New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Left Behind

My memory is superb. I remember my top-post quite clearly. You, on the other hand, have either forgotten it, or you never actually understood it in the first place.

Here's the relevant portion:

"... It occurs to me that the world would probably be better if the most devout believers were, in fact, "raptured" to some other existence... Picture a world in which all the most devout people suddenly vanished -- not just the Christians, mind you, but anyone who has enough faith in a supernatural dogma for it to govern his life in a major way.... I suspect that if if the 10% of mankind that most fervently believes in the supernatural were to vanish, once the shock wore off, the rest of us would find we were a lot happier, more peaceful, and more productive."

Note, my thought experiment in no way envisions succumbing to pestilence, war, famine, and death. If you reread, you'll see that I'm not picturing what life would be like if a "four horsemen of the apocalypse" scenario played out. That's just something you injected into it. In fact, I'm not even picturing what an atheist world would look like. Those believers who weren't among the "most devout" would still be around. I didn't even mean to imply that all the Christians would be gone. My guess, quite to the contrary, is that the "most devout" are disproportionately Muslim, so that you'd probably lose more than 10% of Muslims and less than 10% of Christians.

My thought experiment was specific: what would happen if the 10% of mankind that believes most fervently in the supernatural were to vanish. Not a word about pestilence, war, famine, and death. No implication of universal atheism. Probably the vast majority of Christians still around.

I used to teach the SAT verbal section for the Princeton Review. Teaching the vocabulary part wasn't frustrating. Some people just hadn't been exposed to that many words, or had a poor memory for them, and that was easy enough to fix with a little drilling. The frustrating part was the reading comprehension section. Again and again these students would take a simple paragraph, in which they understood every single word, and they'd come away from it with a completely false idea of what it said, even after reading it carefully. The skill of pulling a clear understanding out of a simple, standard English text is just something some people's brains can't handle very well, and it's very hard to "fix" these lousy readers.


I have no interest in creating a communist cult, like those of China and the Soviet Union. I believe those are essentially religious systems. As with religions, they have strict dogmas, holy texts, cult figures to which they ascribe supernatural powers, empty ceremonies, indoctrination of the very young, etc. Juche, in North Korea, is similar:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Political_religion

I prefer secularism chosen by free will, with a hefty dose of skepticism and strict protection of freedom of speech and of the press. My ideal is for the darkness of religion to fade gradually as people become smarter, more knowledgeable, and more emotionally mature. That, not an enforced substitution of a supernatural religion with a political religion, is the path forward.

So you say. But I contend that only 10% of atheists truly want to sustain freedom.
 
No religious bias here. I'm not religious, and have no "dog in that fight." I simply distinguish between a very small operation that has legitimate non-religious goals (fighting infection), and a much more major operation that, as far as I know, is only there to deprive women of sexual pleasure.

There have been a number of studies about male circumcision reducing HIV infection by a substantial amount. The evidence is compelling.

http://www.who.int/hiv/topics/malecircumcision/en/
http://www.cdc.gov/hiv/prevention/research/malecircumcision/
http://healthland.time.com/2013/04/17/why-circumcision-lowers-risk-of-hiv/

There's also evidence it reduces susceptibility for other diseases, like syphilis:
http://www.aidsmeds.com/articles/syphilis_circumcision_1667_25925.shtml
And urinary tract infections:
http://healthland.time.com/2012/07/09/study-uncircumcised-boys-have-a-higher-risk-of-uti/
and chlamydia:
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2422990/
and HPV and penile cancer:
http://www.cancer.org/cancer/penilecancer/detailedguide/penile-cancer-risk-factors

It also simplifies the task of keeping clean.

So, quite apart to the silly religious reasons for circumcision, there are a number of health benefits. One might, of course, decide that the benefits of being uncircumcised (whatever those are) outweigh those of being circumcised. But there are certainly plenty of secular reasons a person might get a male child circumcised. I don't know of any secular reasons for doing so to a female child.


