New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Might I ask simple question?

Boca

Governor
If President Trump referred to an African-American, let's say Colin Powell or Clarence Thomas, as Dr. King would you consider that a "slur"?

Really? Do you think they would?

Liz Warren, who claims to be part Native American, doesn't know squat about Pocahontas apparently. She was somewhat of a heroine who reportedly saved the life of Capt. John Smith at Jamestown. She is without a doubt the most recognized Native American female in American history. She also went on to a place in history that Liz couldn't dream of. Pocahontas lived 400 years ago; Liz won't be remembered by anyone other than family 50 years from now.

Yep, Pocahontas was quite a remarkable young woman that you'd think Liz would know and think better of.

She was captured and held for ransom by the English during Anglo-Indian hostilities in 1613. During her captivity, she converted to Christianity and took the name Rebecca. When the opportunity arose for her to return to her people, she chose to remain with the English. In April 1614, at the age of 17, she married tobacco planter John Rolfe, and in January 1615, bore their son, Thomas Rolfe.

In 1616, the Rolfes traveled to London. Pocahontas was presented to English society as an example of the "civilized savage" in hopes of stimulating investment in the Jamestown settlement. She became something of a celebrity, was elegantly fêted, and attended a masque at Whitehall Palace. In 1617, the Rolfes set sail for Virginia, but Pocahontas died at Gravesend of unknown causes, aged around 20-21. She was buried in St George's Church, Gravesend in England, but the exact location of her grave is unknown, as the church has been rebuilt.

Numerous places, landmarks, and products in the United States have been named after Pocahontas. Her story has been romanticized over the years, and she is a subject of art, literature, and film. Many famous people have claimed to be among her descendants through her son Thomas, including members of the First Families of Virginia, First LadyEdith Wilson, American Western actor Glenn Strange, Las Vegas performer Wayne Newton, and astronomer Percival Lowell.
​

But Liz believes the very name of Pocahontas is a politically incorrect slur? So she's either stupid regarding Native American history or a racist and it would appear to be both.

So then kiddies....back to the question....what about calling any black man Dr. King.....as opposed to say Sambo or Buckwheat? Or how about Hillary referring to Donna Brazille as "Buffalo". Hillary and Liz have that in common
 
If President Trump referred to an African-American, let's say Colin Powell or Clarence Thomas, as Dr. King would you consider that a "slur"?

Really? Do you think they would?

Liz Warren, who claims to be part Native American, doesn't know squat about Pocahontas apparently. She was somewhat of a heroine who reportedly saved the life of Capt. John Smith at Jamestown. She is without a doubt the most recognized Native American female in American history. She also went on to a place in history that Liz couldn't dream of. Pocahontas lived 400 years ago; Liz won't be remembered by anyone other than family 50 years from now.

Yep, Pocahontas was quite a remarkable young woman that you'd think Liz would know and think better of.

She was captured and held for ransom by the English during Anglo-Indian hostilities in 1613. During her captivity, she converted to Christianity and took the name Rebecca. When the opportunity arose for her to return to her people, she chose to remain with the English. In April 1614, at the age of 17, she married tobacco planter John Rolfe, and in January 1615, bore their son, Thomas Rolfe.

In 1616, the Rolfes traveled to London. Pocahontas was presented to English society as an example of the "civilized savage" in hopes of stimulating investment in the Jamestown settlement. She became something of a celebrity, was elegantly fêted, and attended a masque at Whitehall Palace. In 1617, the Rolfes set sail for Virginia, but Pocahontas died at Gravesend of unknown causes, aged around 20-21. She was buried in St George's Church, Gravesend in England, but the exact location of her grave is unknown, as the church has been rebuilt.

Numerous places, landmarks, and products in the United States have been named after Pocahontas. Her story has been romanticized over the years, and she is a subject of art, literature, and film. Many famous people have claimed to be among her descendants through her son Thomas, including members of the First Families of Virginia, First LadyEdith Wilson, American Western actor Glenn Strange, Las Vegas performer Wayne Newton, and astronomer Percival Lowell.
​

But Liz believes the very name of Pocahontas is a politically incorrect slur? So she's either stupid regarding Native American history or a racist and it would appear to be both.

So then kiddies....back to the question....what about calling any black man Dr. King.....as opposed to say Sambo or Buckwheat? Or how about Hillary referring to Donna Brazille as "Buffalo". Hillary and Liz have that in common
The word is being used sarcastically against a person attempting to pose as a member of a certain race or ethnic class.
It's akin to calling a "stolen valor" fraud something like "George Patton".
It's akin to calling race fraud Rachel Dolezal something sarcastic like "Rosa Parks".

None of these terms should be considered an insult or slur to the actual people it would refer to or their group- not an insult to true Native Americans, military personnel, or African Americans.
 
If President Trump referred to an African-American, let's say Colin Powell or Clarence Thomas, as Dr. King would you consider that a "slur"?

Really? Do you think they would?

Liz Warren, who claims to be part Native American, doesn't know squat about Pocahontas apparently. She was somewhat of a heroine who reportedly saved the life of Capt. John Smith at Jamestown. She is without a doubt the most recognized Native American female in American history. She also went on to a place in history that Liz couldn't dream of. Pocahontas lived 400 years ago; Liz won't be remembered by anyone other than family 50 years from now.

Yep, Pocahontas was quite a remarkable young woman that you'd think Liz would know and think better of.

She was captured and held for ransom by the English during Anglo-Indian hostilities in 1613. During her captivity, she converted to Christianity and took the name Rebecca. When the opportunity arose for her to return to her people, she chose to remain with the English. In April 1614, at the age of 17, she married tobacco planter John Rolfe, and in January 1615, bore their son, Thomas Rolfe.

In 1616, the Rolfes traveled to London. Pocahontas was presented to English society as an example of the "civilized savage" in hopes of stimulating investment in the Jamestown settlement. She became something of a celebrity, was elegantly fêted, and attended a masque at Whitehall Palace. In 1617, the Rolfes set sail for Virginia, but Pocahontas died at Gravesend of unknown causes, aged around 20-21. She was buried in St George's Church, Gravesend in England, but the exact location of her grave is unknown, as the church has been rebuilt.

Numerous places, landmarks, and products in the United States have been named after Pocahontas. Her story has been romanticized over the years, and she is a subject of art, literature, and film. Many famous people have claimed to be among her descendants through her son Thomas, including members of the First Families of Virginia, First LadyEdith Wilson, American Western actor Glenn Strange, Las Vegas performer Wayne Newton, and astronomer Percival Lowell.
​

But Liz believes the very name of Pocahontas is a politically incorrect slur? So she's either stupid regarding Native American history or a racist and it would appear to be both.

So then kiddies....back to the question....what about calling any black man Dr. King.....as opposed to say Sambo or Buckwheat? Or how about Hillary referring to Donna Brazille as "Buffalo". Hillary and Liz have that in common

It would be closer to a real comparison if he referred to them in a derisive manner..which is what Trump was going for....Like hey...how about that "martin luther powell"....or have we heard from "Rosa Parks Rice" yet?

Attempting to spin Trump's comment into paying Warren a complement is funny.
 
The word is being used sarcastically against a person attempting to pose as a member of a certain race or ethnic class.
It's akin to calling a "stolen valor" fraud something like "George Patton".
It's akin to calling race fraud Rachel Dolezal something sarcastic like "Rosa Parks".

None of these terms should be considered an insult or slur to the actual people it would refer to or their group- not an insult to true Native Americans, military personnel, or African Americans.

So she is attempting to pose as something she is not? Actually the reference to Indian heritage was from 10 years ago when she was employed as a professor and it has not been proven false.

The Navajo are offended. I think it is up to them to determine what they consider a slur.

DPsJMfpVQAAIoOe.jpg
 
So she is attempting to pose as something she is not? Actually the reference to Indian heritage was from 10 years ago when she was employed as a professor and it has not been proven false.

The Navajo are offended. I think it is up to them to determine what they consider a slur.

DPsJMfpVQAAIoOe.jpg
I can't account for everyone's level of ethnic or racial sensitivity or political bias, can I?
Sarcastic references to someone who fraudulently claims association with a certain group is NOT being insensitive to the actual group.
 
If President Trump referred to an African-American, let's say Colin Powell or Clarence Thomas, as Dr. King would you consider that a "slur"?

Really? Do you think they would?

Liz Warren, who claims to be part Native American, doesn't know squat about Pocahontas apparently. She was somewhat of a heroine who reportedly saved the life of Capt. John Smith at Jamestown. She is without a doubt the most recognized Native American female in American history. She also went on to a place in history that Liz couldn't dream of. Pocahontas lived 400 years ago; Liz won't be remembered by anyone other than family 50 years from now.

