New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Moderate Catholics

Giving to Ceaser has nothing to do with this subject. That is money. .Obama gave the Church an out. Now those 35 Bishops want blood. It is clear what they are doing.You have 195 diocese that do not agree with them.They have the right to stand up and say,Not in my Name!

Of course God created life,but maybe you can explain to me all the billions of embryos and sperm that never create life.

There are too many people on this planet now and if birth control slows that,so be it. Honestly,I do no care what a group of Right Wing bishops decide is right. Apparently,many Catholics do not either.

Pope John was an enlightened Pope. What you have now is a group of regressives that would be happy to have another Crusade or inquisition. That is how far in the past they are. They are hurting your Church, not making it stronger, so that makes you,"An Enabler,!
 
Giving to Ceaser has nothing to do with this subject. That is money. .Obama gave the Church an out. Now those 35 Bishops want blood. It is clear what they are doing.You have 195 diocese that do not agree with them.They have the right to stand up and say,Not in my Name!

Of course God created life,but maybe you can explain to me all the billions of embryos and sperm that never create life.

There are too many people on this planet now and if birth control slows that,so be it. Honestly,I do no care what a group of Right Wing bishops decide is right. Apparently,many Catholics do not either.

Pope John was an enlightened Pope. What you have now is a group of regressives that would be happy to have another Crusade or inquisition. That is how far in the past they are. They are hurting your Church, not making it stronger, so that makes you,"An Enabler,!


First of all, Obama didn't give the Church an out. He gave them a way to keep their name off the check that will pay for it. But they will be the ones who will fund it, no doubt, regardless of whose name is on the check. That's not an out, MaryAnne. That's shiester accounting. It's the Chicago way.

Second, I posted what the bishop Dionne based his point of view on really said. You ignored it. That's fine. Truly inquiring minds won't ignore the facts. An it's posts like your top one that help bring the BS to light. The people the bishop was talking about were right and left politicians and pundits, not fellow bishops and it was clear in the original article. Dionne cherrypicked what he wanted to sell his own lie.The bishop came back to the same source to repeat himself BECAUSE of Dionne's lie. And you're still hanging onto it. What this tells me is that there is some trepidation among Obama supporters and worry that he might have gone too far if you guys are this desperate that you'll cling to this.

The bishop spoke very clearly about the fact that the bishops are in agreement about the mandate, and that it needs to be stopped. The fact that not every diocese will sue means nothing. The dioceses not suing are not refraining because they don't agree with the others about the mandate. None of the bishops have said "not in my name!". That's all wishful thinking. You really need to get a bit of an idea about how the Church works and you need to accept that Dionne lied before you decide what anything he said means. Just to give you an example, there are no lawsuits coming from the dioceses I visit, but the bishops and priests talk plenty and give plenty of reminders about the fight against the mandate and how we can help, what we can do, what we should do, and how parishes and dioceses are supporting the efforts to fight this. Friends and family in NY, Nevada, and Wisconsin and CA. are hearing the same things I am. And there's plenty of the same discussion on college campuses as well.

The only person who wants blood is Obama. And he is the regressive, resurrecting, practically verbatim, old fight tactics that were used by people who admitted to villianizing the Catholic Church for their agenda FORTY YEARS AGO. That's how far back he's taking us all.

I don't know what they teach about the passage about Ceasar in your church, but I told you what they teach in mine. Every life belongs to God, and that's what Jesus is telling the pharissees. I know people like to use that passage as support for separating religious beliefs from the secular things we support, but we don't see it that way. We believe God creates life. We believe He knows why He chose to begin each life this way. You have a secular right to believe something else and act on it. No one is taking those rights away from you. Why force people who don't believe what you do, to do what you feel you can do? Nobody's coming into your church and telling your leaders what to teach and believe.


There are not too many people on the planet, and if you feel there are, again, you need to wonder about whether God is making mistake after mistake as He creates people. If you're gonna make the case that BC and abortion are the answers to over population, AND you believe God creates life (which is what you said) then in essence what you're saying is that God keeps screwing up and we have to correct His error down here.
Either way, contraceptive use and abortion were supposed to be about the individual woman and what she chose. That's how it was sold to you. But now the left is championing these things as remedies for overpopulation of the "wrong" kinds of people. This is exactly what the original proponents of both had in mind, and you've fallen right in line. You're preaching Sanger's gospel. You have a right to. Lucky for you this egomaniacal president doesn't have a problem with your beliefs....at least not yet.


And about those Crusades...What exactly were they Crusading against again?
 