Though I really did not intend to go down this route since all I was pointing out was your bias in advocating one blood rite over another - both of which sit under a religious umbrella - both of which the ancients knew to be personality changing ( genetic engineering ) and we no longer seem too -

And your understanding of it is as lacking as is most modern understanding of both male and female mutilations - to think one is lesser than another is the biggest of these 'mis understandings' in actual fact most female circumcisions are less horrific that all male circumcisions which you have become ( in your sanitized minds) desensitized too -

From the NHS about your studies -

http://www.nhs.uk/news/2009/03March/Pages/CircumcisionandSTIs.aspx

Drs Opposing Circumcision

http://www.doctorsopposingcircumcision.org/info/HIVStatement.html

Oxford Journal

http://jid.oxfordjournals.org/content/200/3/370.full

Phychology Today

http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog...cision-myths-you-may-believe-hygiene-and-stds

Jews against circumcision

http://www.jewsagainstcircumcision.org/

Intact America

http://www.intactamerica.org/

Male circumcision comes out of suppressing or enhancing certain human traits - it was performed on those who shall rule at a very very early age ( 7 days old) and on slaves at a later age or when captured ( very different times in development)- and on those who shall fight/warriors in the same sort of category as slaves - Europeans began experimenting with it at one point but dropped it very quickly - The main reasoning behind both the European use and the Jewish use were give as - to stop masturbation, ditto the US and Canada at first - this now has morfed into hygene - which is a lie because the foreskin is the protector of the penis as well as being the male clitoris ( so to say most female circumcision is worse in the pleasure area is a fallacy ) and others -

Female circumcision is ditto to male in the when it is performed - usually to dull 'the feminine'.

So we can both do studies eh?

Back to religious bias using secularism to hide behind -

Out of what we think are religious blood rites - have come certain bad habits - one of which you have found an excuse for ( with no real evidence) the other not - both are the same in essence, both performed without the consent, informed or otherwise, of the person they are performed on, both psychologically damaging, both excruciatingly painful and both potentially dangerous to the unwitting victim -
But it is this - human rights and informed consent - which you in your secularism are ignoring -riding roughshod over any morality - all come out of 'religion' as far as you are concerned - in actual fact they were political - and that my dear friend, the political, is what both you and I dislike about the Dogmas - And whose delicate relationship with 'religion' we no longer properly understand -

Now, I know 80% of American Males are circumcised so I know this is a great delema because guilt and grief and mates must be faced full on - courage or carry on with this blood rite no matter the moral 'rites' or wrongs because we have been doing it for the last 100 years?

Some where I have an English Judges ruling on Circumcision which I shall look for later - it is very revealing - in that he says it is legal to knowingly cause pain and knowingly put a childs life at risk - he asked for a serious review and thus ruling on it. Not forth coming -
 
Last edited:
Crafting it forever with deeper understandings? The books were written and deeper understanding was being spread, and continues to be spread to this day.
But yes, I agree with you that the gnostics would do what they always did....borrow bits from different religions and try to lay some ownership to the master level of it, which is what they also attempted to do with Christianity.
What the gnostics did was attempt to rewrite Christianity so that salvation came from being "in the know" and achieving knowledge and power, rather than from the life, death, and resurrection of Christ. The forgeries the gnostics attempted to pass off were merely rewrites of pantheistic beliefs they'd held for centuries. What you claim is that these would still be being written if "dogma" hadn't frozen you. Dogma didn't freeze gnostics. Gnosticism was a widely held belief and the gnostic pseudochristianity was widely popular and gaining popularity at the time it was successfully challenged and usurped. The big bad church didn't blow your house down. The Truth did.

The Gnostics were 'Pagans' - 'Pagans' were always reworking their stories - and they did take from each other - this is how we learn, this is how we grew -

Constantine turned religion into politics, where as before politics was not within the Temple and the relationship between the two was though a sometimes and increasingly uneasy one - it was understood - Zeus ruled everywhere but within the Temple - once there was so much unrest coming out of the philosophies, from the teachers, mystics, philosphers over the Politics of the day - the Temples were destroyed and usurped by Politicos and Dogma replaced free thought. It froze us and destroyed our spirituality, it diverted us into a cul de sac -

Our stories/myths went underground and turned into what we now know as Fairy Stories -

I could go on but it is a nice day and i'm going in the garden to work whilst the rain has a rest :)

My God blesses yours xxx :)
 
Though I really did not intend to go down this route since all I was pointing out was your bias in advocating one blood rite over another - both of which sit under a religious umbrella - both of which the ancients knew to be personality changing ( genetic engineering ) and we no longer seem too -

And your understanding of it is as lacking as is most modern understanding of both male and female mutilations - to think one is lesser than another is the biggest of these 'mis understandings' in actual fact most female circumcisions are less horrific that all male circumcisions which you have become ( in your sanitized minds) desensitized too -

From the NHS about your studies -

http://www.nhs.uk/news/2009/03March/Pages/CircumcisionandSTIs.aspx

Drs Opposing Circumcision

http://www.doctorsopposingcircumcision.org/info/HIVStatement.html

Oxford Journal

http://jid.oxfordjournals.org/content/200/3/370.full

Phychology Today

http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog...cision-myths-you-may-believe-hygiene-and-stds

Jews against circumcision

http://www.jewsagainstcircumcision.org/

Intact America

http://www.intactamerica.org/

Male circumcision comes out of suppressing or enhancing certain human traits - it was performed on those who shall rule at a very very early age ( 7 days old) and on slaves at a later age or when captured ( very different times in development)- and on those who shall fight/warriors in the same sort of category as slaves - Europeans began experimenting with it at one point but dropped it very quickly - The main reasoning behind both the European use and the Jewish use were give as - to stop masturbation, ditto the US and Canada at first - this now has morfed into hygene - which is a lie because the foreskin is the protector of the penis as well as being the male clitoris ( so to say most female circumcision is worse in the pleasure area is a fallacy ) and others -

Female circumcision is ditto to male in the when it is performed - usually to dull 'the feminine'.

So we can both do studies eh?

Back to religious bias using secularism to hide behind -

Out of what we think are religious blood rites - have come certain bad habits - one of which you have found an excuse for ( with no real evidence) the other not - both are the same in essence, both performed without the consent, informed or otherwise, of the person they are performed on, both psychologically damaging, both excruciatingly painful and both potentially dangerous to the unwitting victim -
But it is this - human rights and informed consent - which you in your secularism are ignoring -riding roughshod over any morality - all come out of 'religion' as far as you are concerned - in actual fact they were political - and that my dear friend, the political, is what both you and I dislike about the Dogmas - And whose delicate relationship with 'religion' we no longer properly understand -

Now, I know 80% of American Males are circumcised so I know this is a great delema because guilt and grief and mates must be faced full on - courage or carry on with this blood rite no matter the moral 'rites' or wrongs because we have been doing it for the last 100 years?

Some where I have an English Judges ruling on Circumcision which I shall look for later - it is very revealing - in that he says it is legal to knowingly cause pain and knowingly put a childs life at risk - he asked for a serious review and thus ruling on it. Not forth coming -
No guilt or grief here. I simply made the point that study after study point to health benefits of circumcision, so there are non religious reasons people would support it. You appear to feel very strongly about this. I don't. For me, it's a dispassionate question: are there non-religious reasons for supporting circumcision. There very clearly are.
 
The Gnostics were 'Pagans' - 'Pagans' were always reworking their stories - and they did take from each other - this is how we learn, this is how we grew -

Constantine turned religion into politics, where as before politics was not within the Temple and the relationship between the two was though a sometimes and increasingly uneasy one - it was understood - Zeus ruled everywhere but within the Temple - once there was so much unrest coming out of the philosophies, from the teachers, mystics, philosphers over the Politics of the day - the Temples were destroyed and usurped by Politicos and Dogma replaced free thought. It froze us and destroyed our spirituality, it diverted us into a cul de sac -

Our stories/myths went underground and turned into what we now know as Fairy Stories -

I could go on but it is a nice day and i'm going in the garden to work whilst the rain has a rest :)

My God blesses yours xxx :)

Yes, the gnostics were pagans. And yes they always reworked their stories. But when the timelessTruth came along the need for stories that changed to fit the everchanging desires and social climates disappeared. And now here and there we hear opinions like yours, where excuses are made for the loss of interest in the myths.
 
