New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Lewinsky

That's embarrassing for you, then, since you misunderstood it so badly. Is reading comprehension a recurring problem for you, or was this more of a one-off thing from having skimmed it too quickly?



Every parade has someone in front, and Fox News acted as the drum major for that particular parade to hell. None of us had every seen anything like that before, despite many prior presidents having been known to have mistresses. The difference was the role Fox News played.

why? whatever time i spent skimming it, the result is the same... she needs some attention..so she picked Ailes and here we are.. good for her.

I have no issues with reading comprehension, no matter how big of a dick anyone here behaves towards me.

Everyone went ape shit over the affair and subsequent frenzy that followed. If it makes you happy to align with her view, so be it. Easy mark for her, i guess..
 
You have identified here as male. This means, according to feminists, you are not a feminist and cannot be one (yes, I can document this). The difference between the social imbalance and the power imbalance in the workplace matters (but do remember, I'm spouting the sort of nonsense that I heard alleged feminists say back at the time, and even earlier during the Anita Hill hearings).




Roger Ailes appears to have been a serial sexual harasser, but he didn't have the opportunity to harass Lewinsky. If you accept the feminist view, Clinton harassed Lewinsky. If you accept that Lewinsky was a consenting adult, then she could only expect the sort of coverage she received after having an affair with a president old enough to be her father, whether he was married or not. Fox was no worse to her than any number of tabloids were, and would have been, whether Fox existed or not. Ailes didn't cause that. I don't think the national discourse has become any courser than it was in 1968. Ailes didn't cause that, either.

Of course the discourse has become coarser. The open secret (in Washington circles) that Nixon had an affair with a Chinese spy wasn't even made public at the time.
 
why? whatever time i spent skimming it, the result is the same... she needs some attention..so she picked Ailes and here we are.. good for her.

I have no issues with reading comprehension, no matter how big of a dick anyone here behaves towards me.

Everyone went ape shit over the affair and subsequent frenzy that followed. If it makes you happy to align with her view, so be it. Easy mark for her, i guess..
She had some good insights about the path we took to get to where we are today, and the role Ailes had in putting us on that path.

And, no, not everyone's went ape shit over the affair. Right wingers did because they needed some angle for attacking a remarkably successful president. I thought it was trivial.
 
No. You're trying to recast the story to make it fit. At the time, the knock on Thomas wasn't that he'd had a consensual relationship with someone who had less power than him. It was that he'd repeatedly harassed her, according to her own sworn (and polygraph-passed) testimony.

I'm doing no such thing. If Anita Hill was telling the truth, she was even more harassed by Clarence Thomas than Lewinsky was by Clinton. But the fact remains that (thong snapping or not), he was the president and she was a 24-year-old intern, and there was in fact a power differential between them. Most modern liberal commentators would say this means that her "consent" is questionable. Remember -- in reality I mostly agree with your take on the the matter of how the Lewinsky/Clinton affair played out, but what I'm saying about power differentials is in fact the reasoning that would be used in a similar situation regarding any other given pair of individuals (especially if the offending male were GOP).

As for Jones, if she is telling the truth, that would have been harassment. Is she telling the truth? No clue. She was a known liar, but so was Bill Clinton, so it comes down to which of the two you believe.

Oh, there's little doubt Jones was telling the truth. She reported it to multiple people when it happened, etc. She didn't go public until most of her name appeared in national publications, which allowed Democrats to claim she was simply trumping up a charge with the help of the GOP as an ambush tactic.


As a liberal who runs in liberal social circles, in the most liberal part of the most liberal state in the nation, I get a lot of exposure to feminists. My wife is one. So's my mother. So's my best friend. Your views are not ones I have heard from them.

As a conservative who lives in a liberal enclave in a mostly red state, these are exactly the sorts of things I hear from liberals, all the time. It's also in most literature on the subject. I googled "sexual harassment, power differentials" and received 127,000 hits, including peer-reviewed papers such as this one: http://www.nationalforum.com/Electr...sment-An Abuse of Power IJMBA V13 N1 2010.pdf


No, I can't. CNN did a pretty decent job at pioneering quality journalism in the 24-hour format until Fox News came along and turned it to a race to the bottom. If you think back to early-90s CNN, it's a whole different world. There's a good flick, "Live From Baghdad," recounting that era.

CNN was, during that period, all scandal, all the time, just as was the Fox Network and any other cable outlet that existed. Fox's commentary was aggressively anti-Clinton, which is really the only difference. BTW, I've read the book on which "Live from Bagdad" is based, as well as seen the movie (always been a fan of Michael Keaton), and its basically a story of one success one time. And remember, that teams screwed up and BECAME the story while covering it.

The Fitzgerald affair was well known while he was still in office, but got very little coverage because that's back when Roger Ailes was working for GHW Bush, rather than running a 24/7 "news" network that specialized in trumpeting that kind of smut.

I was a newspaper reporter during part of the GHWB administration and I have no real remembrance of the topic, and I was better informed than the average person. I only learned about it by reading a review of Kitty Kelley's book, and she's scarcely a solid source.
Agreed. As we now know very well, there was a huge, under-served audience of horrible people looking for dumb and hateful coverage of lowest-common-denominator stories like sexual affairs. Ailes can't be blamed for creating that appetite, any more than a coke dealer can be blamed for creating the market for a highly addictive stimulant. But without him, it's quite possible we wouldn't have moved in the direction we moved.... that audience had been confined largely to the super market tabloids for decades, and perhaps would have remained so, if he hadn't started exploiting it. That said, you could be right, that if Ailes hadn't come along to do it, Rupert Murdoch would have found some similar slimemonger who'd have fill the same role. Tough to say.

You would be right only if Fox, then and ongoing for the past 25 years, had focused solely on such affairs. Fox comes in for a lot of valid criticism because it brings a point of view to its coverage: It is unabashedly right wing in a media environment that is abashedly left wing. Ailes can be blamed for inserting a political slant into news coverage -- intentionally. The slant had already been there in U.S. network news since at least 1972, and probably more like 1968. What Fox did, and continues to do, is to service a market that the other news outlets abandoned years before Fox came into existence.
 
I'm doing no such thing. If Anita Hill was telling the truth, she was even more harassed by Clarence Thomas than Lewinsky was by Clinton.

More than zero doesn't say much. Again, as you know, there's no evidence at all that Clinton harassed Lewinsky, and the person who'd be in the best position to know, Lewinsky herself, isn't claiming he did.

But the fact remains that (thong snapping or not), he was the president and she was a 24-year-old intern, and there was in fact a power differential between them.

Yes. And, as I said, there are power differentials in almost every relationship.

Most modern liberal commentators would say this means that her "consent" is questionable

I'm a modern liberal commentator and I don't say that. None of the liberals I know say that. What evidence do you see that this is the majority position of modern liberal commentators?

(especially if the offending male were GOP).

Surely you have an example to back that up -- some Republican who was accused of sexually harassing a woman with whom he had a consensual relationship, when the woman herself says it wasn't harassment. I can't think of any such example. When people on the right get accused of harassment, the person leading the charge is the woman who alleges she was the recipient of the unwelcome attention. That's what we see in the Ailes and O'Reilly stories, for example. By comparison, there have been plenty of right-wingers who had consensual affairs with women who had a lot less power than them. For example, there was Gingrich and Callista Bisek. In fact, most of the prominent Republican names who led the Clinton impeachment turned out to have had affairs of that sort (Henry Hyde, Bob Livingston, Pete Demenici, and so on). Although they were rightly faulted for their sanctimony and hypocrisy, I don't recall them being accused of harassment based on those affairs. They only get accused of harassment when the woman says she was harassed.

Oh, there's little doubt Jones was telling the truth. She reported it to multiple people when it happened, etc.

Is that all it takes for you to say there's little doubt about an accusation -- for someone to make the allegation privately to associates at the time? Then there's little doubt not only that Trump is a serial sexual harasser, but that he's also a rapist. I suspect you wouldn't apply the same standard elsewhere. For example, if someone close to Trump alleged that Trump confided he'd cooperated with the Russians during the election, and that person could produce multiple others that he'd passed along Trump's supposed confession to at the time, I doubt you'd say there was little doubt he was telling the truth. You'd see that all that contemporaneous gossip would do is establish the vintange of the tale, not whether it was true.

I googled "sexual harassment, power differentials" and received 127,000 hits, including peer-reviewed papers such as this one: http://www.nationalforum.com/Electronic Journal Volumes/Lunenburg, Fred C. Sexual Harassment-An Abuse of Power IJMBA V13 N1 2010.pdf

Did you actually look at it? It is very clear that "The harasser’s conduct must be unwelcome." The mere existence of a power differential does not establish sexual harassment. If you look through the paper, you'll see it's a good fit for what Anita Hill alleged (unwelcome and offensive sexual conduct that creates an intimidating or offensive work environment, including verbal or physical behavior of a sexual nature). It is not, however, a fit for the consensual relationship that Clinton and Lewinsky had.

CNN was, during that period, all scandal, all the time

Would it have been that way if it weren't chasing Fox News to the bottom?