First of all, Obama didn't give the Church an out. He gave them a way to keep their name off the check that will pay for it. But they will be the ones who will fund it, no doubt, regardless of whose name is on the check. That's not an out, MaryAnne. That's shiester accounting. It's the Chicago way.

Second, I posted what the bishop Dionne based his point of view on really said. You ignored it. That's fine. Truly inquiring minds won't ignore the facts. An it's posts like your top one that help bring the BS to light. The people the bishop was talking about were right and left politicians and pundits, not fellow bishops and it was clear in the original article. Dionne cherrypicked what he wanted to sell his own lie.The bishop came back to the same source to repeat himself BECAUSE of Dionne's lie. And you're still hanging onto it. What this tells me is that there is some trepidation among Obama supporters and worry that he might have gone too far if you guys are this desperate that you'll cling to this.

The bishop spoke very clearly about the fact that the bishops are in agreement about the mandate, and that it needs to be stopped. The fact that not every diocese will sue means nothing. The dioceses not suing are not refraining because they don't agree with the others about the mandate. None of the bishops have said "not in my name!". That's all wishful thinking. You really need to get a bit of an idea about how the Church works and you need to accept that Dionne lied before you decide what anything he said means. Just to give you an example, there are no lawsuits coming from the dioceses I visit, but the bishops and priests talk plenty and give plenty of reminders about the fight against the mandate and how we can help, what we can do, what we should do, and how parishes and dioceses are supporting the efforts to fight this. Friends and family in NY, Nevada, and Wisconsin and CA. are hearing the same things I am. And there's plenty of the same discussion on college campuses as well.

The only person who wants blood is Obama. And he is the regressive, resurrecting, practically verbatim, old fight tactics that were used by people who admitted to villianizing the Catholic Church for their agenda FORTY YEARS AGO. That's how far back he's taking us all.

I don't know what they teach about the passage about Ceasar in your church, but I told you what they teach in mine. Every life belongs to God, and that's what Jesus is telling the pharissees. I know people like to use that passage as support for separating religious beliefs from the secular things we support, but we don't see it that way. We believe God creates life. We believe He knows why He chose to begin each life this way. You have a secular right to believe something else and act on it. No one is taking those rights away from you. Why force people who don't believe what you do, to do what you feel you can do? Nobody's coming into your church and telling your leaders what to teach and believe.


There are not too many people on the planet, and if you feel there are, again, you need to wonder about whether God is making mistake after mistake as He creates people. If you're gonna make the case that BC and abortion are the answers to over population, AND you believe God creates life (which is what you said) then in essence what you're saying is that God keeps screwing up and we have to correct His error down here.
Either way, contraceptive use and abortion were supposed to be about the individual woman and what she chose. That's how it was sold to you. But now the left is championing these things as remedies for overpopulation of the "wrong" kinds of people. This is exactly what the original proponents of both had in mind, and you've fallen right in line. You're preaching Sanger's gospel. You have a right to. Lucky for you this egomaniacal president doesn't have a problem with your beliefs....at least not yet.


And about those Crusades...What exactly were they Crusading against again?

When there are very wet springs, and mild winters, rabbits reproduce rapidly. The overabundance of rabbits means that foxes have plenty of food, and also reproduce abundantly. When winter comes, the foxes have eaten the abundance of rabbits, produced an overabundance of kits, and many foxes starve. It is the way of the world. When humans discover how to grow crops, nourish the crops with fertilizer, protect the crops with pesticides, there is an abundance of food. An abundance of food allows humans to reproduce abundantly. When the humans reproduce behond the ability to the foodstuffs to feed them, they starve and die. It is the way of the world. Whether a god or no, if humans out reproduce our ability to supply ourselves with food, people will die. Better than, to self-prune our reproduction to a number manageable within this limited sphere we call our world. God created it that way - see 'foxes and rabbits.' If there is a god, he doesn't make mistake after mistake as he creates people, but you can bet your a$$ that we make mistakes. One of those mistakes is to treat this world as though it were an infinite resource, because it's not.
 
MaryAnne, I just hope you don't think that the naysayers/Bishop apologists in this thread represent all Catholics. they don't.
 
MaryAnne, I just hope you don't think that the naysayers/Bishop apologists in this thread represent all Catholics. they don't.

No,Julie,I do not. People who are dogmatic, right or wrong do not impress me at all. A good share of my family was composed of Catholics and Lutherans..I have been around the Church much of my life. I know the difference in right wing idealogues and those who use the brain God gave them.
 
