New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Lost in translation

Part of what I said in my first thread on PJ

THE NATIONAL HEALTHCARE PLAN AS IT SHOULD BE.

To save the quality of our healthcare and expand coverage we need to change our insurance paradigm. No longer should insurance cover regular, urgent, or mild chronic care. The only insurance people should be able to purchase should be emergency and catastrophic coverage. People should be able to pay out of pocket for much of the healthcare they receive. To do so we need a new Health Savings Account (H.S.A.) paradigm. People should be able to put a dollar into an H.S.A. completely tax free. In other words if I made $50,000 this fiscal year and put $8,000 into my H.S.A., then my income taxes should start being calculated at $42,000. Whatever my employer contributes to my H.S.A. should also be completely tax free and that H.S.A. should be a lifetime right.

https://www.politicaljack.com/threads/a-viable-alternative-to-the-affordable-care-act.57028/


Part of what Trump has posted regarding health care.
  1. ...
  2. ...
  3. Allow individuals to fully deduct health insurance premium payments from their tax returns under the current tax system. Businesses are allowed to take these deductions so why wouldn’t Congress allow individuals the same exemptions? As we allow the free market to provide insurance coverage opportunities to companies and individuals, we must also make sure that no one slips through the cracks simply because they cannot afford insurance. We must review basic options for Medicaid and work with states to ensure that those who want healthcare coverage can have it.
  4. Allow individuals to use Health Savings Accounts (HSAs). Contributions into HSAs should be tax-free and should be allowed to accumulate. These accounts would become part of the estate of the individual and could be passed on to heirs without fear of any death penalty. These plans should be particularly attractive to young people who are healthy and can afford high-deductible insurance plans. These funds can be used by any member of a family without penalty. The flexibility and security provided by HSAs will be of great benefit to all who participate.
  5. Require price transparency from all healthcare providers, especially doctors and healthcare organizations like clinics and hospitals. Individuals should be able to shop to find the best prices for procedures, exams or any other medical-related procedure.
...
Providing healthcare to illegal immigrants costs us some $11 billion annually. If we were to simply enforce the current immigration laws and restrict the unbridled granting of visas to this country, we could relieve healthcare cost pressures on state and local governments.


https://www.politicaljack.com/threa...this-before-on-this-forum.89579/#post-1547179
 
Part of what I said in my first thread on PJ

THE NATIONAL HEALTHCARE PLAN AS IT SHOULD BE.

To save the quality of our healthcare and expand coverage we need to change our insurance paradigm. No longer should insurance cover regular, urgent, or mild chronic care. The only insurance people should be able to purchase should be emergency and catastrophic coverage. People should be able to pay out of pocket for much of the healthcare they receive. To do so we need a new Health Savings Account (H.S.A.) paradigm. People should be able to put a dollar into an H.S.A. completely tax free. In other words if I made $50,000 this fiscal year and put $8,000 into my H.S.A., then my income taxes should start being calculated at $42,000. Whatever my employer contributes to my H.S.A. should also be completely tax free and that H.S.A. should be a lifetime right.

https://www.politicaljack.com/threads/a-viable-alternative-to-the-affordable-care-act.57028/


Part of what Trump has posted regarding health care.
  1. ...
  2. ...
  3. Allow individuals to fully deduct health insurance premium payments from their tax returns under the current tax system. Businesses are allowed to take these deductions so why wouldn’t Congress allow individuals the same exemptions? As we allow the free market to provide insurance coverage opportunities to companies and individuals, we must also make sure that no one slips through the cracks simply because they cannot afford insurance. We must review basic options for Medicaid and work with states to ensure that those who want healthcare coverage can have it.
  4. Allow individuals to use Health Savings Accounts (HSAs). Contributions into HSAs should be tax-free and should be allowed to accumulate. These accounts would become part of the estate of the individual and could be passed on to heirs without fear of any death penalty. These plans should be particularly attractive to young people who are healthy and can afford high-deductible insurance plans. These funds can be used by any member of a family without penalty. The flexibility and security provided by HSAs will be of great benefit to all who participate.
  5. Require price transparency from all healthcare providers, especially doctors and healthcare organizations like clinics and hospitals. Individuals should be able to shop to find the best prices for procedures, exams or any other medical-related procedure.
...
Providing healthcare to illegal immigrants costs us some $11 billion annually. If we were to simply enforce the current immigration laws and restrict the unbridled granting of visas to this country, we could relieve healthcare cost pressures on state and local governments.


https://www.politicaljack.com/threa...this-before-on-this-forum.89579/#post-1547179
I'm a practical guy. If such a plan had been tested out successfully in other wealthy nations -- producing better public health outcomes than ours as significantly lower costs than ours -- I'd be eager to try it here. But why reinvent the wheel? I mean, why try to implement some new, untested concept dreamed up in think tanks, when there are so many real, well-tested solutions to choose from?

