Arkady
President
Words without context are meaningless, you should know that.
To give you an FYI, you ARE telling the Catholic Church what they should believe, through your opinion.
You can't say they are "wrong" anymore than I can say the black community is "wrong" to be so offended by the most serious word to ever exist.
I don't care what the Catholic Church believes. It's all mythology to me. It doesn't much matter whether the myth was invented 2000 years ago by a poor follower of an itinerant Rabbi in Palestine, or whether it was invented 1000 years later by a rich bishop living off the tithes of medieval farmers. The antiquity of the myth doesn't make it any truer. So Catholics are welcome to embrace new lies that override the lies that were written in the Bible. But none of that changes what was written in the Bible. It says what it says.
As for your analogy, it's asymmetrical. In the one case you're saying that I can't say someone is wrong to feel offended about something, while in the other case you're saying that I can't say someone is wrong about the contents of a book. One is about the legitimacy of a sentiment, the other about the legitimacy of a belief. Those are different things. For example, you're on shaky ground if you tell me that I'm wrong to feel angry that they killed off Marlon Brando's character in the Godfather, but you're on solid ground if you tell me I'm wrong in my belief that the character's name was Michael Scott. A book's contents are what they are.