I was a newspaper reporter during part of the GHWB administration and I have no real remembrance of the topic, and I was better informed than the average person. I only learned about it by reading a review of Kitty Kelley's book, and she's scarcely a solid source.

I wasn't a news junkie at the time, but I knew about it. It had been an issue both in the 1988 and 1992 campaigns. In fact, Dukakis had fired Donna Brazille for talking about it (Dukakis had this notion that the path to victory was being the more gentlemanly and substantive candidate. Hehe.)

It is unabashedly right wing in a media environment that is abashedly left wing.

It's unabashedly right wing in a media environment where most of the others have a corporatist/consumerist bias that leans them a bit right on economic and foreign policy issues, and a bit left on social issues.

What Fox did, and continues to do, is to service a market that the other news outlets abandoned years before Fox came into existence.

Yes. Before Fox News, the market of stupid, hateful bigots was under-served -- mostly relegated to lurid tabloids in the super market check out lines, where in the early 1990s tales of Clinton's AIDS diagnosis fought for attention against spottings of bat boy and Elvis. Ailes showed that there was a huge amount of money to be made by taking that kind of bottom-feeding political story and giving it glossy 24-hour "news" coverage on Tv.
 
More than zero doesn't say much. Again, as you know, there's no evidence at all that Clinton harassed Lewinsky, and the person who'd be in the best position to know, Lewinsky herself, isn't claiming he did.

Something, possibly nonverbal but nonetheless there, sent the message from Bill Clinton to Monica Lewinsky that he was interested. If the current harassment theory holds water, that nonverbal instance was itself harassment because of the power differential. Under that theory, even if she doesn't think she was harassed, she was. Don't look at me, it's not my theory. I think far too many women have morning after rape, and after-the-fact harassment.

Yes. And, as I said, there are power differentials in almost every relationship.

Not of this nature.

I'm a modern liberal commentator and I don't say that. None of the liberals I know say that. What evidence do you see that this is the majority position of modern liberal commentators?

You are atypical, as the research already provided shows.
Surely you have an example to back that up -- some Republican who was accused of sexually harassing a woman with whom he had a consensual relationship, when the woman herself says it wasn't harassment. I can't think of any such example. When people on the right get accused of harassment, the person leading the charge is the woman who alleges she was the recipient of the unwelcome attention. That's what we see in the Ailes and O'Reilly stories, for example. By comparison, there have been plenty of right-wingers who had consensual affairs with women who had a lot less power than them. For example, there was Gingrich and Callista Bisek. In fact, most of the prominent Republican names who led the Clinton impeachment turned out to have had affairs of that sort (Henry Hyde, Bob Livingston, Pete Demenici, and so on). Although they were rightly faulted for their sanctimony and hypocrisy, I don't recall them being accused of harassment based on those affairs. They only get accused of harassment when the woman says she was harassed.

When GOP members are accused of misbehavior, it's usually hypocrisy rather than harassment that is claimed. I know of none who have been accused of harassment over a consenual affair, but of course that doesn't mean it hasn't happened. Last year there was a South Dakota GOP lawmaker who resigned after having had consensual sex with two of his interns -- I don't know if harassment was claimed or not.



Is that all it takes for you to say there's little doubt about an accusation -- for someone to make the allegation privately to associates at the time? Then there's little doubt not only that Trump is a serial sexual harasser, but that he's also a rapist. I suspect you wouldn't apply the same standard elsewhere. For example, if someone close to Trump alleged that Trump confided he'd cooperated with the Russians during the election, and that person could produce multiple others that he'd passed along Trump's supposed confession to at the time, I doubt you'd say there was little doubt he was telling the truth. You'd see that all that contemporaneous gossip would do is establish the vintange of the tale, not whether it was true.

I'm sorry, but again according to feminist activists women seldom lie about sexual assault and sexual harassment. If Jones reported what happened to other people at the time she was telling the truth, and the man she accused (regardless of who) is guilty until proven innocent -- this is basically codified into any number of college campus sexual behavior rules. It is certainly the statement about women and rape/sexual harassment allegations.
Did you actually look at it? It is very clear that "The harasser’s conduct must be unwelcome." The mere existence of a power differential does not establish sexual harassment. If you look through the paper, you'll see it's a good fit for what Anita Hill alleged (unwelcome and offensive sexual conduct that creates an intimidating or offensive work environment, including verbal or physical behavior of a sexual nature). It is not, however, a fit for the consensual relationship that Clinton and Lewinsky had.

The power differential means "its unwelcome" is the standard even if the victim thinks otherwise.