There about thirty real-world national healthcare systems out there that meet three key criteria:

(1) Having actually been in use in a major wealthy nation for a significant period of time.
(2) Having produced public health outcomes that are measurably better than ours across a breadth of indicators (e.g., higher life expectancy, lower infant mortality, lower prevalence rates of various diseases, etc.)
(3) Having a significantly lower price tag, in terms of total health care spending per capita than we spend here in the US.

With thirty tested options to choose from, any of which would be a big improvement, why gamble on an untested idea cooked up from abstractions? That just strikes me as impractical.
 
I'm a practical guy. If such a plan had been tested out successfully in other wealthy nations -- producing better public health outcomes than ours as significantly lower costs than ours -- I'd be eager to try it here. But why reinvent the wheel? I mean, why try to implement some new, untested concept dreamed up in think tanks, when there are so many real, well-tested solutions to choose from?

There about thirty real-world national healthcare systems out there that meet three key criteria:

(1) Having actually been in use in a major wealthy nation for a significant period of time.
(2) Having produced public health outcomes that are measurably better than ours across a breadth of indicators (e.g., higher life expectancy, lower infant mortality, lower prevalence rates of various diseases, etc.)
(3) Having a significantly lower price tag, in terms of total health care spending per capita than we spend here in the US.

With thirty tested options to choose from, any of which would be a big improvement, why gamble on an untested idea cooked up from abstractions? That just strikes me as impractical.
1) Singapore's health system has many of the same elements and is lauded for its accomplishments at a low price point.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Healthcare_in_Singapore

2) Your need to have someone else to have tested the system as proposed is also a rather absurd point of view. We are entitled to try new things first.

3) Your 30 real world comparison are all socialist programs that are highly dependent on what amounts to a U.S. healthcare system subsidy to them.
 
1) Singapore's health system has many of the same elements and is lauded for its accomplishments at a low price point.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Healthcare_in_Singapore

2) Your need to have someone else to have tested the system as proposed is also a rather absurd point of view. We are entitled to try new things first.

3) Your 30 real world comparison are all socialist programs that are highly dependent on what amounts to a U.S. healthcare system subsidy to them.
I'd be happy to learn from Singapore, but there's a reason I included the word "major" in the phrase "major wealthy nation." There are a number of nations that are just so small and unusual that they don't make very good examples from which to learn. Singapore is one. So's Vatican City, Monaco, Luxembourg, Liechtenstein, San Marino, Macau, UAE, and Qatar.

For all intents and purposes, Singapore is just a city. It doesn't have a whole bunch of the problems that any regular nation has. For example, how do you put emergency health services within reach of the rural population? That's an expensive question, since it involves maintaining a lot of rural trauma centers and small country hospitals, helicopter evacuations facilities, mobile clinics, etc. But it's not a question Singapore needs to answer since it has no rural population -- everyone lives within about ten miles of the very center of the country. That also cuts down on traffic accidents and other drivers of healthcare costs. Consider, for example, the way New York City has average life expectancy far above the national average, including males living 6 years longer than in the nation as a whole. When you spend less time in cars, and less time doing dangerous agricultural and other kinds of rural work, and you're always within a few miles of one of the best hospitals in the world, keeping in good health is easier. More than nearly any other wealthy nation, the US faces healthcare challenges associated with low population density, but we can learn nothing from Singapore about how to deal with those.

Singaporeans also don't have the same issues with dealing with an older population most countries have, which is another big expense. Only 8.1% of their population is 65 or older, compared to 13.9% in the US, 20.9% in Germany, and 24.8% in Japan. The US is soon going to face the issue that Germany and Japan are already facing: how can you afford healthcare when over a fifth of your population consists of elderly people racking up health costs? Looking to nations like Germany and Japan may give us some ideas, but looking at a country like Singapore that won't face that question for a generation isn't going to be a big help.

