New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Looking forward to the debates.

Arkady

President
Here's a strong piece arguing why Romney could still win:

http://www.salon.com/2012/09/20/four_reasons_mitt_still_might_win/

Particularly interesting is the bit about the upcoming debates. I think a lot of liberals just take it for granted that Obama will mop the floor with Romney in the debates, but that's not a clearly merited conclusion. Romney isn't George W. Bush -- so dumb as to require remote control when forced to speak without a script:

http://www.salon.com/2004/10/09/bulge/

He's a relaxed and often fluent speaker, who memorizes talking points reasonably well, and has a CEO's skill at segueing to such talking points without too much awkwardness. He more or less held his own against Ted Kennedy back in the day, and he was unmistakably the most presidential of the Republican debaters during the primaries. He's probably about a natural 6 on a scale of one to 10, but he's gotten a lot of practice in the last year, so he might be capable of a 7.

Obama isn't a bad debater, but he's not great, either. I think Hillary Clinton beat up on him pretty convincingly, to the point that the Obama people were relieved there weren't enough debates scheduled for her to use them to pull ahead in 2008. Obama is bright and articulate, but can be slow and a bit off-putting when he doesn't have a rehearsed speech to deliver. He also doesn't seem to have the facts as close at hand as he should (like, say, Bill Clinton, who sometimes seems to have a Google port installed in his head, when responding to questions where specific facts will be useful). I'd say Obama's also a natural 6 on a scale from one to 10, but out of practice, so he might be capable of a 5.

The saving grace, from a Democratic perspective, is that Romney has painted himself into some bizarre corners, with his various flip-flops and intellectually unsupportable positions, which ups the degree of difficulty for him a lot. He'll need to be able to respond to criticisms in ways that don't create obvious openings for using his own words against him, assuming Obama does the hard work of memorizing those words and keeping them at hand, for such use. He is also defending a lot of positions he presumably doesn't believe (since they contradict his previous positions), which means he'll always be running the risk of sounding phony, where Obama can speak more from the heart. Obama has flip-flopped, too, but not typically in ways that Romney will be positioned to criticize, since Obama flopped to the center, while Romney flopped to the far right.

Overall, I think Obama will be able to score close but convincing victories, but I don't consider it a slam dunk the way I saw, say, Biden over Palin, or Clinton over Dole.
 
It's not over....Romney COULD still win.

But given his "trajectory" the Debates WILL have to be the place where he wins it.

The Romney flip-flops are the Achilles heel...especially things like his recently saying he liked "parts of Obamacare". Which undercuts his own claim that he'd "repeal it". Plus he can offer NO specifics on deductions or loopholes that he'll "get rid of" in his tax plan.
 
I recall the time though when Pres. Obama met with House Repubs at one of their retreats and they thought they were gonna whip up on him. Didn't happen. He went in prepared and didn't have a teleprompter and better than held his own debating a roomful of House Repubs. They haven't invited him to do that since then. Willard's competition in the GOP debates wasn't that good and they still managed to bait him.
 
First, I do not think that Hillary Clinton beat up on Obama in the debates (with the possible exception of Pennsylvania). But I think that reflects the fact that I was an Obama supporter and you were a Clinton supporter. That said, I think that Obama's debate performances against McCain were better than his performances against Clinton. He did improve. So based on past performances I would give him a grade of 7 rather than a grade of 6. As to how "rusty" he is, I talked to degsme about this in another thread. I think that it is possible that he is a little rusty but I don't expect that to be a big problem. He has had to do plenty of news conferences and is used to answering questions on complex issues. I also think that he will be very well prepared and has probably been waiting for a year to debate Romney on these questions. I also suspect that he will come with a command of facts/numbers and common sense that he will copy from Clinton. So I think that it is as likely that he would rise to an 8 as fall to a 6.

I would agree that Romney is about a 6. However, he did have a couple of terrible debates (particularly South Carolina). I do not think that Romney dominated the debates. (If he had, the race would have been over quicker than it was.) He held his own against a pretty weak field. He won the nomination because he had a lot more money than anyone else in my opinion. I didn't see him debate Ted Kennedy so I have no opinion on that.

I do think that if the first debate ends in a draw that that redounds to Obama's advantage. So I think that there is more pressure on Romney. Obama is very competitive and I think that he is more experienced than you might think. I think that he will not underestimate Romney and will not overestimate his own abilities. I will not go for a knockout. He will go into each of the six segments (rounds) attempting to win each segment on points. Romney may try to go for a knockout and leave himself open to counterpunching. (I do think that Obama is a good counterpuncher.)

But, I think that your basic message is useful and important. A debate rout or an election victory is far from guaranteed. It is something that you never take for granted. You do not stop competing until the fat lady sings on November 6. The best way to insure a victory is to work to make the margin of victory as large as possible.