Yep, Pocahontas was quite a remarkable young woman that you'd think Liz would know and think better of.

She was captured and held for ransom by the English during Anglo-Indian hostilities in 1613. During her captivity, she converted to Christianity and took the name Rebecca. When the opportunity arose for her to return to her people, she chose to remain with the English. In April 1614, at the age of 17, she married tobacco planter John Rolfe, and in January 1615, bore their son, Thomas Rolfe.

In 1616, the Rolfes traveled to London. Pocahontas was presented to English society as an example of the "civilized savage" in hopes of stimulating investment in the Jamestown settlement. She became something of a celebrity, was elegantly fêted, and attended a masque at Whitehall Palace. In 1617, the Rolfes set sail for Virginia, but Pocahontas died at Gravesend of unknown causes, aged around 20-21. She was buried in St George's Church, Gravesend in England, but the exact location of her grave is unknown, as the church has been rebuilt.

Numerous places, landmarks, and products in the United States have been named after Pocahontas. Her story has been romanticized over the years, and she is a subject of art, literature, and film. Many famous people have claimed to be among her descendants through her son Thomas, including members of the First Families of Virginia, First LadyEdith Wilson, American Western actor Glenn Strange, Las Vegas performer Wayne Newton, and astronomer Percival Lowell.
​

But Liz believes the very name of Pocahontas is a politically incorrect slur? So she's either stupid regarding Native American history or a racist and it would appear to be both.

So then kiddies....back to the question....what about calling any black man Dr. King.....as opposed to say Sambo or Buckwheat? Or how about Hillary referring to Donna Brazille as "Buffalo". Hillary and Liz have that in common

Your President, Dingbat Trump, is unaware of that history and uses it as a slur. Warren rightfully speaks out as the Indians have in saying that Trump needs to stop mocking with one of their historic figures in history. That he used that while handing out awards to Indian heroes of WW2 knowing how the Indians feel about his use of her as a weapon just shows how ignorant Trump is. Hope that helps.
 
I can't account for everyone's level of ethnic or racial sensitivity or political bias, can I?
Sarcastic references to someone who fraudulently claims association with a certain group is NOT being insensitive to the actual group.

It is up to the members of that group to judge. Not me.

His sarcasm is childish. Nobody has proven or disproven Warren's family lore. It is perfectly irrelevant. Much of what Trump has to say is proven to be a lie. Let's not forget the record breaking attendance at his inauguration. So when he brings up dishonesty...it is certainly going to come back at him in buckets.
 
It is up to the members of that group to judge. Not me.

His sarcasm is childish. Nobody has proven or disproven Warren's family lore. It is perfectly irrelevant. Much of what Trump has to say is proven to be a lie. Let's not forget the record breaking attendance at his inauguration. So when he brings up dishonesty...it is certainly going to come back at him in buckets.
Trump's dishonesty is no excuse for Warren's.
 
Trump's dishonesty is no excuse for Warren's.

As I've said before....I was told by my mother that the family is Irish on both sides. When I did research in to I found that we were actually Danish on my grandmother's side. Did I lie when I told people I was of Irish heritage? No.

Warren was told by her family that a distant ancestor was Cherokee. Nobody has either proven or disproven that impression. It has been proven that Warren received no preferential treatment by any employer.

Trump's dishonesty has no explanation except for the probability that he is such an egomaniac that he can't stand the idea of not being #1 at everything...even if he has to lie about it.
 
If President Trump referred to an African-American, let's say Colin Powell or Clarence Thomas, as Dr. King would you consider that a "slur"?

Really? Do you think they would?

Liz Warren, who claims to be part Native American, doesn't know squat about Pocahontas apparently. She was somewhat of a heroine who reportedly saved the life of Capt. John Smith at Jamestown. She is without a doubt the most recognized Native American female in American history. She also went on to a place in history that Liz couldn't dream of. Pocahontas lived 400 years ago; Liz won't be remembered by anyone other than family 50 years from now.

Yep, Pocahontas was quite a remarkable young woman that you'd think Liz would know and think better of.

She was captured and held for ransom by the English during Anglo-Indian hostilities in 1613. During her captivity, she converted to Christianity and took the name Rebecca. When the opportunity arose for her to return to her people, she chose to remain with the English. In April 1614, at the age of 17, she married tobacco planter John Rolfe, and in January 1615, bore their son, Thomas Rolfe.

