New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Liberal vs. Conservative Values

Yes you do care or you would not have bitched at me for saying the obvious. You need to decide what you want to argue.

you know what? I ran past my post a bit after I wrote that and thought the same thing. In fact I do care from where it eminates.

like in finance there is 'good' debt and 'bad' debt
 
No I just mentioned the known FCSL reality. It is related to the article and does not change the subject so your take on what I said is actually odd. It is a real difference in terms of well-spent money having zip to do with partisan perspective. Look at the budget numbers from the last half century and look at where each side wants money spent. There is no actual savings in equal moneys spent for different causes.

FCSL(?) I know I should know what that stands for, but I don't


but this is exactly my point.

Republicans aren't necessarily conservatives.

there are R initiatives on behalf of which the fed. gov't has allocated resources that would have remained in the private sector were we represented by true conservatives
 
It is not a secret what each side calls for is it. ;)

That is the classic internal tug of war we have been struggling through in politics-and yet they spend like amounts of money.
 
FCSL is Fiscal Conservative Social Liberal. That is what I am. I think moderate republicans get it but moderate republicans are not heard so much. But just speaking in terms of Washington lawmakers where the money gets delegated, you can see by the things they tack onto budgets and conservatives and liberals call for that the reality is like-money gets spent, differently.

My main point is not the moneys conservatives don't want to spend for philosophical differences but where they call to spend that saved money.
 
Here is an example of where the republican party no longer can claim to be the conservative party. Reagan used tax cuts and spending increases to counter the recession that was happening when he took office. The result was that the National Debt tripled. We have done the exact same thing under Obama. While Reagan increased defense spending, he also doubled social spending....

For some reason you think Republicans have not been giving away other people's money. Where do you think republicans stand on farm subsidies? How about Ted Stephens and his "Bridges to Nowhere" spending? That was actually money he was siphoning off to help increase the value of land his buddies owned....but it was also spending that would put people to work (somebody has to build the bridges)....Any comments on the subsidies to oil companies?

Someone should startup a thread to compare conservative policies to republican actions.....
 
As I have mentioned before, I find that being more conservative (based on the non-political definition of the word) has allowed me to be a lot more liberal (also based on the non-political definition of the word) at times.

I don't see them as being mutually exclusive, nor do I see values as something that are to be applied other than universally. A lie, is a lie, is a lie. If something is considered a lie by another when either a "liberal" (politcal definition this time) or a "conservative" (political definition this time) does it, it is still a lie regardless of the poltical affiliation of the liar. Unless application is universal, it negates any value to no value, since it is not universally upheld.

Having credibility is related to the level of hypocrisy one demonstrated. I recognize there are dilemmas and conundrums that leave us no choice, but to be hypocritical, but even recognizing and acknowledging where one has been faced with no good choices provides more credibility than simply being hypocritical and not knowing why or how or ignoring it and not acknowledging it.

The more one admonishes others for their immoralities or lack of values while boasting or intoning of their own or wearing them on their sleeve, the more they open themselves up to additional scrutiny as surely someone who makes so many claims about their higher moral or human values, must also live by them and adhere to them, no?

We are the ones that create the image we want others to expect from us. Certainly I couldn't claim to be perfect and therefore could not expect others to be, but we can ask others how they justify or align their actions with what they claim to beieve in or standfor and let them provide credibility for themselves, in essence, judge themselves.

The more we align the claimed (to others) image of ourselves with our actions, the more we seem to demonstrate we are true to our values and the expectations we set for ourselves for others to expect to see from us.

The more hypocritical we are and the less we align our actions with our claimed "values" the further we get from being credible that what we claim to believe in or value is what we demonstrate by our actions.

We can tell people to expect all kinds of things to expect from us and paint verbally rosy, shiny and virtuous portraits of ourselves. Living up to those expectations is an entirely different thing and a lot more challenging. If we expect perfection in others, shouldn't we at least be as equally perfect?

I think perhaps recognizing or even believing that no human is perfect allows some room to forgive, forget and not sweat the small stuff and when if comes to the big stuff, forgive, but maybe not forget for the purposes of being cautious and wary and in others cases to prevent further tragedy by those who have caused it, by denying them circulation in situations that would increase the risk of their repeating the harm they have already done, forgiven as they might be for that harm. People may have noted that is not dissimilar to our system of justice for the most part and where it is perhaps less perfect, just as the humans that developed and oversee it.

I'm not quite certain how we can believe in 'liberty and justice for all" and not apply it to ALL humanity, not just a limited few on any level. At the same time, freedom is not absolute and when we abuse it, we cannot expect we may not very well lose it or when our "friends" abuse it, they might not very well lose freedom to do what they have abused, but lose it also for people that have not abused it.

Such is the principle and concept of self policing or deterring abuses of freedom based on everyone losing a freedom because only a few abused it. Society or any division of society getting after its own when any one of them abuse freedom is a better way of maintaining freedom than "siding up" and the hypocrisy of an abuse of freedom being wrong, only when the "other side" does it and not being wrong or an abuse of freedom when "our side" does it.

Society breaks down when it divides into sides and each side sees all their acts as their freedom to do as they see fit and any actions that get in the way of that as either too much regulation and intervention or abuses of freedoms.

At one time, groups of people from all sides came together, debated and discussed the conflicts of various people's versions of what they would like to be free to do. Out of those discussions came rules that governed everyone based on mutual agreement and many times, if not always, levels of compromise, but for those actions where there was no conflict in the freedom(s).

Today it seems universal and objective values are out, subjective and a sort of "my "freedoms" are more important than anyone else's" mentality and attitude appears to have become dominant, as well as a rise in hypocrisy and a slow, to quickening rise in the number of people turning away from the hypocritical.

