Arkady
President
Here's a strong piece arguing why Romney could still win:
http://www.salon.com/2012/09/20/four_reasons_mitt_still_might_win/
Particularly interesting is the bit about the upcoming debates. I think a lot of liberals just take it for granted that Obama will mop the floor with Romney in the debates, but that's not a clearly merited conclusion. Romney isn't George W. Bush -- so dumb as to require remote control when forced to speak without a script:
http://www.salon.com/2004/10/09/bulge/
He's a relaxed and often fluent speaker, who memorizes talking points reasonably well, and has a CEO's skill at segueing to such talking points without too much awkwardness. He more or less held his own against Ted Kennedy back in the day, and he was unmistakably the most presidential of the Republican debaters during the primaries. He's probably about a natural 6 on a scale of one to 10, but he's gotten a lot of practice in the last year, so he might be capable of a 7.
Obama isn't a bad debater, but he's not great, either. I think Hillary Clinton beat up on him pretty convincingly, to the point that the Obama people were relieved there weren't enough debates scheduled for her to use them to pull ahead in 2008. Obama is bright and articulate, but can be slow and a bit off-putting when he doesn't have a rehearsed speech to deliver. He also doesn't seem to have the facts as close at hand as he should (like, say, Bill Clinton, who sometimes seems to have a Google port installed in his head, when responding to questions where specific facts will be useful). I'd say Obama's also a natural 6 on a scale from one to 10, but out of practice, so he might be capable of a 5.
The saving grace, from a Democratic perspective, is that Romney has painted himself into some bizarre corners, with his various flip-flops and intellectually unsupportable positions, which ups the degree of difficulty for him a lot. He'll need to be able to respond to criticisms in ways that don't create obvious openings for using his own words against him, assuming Obama does the hard work of memorizing those words and keeping them at hand, for such use. He is also defending a lot of positions he presumably doesn't believe (since they contradict his previous positions), which means he'll always be running the risk of sounding phony, where Obama can speak more from the heart. Obama has flip-flopped, too, but not typically in ways that Romney will be positioned to criticize, since Obama flopped to the center, while Romney flopped to the far right.
Overall, I think Obama will be able to score close but convincing victories, but I don't consider it a slam dunk the way I saw, say, Biden over Palin, or Clinton over Dole.
http://www.salon.com/2012/09/20/four_reasons_mitt_still_might_win/
Particularly interesting is the bit about the upcoming debates. I think a lot of liberals just take it for granted that Obama will mop the floor with Romney in the debates, but that's not a clearly merited conclusion. Romney isn't George W. Bush -- so dumb as to require remote control when forced to speak without a script:
http://www.salon.com/2004/10/09/bulge/
He's a relaxed and often fluent speaker, who memorizes talking points reasonably well, and has a CEO's skill at segueing to such talking points without too much awkwardness. He more or less held his own against Ted Kennedy back in the day, and he was unmistakably the most presidential of the Republican debaters during the primaries. He's probably about a natural 6 on a scale of one to 10, but he's gotten a lot of practice in the last year, so he might be capable of a 7.
Obama isn't a bad debater, but he's not great, either. I think Hillary Clinton beat up on him pretty convincingly, to the point that the Obama people were relieved there weren't enough debates scheduled for her to use them to pull ahead in 2008. Obama is bright and articulate, but can be slow and a bit off-putting when he doesn't have a rehearsed speech to deliver. He also doesn't seem to have the facts as close at hand as he should (like, say, Bill Clinton, who sometimes seems to have a Google port installed in his head, when responding to questions where specific facts will be useful). I'd say Obama's also a natural 6 on a scale from one to 10, but out of practice, so he might be capable of a 5.
The saving grace, from a Democratic perspective, is that Romney has painted himself into some bizarre corners, with his various flip-flops and intellectually unsupportable positions, which ups the degree of difficulty for him a lot. He'll need to be able to respond to criticisms in ways that don't create obvious openings for using his own words against him, assuming Obama does the hard work of memorizing those words and keeping them at hand, for such use. He is also defending a lot of positions he presumably doesn't believe (since they contradict his previous positions), which means he'll always be running the risk of sounding phony, where Obama can speak more from the heart. Obama has flip-flopped, too, but not typically in ways that Romney will be positioned to criticize, since Obama flopped to the center, while Romney flopped to the far right.
Overall, I think Obama will be able to score close but convincing victories, but I don't consider it a slam dunk the way I saw, say, Biden over Palin, or Clinton over Dole.