New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Left Behind

You're trying to claim that circumcision...which you're obsessed with...has a religious basis in all schools of thought that agree with circumcision. And you're just making that up. What else can you blame the Jews for?

It's like saying that if an atheist got on his knees to wash the kitchen floor then he's inspired by some cultural embrace of a religious practice because some people get on their knees to pray. But the truth is really....both got on their knees, but for very different reasons. That's the same with circumcision. IT's the inspiration for and intention of the action that tells the true story. But if you look to closely at that, then you can't blame the Jews for the "mutilation" as you call it, of mankind. You can't make the Jews responsible for "torturing babes" and I think you'd really like to. You even said that a mother-Jewish or not-who has her son circumcised is not even a woman.

As far as health benefits, your explanation is typical of what you do all the time. Forget things that are discovered and facts that are embraced and dismiss it all with the notions of brainwashing, conspiracy, and again, succumbing to cultural influence. In your estimation, these excuses explain why the pagans began to peter out when Christ came, why the world hates hitler, and why circumcision is widely practiced today. And I can't imagine what else.

You claim you heard babies screaming blue bloody murder when they were circumcised. I saw it done to both of my sons and they didn't wake up. So either one of us is lying or we're both telling the truth and it really boils down to the doctor and the preparations he makes rather than the procedure on its own.

A foreskin is not a clitoris. Really, T, think about what you're saying. Why do they remove the clitoris of girls? To keep them home, to deter them from seeking sexual satisfaction. Circumcised men seek and experience sexual satisfaction. And they're not likely to lose interest in sex any sooner than uncircumcised men.
You could compare the two procedures if boys were being castrated instead of circumcised. But they're not.

I don't come here to defend myself but - I do not obsess over such things, I have researched this though and I am concerned, it does worry me -
The History of how circumcision came down to us was, it seems, via the Egyptians who learned of it from captured African High Priests - The Jews and Muslims learned it from the Egyptians but for some reason have entwined it into their religions ( It was not mentioned in the early Torahs and is not demanded nor expected of Muslims in the Q'uran ) - how it was used and why it was used are to do with ruling and subservience and soldiering, depending on when it is done.

Jewish mothers know what their 8 day old baby boys will go through, without anesthetic, and so no - I do not hold them in esteem - But we are not, in this case, talking about Jews in particular though it is because of the Jewish influence that this is not discussed or ruled on in the same why that any other child mutilation might be - debates and rulings on female circumcision is all so on hold because legally they cannot rule on one with out the other - I also do not dismiss that now a days we have to take Muslims into consideration because of the influx of Muslims into our Lands. Both of these in a Christian country ( which European countries are ) should not have to be considered, it is in my view cowardly of our Govs - indeed the EU tried to rule against circumcision but had to back down - because of 'clout'.

The studies Arkady put forth are flawed - we can go through them one by one if you wish - that is up to you -

An over view:-

http://blog.practicalethics.ox.ac.uk/2012/05/when-bad-science-kills-or-how-to-spread-aids/


I said heard one babys' screams when I was sixteen - as for the ops that go wrong and the babies who are damaged -I have left links which include that info - The babys' mother was a very young, 16, unmarried Jewish girl, we were all in a Mother and Baby Home in Putney and all supposed to be giving our babies up for adoption - as was the norm then - she had her baby circumcised by a Mohel - they were alone over the cot and no anesthetic was used - it was one of the saddest and loneliest moments I have ever witnessed but I too was as yet unhardened by life -

Your babies were lucky to have been knocked out most are not - even so body monitors show that the trauma to the body is just the same - for those anesthetized and those who have not been - I think it is Doctors Opposed to Circumcision which I posted to Arkady and elsewhere -

No the male fore skin is not the exact equivalent of the female clitoris, how could it be? but it is close -

It is being discussed here in a 'hands on' sort of way - it is explicit.

http://www.mothering.com/forum/44-c...7-women-what-sensory-equivalent-foreskin.html

