September 27, 2012
(Newser) – You can't be a Catholic in Germany if you don't pay "church tax," a federal court has ruled. Germany requires people registered as Catholics, Protestants, or Jews to pay an extra tax worth 8% to 9% of their income tax bill, but the law was challenged by a retired professor who said he wanted to remain within the Catholic faith without paying the tax, the BBC reports. The professor argued that church membership was determined by a person's beliefs, not by a financial relationship.
The church, which received $6.4 billion from German taxpayers last year, warned that anybody who refused to pay up would be denied Holy Communion and a religious burial, as well as being barred from working for the church and its schools. Critics of the ruling said Germany's bishops were sending the wrong message by taking a hard line on the tax when the church is already in crisis. As in other countries, large numbers of Catholics in Germany have left the church in recent years amid sexual abuse scandals.
This just adds to my dislike of organized religion.
The "crisis" was created by the catholic church.
Does not the situation in Germany appear to be a very unique matter and an anomale? Does this prove anything or maybe disprove NS's charge? I see Germany gives the churches 6.5 billion a year to help run its hospitals, schools and charities. Maybe that adds to the need for this tax? Whatever the case may be there that is not how the Catholic Church is operated around the world and throughout history, and pretty much the same for Protestant faiths as well. All are welcome, you do not have to pay to worship.
Are there "incentives" for CEO's to not want to pay more in taxes or take less in pay??? Why are they "worth it" and those at the bottom, especially those working two jobs, but at wages too low to get out from under poverty NOT worth a living wage?
What is it you are trying to argue here? Is this some Republican belief that CEO’s should make a lot of money? Or is a democrat belief that there should be some law limiting private earnings? I am not following?
People want everyone to have children, yet when it comes to supporting those who have children, they suddenly back up and start claiming they can't afford that because they have plans to buy another mansion instead and "need" that money to "survive" all the "hardships" they face compared to those trying to feed their children on wages and benefits that those at the top keep shrinking for those at the bottom and middle. The more those at the bottom and middle give up, the more those at the top pocket the "savings".
What??? I do not follow this paragraph?
Except a portion of it you seem to be implying there is this “hypocrisy” of conservatives who believe in allowing families to have children but are not willing to pay taxes because some goes to helping them? I don’t follow?
I used that example because it was so current.
I was a Catholic all my life until the last few years. With respect to anyone who is of the C faith I hate to ever post things against a faith you have such faith in as I know many do. In fact in these past few years, I have fought for the people in the U.S. to keep their churches open.
However, I know for a fact after having four children in the Catholic school system you either give to the church and pay tuition or you are out. We were doing both at the time when they went member to member to each home to get pledges that could be made over a three year period to build a new church. They were not asking for a $1,000 but thousands and we did not have enough in our already stretched budget to pledge.
Things changed for us and our kids suffered some because of it. We were one of the families who suffered little but those where one partner was lost from death or illness and could not work suffered the most because they were asked to make arrangements at a public school in our area.
I should have said this but didn't at the time but did when fighting to keep the churches open for these dear people whose church they had supported in some cases for 70 and 80 years.
" If you would sell just a little of the gold in the Vatican, you could feed the starving children of the world and also take care of your members who have been loyal to you all these years"
I used that example because it was so current.
I was a Catholic all my life until the last few years. With respect to anyone who is of the C faith I hate to ever post things against a faith you have such faith in as I know many do. In fact in these past few years, I have fought for the people in the U.S. to keep their churches open.
However, I know for a fact after having four children in the Catholic school system you either give to the church and pay tuition or you are out. We were doing both at the time when they went member to member to each home to get pledges that could be made over a three year period to build a new church. They were not asking for a $1,000 but thousands and we did not have enough in our already stretched budget to pledge.
Things changed for us and our kids suffered some because of it. We were one of the families who suffered little but those where one partner was lost from death or illness and could not work suffered the most because they were asked to make arrangements at a public school in our area.
I should have said this but didn't at the time but did when fighting to keep the churches open for these dear people whose church they had supported in some cases for 70 and 80 years.
" If you would sell just a little of the gold in the Vatican, you could feed the starving children of the world and also take care of your members who have been loyal to you all these years"
You were speaking of "incentives" for people to do things like stay on assitance, no? How about "incentives" for people to bilk their customers, to cut wages and benefits or generally to be corrupt in some manner because they profit from it?