Would it have been that way if it weren't chasing Fox News to the bottom?
Blather. Without Fox, there were the network tabloids like "Inside Edition." Fox may have rushed to the bottom but it wasn't alone once it got there.
I wasn't a news junkie at the time, but I knew about it. It had been an issue both in the 1988 and 1992 campaigns. In fact, Dukakis had fired Donna Brazille for talking about it (Dukakis had this notion that the path to victory was being the more gentlemanly and substantive candidate. Hehe.)

I WAS a news junkie at the time and basically didn't hear about it. Dukakis would have been president if he'd stayed off the damned Abrams tank.
It's unabashedly right wing in a media environment where most of the others have a corporatist/consumerist bias that leans them a bit right on economic and foreign policy issues, and a bit left on social issues.

Stripped of arrant pedantry, you merely repeated what I said above. I'll narrow it further: Fox openly leans right. The bulk of the rest of the media attempts to conceal that it leans left. It does this by attempting to show a bit right on economic and foreign issues.
Yes. Before Fox News, the market of stupid, hateful bigots was under-served -- mostly relegated to lurid tabloids in the super market check out lines, where in the early 1990s tales of Clinton's AIDS diagnosis fought for attention against spottings of bat boy and Elvis. Ailes showed that there was a huge amount of money to be made by taking that kind of bottom-feeding political story and giving it glossy 24-hour "news" coverage on Tv.

Before Fox news there was also a large population of right leaning people who are not stupid, nor hateful, nor bigots, who were under served by a primarily left leaning media. Ailes showed that there was a lot of money to be made by serving that population.
 
She had some good insights about the path we took to get to where we are today, and the role Ailes had in putting us on that path.

And, no, not everyone's went ape shit over the affair. Right wingers did because they needed some angle for attacking a remarkably successful president. I thought it was trivial.

Everyone, meaning the media..not just ailes and fox.
 
Everyone, meaning the media..not just ailes and fox.
Ailes and Fox led the way and the other for-profit media followed. I didn't. I continued to see the story as what it was: a trivial bit of celebrity gossip -- no more interesting than if we were talking about Kristen Stewart cheating on her boyfriend. I never got why anyone other than teenage girls would get into that kind of thing.
 
Ailes and Fox led the way and the other for-profit media followed. I didn't. I continued to see the story as what it was: a trivial bit of celebrity gossip -- no more interesting than if we were talking about Kristen Stewart cheating on her boyfriend. I never got why anyone other than teenage girls would get into that kind of thing.

Enjoy the narrative. At the time, methinks it wasnt so trivial to a great many..
 
Enjoy the narrative. At the time, methinks it wasnt so trivial to a great many..
A great many also obsess over the pregnancies of assorted Hollywood starlets, or the latest B-lister caught sleeping with the nanny, or royal weddings and funerals. The masses have a great appetite for celebrity gossip, and they talk themselves into thinking it's not trivia, to excuse their desire to wallow in that crap. It was never my thing. If what gets it up for you is reading the smutty details of a politician's sex life, then I guess that's fine -- enjoy your dog-eared copy of the Starr Report. But don't fool yourself into thinking it's anything more than pornographic gossip.
 
A great many also obsess over the pregnancies of assorted Hollywood starlets, or the latest B-lister caught sleeping with the nanny, or royal weddings and funerals. The masses have a great appetite for celebrity gossip, and they talk themselves into thinking it's not trivia, to excuse their desire to wallow in that crap. It was never my thing. If what gets it up for you is reading the smutty details of a politician's sex life, then I guess that's fine -- enjoy your dog-eared copy of the Starr Report. But don't fool yourself into thinking it's anything more than pornographic gossip.

nope not me. naturally the comparison of the president and lewinsky, to b list junk is a miss as far as relative scale and pablum for the masses goes. but.. use what you need to to maintain your narrative. i get it..
 
naturally the comparison of the president and lewinsky, to b list junk is a miss as far as relative scale and pablum for the masses goes.
It's not an exact fit, since when it comes to Hollywood starlets and the like, there's very little to care about other than the gossip, so I can sort of get why shallow people get sucked into such stories. I mean, it's not like you're going to talk about Kim Kardashian's views about consumer loan regulation if you're not talking about her sex life. But how much shallower would someone have to be if the topic were the president of the United States and yet the most interesting angle to him were details of the guy's consensual sex life?
 
It's not an exact fit, since when it comes to Hollywood starlets and the like, there's very little to care about other than the gossip, so I can sort of get why shallow people get sucked into such stories. I mean, it's not like you're going to talk about Kim Kardashian's views about consumer loan regulation if you're not talking about her sex life. But how much shallower would someone have to be if the topic were the president of the United States and yet the most interesting angle to him were details of the guy's consensual sex life?


dunno.

methinks it would have been a lesser event it he simply came clean.
 
Back
Top