Having said that, though, Singapore's system sounds very unlike what Trump has proposed. Read the text from your own Wiki link. Singapore has something closer to "Medicare for All" -- the system liberals were urging back when Obamacare was being debated. As with Medicare, Singapore has a national health insurance plan that people are forced to contribute to through payroll deductions. Unlike Medicare, the accounts are pooled at the family level rather than the national level, so perhaps it would be closer to say it's like the "public option" that liberals proposed -- a government-run insurance system. It looks like 70-80% of Singaporeans are covered by that socialized system, with only 20-30% getting private health insurance. And the government imposes price controls on services provided through the government-run insurance, which is something conservatives object to here (remember, even with the prescription drug benefit, Bush pushed through a rule preventing the government from negotiating prices). In Singapore, public hospitals are government-owned corporations, which I also can't see flying here.

Does that really sound like Trump's plan? He's calling for health insurance premiums to be fully deductible. Think of what that would mean. If I earned over half a million bucks this year, then the benefit of deducting all my premiums would, in effect, be like the government paying for 39.6% of those premiums for me. If you are a middle-class person whose top rate was 25%, then it would be like the government paying 25% of your premiums for you. So, it amounts to a scheme where the government would subsidize health premium costs the most for the rich and the least for the poor.

Tax free HSAs have the same issue. If you and I each put the same $20,000 into an HSA, that will reduce my tax burden by $7,920, and it will reduce your tax burden by $5,000. Again, this has the same effective impact as the government agreeing to pay more of my health costs than yours, simply because I'm richer.

The idea about price transparency isn't a bad one, but probably isn't going to be very effective either. With most medical procedures, there will be a huge number of variables and most people aren't going to have the medical sophistication to be able to price out their options effectively -- it's not like you can walk into a store, see two hip replacement surgeries up on the shelf, each at a clear fixed price, and buy the cheaper one. Each offering will actually be a confusing package of interrelated prices making meaningful comparisons difficult (different equipment, different surgeries, different rehab, different drugs). And the decision-makers will be disproportionately the least savvy consumers, such as elderly people with trouble reading small print. The lower-priced systems you find abroad, including in Singapore, didn't get there by way of government simply requiring more transparent pricing. They did it with price controls, which allow bureaucrats whose whole full-time job is to understand the pricing considerations to work on the problem, rather than requiring every individual, in the midst of a health crisis, to take the time to transform himself into an expert on esoteric medical issues.
 
Last edited:
I'd be happy to learn from Singapore, but there's a reason I included the word "major" in the phrase "major wealthy nation." There are a number of nations that are just so small and unusual that they don't make very good examples from which to learn. Singapore is one. So's Vatican City, Monaco, Luxembourg, Liechtenstein, San Marino, Macau, UAE, and Qatar.

For all intents and purposes, Singapore is just a city. It doesn't have a whole bunch of the problems that any regular nation has. For example, how do you put emergency health services within reach of the rural population? That's an expensive question, since it involves maintaining a lot of rural trauma centers and small country hospitals, helicopter evacuations facilities, mobile clinics, etc. But it's not a question Singapore needs to answer since it has no rural population -- everyone lives within about ten miles of the very center of the country. That also cuts down on traffic accidents and other drivers of healthcare costs. Consider, for example, the way New York City has average life expectancy far above the national average, including males living 6 years longer than in the nation as a whole. When you spend less time in cars, and less time doing dangerous agricultural and other kinds of rural work, and you're always within a few miles of one of the best hospitals in the world, keeping in good health is easier. More than nearly any other wealthy nation, the US faces healthcare challenges associated with low population density, but we can learn nothing from Singapore about how to deal with those.

Singaporeans also don't have the same issues with dealing with an older population most countries have, which is another big expense. Only 8.1% of their population is 65 or older, compared to 13.9% in the US, 20.9% in Germany, and 24.8% in Japan. The US is soon going to face the issue that Germany and Japan are already facing: how can you afford healthcare when over a fifth of your population consists of elderly people racking up health costs? Looking to nations like Germany and Japan may give us some ideas, but looking at a country like Singapore that won't face that question for a generation isn't going to be a big help.