Here's a strong piece arguing why Romney could still win:

http://www.salon.com/2012/09/20/four_reasons_mitt_still_might_win/

Particularly interesting is the bit about the upcoming debates. I think a lot of liberals just take it for granted that Obama will mop the floor with Romney in the debates, but that's not a clearly merited conclusion. Romney isn't George W. Bush -- so dumb as to require remote control when forced to speak without a script:

http://www.salon.com/2004/10/09/bulge/

He's a relaxed and often fluent speaker, who memorizes talking points reasonably well, and has a CEO's skill at segueing to such talking points without too much awkwardness. He more or less held his own against Ted Kennedy back in the day, and he was unmistakably the most presidential of the Republican debaters during the primaries. He's probably about a natural 6 on a scale of one to 10, but he's gotten a lot of practice in the last year, so he might be capable of a 7.

Obama isn't a bad debater, but he's not great, either. I think Hillary Clinton beat up on him pretty convincingly, to the point that the Obama people were relieved there weren't enough debates scheduled for her to use them to pull ahead in 2008. Obama is bright and articulate, but can be slow and a bit off-putting when he doesn't have a rehearsed speech to deliver. He also doesn't seem to have the facts as close at hand as he should (like, say, Bill Clinton, who sometimes seems to have a Google port installed in his head, when responding to questions where specific facts will be useful). I'd say Obama's also a natural 6 on a scale from one to 10, but out of practice, so he might be capable of a 5.

The saving grace, from a Democratic perspective, is that Romney has painted himself into some bizarre corners, with his various flip-flops and intellectual unsupportable positions, which ups the degree of difficulty for him a lot. He'll need to be able to respond to criticisms in ways that don't create obvious openings for using his own words against him, assuming Obama does the hard work of memorizing those words and keeping them at hand, for such use. He is also defending a lot of positions he presumably doesn't believe (since they contradict his previous positions), which means he'll always be running the risk of sounding phony, where Obama can speak more from the heart. Obama has flip-flopped, too, but not typically in ways that Romney will be positioned to criticize, since Obama flopped to the center, while Romney flopped to the far right.

Overall, I think Obama will be able to score close but convincing victories, but I don't consider it a slam dunk the way I saw, say, Biden over Palin, or Clinton over Dole.
 
Obama's best bet is to go in to the debates with enough of a lead to force Romney to be the aggressor. If Romney has to play the part of the rabid Republican attack dog, while Obama looks calm and presidential, Romney could do more harm than good for himself. As things stand today, Obama could afford to play it cool, which is his natural game.
 
I completely disagree. Never before has Mutt stepped on the stage bearing so many crosses, and there's nary an issue to be covered in them that BHO won't have completely covered.

Furthermore, unlike with Hillary, and too some extent the "moderate" Mutt against Kennedy, the ideological divide between them on domestic issues is quite stark, and what Mutt is proposing, a proven and easily demostratable failure. ANd on foreign policy? Don't make me laugh.

As BD argued, he mopped the floor with a roomful of repugs at the Baltimore Beatdown, and that to some extent is the reason why -- they had nothing. Between the fabricated BHO Mutt is running against, and the failure or unacceptability of what he's proposing -- the "Ryan Plan" basically -- those examples are an apple and oranges comparison imo, because there wasn't near the ideological separation between the combatants as is there will be between those two. ANd the idea that Mutt won't be taken to task over the many lies is a questionable assumption. If I was BHO, I'd be hammering his integrity at every available opportunity, and the idea that BHO, who had his boiling blood "built" by Mutt, and isn't acutely aware of all of the "biggies" he's spewed that got it boiling, would be another assumption I wouldn't make.

I'd say you're grossly overestimating what Mutt can do with lies, BS, and his econ plans, and grossly underestimating BHO's ability to exploit them as energetically and devastatingly as they can be.

We'll see.
 
I really hope you're right, Mytzlplk. Obama will be somewhat hamstrung, I'm sure, by the debate format. If the past is any indication, the debate rules will make those events more like joint press conferences than like a genuine debate. The candidates will be asked canned, predictable questions by the moderators, from which they can transition quickly to vaguely relevant portions of their stump speeches, with little follow-up, and no real ability for the candidates to challenge each other. Romney has positioned himself in such a way that he'd be absolute toast in a real debate, because there are a million ways an opponent could make him look absurd simply by asking some direct questions and preventing him from squirming out of them. But it won't be a real debate, so Obama's job will be tougher -- he can't, for example, just use the Socratic method to walk Romney over one of the countless landmines he's buried around himself. Instead, he'll need to seize on specific things Romney says in his answers,then come up with specific facts that demolish those things, and put the two together in a way that's snappy and clear enough for the average moron watching the debate to grasp, all on the fly. That takes a particular kind of brain power that I'm not sure Obama has. I don't mean that to sound as insulting as it probably does. I have an enormously high opinion of my own intelligence, but I also lack that kind of brain power that's needed to take down an opponent like Romney in a setting like a "joint press conference" debate. You need to be very quick-thinking, verbally clever, and have incredible recall. Plus, you need to have done your homework, to memorize all the material you might need. I hope Obama proves to have that kind of intelligence. We'll see.
 