There are remnants of what was a much larger migration to the resurgence of Ayn The Virtues of Selfishness Rand's type of philosphy, which seemed to be a lot more infectious below the level of politics than when taken to a political level because people already hate the politicians they vote for because of their being politicians, but not on what they can do for the people that vote for them. By that, we're no less politicians and political than politicians when it comes to "having principles" while at the same time voting for people we claim don't have any principles. Ironically, politicians seem to be "typical politicians" because they can't get elected unless they promise what they know they cannot necessariy keep as a promise and they have to enough people what they want to hear in order to get elected. That means stretching the stories and in some cases where winning means more than scruples, couth, integrity, ethics, honesty and high values, purposeful lying in order to "win" votes, rather than tell them the truth they may not want to hear and certainly would not vote someone based on, because even if the truth hurts, some people seem to chose their temporary personal pleasure over temporary pain regardless of whether short term pleasure means a build up to a longer term pain and short term pain leads to fewer incidents of future pain.
 
Exactly. We all do. Don't know that sides can ever agree fully on the philosophical aspects of money spent that drives the spending but man I would love politics taken out of it in Washington to find out if they can actually back off on the spending and spend logically to merge the best of both sides. I'm dreaming. ;)
 
FCSL is Fiscal Conservative Social Liberal. That is what I am. I think moderate republicans get it but moderate republicans are not heard so much. But just speaking in terms of Washington lawmakers where the money gets delegated, you can see by the things they tack onto budgets and conservatives and liberals call for that the reality is like-money gets spent, differently.

My main point is not the moneys conservatives don't want to spend for philosophical differences but where they call to spend that saved money.

you wouldn't characterize yourself as a libertarian? (I know you didn't, but FCSL is quite close to a libertarian, no?)

conservatives don't want to spend ANY money. I think you're using 'conservative' in a relative sense or interchangeably with 'republican'.

again, I don't think there are but a handful of conservatives in the entire congress and I certainly know that little if no lawmaking is owned by them
 
"There are remnants of what was a much larger migration to the resurgence of Ayn The Virtues of Selfishness Rand's type of philosphy, which seemed to be a lot more infectious below the level of politics than when taken to a political level because people already hate the politicians they vote for because of their being politicians, but not on what they can do for the people that vote for them."

in my opinion I think your characterization of today's politics relative to the past is through rose colored glasses. Not sure if you saw the movie "Lincoln" but what struck me was the raw partisanship that was exhibited. And those guys went after each other. I'm assuming of course that it was a realistic portrayal.

and I quoted the part of your piece cited above to take issue with your choice of the words:

"but not on what they can do for the people that vote for them."

today's career politician rarely does 'for' anyone. they do 'to' others to win the next election.

but an interesting reflection overall
 
No not agreed. Too many things left out of the liberal argument. Both have their arguments stated in ways that over simplified the subjects they are meant to address.
 
Again, Blank....you claim "no difference" in the parties. Yet...can we assume you voted Republican in the last national election??? Or did you abstain from voting in protest?

I'm sure you'll assume anything you want.

I go back and forth depending on the threat assessment.

Sometimes I vote ideology sometimes my vote is strictly mercenary, sometimes as you note I sit it out.

I held my nose and voted for Romney.
 
It is more a combination of old moderate republican and democrat fiscal responsibility and moderate democrats attention to social issues that are necessary. I am not at all like a Libertarian as they seem unrealistic even on the fiscal side of things and impossible on the social side. It appears to me Conservatives don't want any money spent when there is a democrat President as seen by the wild spending without protest when Bush was in office. That part is just politics. I agree with your take on few fiscal conservatives currently but I'll add that the ones that are seem to be whacky the other way. By and large republican and conservative is interchangeable as that is who they dance to in Washington. That is just my take on it. You'll probably disagree but it gives you a peek at another perspective.
 
in my opinion I think your characterization of today's politics relative to the past is through rose colored glasses. Not sure if you saw the movie "Lincoln" but what struck me was the raw partisanship that was exhibited. And those guys went after each other. I'm assuming of course that it was a realistic portrayal.

and I quoted the part of your piece cited above to take issue with your choice of the words:

"but not on what they can do for the people that vote for them."

today's career politician rarely does 'for' anyone. they do 'to' others to win the next election.

but an interesting reflection overall

They got things done in those days BBB, even if they went to war to do so and the nation and humanity came out better at least in one way, unless you would like to disagree and suggest that some humans should be able to own other humans and those humans should have no rights accorded human beings.

You might also note how some "conservatives" feel that Lincoln would not be nominated to be President by the current RNC.

When a "people" are kidnapped from one's home, sailed across an ocean to be traded on an auction block and denied education and all the tools one needs to survive outside a slavery relationship over a period of centuries, there is some catching up to do when suddenly put in charge of one's own freedom. It's in many ways like giving birth to a baby in the woods, walking away and expecting them to "fend for themselves" believing that because they are human beings, they naturally have that capacity and to help them would actually be to make them dependent upon us, NOT actually help them become MORE INDEPENDENT because they learned skills they otherwise would not have learned without parents or their society willing to help them.

How many slaves in the south were white? How many were the offspring of plantation owners or any other whites, sold to other human beings for profit?

While you might think a little BBB, you do not appear to do very much extensive thought, nor reciprocal or two way thinking. Introspection also seems to elude you. You seem to think all people should see the world through your eyes rather than you trying to see the world through anyone else's eyes.

I find it quite interesting you claim Ayn Rand as a heroine at the same time you claim to be a Christian.
 
Back
Top