Having said that, though, Singapore's system sounds very unlike what Trump has proposed. Read the text from your own Wiki link. Singapore has something closer to "Medicare for All" -- the system liberals were urging back when Obamacare was being debated. As with Medicare, Singapore has a national health insurance plan that people are forced to contribute to through payroll deductions. Unlike Medicare, the accounts are pooled at the family level rather than the national level, so perhaps it would be closer to say it's like the "public option" that liberals proposed -- a government-run insurance system. It looks like 70-80% of Singaporeans are covered by that socialized system, with only 20-30% getting private health insurance. And the government imposes price controls on services provided through the government-run insurance, which is something conservatives object to here (remember, even with the prescription drug benefit, Bush pushed through a rule preventing the government from negotiating prices). In Singapore, public hospitals are government-owned corporations, which I also can't see flying here.

Does that really sound like Trump's plan. He's calling for health insurance premiums to be fully deductible. Think of what that would mean. If I earned over half a million bucks this year, then the benefit of deducting all my premiums would, in effect, be like the government paying for 39.6% of those premiums for me. If you are a middle-class person whose top rate was 25%, then it would be like the government paying 25% of your premiums for you. So, it amounts to a scheme where the government would subsidize health premium costs the most for the rich and the least for the poor.

Tax free HSAs have the same issue. If you and I each put the same $20,000 into an HSA, that will reduce my tax burden by $7,920, and it will reduce your tax burden by $5,000. Again, this has the same effective impact as the government agreeing to pay more of my health costs than yours, simply because I'm richer.

The idea about price transparency isn't a bad one, but probably isn't going to be very effective either. With most medical procedures, there will be a huge number of variables and most people aren't going to have the medical sophistication to be able to price out their options effectively -- it's not like you can walk into a store, see two hip replacement surgeries up on the shelf, each at a clear fixed price, and buy the cheaper one. Each offering will actually be a confusing package of interrelated prices making meaningful comparisons difficult. And the decision-makers will be disproportionately the least savvy consumers, such as elderly people with trouble reading small print. The lower-priced systems you find abroad, including in Singapore, didn't get there by way of government simply requiring more transparent pricing. They did it with price controls, which allow bureaucrats whose whole full-time job is to understand the pricing considerations to work on the problem, rather than requiring every individual, in the midst of a health crisis, to take the time to transform himself into an expert on esoteric medical issues.

The health care systems you tout are also (typically) low in user satisfaction, and yet still expensive enough to require rationing. Why should we aspire to that?

We have a current (insurance) model that works pretty well, and that would be auto/home insurance. We don't insure our autos and homes for every first dollar repair, or even maintenance at all (although we can, as products exist for that). But rather against "catastrophic loss" such that it behooves people to a) take care of their cars/homes by being more careful behind the wheel (and doing regular preventive maintenance) and b) incents them to price shop for all but the most extreme damages. And insurance costs are kept down by our being able to buy national policies (with only minor differences among the states).

Such a system would work great in healthcare as well. Say for instance we provide tax deductions and subsidies, but only for high deductable plans whereby we are given the incentives to maintain our health in order to minimize our out of pocket expenses. The poor and low wage workers could, as they do now, receive maintenance services from a Federally Qualified Health Center:

http://www.hrsa.gov/healthit/toolbox/RuralHealthITtoolbox/Introduction/qualified.html

On a sliding scale based on income, and other charity forms of care funded by private donations. Then, unless you pay out of pocket for a "maintenance" care policy (not-tax deductable) you pay as you go for routine care. This puts the subsidies where they belong (only on catastrophic illness and injury) while providing the proper incentives to control overall use (and cost) of the system. This isn't rocket science (either)...
 
The health care systems you tout are also (typically) low in user satisfaction, and yet still expensive enough to require rationing. Why should we aspire to that?

Our system involves rationing, too. It's just that the rationing is done by impersonal market forces, rather than the government: if you are too poor to afford a life-saving treatment, you die. And even though, once you're dead, you won't be surveyed about your satisfaction, we still rank at the bottom of surveyed nations:

http://www.commonwealthfund.org/publications/fund-reports/2014/jun/mirror-mirror

So, the question is why should we cling to a system that costs much more and produces worse results. I get what the answer is from the perspective of a for-profit healthcare operative, or from the perspective of a Republican politician cashing checks from for-profit healthcare operations, but I don't see a reason most of us should prefer a miserable failure of a system like ours over these better international options.