And here is a link to the fore skins make up - from drs opposing -

http://www.doctorsopposingcircumcision.org/info/foreskin.html

http://research.cirp.org/index-e.html

No - wrong - the clitoris is usually only taken externally - it is usually, only in rarer and extreme cases internally so it is still functioning -

http://www.circumstitions.com/FGM-defined.html

Btw The Chinese used to circumcise their women Mao stopped that on pain of death -

But the details of either or both were not what my criticism of Arkady was - he was criticizing one for being a 'religious' horror and the other went unmentioned - religious or not they deserve equal rights or no rights -
 
I have taken no stance here about whether male circumcision is a good thing or a bad thing, nor whether it should be legal or illegal. I've simply said there are solid secular reasons for supporting it, based on research substantiating the health benefits of it. I am unaware of any such health benefits for female circumcision.

The studies are flawed - we can go through them if you wish ( I don't particularly but will if needs be )

''These studies have generated a lot of media attention. In part this is because they claim to show that circumcision reduces HIV transmission by about 60%, a figure that (interpreted out of context) is ripe for misunderstanding, as we’ll see. Nevertheless, as one editorial [2] concluded: “The proven efficacy of MC [male circumcision] and its high cost-effectiveness in the face of a persistent heterosexual HIV epidemic argues overwhelmingly for its immediate and rapid adoption.”

Well, hold your horses. The “randomized controlled trials” upon which these recommendations are based are not without their flaws. Their data have been harnessed to support public health recommendations on a massive scale whose implementation, it has been argued, may have the opposite of the claimed effect, with fatal consequences. As Gregory Boyle and George Hill explain in their extensive analysis of the RCTs:

While the “gold standard” for medical trials is the randomised, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial, the African trials suffered [a number of serious problems] including problematic randomisation and selection bias, inadequate blinding, lack of placebo-control (male circumcision could not be concealed), inadequate equipoise, experimenter bias, attrition (673 drop-outs in female-to-male trials), not investigating male circumcision as a vector for HIV transmission, not investigating non-sexual HIV transmission, as well as lead-time bias, supportive bias (circumcised men received additional counselling sessions), participant expectation bias, and time-out discrepancy (restraint from sexual activity only by circumcised men).

That’s a whole laundry list of issues, so let me highlight a few of the more substantial. First, consider the “lack of placebo control.” What does that mean? Normally, when you’re trying to determine whether some medical intervention has a disease-fighting effect specific to its own (hypothesized) mechanisms—and over and above the placebo baseline—you have to have a control group. That group gets a dummy intervention, and nobody is supposed to know which participants were exposed to the actual treatment until after the results are in.

After all, if someone knows (or thinks) that they’re getting a great big helping of medicine, they might act in various ways—whether consciously or unconsciously—that have the effect of generating positive health outcomes but which have nothing to do with the intervention itself. In the case of circumcision, however, there’s no way not to know if you’ve received the “medicine”—you have to go through a surgery and then you don’t have a foreskin anymore—so this basic condition of a true clinical trial is violated in the first instance.''

But that’s just the tip of the iceberg. As Boyle and Hill point out, the men who were circumcised got additional counseling about safe sex practices compared to the control group, and then they had to refrain from having sex altogether for the simple reason that their lacerated penises had to be wrapped in bandages until their wounds healed – leading to what Boyle and Hill refer to as “time-out discrepancy” in the quote above. By contrast, the non-circumcised men got to keep having sex during the full two month period during which the treatment group was in recovery mode. Then (due to a statistically significant effect having been detected) the trials were stopped early — which tends to lead to an overestimation the true effect size of the treatment. These issues may pose problems for the scientific credibility of the studies. Taken together with the other flaws, here is why:

Let us assume for a second that the circumcised men really did end up getting infected with HIV at a lower rate than the control-group men who were left intact—even though, as we will see in a moment, it would be premature to be convinced that this is so. Why might that outcome have happened?

If you answered, “Because those men knew they were in the treatment group in the first place, had less sex over the duration of the study (because they had bandaged, wounded penises for much of it), and had safer sex when they had it (because they received free condoms and special counseling from the doctors), thereby reducing their overall exposure to HIV compared to the control group” then you are on the right track.