Obama's best bet is to go in to the debates with enough of a lead to force Romney to be the aggressor. If Romney has to play the part of the rabid Republican attack dog, while Obama looks calm and presidential, Romney could do more harm than good for himself. As things stand today, Obama could afford to play it cool, which is his natural game.

THAT's the key.

A possible scenario---

Romney, in the FIRST debate, gets into the mind-set of "Okay. Okay. Gotta make a BIG impression in this one to get the campaign out of the doldrums since September. Really go after Obama, fire up the base, show Moderates and Indies I can be 'tough'. Hammer him hard!".....and comes off looking like a deranged lunatic....or Rush Limbaugh.....(or is that being redundant? :) )....and the President plays it cool?

Mitt's screwed.

The 2nd debate, he'll be told by his advisors to "calm down"....and he'll try to be "warm and friendly" (as warm and friendly as his programming allows him) and it'll come off TEPID and WEAK and again the President will look "Presidential".

Then you hit the 3rd debate on foreign policy....and Romney would be coached "Okay, the warm and friendly thing didn't work....hit Obama HARD on Libya and Egypt and the Middle East. Attack him for the embassy deaths, etc.".....and it comes off as BOTH a repeat performance of his "Rush to the microphones" blunder on Libya a few weeks ago.....and a repeat of "Romney the rabid attack dog" of the 1st Debate.


Will that happen? Maybe not....but it's a trap Romney will HAVE to avoid.
 
I completely disagree. Never before has Mutt stepped on the stage bearing so many crosses, and there's nary an issue to be covered in them that BHO won't have completely covered.

Furthermore, unlike with Hillary, and too some extent the "moderate" Mutt against Kennedy, the ideological divide between them on domestic issues is quite stark, and what Mutt is proposing, a proven and easily demostratable failure. ANd on foreign policy? Don't make me laugh.

As BD argued, he mopped the floor with a roomful of repugs at the Baltimore Beatdown, and that to some extent is the reason why -- they had nothing. Between the fabricated BHO Mutt is running against, and the failure or unacceptability of what he's proposing -- the "Ryan Plan" basically -- those examples are an apple and oranges comparison imo, because there wasn't near the ideological separation between the combatants as is there will be between those two. ANd the idea that Mutt won't be taken to task over the many lies is a questionable assumption. If I was BHO, I'd be hammering his integrity at every available opportunity, and the idea that BHO, who had his boiling blood "built" by Mutt, and isn't acutely aware of all of the "biggies" he's spewed that got it boiling, would be another assumption I wouldn't make.

I'd say you're grossly overestimating what Mutt can do with lies, BS, and his econ plans, and grossly underestimating BHO's ability to exploit them as energetically and devastatingly as they can be.

We'll see.

I have to go with you on this one. I was a Hillary supporter and did not see Hillary mop the floor.
As we have already seen. Mitt is good when he is with his own kind. He is awkward as heck when he is with the simple folk.(That is you and I,whether you like it or not.)

Mitt was a CEO who you did not dare question. Being President or running for office is a whole different ball game.

One question here, if Romney held his own with Kennedy why did Kennedy win?
 
I really hope you're right, Mytzlplk. Obama will be somewhat hamstrung, I'm sure, by the debate format. If the past is any indication, the debate rules will make those events more like joint press conferences than like a genuine debate. The candidates will be asked canned, predictable questions by the moderators, from which they can transition quickly to vaguely relevant portions of their stump speeches, with little follow-up, and no real ability for the candidates to challenge each other. Romney has positioned himself in such a way that he'd be absolute toast in a real debate, because there are a million ways an opponent could make him look absurd simply by asking some direct questions and preventing him from squirming out of them. But it won't be a real debate, so Obama's job will be tougher -- he can't, for example, just use the Socratic method to walk Romney over one of the countless landmines he's buried around himself. Instead, he'll need to seize on specific things Romney says in his answers,then come up with specific facts that demolish those things, and put the two together in a way that's snappy and clear enough for the average moron watching the debate to grasp, all on the fly. That takes a particular kind of brain power that I'm not sure Obama has. I don't mean that to sound as insulting as it probably does. I have an enormously high opinion of my own intelligence, but I also lack that kind of brain power that's needed to take down an opponent like Romney in a setting like a "joint press conference" debate. You need to be very quick-thinking, verbally clever, and have incredible recall. Plus, you need to have done your homework, to memorize all the material you might need. I hope Obama proves to have that kind of intelligence. We'll see.