Such a system would work great in healthcare as well.

Do you have any evidence to support that -- some evidence of some major wealthy nation, at some point in history, having implemented an auto-insurance-style scheme for healthcare, with good results, in terms of lower per-capita costs and better public health outcomes? Or are you just urging us to try something completely untested and hope it works out well?
 
Part of what I said in my first thread on PJ

THE NATIONAL HEALTHCARE PLAN AS IT SHOULD BE.

To save the quality of our healthcare and expand coverage we need to change our insurance paradigm. No longer should insurance cover regular, urgent, or mild chronic care. The only insurance people should be able to purchase should be emergency and catastrophic coverage. People should be able to pay out of pocket for much of the healthcare they receive. To do so we need a new Health Savings Account (H.S.A.) paradigm. People should be able to put a dollar into an H.S.A. completely tax free. In other words if I made $50,000 this fiscal year and put $8,000 into my H.S.A., then my income taxes should start being calculated at $42,000. Whatever my employer contributes to my H.S.A. should also be completely tax free and that H.S.A. should be a lifetime right.

https://www.politicaljack.com/threads/a-viable-alternative-to-the-affordable-care-act.57028/


Part of what Trump has posted regarding health care.
  1. ...
  2. ...
  3. Allow individuals to fully deduct health insurance premium payments from their tax returns under the current tax system. Businesses are allowed to take these deductions so why wouldn’t Congress allow individuals the same exemptions? As we allow the free market to provide insurance coverage opportunities to companies and individuals, we must also make sure that no one slips through the cracks simply because they cannot afford insurance. We must review basic options for Medicaid and work with states to ensure that those who want healthcare coverage can have it.
  4. Allow individuals to use Health Savings Accounts (HSAs). Contributions into HSAs should be tax-free and should be allowed to accumulate. These accounts would become part of the estate of the individual and could be passed on to heirs without fear of any death penalty. These plans should be particularly attractive to young people who are healthy and can afford high-deductible insurance plans. These funds can be used by any member of a family without penalty. The flexibility and security provided by HSAs will be of great benefit to all who participate.
  5. Require price transparency from all healthcare providers, especially doctors and healthcare organizations like clinics and hospitals. Individuals should be able to shop to find the best prices for procedures, exams or any other medical-related procedure.
...
Providing healthcare to illegal immigrants costs us some $11 billion annually. If we were to simply enforce the current immigration laws and restrict the unbridled granting of visas to this country, we could relieve healthcare cost pressures on state and local governments.


https://www.politicaljack.com/threa...this-before-on-this-forum.89579/#post-1547179

It's typical right wing pie-in-the-sky.

Most people don't have disposable incomes to fund health savings accounts. Given various immediate needs, most peoples' funds will be devoted to other, more immediate uses. For those that can fund such accounts, they would often still have insufficient funds to meet their medical costs when they need it.

It's an idiotic idea cooked up by some right wing think tank hack for the purpose of diverting attention from rational solutions to the health care problems.
 
Meanwhile - We did have a perfectly good National Health System in England. It is now on melt down because of Government ( Thatcher began it) interference in bringing in private companies who answer to no-one and don't know the first thing about medicine, they are just privately run businesses run as, just that, businesses.

My sister has a benign but inoperable brain tumor, she has an MRI scan every year just to monitor its growth, or not growth.
The Neurology Dept was in a lovely little cottage hospital half way between Brighton and London - it is now being moved to Brighton. So the inpatients and the consultants are now in Brighton but the outpatient dept is still in the cottage hospital - My sisters last scan was three months ago - she phoned, yet again, for an appointment today, until a couple of weeks ago the Consultant had not got her results back because they do not have enough people to write them up. The nurse told sis, we can make NO appointments because we do not have enough Consultants for both Brighton and the cottage hospital - none, zilch, we cannot make any appointments at all, nurse said we have hundreds of you -hundreds - and can see no one, she said we are frantic - it is more than demoralizing, the whole of the NHS is in melt down. Luckily for sis the nurse did find her results and read them out to her, no change, but that is sis, there are people waiting who can die because no Dr is available, even though these are dedicated specialist Dr who do give a damn.