2. Misleading results

Experimental design issues notwithstanding, it is tempting to think that the 60% figure that’s being thrown around in media reports is just too large a percentage to ignore–even if the studies had some flaws. But do you know what the “60%” statistic is actually referring to? Boyle and Hill explain:

What does the frequently cited “60% relative reduction” in HIV infections actually mean? Across all three female-to-male trials, of the 5,411 men subjected to male circumcision, 64 (1.18%) became HIV-positive. Among the 5,497 controls, 137 (2.49%) became HIV-positive, so the absolute decrease in HIV infection was only 1.31%.

That’s right: 60% is the relative reduction in infection rates, comparing two very small percentages: a bit of arithmetic that generates a big-seeming number, yet one which–without also reporting the absolute risk reduction alongside–arguably misrepresents the results of the study. The absolute decrease in HIV infection between the treatment and control groups in these experiments was just 1.31%, which is likely to have no appreciable effect at the demographic level.

4. This is serious business

The most troubling part about all of this is not just that the science behind “the circumcision solution” is being promoted with so little caution or debate, but that the actual implementation of these recommendations may very well lead to more HIV infections, not less. The big idea here is “risk compensation” – the subject of an interesting paper by Robert Van Howe and Michelle Storms.

Risk compensation occurs when people believe they have been provided additional protection (wearing safety belts) [such that] they will engage in higher risk behavior (driving faster). As a consequence of the increase in higher risk behavior, the number of targeted events (traffic fatalities) either remains unchanged or [actually] increases.

http://blog.practicalethics.ox.ac.uk/2012/05/when-bad-science-kills-or-how-to-spread-aids/
 
Yes, babies and children have rights. They have a right to be protected and to receive care to keep them healthy. So parents make the decisions for their health until they are old enough to make them themselves. Yes, circumcision could hurt. So could tooth extraction, splinter removal, sunburn care and vaccinations. Are you suggesting that we don't provide medical care that we feel is necessary for our children because it may hurt?
Do you come out against vaccines and the administering of antibiotics the way you come out against circumcision? Following your logic, children shouldn't have anything done to their bodies without first making informed consent.

teeth are extracted if they are rotten and hurting - splinters are a foreign object - sunburn? huh?

I have reservations about vaccinating young children when the medical profession admits it does not understand how babies and tiny childrens' immune system works and also I have questions about some adjuvants which are being used -

No I have no problems with antibiotics used in some cases -

Needlessly chopping off important bits of a babies anatomy hardly counts as an equivalent you have given - and is not protective nor care - it is now based on falsified science - it was based on false morality - it is still based on archaic religious blood rites whose basis is long forgotten.
 
The studies are flawed - we can go through them if you wish ( I don't particularly but will if needs be )

''These studies have generated a lot of media attention. In part this is because they claim to show that circumcision reduces HIV transmission by about 60%, a figure that (interpreted out of context) is ripe for misunderstanding, as we’ll see. Nevertheless, as one editorial [2] concluded: “The proven efficacy of MC [male circumcision] and its high cost-effectiveness in the face of a persistent heterosexual HIV epidemic argues overwhelmingly for its immediate and rapid adoption.”

Well, hold your horses. The “randomized controlled trials” upon which these recommendations are based are not without their flaws. Their data have been harnessed to support public health recommendations on a massive scale whose implementation, it has been argued, may have the opposite of the claimed effect, with fatal consequences. As Gregory Boyle and George Hill explain in their extensive analysis of the RCTs:

While the “gold standard” for medical trials is the randomised, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial, the African trials suffered [a number of serious problems] including problematic randomisation and selection bias, inadequate blinding, lack of placebo-control (male circumcision could not be concealed), inadequate equipoise, experimenter bias, attrition (673 drop-outs in female-to-male trials), not investigating male circumcision as a vector for HIV transmission, not investigating non-sexual HIV transmission, as well as lead-time bias, supportive bias (circumcised men received additional counselling sessions), participant expectation bias, and time-out discrepancy (restraint from sexual activity only by circumcised men).

