseled away from the inside by folks like you.

Shame.
 
I do believe that English should be taught to every student who attends public school just for the fact that they will encounter it more often than not, in their liefs if they are to ever leave the area of their growing up. If you want to move on to the next level of of education in Spanish you must first accomplish the level of English that is required. I don't have a problem with both being taught, but there is an added cost, and I expect that is the biggest problem with most people who complain from the white/black side of looking at it.
 
KG you know this for a fact? "A 5-6 year old Spanish speaking child isn't going to be estranged from their family if they're taught only English in the classroom"

or is this just another "well I think it only stands to reason that is what will happen" statement from right wingers. that soon will become a part of your belief that no one will ever convince you otherwise because you have seen it in print.
 
Sure, but they all speak English.

English is the language of business, politics, and the vast majority of social interactions in this nation.

It is, the de facto language of the US.
 
Interestingly, folks like Al claim Latino kids CAN be successful if they are ONLY taught in English....okay, so I guess he's saying that language is the only thing holding them back.

So...why will they not decide to learn it on their own? Do they WANT to "not be successful"???
 
Back
Top