The money is there, we know the money is there - but it is all going to private companies who are not medically anything at all - not Drs or nurses - just businesses ( jobs for the boys) whose job it is to manage the NHS etc. Our Dr and nurses are all going abroad to work - they've had it.

And we have nothing in place - nothing. They are ripping it apart and replacing it with nothing a void.
 
Meanwhile - We did have a perfectly good National Health System in England. It is now on melt down because of Government ( Thatcher began it) interference in bringing in private companies who answer to no-one and don't know the first thing about medicine, they are just privately run businesses run as, just that, businesses.

My sister has a benign but inoperable brain tumor, she has an MRI scan every year just to monitor its growth, or not growth.
The Neurology Dept was in a lovely little cottage hospital half way between Brighton and London - it is now being moved to Brighton. So the inpatients and the consultants are now in Brighton but the outpatient dept is still in the cottage hospital - My sisters last scan was three months ago - she phoned, yet again, for an appointment today, until a couple of weeks ago the Consultant had not got her results back because they do not have enough people to write them up. The nurse told sis, we can make NO appointments because we do not have enough Consultants for both Brighton and the cottage hospital - none, zilch, we cannot make any appointments at all, nurse said we have hundreds of you -hundreds - and can see no one, she said we are frantic - it is more than demoralizing, the whole of the NHS is in melt down. Luckily for sis the nurse did find her results and read them out to her, no change, but that is sis, there are people waiting who can die because no Dr is available, even though these are dedicated specialist Dr who do give a damn.

The money is there, we know the money is there - but it is all going to private companies who are not medically anything at all - not Drs or nurses - just businesses ( jobs for the boys). Our Dr and nurses are all going abroad to work - they've had it.

And we have nothing in place - nothing. They are ripping it apart and replacing it with nothing a void.

Best wishes to your sister. I'm at my brother's house for a few weeks, he had a benign tumor removed and suffered complications so I'm looking after him now that he's out of the hospital. Brain tumors are scary stuff.
 
Our system involves rationing, too. It's just that the rationing is done by impersonal market forces, rather than the government: if you are too poor to afford a life-saving treatment, you die. And even though, once you're dead, you won't be surveyed about your satisfaction, we still rank at the bottom of surveyed nations:

http://www.commonwealthfund.org/publications/fund-reports/2014/jun/mirror-mirror

So, the question is why should we cling to a system that costs much more and produces worse results. I get what the answer is from the perspective of a for-profit healthcare operative, or from the perspective of a Republican politician cashing checks from for-profit healthcare operations, but I don't see a reason most of us should prefer a miserable failure of a system like ours over these better international options.



Do you have any evidence to support that -- some evidence of some major wealthy nation, at some point in history, having implemented an auto-insurance-style scheme for healthcare, with good results, in terms of lower per-capita costs and better public health outcomes? Or are you just urging us to try something completely untested and hope it works out well?

Yes, I am well aware of your disdain for "profitable" endeavors, comrade. But your cherry picked "studies" don't impress me.

http://www.npr.org/sections/health-...re-system-but-are-pleased-with-their-own-care

And the European health care systemic breakdowns have driven them to pursue market based reform, as their systems are plagued with high costs, excessive waits and low quality:

http://www.united-europe.eu/news-an...stems-face-reform-to-meet-growing-challenges/

The fact is that, just as you are urging us to emulate Europe, they are moving in the opposite direction because the policies you encourage us to adopt are failing. The better question is, why should we make the same mistakes that the Europeans made?
 
Yes, I am well aware of your disdain for "profitable" endeavors, comrade. But your cherry picked "studies" don't impress me.

As we both know, the only studies that impress you are the ones that tell you what you already wanted to believe. But, the simple fact is that all the other major wealthy nations have used more socialized solutions than ours to achieve healthcare that is both considerably cheaper than ours, and better in quality, as measured by any major public health statistics you care to name. We can, of course, choose the impractical path of rejecting all those successful stories and experimenting with some untested solution cooked up by conservative economists, and hope for the best. But I'm a practical guy, so I'd prefer just going with something we've seen work, rather than reinvent the wheel.

The better question is, why should we make the same mistakes that the Europeans made?

If by "mistake" you mean "a system that costs much less and produces better results," I'd think the answer is obvious.
 
