New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Let's compromise on ACA...

Number_58

I'm one of the deplorables lefty warns you about.
I'll submit to Congress being able to force people to purchase health insurance...to get rid of "freeloaders" on the healthcare system...if we do away with Medicaid. After all, we will no longer need Medicaid because the government can step in to regulate what an insurance company can charge for each person's coverage...under the Commerce Clause. The money that is coming out in payroll taxes on those that can't afford insurance will not need to go to the government anymore, since we're doing away with Medicaid, and they can use that extra money to purchase health insurance at the price regulated by the government.

Why wouldn't something like this work? Discuss...
 
That would sound so damned logical.... BUT Obama didn't cut Medicaid... he cut MEDICARE - by a half trillion dollars. I am not sure NBC News reported that to the seniors.... well, we know what and how the mainstream media reports so that's pretty much confirmed and why people are so stupid on this.

ObamaCare is Un-American.
 
BTW - isn't Obama using Medicaid to pay for ObamaCare for his 40 Milion dregs??? I'm not sure how "those who can't afford it" actually pay for their "insurance" the rest of us have to buy.

This ObamaCare is so f'ing sinister - SAVE US USSC - PLEASE!!!
 
Then respond to NC...I see you dodged the material in my post completely. Now, there's something you don't see everyday...:wink:
 
Then respond to NC...I see you dodged the material in my post completely. Now, there's something you don't see everyday...:wink:

That's because your analogy doesn't hold. There is already state-based regulation of what insurance companies can pay and that's not the argument going on over the individual mandate.

And Medicaid receipiants....and those who pay taxes FOR Medicaid...are not necessarily the same people...are they?
 
We DID compromise on ACA. The efficient solution would have been Medicare for all. As a compromise, we have Medicare only for the old and a corporate-friendly system designed by the Heritage Foundation and mimicking Romneycare, for everyone else.
 
As for why your plan wouldn't be a good idea, the advantage of Medicaid is that the government has more control over costs. If it were simply to have the poor covered by ACA, paying whatever the corporate health insurance providers charge, with the government subsidizing the purchases for the poor, it would be more expensive for the taxpayer. ACA, as currently written, doesn't have much in the way of cost controls, and nothing in the way of price caps.
 
I'd prefer Medicare for all, so I can retire before I'm too disabled to enjoy any of it. No chance of that happening, tho.
 
NC, you know as well as I do that anything remotely resembling Medicare for all would never have gotten out of the House, and would have been filibustered to death in the Senate. It would have made Obama far too popular. I think he erred in not trying that, but I understand why he didn't.
 
I think he is a dunce - a bad salesman. He is getting angry and his "nice smile" which I always thought was fake - was always a prop - and now we are seeing it as the smirk it always was.
 
You idea was too logical... I have ideas and solutions too - they may differ from yours but I respect yours because it actually makes sense ... libs have a way of opposing everything and doubling down on failed policies by Obama and ignoring or rejecting great solutions they don't take time to understand.

IMHO - that refusal to face reality or take suggestions for real solutions makes any liberal the same as Obama - a dunce.

Then respond to NC...I see you dodged the material in my post completely. Now, there's something you don't see everyday...:wink:
 
The plan would have been implemented by now and coverage for ages 50-64 would already be in place. Libs hated the Medicare For All plan because it included a national sales tax to pay for it... libs want REAL FREE STUFF... not viable solutions.
 
NC, Liberals would have loved the Medicare for all plan. Every one who proposed it got shouted down by the centrists, the so-called "Third Way."

You know, the corporatists.
 
you want to do away with Medicaid?

that's the program that primarily pays for custodial care for disabled children and adults, and elderly in nursing homes.
 
Back
Top