I cannot wait to hear Kathy Crawley,(Crowley), ask the questions:eek:)
 
I know what you're saying about the limitations of the format kind -- it's not like the adversarial debate we engage in here (well, assuming the rightwingers weren't the dodgeboys, etc they usually are) but mostly because of the time element. But, one thing I had as an afterthought that I see as a potential flaw in your reasoning, is basing his potential now on past performances, both because it fails to account for his growth, as well as the nature and character of his opposition then and now. He's grown in many ways intellectually I'm sure since Hillary, and been seasoned by the many defamations from Romney, all of which if the scuttlebutt is correct, he's taken personally. Any questions dealing with that material, he will no doubt know Romney's positition ("positions" in some cases) as well as his own, whereas Mutt will be handicapped by the positions of the BHO he created. Many of these things, like "built that", "apology tour", and even the non-defamatory kind dealing with policy differences, like the efficacy of tax cuts for the rich in terms of job creations, Medicare/SS, etc, are all common knowledge by now, and it doesn't take "total recall" to cite the now common knowledge and skewering fact checkers have done to Mutt's proclamations about BHO on a wide range of issues. All BHO has to do is "compare and contrast" his real record with that of the imaginary BHO and Mutt's, like "Thank you for your input into that socialistic Obamacare, but I don't understand why you want to repeal it now."

ANd what makes Mutt particularly vulnerable to BHO weaving all that into his responses -- which would hardly qualify as an intellectual equivalent of a Herculean task -- is that there's nary an issue from SS/Medicare, taxes, hell, all things domestic whether fiscal or dealing with social wedge issues, where BHO doesn't already enjoy majority support. Mutt on the other hand, is selling what I'm sure BHO is fully aware of, "Bush on steroids" across the policy board, and will frame it as such. Again, all BHO has to do is respond to Mutt's BS with "Again, my adversary wants to return to the failed policies of the past, and compound those failures with policy proposals flowing from the same pool of ideas.". He can hammer him all night long on that for what it is and the diff message and policy pursuits between the two it results in -- the stark contrast I wrote about previously -- which is basically Mutt's "me me!" meme, as opposed to BHO's "we we" one.

And as far as the "optics" of it all, given that all of this basically puts Mutt on the defensive before he even opens his mouth, and BHO's script has pretty much been handed to him, if anyone is gonna get their dander up due to frustrations stemming from civil smartasshood (which I think BHO can excel at over a robot like Mutt) or a lack of history and the facts not being kind to them, It will be Romney. This will be particularly precarious ground for him, because he no doubt is torn between satisfying the blood lust of his base base, and awareness of the traps and pitfalls of revisiting any of the numerous defamations he's leveled against BHO that would lead to his being knocked the [Unwelcome language removed] out.

I think you underestimate BHO and yourself dude, largely because you're focusing on past performances wherein many factors that will be present in this battle were absent. The ideological line between what BHO has attempted in the past as pres and proposes for the future couldn't be brighter or wider between he and Mutt (well, given the faux duopoly nature of much of DC politics today), which wasn't the case in BHO's previous battles, despite the many things on which they agree. And Mutt is proposing, and then some, what was already rejected four years ago. He knows this, which is why his campaign so far has been nothing but an exercise in lying by omission with his "just trust me" BS. And BHO is too, which is why "the differences" has figured so prominently in his efforts to date. This means that Romney is gonna be totally unarmed without his quiver full of "apologizing for america, socialist, etc" defamations, and left with selling what has already been rejected by most of us. I don't see the outcome being determined by quickness of wit or sharpness of thought, but rather the exploitation and repetition of what much/most of the viewing audience is already aware of.

None of this is something BHO "has to learn or be prepared for", he's lived it. Quite frankly arky, I'll be extremely surprised if they look like anything other than the professor lecturing a student barely able to hide their petulance they've already displayed in vast quantities as everyone knows, before the lecture began. As I understand it, but perhaps I'm wrong, you're an attorney. Even if you aren't, you're surely intelligent enough, based on my reading of your work here, to understand that the successful prosecution of any case depends heavily if not exclusively on the evidence submitted and the credility of the witnesses that supply it. A chronically flip-flopping liar peddling refurbished widgets from the warehouse of failed ideas and policies has a heavy if not insurmountable burden when trying to convince the jury that they are really "new and improved" widgets fresh off the production line, and aren't guilty of fraud.

The case is so easy, I'd bet you could stomp the Mutt, because he's the best witness your prosecution of him could hope for.
 
indeed mary, Mutt outstupiding/lying his opposition is hardly a measure of his talents in a debate where such ngarbage can be challenged, and easily so.