Best wishes to your sister. I'm at my brother's house for a few weeks, he had a benign tumor removed and suffered complications so I'm looking after him now that he's out of the hospital. Brain tumors are scary stuff.

Sis had one removed, they had to cut her scull open - no complications. This one is on the main artery which takes the blood flow out of the brain so they dare not operate, the artery is too fragile.

After looking after my Ma, who died of breast cancer, she herself got breast cancer -which she fought by natural means, diet and supplements and peace - four years later she was so tired of rabbit food she did say take it away to her Dr who was saying No No No keep going, this is a miracle - but she just couldn't keep it up - but that was it, no after treatment in either case, no nothing, just healthy eating and such --- so when she was diagnosed with first one and then another brain tumor she has fared better than most do because she has kept her body as clean as she could --- poor darling has had all sorts of terrible things but she fights and lives a good life.

Big Pharma has a lot to answer for - because they have an absolute monopoly over 'the knowledge' and because profit is their main concern they are as dangerous, or more so, as they are beneficial.

I am so sorry your bro is having problems - darling all I can say is look into holistic care - even if you use it along with conventional meds our planets natural meds help massively xxx

Brain tumors are going to be a part of us for a long time - our brains are being blasted with all sorts of stuff from TV to mobile phones to ear phones, we are just not made to withstand.

Peace and love xxx

ps - for instance, antibiotics knock out the immune system as well as any infections - so when the infection clears the immune system is too weak to pick up the healing process after the antibiotics have done their job - There are lots of things we can do to boost our immune systems = holistic xxx
 
Last edited:
As we both know, the only studies that impress you are the ones that tell you what you already wanted to believe. But, the simple fact is that all the other major wealthy nations have used more socialized solutions than ours to achieve healthcare that is both considerably cheaper than ours, and better in quality, as measured by any major public health statistics you care to name. We can, of course, choose the impractical path of rejecting all those successful stories and experimenting with some untested solution cooked up by conservative economists, and hope for the best. But I'm a practical guy, so I'd prefer just going with something we've seen work, rather than reinvent the wheel.



If by "mistake" you mean "a system that costs much less and produces better results," I'd think the answer is obvious.

Yes, but not typically in user satisfaction, so we are faced again with your demand that we only use "official" measures, which are often subject to bureaucratic bias. In fact, I have repeatedly had to correct you on this very matter, as you refuse to acknowledge the differences in statistical reporting among countries:

https://www.aei.org/publication/us-health-care-a-reality-check-on-cross-country-comparisons/

And I see you are just going to avoid the whole "they are moving the other way" situation, and persist in your typical denial of the facts in favor of your patented narrative, supported by biased "measures" and "studies."
 
Yes, but not typically in user satisfaction, so we are faced again with your demand that we only use "official" measures, which are often subject to bureaucratic bias.

Yes, as we've discussed, you will only consider statistics that happen to agree with whatever your starting assumptions were, whereas I go with the best available evidence, whether it lines up with what I initially believed or not.

Fortunately for you, there are a lot of billionaire family trusts out there that will keep shoveling money to propaganda factories like the American Enterprise Institute to churn out quasi-stats to satisfy your needs.
 
Yes, as we've discussed, you will only consider statistics that happen to agree with whatever your starting assumptions were, whereas I go with the best available evidence, whether it lines up with what I initially believed or not.

Fortunately for you, there are a lot of billionaire family trusts out there that will keep shoveling money to propaganda factories like the American Enterprise Institute to churn out quasi-stats to satisfy your needs.

As I pointed out, the "available evidence" indicates that there are very real and significant anomalies in the data as collected here and abroad!
 
It's typical right wing pie-in-the-sky.

Most people don't have disposable incomes to fund health savings accounts. Given various immediate needs, most peoples' funds will be devoted to other, more immediate uses. For those that can fund such accounts, they would often still have insufficient funds to meet their medical costs when they need it.

It has nothing to do with disposable income and everything to do with income. And Singapore demonstrates that you are WRONG on the matter; people are happy to shop for and pay for reasonably priced healthcare.

It's an idiotic idea cooked up by some right wing think tank hack for the purpose of diverting attention from rational solutions to the health care problems.

Your socialized solution is a turd that won't even float for a living.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top