No guilt or grief here. I simply made the point that study after study point to health benefits of circumcision, so there are non religious reasons people would support it. You appear to feel very strongly about this. I don't. For me, it's a dispassionate question: are there non-religious reasons for supporting circumcision. There very clearly are.

There were NO religious reasons in the first place - They were always political - but you have lost this knowledge and are saying/excusing one religions blood rites as being correct ( from bias and manipulated studies, look at the others too and make up your mind) and another not - and thus you may perform one with out conscience and the other you must condemn - so you are passionate - since you condemn one.

Your morality you are saying is secular and yet - you are denying human rights to babes and children of one religion or none religion but that which you perceive as coming out of religion - but you condemn the morality of exactly the same denial of their rights to another ditto as above babes and children -

It is hypocritical to say the least - and not thought through - Indeed you are saying that 'we/owned for profit science' knows best and some children can/should be mutilated - excruciating pain should be inflicted -and endangering their lives is acceptable - and this is your secular morality -

This too is a very great sorrow for us all - which has come out of Dogma - the fragmenting of the Philosophies - natural from moral - we have lost our morality when it come to the natural -
 
Last edited:
Yes, the gnostics were pagans. And yes they always reworked their stories. But when the timelessTruth came along the need for stories that changed to fit the everchanging desires and social climates disappeared. And now here and there we hear opinions like yours, where excuses are made for the loss of interest in the myths.

What happened was that the stories as they were , up to date, were no longer worked on ( well they were we know from those we have since found but ) and so the story stood still, was petrified - but we have gone further since Time, rolls on - we had though lost our way, our lamp to lead the way. Because we were trapped in Time Past - In essence the stories are right but -------------------- they are old, too old, even though the outter truths are within we no longer have the inner wisdoms and nor have we worked our stories to travel with us in time -

I make no excuses - not ever over anything - just give explanations - long researched in some cases -
 
There were NO religious reasons in the first place - They were always political - but you have lost this knowledge and are saying/excusing one religions blood rites as being correct ( from bias and manipulated studies, look at the others too and make up your mind) and another not - and thus you may perform one with out conscience and the other you must condemn - so you are passionate - since you condemn one.

Your morality you are saying is secular and yet - you are denying human rights to babes and children of one religion or none religion but that which come out of religion - but you condemn the morality of exactly the same denial of their rights to another ditto as above babes and children -

It is hypocritical to say the least - and not thought through - Indeed you are saying that 'we/owned for profit science' knows best and some children can/should be mutilated - excruciating pain should be inflicted -and endangering their lives is acceptable - and this is your secular morality -

This too is a very great sorrow for us all - which has come out of Dogma - the fragmenting of the Philosophies - natural from moral - we have lost our morality when it come to the natural -
I'm not saying any religion's rites are correct. I'm saying there's a non religious reason for that particular rite. In the same way, I support cremation for non religious reasons, not because of a bias towards religions that favor it.
 
I'm not saying any religion's rites are correct. I'm saying there's a non religious reason for that particular rite. In the same way, I support cremation for non religious reasons, not because of a bias towards religions that favor it.

But there is not - the studies do not stand up to scrutiny - try them and you will see -


- and if you had condemned all circumcision I would not have said a bloody word - it is that for almost exactly the same procedure with all its ramifications - you condemned one as being a religious horror and the other not -

They are the same thing -

Cremation? wtf - dead people do not feel excruciating pain when on the slab do they? It the knife slips they do not have to live with the consequences do they? Do they rupture their stomachs screaming? Turn blue? - well yes - but not from screaming -

ect --------------------- are dead bodies human rights ignored? informed consent? -
 
Yes, the gnostics were pagans. And yes they always reworked their stories. But when the timelessTruth came along the need for stories that changed to fit the everchanging desires and social climates disappeared. And now here and there we hear opinions like yours, where excuses are made for the loss of interest in the myths.

ps The underlaying difference between us is that you have an interpreter and I do not -
 
No where in the Bible is the Rapture mentioned. This is something of much later origin.

