justoffal
Senator
The predominant separation of political ideologies in this nation today is based on the premise that the two opposing poles of social development cannot coexist or are mutually exclusive.
The two poles I prefer to call micro and macro development.
Micro development is based on the theory that a stronger individual makes for a stronger whole. By and large this is the conservative mantra.
Macro development is based on the theory that a stronger whole makes for a stronger individual. By and large this is the progressive Mantra.
Both have their merits and their weaknesses. As a systems engineer I am keenly aware of the relationship between the components and the whole.
I often find myself torn when it comes to politics because I have to work with both theories to make systems succeed in the real, mechanical world and while I realize that the correlation between machinery and people is not a perfect one I suspect that it is closer and more related than most realize.
So as I see it we have three major issues at hand.
Micro development....and its adherents...Friedman was one.
Macro development...and its adherents...Keyens was one.
The idea that they are mutually exclusive. Is this true?
Lets begin by saying that micro development is where everything begins. You simply cannot have a good whole if you don't have good components. Now hold on for a bit...this gets a bit tricky. While it is absolutely true that you cannot have a good, solid whole system without good solid components...it is also coincidentally true that all of the good components on earth won't make a good system unless they work together efficiently so there is a lot to be said about the macro view also.
If I need a system of pumps and pipes to move a fluid there are many things to consider. The total amount of fluid being moved, the viscosity and specific gravity of the fluid, the pressure tolerances of the piping, the distance of the move, the amount of total friction from contact with the piping and the bends involved on the total journey, the total head and last but not least the speed of the delivery.
On the micro side I am looking at pump horsepower and total wear on the pump components such as impellers and shafts, the integrity of the pipe materials and the necessary compliance items like safety and relief valving.
On the macro side I need to consider if a large single unit pump will run better and more efficiently than several smaller units placed in line on the way to the delivery site. If I am using multiple pumps I have to consider the power usage and whether or not I need same size or varying size motors, should they be vfd or synchronous? In the final analysis there is an equation that will render the answer. Depending on what my employer wants at the time there is usually only one right answer.
Human society is quite similar though I will concede that the parallel is not perfect of course. However as a nation and a people we are constantly struggling with the two approaches. Does a well designed whole make the component stronger? Why yes it does. On the other hand we cannot have the whole without the component. The whole is the result of the component and not the other way around and never will be the other way around.
IMO we currently have a macro system that is chewing up the micro system. In time it will show as the failures begin to mount and the system begins to falter, not delivering what it must to succeed. It will not bend to prefrence or wishful thinking or even poltical ideology....it will only do what it is physically and mechanically capable of doing.
I'ts pretty clear that we begin with the micro. Now that is not to say that we can afford to ignore the macro. I guess in the final analysis we need to decide what is more important. In closing let me just interject that there are some things that speak for themselves. The whole system is not possible without the component system but the component system can and does exist without the whole.
Need I say more?
JO
The two poles I prefer to call micro and macro development.
Micro development is based on the theory that a stronger individual makes for a stronger whole. By and large this is the conservative mantra.
Macro development is based on the theory that a stronger whole makes for a stronger individual. By and large this is the progressive Mantra.
Both have their merits and their weaknesses. As a systems engineer I am keenly aware of the relationship between the components and the whole.
I often find myself torn when it comes to politics because I have to work with both theories to make systems succeed in the real, mechanical world and while I realize that the correlation between machinery and people is not a perfect one I suspect that it is closer and more related than most realize.
So as I see it we have three major issues at hand.
Micro development....and its adherents...Friedman was one.
Macro development...and its adherents...Keyens was one.
The idea that they are mutually exclusive. Is this true?
Lets begin by saying that micro development is where everything begins. You simply cannot have a good whole if you don't have good components. Now hold on for a bit...this gets a bit tricky. While it is absolutely true that you cannot have a good, solid whole system without good solid components...it is also coincidentally true that all of the good components on earth won't make a good system unless they work together efficiently so there is a lot to be said about the macro view also.
If I need a system of pumps and pipes to move a fluid there are many things to consider. The total amount of fluid being moved, the viscosity and specific gravity of the fluid, the pressure tolerances of the piping, the distance of the move, the amount of total friction from contact with the piping and the bends involved on the total journey, the total head and last but not least the speed of the delivery.
On the micro side I am looking at pump horsepower and total wear on the pump components such as impellers and shafts, the integrity of the pipe materials and the necessary compliance items like safety and relief valving.
On the macro side I need to consider if a large single unit pump will run better and more efficiently than several smaller units placed in line on the way to the delivery site. If I am using multiple pumps I have to consider the power usage and whether or not I need same size or varying size motors, should they be vfd or synchronous? In the final analysis there is an equation that will render the answer. Depending on what my employer wants at the time there is usually only one right answer.
Human society is quite similar though I will concede that the parallel is not perfect of course. However as a nation and a people we are constantly struggling with the two approaches. Does a well designed whole make the component stronger? Why yes it does. On the other hand we cannot have the whole without the component. The whole is the result of the component and not the other way around and never will be the other way around.
IMO we currently have a macro system that is chewing up the micro system. In time it will show as the failures begin to mount and the system begins to falter, not delivering what it must to succeed. It will not bend to prefrence or wishful thinking or even poltical ideology....it will only do what it is physically and mechanically capable of doing.
I'ts pretty clear that we begin with the micro. Now that is not to say that we can afford to ignore the macro. I guess in the final analysis we need to decide what is more important. In closing let me just interject that there are some things that speak for themselves. The whole system is not possible without the component system but the component system can and does exist without the whole.
Need I say more?
JO
Last edited: