New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Michael Sam Drafted

Words without context are meaningless, you should know that.

To give you an FYI, you ARE telling the Catholic Church what they should believe, through your opinion.

You can't say they are "wrong" anymore than I can say the black community is "wrong" to be so offended by the most serious word to ever exist.

I don't care what the Catholic Church believes. It's all mythology to me. It doesn't much matter whether the myth was invented 2000 years ago by a poor follower of an itinerant Rabbi in Palestine, or whether it was invented 1000 years later by a rich bishop living off the tithes of medieval farmers. The antiquity of the myth doesn't make it any truer. So Catholics are welcome to embrace new lies that override the lies that were written in the Bible. But none of that changes what was written in the Bible. It says what it says.

As for your analogy, it's asymmetrical. In the one case you're saying that I can't say someone is wrong to feel offended about something, while in the other case you're saying that I can't say someone is wrong about the contents of a book. One is about the legitimacy of a sentiment, the other about the legitimacy of a belief. Those are different things. For example, you're on shaky ground if you tell me that I'm wrong to feel angry that they killed off Marlon Brando's character in the Godfather, but you're on solid ground if you tell me I'm wrong in my belief that the character's name was Michael Scott. A book's contents are what they are.
 
He certainly sacrificed.. but like I said, there have been plenty of gay players who have played in the NFL, plenty whom the whole locker room knew was gay, plenty that came out to their fellow teammates.

This isn't about football as much as it is about somewhat imposing a celebration of being outspokenly gay on people who might not be completely comfortable with it, which they have every right to be.. just like people might not be comfortable with a guy who cheats on his wife and is proud of it. Those who feel as such will be labeled as "bigots" by people like yourself, Ark, even though they aren't. These are the type who don't wish to be malicious towards anyone who is gay, have differing rights as far as the law, or anything like that. They simply don't support and celebrate the gay lifestyle. That doesn't make them bigots at all, it's an extreme ultimatum the gay community lays down.
Which NFL players, in particular,were out to their whole locker room?

And what, exactly, is this "gay lifestyle" of which you speak? I don't recall Michael Sam saying anything about his lifestyle.
 
Actually, according to Arkady, it's mostly about NFL teams being anti-gay.. even though countless numbers of openly gay players in the locker room have played with no problem.

It's just that this one created his own media circus, and literally paid the price.
Where, exactly, did I say or suggest that the NFL draft is mostly about teams being anti-gay? And could you list a few of these "countless openly gay players" who have played with no problem?
 
Which NFL players, in particular,were out to their whole locker room?
I've listened to former pro players talk about this over the years, and now more recently once again. They weren't direct, but they had no reason to lie. These guys were straight from NFL locker rooms..
And what, exactly, is this "gay lifestyle" of which you speak? I don't recall Michael Sam saying anything about his lifestyle.

I was only referring to showing public displays of affection to the same sex..
 
I don't care what the Catholic Church believes. It's all mythology to me. It doesn't much matter whether the myth was invented 2000 years ago by a poor follower of an itinerant Rabbi in Palestine, or whether it was invented 1000 years later by a rich bishop living off the tithes of medieval farmers. The antiquity of the myth doesn't make it any truer. So Catholics are welcome to embrace new lies that override the lies that were written in the Bible. But none of that changes what was written in the Bible. It says what it says.

As for your analogy, it's asymmetrical. In the one case you're saying that I can't say someone is wrong to feel offended about something, while in the other case you're saying that I can't say someone is wrong about the contents of a book. One is about the legitimacy of a sentiment, the other about the legitimacy of a belief. Those are different things. For example, you're on shaky ground if you tell me that I'm wrong to feel angry that they killed off Marlon Brando's character in the Godfather, but you're on solid ground if you tell me I'm wrong in my belief that the character's name was Michael Scott. A book's contents are what they are.

You're fine to read the bible and make your own conclusions, just as you're fine to pick up some egyptian heiroglyphics and try to make sense of those. However, you'd be foolish to take the words you might end up with in today's context and not consider the cultural, historic, and meaning differences...

In the two cases, you'd want an authority to enlighten you on what the true meaning is... Yet, for some reason, you think you can just pick up heiroglyphics and be able to impossibly master the thousands-of-years-old context... I say you're at the very least extremely audacious and arrogant, borderline ignorant, to think this.

Once again, you don't get to tell me what the Bible says, I'll listen to a true authority, thank you. The least you can do, as an outsider, is address what the actual stance is by the church and go from there. But once you go into your own world of what you think the interpretation is, you've lost any reason to further the debate.
 
I've listened to former pro players talk about this over the years, and now more recently once again. They weren't direct, but they had no reason to lie. These guys were straight from NFL locker rooms..


I was only referring to showing public displays of affection to the same sex..
If you hear names, I'd be interested. Not one name has been provided, for an NFL player generally known to be gay in his playing days. Considering the many thousands who have played, isn't that conspicuous absence of even one name very telling?

As for the "gay lifestyle," as you've defined it (a public display of affection to the same sex), I guess I share in the gay lifestyle. I recently took a vacation with my Dad, and we hugged when we parted.
 
Last edited:
You're fine to read the bible and make your own conclusions, just as you're fine to pick up some egyptian heiroglyphics and try to make sense of those. However, you'd be foolish to take the words you might end up with in today's context and not consider the cultural, historic, and meaning differences...

In the two cases, you'd want an authority to enlighten you on what the true meaning is... Yet, for some reason, you think you can just pick up heiroglyphics and be able to impossibly master the thousands-of-years-old context... I say you're at the very least extremely audacious and arrogant, borderline ignorant, to think this.