In 1616, the Rolfes traveled to London. Pocahontas was presented to English society as an example of the "civilized savage" in hopes of stimulating investment in the Jamestown settlement. She became something of a celebrity, was elegantly fêted, and attended a masque at Whitehall Palace. In 1617, the Rolfes set sail for Virginia, but Pocahontas died at Gravesend of unknown causes, aged around 20-21. She was buried in St George's Church, Gravesend in England, but the exact location of her grave is unknown, as the church has been rebuilt.

Numerous places, landmarks, and products in the United States have been named after Pocahontas. Her story has been romanticized over the years, and she is a subject of art, literature, and film. Many famous people have claimed to be among her descendants through her son Thomas, including members of the First Families of Virginia, First LadyEdith Wilson, American Western actor Glenn Strange, Las Vegas performer Wayne Newton, and astronomer Percival Lowell.
​

But Liz believes the very name of Pocahontas is a politically incorrect slur? So she's either stupid regarding Native American history or a racist and it would appear to be both.

So then kiddies....back to the question....what about calling any black man Dr. King.....as opposed to say Sambo or Buckwheat? Or how about Hillary referring to Donna Brazille as "Buffalo". Hillary and Liz have that in common

Yes, obviously it would be offensive to call every Black person "Martin Luther King."
 
Your President, Dingbat Trump, is unaware of that history and uses it as a slur. Warren rightfully speaks out as the Indians have in saying that Trump needs to stop mocking with one of their historic figures in history. That he used that while handing out awards to Indian heroes of WW2 knowing how the Indians feel about his use of her as a weapon just shows how ignorant Trump is. Hope that helps.

Sarcasm yes, insult maybe if one is sensitive, but Warren, calling the name of a historically important Native American a slur should offend all Native Americans.

Hope that helps.
 
As I've said before....I was told by my mother that the family is Irish on both sides. When I did research in to I found that we were actually Danish on my grandmother's side. Did I lie when I told people I was of Irish heritage? No.

Warren was told by her family that a distant ancestor was Cherokee. Nobody has either proven or disproven that impression. It has been proven that Warren received no preferential treatment by any employer.

Trump's dishonesty has no explanation except for the probability that he is such an egomaniac that he can't stand the idea of not being #1 at everything...even if he has to lie about it.

Family lore counts for nothing. I know that to be true. My wife had some family lore herself. She has some Cherokee blood herself and thought it would be interesting to claim some of the rewards of the Cherokee community in Cherokee NC. (Harrah's Casino).

No genealogical records, no luck. As for preferential treatment...Harvard University was under the diversity gun when she was hired.
 
Family lore counts for nothing. I know that to be true. My wife had some family lore herself. She has some Cherokee blood herself and thought it would be interesting to claim some of the rewards of the Cherokee community in Cherokee NC. (Harrah's Casino).

No genealogical records, no luck. As for preferential treatment...Harvard University was under the diversity gun when she was hired.

Harvard recruiter said it never entered into the conversation when they hired her.
 
It would be closer to a real comparison if he referred to them in a derisive manner..which is what Trump was going for....Like hey...how about that "martin luther powell"....or have we heard from "Rosa Parks Rice" yet?

Attempting to spin Trump's comment into paying Warren a complement is funny.

I'm not spinning anything Trump. I'm calling out an apparent bigot, and idiot,who should know better than to say the name of a revered Native American is a slur in itself.
 
A hurt being pretended where none exists. I'm so sick of minorities taking offense over every little thing, but in this case, Warren isn't even a minority so no pretend foul.
 
If President Trump referred to an African-American, let's say Colin Powell or Clarence Thomas, as Dr. King would you consider that a "slur"?

It would certainly be incredibly bizarre, since it would suggest he lumps all members of that race into one bucket. As for "slur," it probably wouldn't be intended that way. But, let's take a closer approximation of what Trump did with regard to Warren. To do that, we need him to be referring to someone whom he deeply dislikes and frequently attacks. And we need to epithet to be intended to ridicule the person, not to honor him or her. And w'd need the epithet not to refer to a modern person of that race who is broadly respected by nearly everyone, but instead to some long-ago member of the race who is frequently subject to racial caricature.

So, it would be more like if Trump referred to Obama as "Shaka Zulu." And, yes, that would obviously be a slur.
 
Family lore counts for nothing. I know that to be true. My wife had some family lore herself. She has some Cherokee blood herself and thought it would be interesting to claim some of the rewards of the Cherokee community in Cherokee NC. (Harrah's Casino).