I'm not so sure about that. The rapture meme speaks to a plague of frogs. A coupla tree frogs took up residence and spawned a brood in my man-made backyard pond this spring. So, at my my wife's insistence, I put off all my usual lawn maintenance. Evidently, that sort of thing isn't conducive to frogdom.

So, here we are in mid-October and there are still a half dozen polliwogs left in that pond, finishing up their froggy thing. The pump's been clogged and shut down for a month now. I need to drain it to clean the pump. But...until every last tadpole's gone?....I'm not allowed to.

Now THAT'S a plague!
 
There were NO religious reasons in the first place - They were always political - but you have lost this knowledge and are saying/excusing one religions blood rites as being correct ( from bias and manipulated studies, look at the others too and make up your mind) and another not - and thus you may perform one with out conscience and the other you must condemn - so you are passionate - since you condemn one.

Your morality you are saying is secular and yet - you are denying human rights to babes and children of one religion or none religion but that which you perceive as coming out of religion - but you condemn the morality of exactly the same denial of their rights to another ditto as above babes and children -

It is hypocritical to say the least - and not thought through - Indeed you are saying that 'we/owned for profit science' knows best and some children can/should be mutilated - excruciating pain should be inflicted -and endangering their lives is acceptable - and this is your secular morality -

This too is a very great sorrow for us all - which has come out of Dogma - the fragmenting of the Philosophies - natural from moral - we have lost our morality when it come to the natural -
I have taken no stance here about whether male circumcision is a good thing or a bad thing, nor whether it should be legal or illegal. I've simply said there are solid secular reasons for supporting it, based on research substantiating the health benefits of it. I am unaware of any such health benefits for female circumcision.
 
I'm not so sure about that. The rapture meme speaks to a plague of frogs. A coupla tree frogs took up residence and spawned a brood in my man-made backyard pond this spring. So, at my my wife's insistence, I put off all my usual lawn maintenance. Evidently, that sort of thing isn't conducive to frogdom.

So, here we are in mid-October and there are still a half dozen polliwogs left in that pond, finishing up their froggy thing. The pump's been clogged and shut down for a month now. I need to drain it to clean the pump. But...until every last tadpole's gone?....I'm not allowed to.

Now THAT'S a plague!

In 1997, The City of Annapolis was hit by fire, floods...and 17 year locusts. Oh my!
 
I have taken no stance here about whether male circumcision is a good thing or a bad thing, nor whether it should be legal or illegal. I've simply said there are solid secular reasons for supporting it, based on research substantiating the health benefits of it. I am unaware of any such health benefits for female circumcision.

The only reasons for supporting it are $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ and all of the studies are made by the $$$$$$$$$$$$$$ who make the $$$$$$$$$$$ and so on -

You are backing out :)

I will let you off for now 'cos I can't be bovered - but .............. do babies and children have rights? According to you girls do and boys don't - if that is secularism you can keep it - it is no better than that which you are railing against
 
In 1997, The City of Annapolis was hit by fire, floods...and 17 year locusts. Oh my!

I imagine Annapolis's bigger concern today, should be sociopolitical. After all, being swept aside by a buncha "royals", in this modern democratic age, must be a sign of something!
 
I imagine Annapolis's bigger concern today, should be sociopolitical. After all, being swept aside by a buncha "royals", in this modern democratic age, must be a sign of something!

Ouch.

To continue the Oz metaphor...people in Annapolis do go both ways.

Disinterested Nationals care little for such local politics...concerning themselves with the ongoing plight of the invasion of the giant people of the west...
 