I've never watched the debate between him and Kennedy, but as noted, that as I recall was the "moderate" Mutt that was much closer to Kennedy ideologically and policy proposal-wise than he is with BHO now. He also likely didn't have a trail of defamations behind him of the size or of the common knowledge kind either he can be made to defend.

He's not been running against BHO, but rather a bizarro world-like caricature of him. It's real easy to punch something like that, as opposed to the real deal that will punch back
 
This is an interesting discussion. It will be interesting to revisit the discussion after the first debate.

Here are a few additional thoughts:

Both the Romney and Obama teams are formulating game plans for the series of debates and for each individual debate. Both of these teams have a sense of the strengths and weaknesses of the respective candidates. They also understand the debate formats and the sort of game plan that works in the context of those formats. I think that all of us are really focused on these three things (debate format, strengths and weaknesses of the primaries, and respective game plans).

Personally, I think that Romney does not respect Obama or Obama's ability and is a bit arrogant. I think that in his own mind, he thinks that he is going to wipe the floor with Obama. I actually went back and watched a bit of the Romney/Kennedy debates and understand where Arkady is coming from on that score. Romney actually respected Kennedy. I think that he disdains Obama. (He actually believes the rhetoric that gets spouted by some of our rightie pals on PJ on Obama being incompetent and a total failure.) To tell you the truth, I thought that Romney had the same disdainful attitude toward his debate opponents in the primaries and it got him into trouble. His opponents periodically got under his skin and he became non-plussed.

Relatedly, I think that Romney can choose to follow one of two strategies. He can try to debate John Huntsman style (as he did against Ted Kennedy) or he can try to debate Donald Trump style or can try to do a mix of those two styles. Unfortunately for Romney he is not as good as Huntsman in Huntsman style and he is not as good as Trump in Trump style. And he is not talented enough to switch between the two styles. (Newt Gingrich is much better at switching styles. Mitt is not Newt in this respect.) If Romney follows Huntsman style, I think that the debates might be a draw (though I tend to think Obama would win on points.) If Romney decides to go the Trump style, I think that Obama will be able to counterpunch viciously. (I remember how Obama eviscerated Trump at the Washington news gala right before OBL was killed.)

As I said, I think that Obama respects Romney as a dangerous opponent. He does not underestimate him. I think that he will be conditioned to spar ably over the six segments of the debate.

Nevertheless, you never quite know what Romney will do or what he is capable of. But if Romney follows either the Huntsman or the Trump game plan outlined above, I think that Obama will be well-prepared (which is all that you can really expect.)

I know what you're saying about the limitations of the format kind -- it's not like the adversarial debate we engage in here (well, assuming the rightwingers weren't the dodgeboys, etc they usually are) but mostly because of the time element. But, one thing I had as an afterthought that I see as a potential flaw in your reasoning, is basing his potential now on past performances, both because it fails to account for his growth, as well as the nature and character of his opposition then and now. He's grown in many ways intellectually I'm sure since Hillary, and been seasoned by the many defamations from Romney, all of which if the scuttlebutt is correct, he's taken personally. Any questions dealing with that material, he will no doubt know Romney's positition ("positions" in some cases) as well as his own, whereas Mutt will be handicapped by the positions of the BHO he created. Many of these things, like "built that", "apology tour", and even the non-defamatory kind dealing with policy differences, like the efficacy of tax cuts for the rich in terms of job creations, Medicare/SS, etc, are all common knowledge by now, and it doesn't take "total recall" to cite the now common knowledge and skewering fact checkers have done to Mutt's proclamations about BHO on a wide range of issues. All BHO has to do is "compare and contrast" his real record with that of the imaginary BHO and Mutt's, like "Thank you for your input into that socialistic Obamacare, but I don't understand why you want to repeal it now."

ANd what makes Mutt particularly vulnerable to BHO weaving all that into his responses -- which would hardly qualify as an intellectual equivalent of a Herculean task -- is that there's nary an issue from SS/Medicare, taxes, hell, all things domestic whether fiscal or dealing with social wedge issues, where BHO doesn't already enjoy majority support. Mutt on the other hand, is selling what I'm sure BHO is fully aware of, "Bush on steroids" across the policy board, and will frame it as such. Again, all BHO has to do is respond to Mutt's BS with "Again, my adversary wants to return to the failed policies of the past, and compound those failures with policy proposals flowing from the same pool of ideas.". He can hammer him all night long on that for what it is and the diff message and policy pursuits between the two it results in -- the stark contrast I wrote about previously -- which is basically Mutt's "me me!" meme, as opposed to BHO's "we we" one.