Um, no, 13 out of 195 Diocese did sue. So 182 diocese didn't sue.



The headlines this week were about lawsuits brought by 43 Catholic organizations, including 13 dioceses, to overturn regulations issued by the administration requiring insurance plans to cover contraception under the new health care law. But the other side of this news was also significant: That the vast majority of the nation's 195 dioceses did not go to court.

Ok,45 Catholic organizations did sue,including 13 Diocese. I would say that is a majority,wouldn't you?
 
No,Julie,I do not. People who are dogmatic, right or wrong do not impress me at all. A good share of my family was composed of Catholics and Lutherans..I have been around the Church much of my life. I know the difference in right wing idealogues and those who use the brain God gave them.


The USCCB has received tremendous support from their brother priests and from Catholic and non-Catholic communities on this issue. I guess that translates to you as just a group of people not using their brains because they don't see things the way you do. But that aside, the Church doesn't work by majority rule, MaryAnne. And because they don't, they don't seek to create a majority on any issue. The results of lawsuits filed will speak to many ministries of the same kinds.

I made the mistake of offering you the faith belief that makes adhering to this mandate impossible for the Church leaders, since YOU brought the issue up again. I thought you might better understand the predicament the Church is in, even if your own beliefs are different. But somehow, explaining the belief makes one a "right wing ideologue." Your implication that anyone who espouses the Catholic Church's positions is a "right wing ideologue" only illustrates how little you know about what we believe.

I didn't see any of the other Catholics here explaining to you the Church's belief about life that makes this mandate impossible.Even if they don't believe it, you'd think they'd at least know it. So I thought I would explain it. And for that you resort to namecalling. It's an intersting thing that Catholics who champion some other voice in Catholicism not only refuse to explain the Church belief, but also refuse to discuss the error they find in it.

Perhaps you can use that brain God gave you and explain to leaders and members of a Church that believes God creates every life WHY it's okay to stop those lives. And then we can all agree, and the Church will no longer have a problem providing the products and services that stop those lives. I've brought it up to you twice. You haven't addressed it yet.

I certainly wasn't trying to impress you. If I wasn't Catholic, I'd be supporting the Church on this one. This is a religious liberty issue.


ETA: In my own defense I'll add that at least I used the brain God gave me to check the source Dionne offered.
 
The USCCB has received tremendous support from their brother priests and from Catholic and non-Catholic communities on this issue. I guess that translates to you as just a group of people not using their brains because they don't see things the way you do. But that aside, the Church doesn't work by majority rule, MaryAnne. And because they don't, they don't seek to create a majority on any issue. The results of lawsuits filed will speak to many ministries of the same kinds.

I made the mistake of offering you the faith belief that makes adhering to this mandate impossible for the Church leaders, since YOU brought the issue up again. I thought you might better understand the predicament the Church is in, even if your own beliefs are different. But somehow, explaining the belief makes one a "right wing ideologue." Your implication that anyone who espouses the Catholic Church's positions is a "right wing ideologue" only illustrates how little you know about what we believe.

I didn't see any of the other Catholics here explaining to you the Church's belief about life that makes this mandate impossible.Even if they don't believe it, you'd think they'd at least know it. So I thought I would explain it. And for that you resort to namecalling. It's an intersting thing that Catholics who champion some other voice in Catholicism not only refuse to explain the Church belief, but also refuse to discuss the error they find in it.

Perhaps you can use that brain God gave you and explain to leaders and members of a Church that believes God creates every life WHY it's okay to stop those lives. And then we can all agree, and the Church will no longer have a problem providing the products and services that stop those lives. I've brought it up to you twice. You haven't addressed it yet.

I certainly wasn't trying to impress you. If I wasn't Catholic, I'd be supporting the Church on this one. This is a religious liberty issue.


ETA: In my own defense I'll add that at least I used the brain God gave me to check the source Dionne offered.

Gigi,the prediciment that Church is in is due to the leaders of same Church. I misquoted the number of lawsuits. That was what I heard on the news,but the number is higher than I said. Just not Diocese,it was Catholic organisations.

They have ignored the Priests who used young boys very much against the teachings of the Church. Allowed those same Leaders to move Priests around,making a mockery of how they obey civil law.

Now,they are embroiled in a scandal of greed and treachery at the very top of the Vatican.