Once again, you don't get to tell me what the Bible says, I'll listen to a true authority, thank you. The least you can do, as an outsider, is address what the actual stance is by the church and go from there. But once you go into your own world of what you think the interpretation is, you've lost any reason to further the debate.
I consider the cultural context. Ancient history is a hobby of mine. I've particularly enjoyed the writing of Karen Armstrong, who recounts how ancient Judaism grew out of the cult of Yahweh, who was once just one of many Canaanite gods in a polytheistic pantheon, but gradually evolved into being a singular sky god. It's fascinating stuff. I highly recommend it, if you're looking for some authoritative insight into the real development of the faith, as opposed to dogmatic Catholic theology.

As for the Bible, it's a text, like any other. I don't need to submit to the mythology to understand it, any more than you need to worship Zeus in order to have an understanding of Greek myth. Yes, ancient texts need to be approached with humility, since there are difficult language issues and problems of cultural context. And I come in with exactly that humility -- not assuming I have all the right answers. When issues get thorny, I read a diverse span of authorities and then decide what I think. When the language gets problematic, I read multiple translations and start looking up the individual Greek or Hebrew words for guidance.

If you want to talk about extreme audacity and arrogance, look no further than that sham with the pointy hat in Rome. He's the one who has convinced himself that he has some special communication with divine authority that allows him, whenever the whim strikes him to speak ex cathedra, to be infallible on any question of scriptural interpretation. That's beyond arrogant. It's quite literally insane. And those who simply submit to the notion that such a madman, and his nutty predecessors, must be right, are arrogant, too, in that they simply assume he must be spouting the one true faith, because it's the one they happen to belong to.
 
Why do you say that?

I think there could be aspects, certain cliques in certain locker rooms.. perhaps some teams who have a culture.. but from what I hear from former players, it's not that bad. Guys don't care about your sexuality, it's just on their ability to help out on the football field.

I don't claim to know many players or former players, I know two and they both played over 20 years ago, but I've read quotes in the media from time to time from some players. People can say whatever they want but the real test is when Sam is in the locker room with them and when I see or hear a lot of players repeating the exact same thing I wonder if they really believe it or if they're saying what they think they're supposed to say.

It wasn't too long ago that Jonathon Martin was being harassed in the Dolphins locker room and one of the insults thrown at him was that he was gay, even though he isn't. According to the reports about those incidents some of the players had a problem with that but they didn't speak out at the time, they didn't stand up. The Vikings had a somewhat similar incident in their locker room and from what I've read not everyone there either was down with the pro-gay message Kluwe was advocating.

There have to be gay players in the NFL right now but they're not coming out and I suspect there's a very good reason for that.
 
10342455_10152108583957596_8298189758966449349_n.jpg
 
There is nothing wrong with anyone thinking they are someone special. If you can't see yourself as special it's doubtful anyone else will. It's kind'a like those who are cocky about being talented. There's nothing wrong with it if you can walk the walk. More people than not envy a smug mug it he's made of the right stuff.

gramps
All pro football players are special; they are the best of the best. It's a very small percentage of the huge numbers of football players in the country who ever get to the pros. In the end I doubt that Michael Sam will rise or fall based on his goop-gobbling but rather on his tackling.
 
I applaud the Rams and Sam but will also say the road ahead for Sam will be rough, and he might not even make it in the NFL...

I am glad he came out and applaud his choice but he has to understand that in the locker room he will be shun, and treated in a hostile way...

So as you and I see this as a open window for the gay rights we must also be cautious when celebrating this draft...

I bet you'll be wrong. Young people are not that hung up as older people. I just did a workshop with African-American seventh graders and almost everyone of them believed in gay marriage.. I hope you're wrong. Team camaraderie is. Very powerful and supportive
 
The fact that you're praising Sam for being gay is also telling. Most people don't "come out" about their sexuality. Most consider it nobody's business. That you encourage gays to make themselves a spectacle speaks volumes.
Wow you sure don't get it. Everybody is considered straight so we don't have to "come out" about our sexuality. Every time you mention your wife you're "coming out" about your sexuality. Wanting not to hide and closet themselves is making a spectacle? Look what happened when he kissed his partner. Everyone went ape shit.....
 
All pro football players are special; they are the best of the best. It's a very small percentage of the huge numbers of football players in the country who ever get to the pros. In the end I doubt that Michael Sam will rise or fall based on his goop-gobbling but rather on his tackling.

Hello Jack, long time no see. Good to hear from you.

gramps
 
Wow you sure don't get it. Everybody is considered straight so we don't have to "come out" about our sexuality. Every time you mention your wife you're "coming out" about your sexuality. Wanting not to hide and closet themselves is making a spectacle? Look what happened when he kissed his partner. Everyone went ape shit.....

Wanting not to hide and closet yourself is one thing. Announcing it on national tv is very much another. Especially when Sam's profession has nothing to do with his sexual orientation.

And at least Sam still has his job. All Sterling did was make a comment and it cost him his team. it is a whole lot easier to be gay than to not be politically correct in today's liberal NAZI climate.
 
I bet you'll be wrong. Young people are not that hung up as older people. I just did a workshop with African-American seventh graders and almost everyone of them believed in gay marriage.. I hope you're wrong. Team camaraderie is. Very powerful and supportive
It's also called "peer pressure" and the results of that can be devastating.
 
Wow you sure don't get it. Everybody is considered straight so we don't have to "come out" about our sexuality. Every time you mention your wife you're "coming out" about your sexuality. Wanting not to hide and closet themselves is making a spectacle? Look what happened when he kissed his partner. Everyone went ape shit.....

I am openly straight.
 
Back
Top