New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Liberal vs. Conservative Values

I'm not interested in their characterizations, I'm interested in reality. So, going from 1860 to 1932, what during that period when we were a more Conservative country do you think we need to bring back to make our society better and more fair?

I could care less about fair. I mean I believe in opportunity for all which is guaranteed in the constitution. so I have no need to measure/monitor a wholly subjective marker.

nor do I care about government 'making society better'. it's the nature of free people to do that.

I don't need anything. it was a gift from our founding fathers. all I need to do is read that and I'm good to go.
 
and liberal politicians have the luxury of giving away other people's money to further their stranglehold while conservatives have to sell the idea of less.

"idea of less"? You mean when they pass tax cuts....never pass spending cuts....spend MORE in fact, even on non-defense spending....put WARS "off the books"......and then scream about "Democrats' deficits"???
 
your definition of 'win' being, what?

That the ideologically conservative position on an issue eventually is supplanted or defeated by the ideologically progressive one.

Even if "conservatives" embrace a policy of expanded freedoms (since the Founding), it is not a "conservative" idea, since by its very definition a conservative stance on an issue would be to maintain the status quo and "the way the Founders intended".

Example....one of the earliest ones? Voting suffrage for non-property owners. The progressive idea was to expand it to them, the conservative position was to stay with the "Founders' intent", which was to keep franchise ONLY to property-owners. Which side won?
 
That may actually be THE most objective and useful delineation of the two, that I've ever seen. And, I don't think it's very useful for us to try debating or parsing any of the specifics.

The problem is (as I've babbled many times over), ALL Americans are liberals and ALL Americans are conservatives. And, I'm not talking some sort of half 'n half mish-mash of the two, as if we're all some of one and some of the other. Liberalism and Conservatism aren't opposites of one another. They're two seperate constructs that run parallel to one another.

Therefore, the one bone I have to pick with this piece, is that it implies that "conservatives think all these things" and "liberals think all these things". In fact though, I think that we were to set aside our partisan affiliation for a moment and review these lists with eyes wide open, I think we'd find that we're drawn to some of both. Maybe someone who identifies themself as a liberal identifies, with MORE things from liberal column and vice versa in terms of someone who self-identifies as a conservative.

BUT...I think we probably all recognize that we've gotta problem, when we feel compelled to force ourselves 100% into one box or another, even as we're not necessarily sanguine with some of the elements in that box.

On the OTHER hand, given our political system, it DOES make sense that the person who likes more of the elements in the liberal column, might vote Democratic, and vice versa.

the balkanization of America. not sure who started it or when, but I could do without the hyphens/labels.

I mentioned 'ideas' in another thread. I'm more interested in communicating an idea and have folks chime in on it's merits/alternatives.

I think this piece is great for those who are newly attuned to politics; hear the terms tossed about and interested in discovering where their leanings, lie
 
"idea of less"? You mean when they pass tax cuts....never pass spending cuts....spend MORE in fact, even on non-defense spending....put WARS "off the books"......and then scream about "Democrats' deficits"???

actually you're absolutely correct on the tax cuts. whether Kennedy/Bush/Reagan, both the government and the citizen got 'more

and the 'they' in 'when they pass tax cuts' is dem and rep
 
It's the main problem I have between the ideologies. You can be a liberal in a conservative America if you choose to, but you can't be a conservative in a liberal America. Liberalism won't allow it.
 
That the ideologically conservative position on an issue eventually is supplanted or defeated by the ideologically progressive one.

sounds good in theory.. give me a particular, please

Even if "conservatives" embrace a policy of expanded freedoms (since the Founding), it is not a "conservative" idea, since by its very definition a conservative stance on an issue would be to maintain the status quo and "the way the Founders intended".

the status quo then is 'life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness'. there's no need for 'expanded freedoms' when we were granted unconditional freedoms.

Example....one of the earliest ones? Voting suffrage for non-property owners. The progressive idea was to expand it to them, the conservative position was to stay with the "Founders' intent", which was to keep franchise ONLY to property-owners. Which side won?

ah... ok you provided one...my bad.

ok, if I accept your assignment of 'progressive' I'll give you that victory.

but you said lib's always win. don't the "Bush tax cuts" you cited in another of your posts, destroy your argument?
 
That's an assessment I am not comfortable in making. Although most people skew toward conservative values, i.e. less intrusive government, lower taxes, more social freedom, etc..., the game board is skewed toward people fearing for their futures, and therefore looking to government to help them in a time when they haven't been able to find a job in years.
 
ah... ok you provided one...my bad.

ok, if I accept your assignment of 'progressive' I'll give you that victory.

but you said lib's always win. don't the "Bush tax cuts" you cited in another of your posts, destroy your argument?

Have the "Bush tax cuts" proven a conservative ideological "victory" or "defeat"? They were supposed to grant eternal prosperity and (as with Reagan) not INCREASE deficits....but provide balanced budgets even surpluses (again, according to conservative ideology).

But pick any issue from history.....non-property owner franchise, abolishing slavery, monopoly and trust-busting, Pure Food & Drug Act, progressive income tax, labor reform (unions, no child labor, 8 hour work-day), women's sufferage, old age pension/widows & children relief (Social Security), international cooperation, military integration, school integration, separation of church and state, voting and civil rights enforced by Federal mandate over state law, Medicare, OSHA, environmental regulation, abortion choice, laws against sexual discrimination, all the way up to today and gay rights and even global warming (which MITT ROMNEY himself said was real, man-made, and needed addressing).

The "conservative" position (regardless of political party)....eventually lost and the progressive position won.
 
entitlement reform. what needs to be done to reform them will require people having less.

that's certainly not going to come from the lips of liberals

It hasn't COME...yet....has it?

Again, you're talking about hypothetical FUTURE "victories" or even agenda promotion for conservative ideology...note the two qualifiers.


BTW, the last time an entitlement was reform was Social Security in '83 with Reagan working with Tip O'Neil.....and it wasn't "partial privatization", was it??? :smile:
 
It hasn't COME...yet....has it?

Again, you're talking about hypothetical FUTURE "victories"

no I'm not. I cited an issue on which the answer will be less. that point of view will be promoted by conservatives. it will not come from the liberals.

re-read the posts...I was citing an example of 'less' messaging....

at least that was my interpretation of your question
 
no I'm not. I cited an issue on which the answer will be less. that point of view will be promoted by conservatives. it will not come from the liberals.

re-read the posts...I was citing an example of 'less' messaging....

at least that was my interpretation of your question

Depends on one vital...yet always elusive thing, Blank.....a conservative ideological VICTORY on entitlement reform. You haven't gone one yet. Dubya's Domestic Debacle was his 2005 attempt at partial privatization which possibly led to the ousting of the GOP in 2006, but DEFINITELY led to him burning up his post-re-election political "capital" on an issue the majority of Americans OPPOSED.


Let's go MORE recent...Paul Ryan. Major proponent of cutting entitlements (Please, let's not lie to each other and call it "reform". It was about cutting Medicare.)......picked as Romney's Veep....and...

not only lost, but began, after his initial roll-out, to slowly back away from his OWN PLAN for Medicare and had to "explain" his previous positions for full-out abolishment of Social Security and Medicare.
 
Depends on one vital...yet always elusive thing, Blank.....a conservative ideological VICTORY on entitlement reform.

no. it doesn't. nor does it require a label, liberal or conservative. it's Math. which doesn't have politics. We've made obligations we can't possibly keep.

now how the 'less' will be allocated, will most certainly be a political issue.
 
Back
Top