That’s a whole laundry list of issues, so let me highlight a few of the more substantial. First, consider the “lack of placebo control.” What does that mean? Normally, when you’re trying to determine whether some medical intervention has a disease-fighting effect specific to its own (hypothesized) mechanisms—and over and above the placebo baseline—you have to have a control group. That group gets a dummy intervention, and nobody is supposed to know which participants were exposed to the actual treatment until after the results are in.

After all, if someone knows (or thinks) that they’re getting a great big helping of medicine, they might act in various ways—whether consciously or unconsciously—that have the effect of generating positive health outcomes but which have nothing to do with the intervention itself. In the case of circumcision, however, there’s no way not to know if you’ve received the “medicine”—you have to go through a surgery and then you don’t have a foreskin anymore—so this basic condition of a true clinical trial is violated in the first instance.''

But that’s just the tip of the iceberg. As Boyle and Hill point out, the men who were circumcised got additional counseling about safe sex practices compared to the control group, and then they had to refrain from having sex altogether for the simple reason that their lacerated penises had to be wrapped in bandages until their wounds healed – leading to what Boyle and Hill refer to as “time-out discrepancy” in the quote above. By contrast, the non-circumcised men got to keep having sex during the full two month period during which the treatment group was in recovery mode. Then (due to a statistically significant effect having been detected) the trials were stopped early — which tends to lead to an overestimation the true effect size of the treatment. These issues may pose problems for the scientific credibility of the studies. Taken together with the other flaws, here is why:

Let us assume for a second that the circumcised men really did end up getting infected with HIV at a lower rate than the control-group men who were left intact—even though, as we will see in a moment, it would be premature to be convinced that this is so. Why might that outcome have happened?

If you answered, “Because those men knew they were in the treatment group in the first place, had less sex over the duration of the study (because they had bandaged, wounded penises for much of it), and had safer sex when they had it (because they received free condoms and special counseling from the doctors), thereby reducing their overall exposure to HIV compared to the control group” then you are on the right track.

2. Misleading results

Experimental design issues notwithstanding, it is tempting to think that the 60% figure that’s being thrown around in media reports is just too large a percentage to ignore–even if the studies had some flaws. But do you know what the “60%” statistic is actually referring to? Boyle and Hill explain:

What does the frequently cited “60% relative reduction” in HIV infections actually mean? Across all three female-to-male trials, of the 5,411 men subjected to male circumcision, 64 (1.18%) became HIV-positive. Among the 5,497 controls, 137 (2.49%) became HIV-positive, so the absolute decrease in HIV infection was only 1.31%.

That’s right: 60% is the relative reduction in infection rates, comparing two very small percentages: a bit of arithmetic that generates a big-seeming number, yet one which–without also reporting the absolute risk reduction alongside–arguably misrepresents the results of the study. The absolute decrease in HIV infection between the treatment and control groups in these experiments was just 1.31%, which is likely to have no appreciable effect at the demographic level.

4. This is serious business

The most troubling part about all of this is not just that the science behind “the circumcision solution” is being promoted with so little caution or debate, but that the actual implementation of these recommendations may very well lead to more HIV infections, not less. The big idea here is “risk compensation” – the subject of an interesting paper by Robert Van Howe and Michelle Storms.

Risk compensation occurs when people believe they have been provided additional protection (wearing safety belts) [such that] they will engage in higher risk behavior (driving faster). As a consequence of the increase in higher risk behavior, the number of targeted events (traffic fatalities) either remains unchanged or [actually] increases.

http://blog.practicalethics.ox.ac.uk/2012/05/when-bad-science-kills-or-how-to-spread-aids/
The problems with the studies are ones that are unavoidable given the nature of the procedure. It's not like you can circumcise one set of men and perform some dummy procedure on another set and not let either the researchers or the men know which is which, so a double-blind, placebo-controlled test is impossible. We're left, necessarily, with something less than the gold standard. Yet, that's very often the case in these kinds of population studies. They remain the best we have to work with, and what they show is a health benefit. If someone comes up with superior experimental methodology and that statistical benefit vanishes, then there will be no secular reason to support male circumcision. But that hasn't happened. Right now, the best studies we have support the health benefits, and so there is a secular reason to support it. You can argue, of course, that the reasons aren't strong enough, given the disadvantages of the procedure (whatever they might be), but that's a different argument. I'm simply addressing the question of whether there is some non-religious support for the procedure and, quite obviously, there is. That is why so many of millions of people who are from faith traditions that do not call for circumcision have, nonetheless, had their boys circumcised.
 