I understand how you believe your faith, and feel for you. I am also quite sure in your heart this saddens you too. I know how I feel when I am let down by so called Leaders in my Church. But since I can belong to any Protestant Church I choose I can move on. I do not follow the dogma of any man. My faith is within me,it is not the laws of any church. My posts are not an attack on you, but until the leaders clean up their attack this will get worse for the Church. The hits just keep coming and they come from the top. The latest is just anoter exapmple of a Church that piles up millions,allows the Pope to live in such spendor while taking from the poor.And,now they are even attacking the Nuns who take care of the poor. You dwell on birth control and how it is so awful but fail to thinks of those born who are starving.
I am not discussing the faith of any of the Catholics on the board. I am disussing the failure of the leaders,much as I discuss the falure of our Leaders. Like the Church,until we clean house, nothing will be done about the failures.

I feel for the millions of Catholics who are there,and do not agree with this group.

I see the Nuns are getting organized for the attack on them. This will not help.
 
Gigi,the prediciment that Church is in is due to the leaders of same Church. I misquoted the number of lawsuits. That was what I heard on the news,but the number is higher than I said. Just not Diocese,it was Catholic organisations.

They have ignored the Priests who used young boys very much against the teachings of the Church. Allowed those same Leaders to move Priests around,making a mockery of how they obey civil law.

Now,they are embroiled in a scandal of greed and treachery at the very top of the Vatican.

I understand how you believe your faith, and feel for you. I am also quite sure in your heart this saddens you too. I know how I feel when I am let down by so called Leaders in my Church. But since I can belong to any Protestant Church I choose I can move on. I do not follow the dogma of any man. My faith is within me,it is not the laws of any church. My posts are not an attack on you, but until the leaders clean up their attack this will get worse for the Church. The hits just keep coming and they come from the top. The latest is just anoter exapmple of a Church that piles up millions,allows the Pope to live in such spendor while taking from the poor.And,now they are even attacking the Nuns who take care of the poor. You dwell on birth control and how it is so awful but fail to thinks of those born who are starving.
I am not discussing the faith of any of the Catholics on the board. I am disussing the failure of the leaders,much as I discuss the falure of our Leaders. Like the Church,until we clean house, nothing will be done about the failures.

I feel for the millions of Catholics who are there,and do not agree with this group.

I see the Nuns are getting organized for the attack on them. This will not help.

MaryAnne, attack is a strong word for this context in my opinion. But clearly you've made remarks that are personal. The opinion you've expressed is...people who disagree with the Church leadership are using their brains, and people who support the Church leadership are just dogmatics and right wing ideologues. You don't respect them because they don't use their brains. I'm the one arguing this with you. So it's not as if we have to look around and think, gee, I wonder who MaryAnne is talking about when she uses these names.


I'm free to go join any Protestant church I choose, too. We all are. You feel for Catholics who don't agree with the Church. But have you stopped and thought about why they continue to call themselves Catholic when they disagree with so much of what this particular church believes? Don't you think that if they were using the brain God gave them, they'd go worship at a church they believe teaches the truth instead of hanging around a church they believe oppresses women and the poor, is full of evil men, and teaches fake things? Imagine me saying I agree with some of the things the Methodists believe, so I guess I'm a Methodist and if I keep bellyaching and pushing them against what they believe is true, eventually, they'll cave and embrace my definition of the Methodist faith. In the meantime, I ought to count myself as one of those rare "thinking" methodists who has to suffer ideologues until they wake up. Really, that's the mentality of the people you "feel for" while the rest of us who are just trying to explain the issue are defined as "RW Ideologues" who don't use our brains. I think the real problem is that you don't have an answer to our dilemma either and so you'd rather not hear about it. It certainly does get in the way of all the judgements people have about our beliefs when they themselves cant' reconcile their belief that God creates all life in the manner He sees fit to their opinion that we should be free to stop those lives. Maybe you just got mad at me for bringing it up. I don't know. You never did answer my question.

We don't believe our dogma is manmade. Everything we believe is from Scripture. We don't ask you to believe it too. I think at this point we're only asking that you don't support forcing us to act counter to what we believe is true. Perhaps when you go to a new church and "move on", you've gone to a place where you like the message. The MAN at one church gave a message you disagreed with. The man at the new church has created something from his interpretation that you can agree with. When you don't like what he says anymore, you go other churches looking for a pastor (a man or woman) who has come up with(as in MADE) something you agree with. When you find what you like, you sit down inside and assure yourself that you don't follow manmade rules.
Whatever works for you.

We believe that sometimes the message will be incovenient. But if we believe it's true, then we don't abandon it because it might get in the way of things we'd like to do or not do. The fact that we're not perfect doesn't mean that we're not supposed to keep trying to be faithful to what we believe is true.