And as far as the "optics" of it all, given that all of this basically puts Mutt on the defensive before he even opens his mouth, and BHO's script has pretty much been handed to him, if anyone is gonna get their dander up due to frustrations stemming from civil smartasshood (which I think BHO can excel at over a robot like Mutt) or a lack of history and the facts not being kind to them, It will be Romney. This will be particularly precarious ground for him, because he no doubt is torn between satisfying the blood lust of his base base, and awareness of the traps and pitfalls of revisiting any of the numerous defamations he's leveled against BHO that would lead to his being knocked the <img src=images/smilies/animated/censored.gif> out.

I think you underestimate BHO and yourself dude, largely because you're focusing on past performances wherein many factors that will be present in this battle were absent. The ideological line between what BHO has attempted in the past as pres and proposes for the future couldn't be brighter or wider between he and Mutt (well, given the faux duopoly nature of much of DC politics today), which wasn't the case in BHO's previous battles, despite the many things on which they agree. And Mutt is proposing, and then some, what was already rejected four years ago. He knows this, which is why his campaign so far has been nothing but an exercise in lying by omission with his "just trust me" BS. And BHO is too, which is why "the differences" has figured so prominently in his efforts to date. This means that Romney is gonna be totally unarmed without his quiver full of "apologizing for america, socialist, etc" defamations, and left with selling what has already been rejected by most of us. I don't see the outcome being determined by quickness of wit or sharpness of thought, but rather the exploitation and repetition of what much/most of the viewing audience is already aware of.

None of this is something BHO "has to learn or be prepared for", he's lived it. Quite frankly arky, I'll be extremely surprised if they look like anything other than the professor lecturing a student barely able to hide their petulance they've already displayed in vast quantities as everyone knows, before the lecture began. As I understand it, but perhaps I'm wrong, you're an attorney. Even if you aren't, you're surely intelligent enough, based on my reading of your work here, to understand that the successful prosecution of any case depends heavily if not exclusively on the evidence submitted and the credility of the witnesses that supply it. A chronically flip-flopping liar peddling refurbished widgets from the warehouse of failed ideas and policies has a heavy if not insurmountable burden when trying to convince the jury that they are really "new and improved" widgets fresh off the production line, and aren't guilty of fraud.

The case is so easy, I'd bet you could stomp the Mutt, because he's the best witness your prosecution of him could hope for.
 
It will be interesting to see the "salesman" and the "lawyer" debate and which Americans find more convincing.

I never see anything as a slam dunk and I agree that Mr. Obama does not seem to hit on what seem like the obvious, although I have seen signs recently that he's right on target.

I would hope that Mr. Obama would remain serious and even though he will not control the questions, keep hammering away in question form at Mr. Romney and his supporters as to how their platform adds up? Ask them how they can place such high importance on less government, less government spending, then complain how the government is not creating jobs? Ask Mr. Romney how cutting budgets that include cutting employees, helps the employment rate. Ask him if cuts are to "save" money where has all the saved money gone? Ask him if unemployed Americans pay income taxes. Ask him about HINT (High Income No Taxes) Ask him about American companies hiring foreign labor helps the American economy and employment rate.

Present Mr. Romney with a simple math problem. If more Americans are unemployed, underemployed, paid less, offered fewer benefits, how do they consume to the rate needed to keep up with required growth (population growth)? How do they pay income taxes, how do they put food on the table? Do Americans who pocket the savings from cutting budgets and cutting wages and benefits and firing Americans (hiring foreigners or not) merely want all those people to go without assistance until they can find employment that supports them and their families?

Ask Mr. Romney if his feeling is that the unemployed should simply be cut loose to fend for themselves anyway they can and ask him if he believes that what he feels is likely to happen to the crime rate and/or the burden upon not-for-profit charities?

So far as I can tell, Mr. Romney will not be able to avoid tangling himself in a web of his own making. Take away the half truths and include whole truths and while both will be put on the spot, I believe Romney will have a much harder time coming up with credible answers and ARITHMETIC than Mr. Obama. The other important thing will be the moderators and the questions they put forth.

I have been discouraged for a long time by the failure of so many to ask what I've always felt should be obvious questions, but apparently are not obvious as they are rarely asked), but I more recently have been encouraged by people asking those questions of the candidates and not letting them talk past them or around them completely ignoring a direct reponse.

I'd like to see Mr. Obama ask Mr. Romney to "clarify" his intended "meaning" from the 47% tape and why Mr. Romney didn't further specify who of the 47% he spoke of did not pay income taxes and why and discuss the cut off for income tax at the lower end and tax credits and who from a political party standpoint, was involved in setting those limits and amounts.

I would drive home questions about how one increases defense spending (government spending) cuts in revenue to pay for that increased spending, then complains about deficit spending and the size of the national debt.