The problems with the studies are ones that are unavoidable given the nature of the procedure. It's not like you can circumcise one set of men and perform some dummy procedure on another set and not let either the researchers or the men know which is which, so a double-blind, placebo-controlled test is impossible. We're left, necessarily, with something less than the gold standard. Yet, that's very often the case in these kinds of population studies. They remain the best we have to work with, and what they show is a health benefit. If someone comes up with superior experimental methodology and that statistical benefit vanishes, then there will be no secular reason to support male circumcision. But that hasn't happened. Right now, the best studies we have support the health benefits, and so there is a secular reason to support it. You can argue, of course, that the reasons aren't strong enough, given the disadvantages of the procedure (whatever they might be), but that's a different argument. I'm simply addressing the question of whether there is some non-religious support for the procedure and, quite obviously, there is. That is why so many of millions of people who are from faith traditions that do not call for circumcision have, nonetheless, had their boys circumcised.


Yes I have seen a lot more 'studies' and Drs physical and of the thinker and endocrinology and mothers and nurses and so ons testimonies and findings and so ons - and of victims and I made my own mental notes in my sphere of work and in life - so yes I disagree, passionately.

But -

I also disagree on your so called secular-ness ( sorry not a word eh? I'm tired)

Or objectivity - It is prejudice, not that I am saying that as an automatically bad thing, but that it is in favor of the familiar.

Take what I have said on board or don't Arkady - up to you - I suppose what I was pointing out was that though secular, you think, you are prejudice in what was/is perceived as the religious ( even with, falsified at worse unsafe at best, scientific basis ) rites of one but not the other out of hand.

Actually - in there somewhere is the fundamental difference between yours and my disagreements with Orthodox Religion/Dogma/God imprisoned, give it what ever title we like ad before we got into the specifics that is I think were I was going - but that is perhaps for another day :) the differences between those who deny the existence of God.
 
Last edited:
teeth are extracted if they are rotten and hurting - splinters are a foreign object - sunburn? huh?

I have reservations about vaccinating young children when the medical profession admits it does not understand how babies and tiny childrens' immune system works and also I have questions about some adjuvants which are being used -

No I have no problems with antibiotics used in some cases -

Needlessly chopping off important bits of a babies anatomy hardly counts as an equivalent you have given - and is not protective nor care - it is now based on falsified science - it was based on false morality - it is still based on archaic religious blood rites whose basis is long forgotten.


It's not up to you to decide what's "needless" or what's protective or what's care. That is for parents and the doctors they trust to decide. And that's the point. You can go on about informed consent and babies' rights but you know you can't get through that argument without conceding that ultimately, parents have to make medical decisions for their children. So there goes your "rights" argument.

And there you go with the "false morality". I'm not even gonna say what I'm thinking.
 
It's not up to you to decide what's "needless" or what's protective or what's care. That is for parents and the doctors they trust to decide. And that's the point. You can go on about informed consent and babies' rights but you know you can't get through that argument without conceding that ultimately, parents have to make medical decisions for their children. So there goes your "rights" argument.

And there you go with the "false morality". I'm not even gonna say what I'm thinking.

"Formerly it was the lie under the guise of religion that deceived mankind; now it is the same lie under the guise of science that is deceiving the whole world, and there is no weapon against it other than reason - reason teaches us that the true healing of diseases and the maintenance of health consists in freeing the body of impurities and keeping it clean." - Dr. med. Franz Hartmann, Hallein in Tyrol (Lotusblueten, 1895)
 
Back
Top