But there is not - the studies do not stand up to scrutiny - try them and you will see -


- and if you had condemned all circumcision I would not have said a bloody word - it is that for almost exactly the same procedure with all its ramifications - you condemned one as being a religious horror and the other not -

They are the same thing -

Cremation? wtf - dead people do not feel excruciating pain when on the slab do they? It the knife slips they do not have to live with the consequences do they? Do they rupture their stomachs screaming? Turn blue? - well yes - but not from screaming -

ect --------------------- are dead bodies human rights ignored? informed consent? -


You're trying to claim that circumcision...which you're obsessed with...has a religious basis in all schools of thought that agree with circumcision. And you're just making that up. What else can you blame the Jews for?

It's like saying that if an atheist got on his knees to wash the kitchen floor then he's inspired by some cultural embrace of a religious practice because some people get on their knees to pray. But the truth is really....both got on their knees, but for very different reasons. That's the same with circumcision. IT's the inspiration for and intention of the action that tells the true story. But if you look to closely at that, then you can't blame the Jews for the "mutilation" as you call it, of mankind. You can't make the Jews responsible for "torturing babes" and I think you'd really like to. You even said that a mother-Jewish or not-who has her son circumcised is not even a woman.

As far as health benefits, your explanation is typical of what you do all the time. Forget things that are discovered and facts that are embraced and dismiss it all with the notions of brainwashing, conspiracy, and again, succumbing to cultural influence. In your estimation, these excuses explain why the pagans began to peter out when Christ came, why the world hates hitler, and why circumcision is widely practiced today. And I can't imagine what else.

You claim you heard babies screaming blue bloody murder when they were circumcised. I saw it done to both of my sons and they didn't wake up. So either one of us is lying or we're both telling the truth and it really boils down to the doctor and the preparations he makes rather than the procedure on its own.

A foreskin is not a clitoris. Really, T, think about what you're saying. Why do they remove the clitoris of girls? To keep them home, to deter them from seeking sexual satisfaction. Circumcised men seek and experience sexual satisfaction. And they're not likely to lose interest in sex any sooner than uncircumcised men.
You could compare the two procedures if boys were being castrated instead of circumcised. But they're not.
 
Last edited:
The only reasons for supporting it are $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ and all of the studies are made by the $$$$$$$$$$$$$$ who make the $$$$$$$$$$$ and so on -

You are backing out :)

I will let you off for now 'cos I can't be bovered - but .............. do babies and children have rights? According to you girls do and boys don't - if that is secularism you can keep it - it is no better than that which you are railing against


Yes, babies and children have rights. They have a right to be protected and to receive care to keep them healthy. So parents make the decisions for their health until they are old enough to make them themselves. Yes, circumcision could hurt. So could tooth extraction, splinter removal, sunburn care and vaccinations. Are you suggesting that we don't provide medical care that we feel is necessary for our children because it may hurt?
Do you come out against vaccines and the administering of antibiotics the way you come out against circumcision? Following your logic, children shouldn't have anything done to their bodies without first making informed consent.
 
the studies do not stand up to scrutiny - try them and you will see

I'm not an MD, nor do I have any special expertise in public health matters. So, I'd be skeptical of my own lay-person's take on the studies. However, when I see similar results come up repeatedly in top peer reviewed journals, I'm disposed to think there's something to it. If you would like to identify some particular problem with one of the studies, I'd be happy to look into it.

you condemned one as being a religious horror and the other not -

Where did I say anything was a religious horror? What I said is that I'm aware of strong secular arguments for one, based on health benefits, and not the other. Because of that, I suspect that if the most religious people vanished, we'd probably not see much if any female circumcision, but we'd still see plenty of male circumcision... for the same reason that male circumcision is still done by many people today who don't come from a religious tradition that calls for it.
 
Ouch.

To continue the Oz metaphor...people in Annapolis do go both ways.

Disinterested Nationals care little for such local politics...concerning themselves with the ongoing plight of the invasion of the giant people of the west...


My Mariners missed the playoffs by one game, on the last day of the season! Now some might assume we're pretty busted up about that. But to us, the fact of their remaining relevant until the very last day, was a completely unanticipated miracle in and of itself. Shoot, we would've been pleased if their high point had been single-digits out, on the 1st of September!
 
Back
Top