We don't dwell on birth control and ignore starving people. That's a very dishonest thing to say. Obama has pushed a religious belief into the center ring because HE wants it changed. So it's being discussed. It's hardly something we discuss constantly. Believe me, direction on how to serve the poor and needing is given more attention than anything else from the pulpit. A great number of people are so eager to defend Obama and this thing they swore he'd never do, that they twist and spin Church belief and ignore the Church's contributions in the world so they can write untrue things about "punishing poor s l u t s" or ignoring the poor.

The Catholic Church is the largest charitable organization in the world. When government "funds" Church ministries, what really takes place is local, state, and federal government goes to the Church and asks that they expand a ministry that's making a difference. What the people of a locale get in return are the benefits of all the Church's own funding of these ministries, armies of volunteers, and results. There's a great deal of help in the way of man hours and personal financial resources that come from those brainless ideologues and dispicable priests. That you'll take, as long as we check what's true in our hearts at the door. Up til now, partnerships between governments and Church have worked fine, with government realizing that when they ask the Church to spread their involvement, the Church would do it without sacrificing their understanding of God. Obama is the one destroying that partnership that has brought relief and education to so many. He actually believes that thinking, compassionate women will respect what he's doing to the poor and the sick in this country and around the world for the sake of free birth control.



As far as the abuse, at this point, it's a stick people use to beat up members of the Church with. If the scandal hadn't happened, the people, like yourself, who bring it up, would not be viewing the Church's beliefs any differently than you do now. The inspiration for bringing it up in conversations about this mandate is to cast stones, so to speak. Some people in the Church did terrible things. So therefore the whole Church is corrupt and the message the Church teaches is false, their credibility is shot forever, they should teach nothing, and they deserve everything that happens to them. It's ironic, because that's actually in conflict with what Christ teaches. He picks a sinner up out of the dirt and saves her from being killed because she's still precious to Him regardless of her sins.He doesn't end her existence on earth right there. He promises paradise to a thief because of the bit of faith the thief had inside. He's picked the Church up out of the dirt before, and He will do it again. Let the one who has no sin cast stones. The rest can go on preaching about forgiveness.

Bad men and women do bad things. The acts those priests committed have been committed by many people in leadership positions....including ministers in Protestant churches. The acts of evil people don't change what's true in the world. The fact that men did these heinous things doesn't make all the things the Church believes and teaches into lies. IF you have a family member that did terrible things, you don't stop teaching your own children right from wrong because you feel your credibility is shot since you didn't know about that family member's evil. People like to talk about Pope Benedict and what did he know, not know, etc... But the pope didn't come up with these beliefs we embrace that seem to be so annoying to some lately. The beliefs existed before he did. Yet he's being criticized for holding faithful to these beliefs after others in the Church have committed sins.

The "scandal" that's going on now has to do with the pope being betrayed by someone who was close to him on a daily basis. . Jesus was betrayed by someone close to Him. Talk about it happening at the Top! Of course, if you're going to rely on people like Dionne for the facts, you're going to be lied to In fact, when I get time, I want to comb over that site you linked, because at a glance, I saw a couple of "headlines" that were completely untrue.

The nuns have not been attacked. It's been a great number of years that the Church has been trying to fix what's terribly wrong in their orders. They're anti-Catholic feminists. They've simply been using the same schtick Obama is using, but for years before he did. The MO is to force the Church to compromise on truths by waiving the poor around. In addition, they don't teach the faith to anyone anymore. They teach new age "religion". They believe that the answers to the world's problems are 'beyond Jesus', "beyond the Crucifixion" and in pagan beliefs. Do a bit of research on them before you feel so sorry for them. I've worked with a couple of them. Not Catholic by any stretch of the imagination. I'm Catholic, and a woman, and I'm grateful that the pope is finally telling them to put a sock in it. JP2 was way too laid back with them.
If you feel so sorry for them, do us all a favor and invite them to join your church and let them teach there. You wouldn't want me in your Sunday School classroom giving out Rosaries. Maybe you'll be okay with these sisters giving the kids their 'power crystals" though. Really. Call them, write to them. Tell them you have a place where they'll be welcomed with open arms.

It's ironic though. Clergy that tries to be faithful to the beliefs and live with the stigma that has attached itself to the Catholic priesthood because others have been unfaithful, are hypocrites. But nuns who are so unabashedly unfaithful to the beliefs are martyrs.
 
Back
Top