No genealogical records, no luck. As for preferential treatment...Harvard University was under the diversity gun when she was hired.
Family lore counts when it comes to the question of whether or not Warren behaved fraudulently. If she honestly believed she had Native American ancestry, based on having been told that by older members of her family, and it later turned out not to be true (or simply turned out not to be proven), that wouldn't be fraud.

I'm a genealogy buff, and I've notice a big gap between family lore and truth. I'd been told by my grandmother that her family line came from South Carolina, where they owned a plantation before the Civil War. This was untrue. There was, indeed, a family with her last name (which is fairly rare), that owned a plantation in pre-Civil War South Carolina, but she wasn't descended from them. My research found definitively when and where her people came to America, and that other group with her last name were already set up at the time. All I can guess is the false claim was the product of a less careful genealogist in an earlier period, or just guesswork from snippets of family stories. And yet, before I did the research, I'd told others that my people came from South Carolina. That wasn't fraud on my part -- just a good faith passing along of an incorrect family legend.

I've also been told that a couple of my ancestors were Native American. For a while, I repeated that. But, so far, I haven't been able to confirm it. I can find the ancestors in question in Census documents, but it's back in 1850 when they didn't list race in those documents. Their names are English-style names (as were all the Native Americans living in that area at that time), so I have no clue. So, at this point, I don't make the claim any more. I'm going to do one of those genetics tests to see if that helps me nail down whether the story is true or just another false legend.

That said, some of the family legends turned out to be dead right. Another line came from exactly the place in Europe I was told it did, at exactly the time they said, and the stories about Revolutionary War ancestors and Mayflower ancestors proved correct. Family lore is a hit or miss thing.
 
It would certainly be incredibly bizarre, since it would suggest he lumps all members of that race into one bucket. As for "slur," it probably wouldn't be intended that way. But, let's take a closer approximation of what Trump did with regard to Warren. To do that, we need him to be referring to someone whom he deeply dislikes and frequently attacks. And we need to epithet to be intended to ridicule the person, not to honor him or her. And w'd need the epithet not to refer to a modern person of that race who is broadly respected by nearly everyone, but instead to some long-ago member of the race who is frequently subject to racial caricature.

So, it would be more like if Trump referred to Obama as "Shaka Zulu." And, yes, that would obviously be a slur.

It would be a bit like referring to all Jewish people as "Israel" or "Sarah" as was done in Nazi Germany.
 
Family lore counts when it comes to the question of whether or not Warren behaved fraudulently. If she honestly believed she had Native American ancestry, based on having been told that by older members of her family, and it later turned out not to be true (or simply turned out not to be proven), that wouldn't be fraud.

I'm a genealogy buff, and I've notice a big gap between family lore and truth. I'd been told by my grandmother that her family line came from South Carolina, where they owned a plantation before the Civil War. This was untrue. There was, indeed, a family with her last name (which is fairly rare), that owned a plantation in pre-Civil War South Carolina, but she wasn't descended from them. My research found definitively when and where her people came to America, and that other group with her last name were already set up at the time. All I can guess is the false claim was the product of a less careful genealogist in an earlier period, or just guesswork from snippets of family stories. And yet, before I did the research, I'd told others that my people came from South Carolina. That wasn't fraud on my part -- just a good faith passing along of an incorrect family legend.

I've also been told that a couple of my ancestors were Native American. For a while, I repeated that. But, so far, I haven't been able to confirm it. I can find the ancestors in question in Census documents, but it's back in 1850 when they didn't list race in those documents. Their names are English-style names (as were all the Native Americans living in that area at that time), so I have no clue. So, at this point, I don't make the claim any more. I'm going to do one of those genetics tests to see if that helps me nail down whether the story is true or just another false legend.

That said, some of the family legends turned out to be dead right. Another line came from exactly the place in Europe I was told it did, at exactly the time they said, and the stories about Revolutionary War ancestors and Mayflower ancestors proved correct. Family lore is a hit or miss thing.

Part of the problem is they actually did not keep records on Indians. The second issue is even the known DNA test is just for entertainment and not accurate so we are all destined to rely on that inexact science of information handed down by generations of our own families. No one can say Warren does not have Indian in her bloodline so the slam on her is very much like all of them thinking they are only 3 or 4 nationalities after 10 or 20 generational marriages. It is a nice hat trick but not exactly accurate. However what is true is every American seems to be Irish on Saint Patrick's Day.
 
Back
Top