Maybe Romney has some magic up his sleeve, I don't know.
 
Obama will come prepared but we should never take things for granted.

I've seen Obama in some off situations where he just can't get the words but in this first debate October 3rd on the economy, he has had war against those issues already.

However Romney will come in hoping he can keep his flip flops straight and that doesn't leave you with a clear head.

Go Obama!
 
THAT's the key.

A possible scenario---

Romney, in the FIRST debate, gets into the mind-set of "Okay. Okay. Gotta make a BIG impression in this one to get the campaign out of the doldrums since September. Really go after Obama, fire up the base, show Moderates and Indies I can be 'tough'. Hammer him hard!".....and comes off looking like a deranged lunatic....or Rush Limbaugh.....(or is that being redundant? :) )....and the President plays it cool?

Mitt's screwed.

The 2nd debate, he'll be told by his advisors to "calm down"....and he'll try to be "warm and friendly" (as warm and friendly as his programming allows him) and it'll come off TEPID and WEAK and again the President will look "Presidential".

Then you hit the 3rd debate on foreign policy....and Romney would be coached "Okay, the warm and friendly thing didn't work....hit Obama HARD on Libya and Egypt and the Middle East. Attack him for the embassy deaths, etc.".....and it comes off as BOTH a repeat performance of his "Rush to the microphones" blunder on Libya a few weeks ago.....and a repeat of "Romney the rabid attack dog" of the 1st Debate.


Will that happen? Maybe not....but it's a trap Romney will HAVE to avoid.

Gordon, your sequence of the three debates and how you think they might go sounds EERILY similar to the sequence of three debates that Al Gore had with George W. Bush back in 2000. Al Gore blew his campaign in those three debates. In the first debate, Al Gore had an 'aggressive' approach to Bush that consisted of trying to make it look as though debating George was actually beneath him. You remember the exaggerated sighing by Al, as though he thought he was debating an idiot. [He was, but that's beside the point.] The American public CLEARLY didn't like this facet of Al Gore's personality---he seemed like the know-it-all kid that everybody loathed back in high school---so his advisers told him to adopt a very different approach in the second debate.

In the second debate, which had both Al and George sitting at a table with the interviewer, Al was all 'agreeable' with George. After George would say something, Al would respond: "Well, I agree with that, for the most part, but we have one small difference on...." Al seemed to have a very different PERSONALITY in the second debate, which left the public confused as to who the real Al Gore was. So, again, his advisers said, no, no, NO! You can't do that. You need to really CHALLENGE him in the third debate!

And boy howdy, did Al do that. In that third debate, which had Al and George both walking around a stage while taking questions, Al was actually INVADING George's personal space. It was downright weird. Even though the stage was large, Al was getting to within a foot or so of George, and it was making BOTH George and the audience uncomfortable.

Al Gore seemed to reveal three different personalities in those three debates, and some of the public was wondering if he might actually be schizophrenic. THAT'S why he lost an election that shouldn't have even been close.

If Mitt Rmoney reveals three different personalities in these debates, while Mr. Obama remains the cool, calm, and collected Commander-in-Chief that he is, it's over. Obama in a landslide.

Al Gore was not comfortable in his own skin back in 2000. [He really is, today.] I don't think Mitt Rmoney is comfortable in his own skin. He is one of the most AWKWARD candidates I have ever seen. His laughter seems forced, almost robotic. It's enough to make you truly wonder if he is an android.

I think that is what Americans will see in these debates. A very likeable, confident, and competent leader (Obama) versus a man who all too often behaves like you would expect a robot to behave.
 
I am an attorney, but not a trial lawyer. I could stomp him well in a real debate, where I could keep picking at him in a Socratic manner until it was obvious how incoherent his positions were. But in a stylized "debate" like the ones they'll actually be doing, I'm not so sure. In those, you effectively get one crack at each vulnerability of your opponent. That's not great for my style, and I'm not yet convinced Obama has that specialized skill, either.

For example, if someone accused me of apologizing for America, I'd tear that down well if I got several swipes at it. First I could demand to know exactly which comments he considered inappropriate, then, once I'd nailed down the specifics (rather than allowing a vague critique), I could explain why the comments were appropriate, and I could cite similar comments from Republican heroes like Reagan, and I could ask whether he thinks those people were wrongly apologizing for America, too. Assuming he wouldn't just say yes, but would instead try to draw some intellectually dishonest distinction between the two, I could poke holes in the reasoning underlying that distinction, making it clear to the audience that the only distinction he really cares about is that one was a Republican and one a Democrat. But that approach doesn't work if I basically just get one thirty second rebuttal. With that limitation, all I could do is respond with a vague rebuttal and counterattack to his vague attack, which will play fine with those who already supported me, but isn't going to convert anyone.

I think the handcuffs for these kinds of debates are particularly frustrating when going after a flip-flopper, since flip-floppers are particularly vulnerable to follow-up questioning. Basically, you want to nail down why they changed their mind, exactly, and your further attacks are dictated by their excuses. Romney could be reduced to a pool of quivering jelly with about five follow-up questions about his position in healthcare reform, but not with a single 30-second rebuttal.
 
I was thinking that, too. Gore tromped Bush badly on the facts, and polling suggested he won all three debates, but they actually hurt his overall polling numbers, because he came across as weird and unlikeable. In the first debate, especially, he came across looking well-informed and well-prepared for the presidency, and made Bush look like an amateur, but Bush looked like a likeable amateur, while Gore looked like someone who could barely contain his contempt -- like a know-it-all jerk who isn't quite as smart as he thinks he is.
 
An analogy of Romney to Gore-2000, isn't completely false.

Remember, Gore did the big "Tipper lip-lock" to try to break his image as "stiff and emotionless" at the DNC Convention.....just as they trotted out all those folks and ANN to try to break the image of Romney as "stiff and elitist" at the RNC Convention.

Both were silver-spooners. Both had fathers in politics, but who never made it to "The Show". Both were wonkish. Both had rivals that were the "kind of guy you'd want to have a beer with"...while they were not. Both had difficulty "getting traction" off the past four years (Gore for Clinton's success...Romney for the slowly recovering economy).

Unfortunately for Romney, President Obama isn't the drugstore cowboy of Dubya....he's got charm AND brains.
 
I used to think Romney was more principled and there seemed a discernable pushback by him to resist sinking to the depths we have seen politics have sunk to with regard to negativity and "truths" that push the limits of credibility if not cross over the line into the category of blatant lies.

I have seen and it could be my imagination, Mr. Romney succumb to what appears to be coaching and coaching that has told him if we wants to win, he has to act totally sincere (an oxymoron) about what you are trying to sell. If people will remember, Mr. Romney was, in the past described as being a lot more awkward and a lot more frequently than he is now. That means he has taken to his acting lessons and/or come to actually believe them to the point of a real sincerity. It is difficult for me to believe someone who heads up a multi-billion or multi-million dollar business can be so clueless about so much and having grown up in a Republican family and having many Republican friends, I have long had insight into how some operate. This does not mean people from other politcal parties do not act in equal ways, it means I have a personal insight into how some of Mr. Romney's party act with regard to promoting and profiting themselves. Others of other parties might do the same, but I think one is able to test where people are coming from by testing the validity of their claims.

Romney seems to have abandoned most or all of his principles to move himself forward and no holds barred on the theory that in the past, many, perhaps most Americans will not bother to check into the details of what any candidates say. Look how America responded to 9/11 and to WMD in Iraq. 15 of the 19 hijackers on 9/11 were Saudi Arabians, there was no connection between Al qaeda and Iraq, but where was the most money spent on "fighting terrorism" spend in the last decade? George W. Bush "won" the 2000 election by a single SCOTUS justice's vote. He won a second term by the lowest margin of victory for a sitting president in the history of the nation. John McCain lost to GW Bush in 2000, yet he was the top republican in 2008 (Mitt Romney losing the nomination to him).

Romney lost to Ted Kennedy in a run for his seat, went to Utah to "save the Olympics" with the help of a huge federal government infusion of money following 9/11, saw an opening for the governorship of Massachusetts and abandoned the Utah Olympic committee clean-up for a run at the governorship of which he won by 5% points, had good popularity 66% at the top and lost closer to the end of his with a low point of 34% in November of 2006, two months before he left office, one month before he filed papers to begin exploring a presidential candidacy for 2008.

The man is ambitious for sure, but his popularity is not consistent to a particular level and that may in part be because some see the ambition, but not a reason behind it other than personal profit and checking off the last thing on a fame and fortune bucket list. While most candidates have some flip flops to contend with, Mr. Romney seems to have more than enough for 10 candidates and they are fairly obvious and not easily sloughed off for all his attempts to ignore them and act as if they do not exist.

Ignoring the details and his flip flops seem to be Mr. Romney's biggest problems. One can take the strategy that if they don't mention their own failings the out-of-sight-out-of-mind factor will play an advantageous role. That might work in some instances if what one wants to be out of sight is minimal. In Mr. Romney's case his efforts to ignore the details and his flip flops are so obvious those efforts seem to work against him as it becomes obvious he is hiding from acknowledging them and hiding for what seem to be obvious reasons.

Can he overcome that without presenting yet more flipflops and confusion about where he really stands on anything or more specific details about the "truths" he is trying to pass off as true, by intentionally neglecting to supply more detail which would totally change the message the parital truths imply?
 
Back
Top