"This comparison of yours carries no meaning for me. Yes, I think I get it, the latter is very dishonest and sinful. So? How does that address government assistance? Anyway, if someone is foolish enough to think additional profits is an incentive for biliking their customers, well, I do not think I can reason with them on any subject."
Would you say there is some hypocrisy in suggesting a woman would be a murderer for having an abortion based on here estimation of being able to afford to raise a child while at the same time also suggesting that it is too expensive to pay for the welfare of children whose parents cannot afford to raise them to reasonable standard?
Oh, perhaps a little hypocrisy, but it would not change my main point which is not about children on welfare. I was explaining that for able-bodied men (and women), it is not in their best interests or ours to allow them to collect welfare benefits perpetually without either having them work for it. Same with unemployment. If it goes beyond a reasonable period, like 9 or 10 months, then there should be some labor attached to the benefits. In both cases it would be an incentive to get them to find a better way out and it would help the rest of us tax payers and the economy. I do not think we can punish women for having children nor would I deny them benefits. It is this crazy culture that laughs at God and morals that has brought about so much sexual activity outside of marriage. Killing the innocent child within is hardly the answer.
As to legal abortion in another sense… you, too, are a murderer for wanting it legal. So is everyone who votes accordingly. I am a murderer for being too passive in my battle to change it. Many others complicit in these acts. I am certain this act causes God as much sorrow as anything. Especially in affluent nations such as ours.
September 27, 2012
(Newser) – You can't be a Catholic in Germany if you don't pay "church tax," a federal court has ruled. Germany requires people registered as Catholics, Protestants, or Jews to pay an extra tax worth 8% to 9% of their income tax bill, but the law was challenged by a retired professor who said he wanted to remain within the Catholic faith without paying the tax, the BBC reports. The professor argued that church membership was determined by a person's beliefs, not by a financial relationship.
Thanks Lily,I was about to post that.The same holds true of Mormons.
The church, which received $6.4 billion from German taxpayers last year, warned that anybody who refused to pay up would be denied Holy Communion and a religious burial, as well as being barred from working for the church and its schools. Critics of the ruling said Germany's bishops were sending the wrong message by taking a hard line on the tax when the church is already in crisis. As in other countries, large numbers of Catholics in Germany have left the church in recent years amid sexual abuse scandals.
I used that example because it was so current.
I was a Catholic all my life until the last few years. With respect to anyone who is of the C faith I hate to ever post things against a faith you have such faith in as I know many do. In fact in these past few years, I have fought for the people in the U.S. to keep their churches open.
However, I know for a fact after having four children in the Catholic school system you either give to the church and pay tuition or you are out. We were doing both at the time when they went member to member to each home to get pledges that could be made over a three year period to build a new church. They were not asking for a $1,000 but thousands and we did not have enough in our already stretched budget to pledge.
Things changed for us and our kids suffered some because of it. We were one of the families who suffered little but those where one partner was lost from death or illness and could not work suffered the most because they were asked to make arrangements at a public school in our area.
I should have said this but didn't at the time but did when fighting to keep the churches open for these dear people whose church they had supported in some cases for 70 and 80 years.
" If you would sell just a little of the gold in the Vatican, you could feed the starving children of the world and also take care of your members who have been loyal to you all these years"
What you are dealing with above is not the same as to what was being implied by N.S. Yes, to go to a Catholic school one has to pay, that is not a volunteer pledge of money. Most families cannot afford to send their kids to a Catholic school, I could not. But I did not see where I had a right to expect it. I also see all this crticism of tax free land, etc., for the Catholic Church, but almost no one thanking them for putting millions of children through a high standard education without any tax payer funding.
I note in your comment they went from door to door asking for pledges. Once again, no one would be denied attending mass or receiving the sacraments because they could not afford to pledge even one dime.
As far as keeping churches open is concerned, that is the reality of today. There are far fewer families interested in being true Catholics, attending mass, etc., consequently far fewer members to support the cost, and even worse, a generation of children raised without the slightest idea who God is and what does it matter.
This "gold in the Vatican" line is really not well thought out. The Vatican budget is spartan, the art works in the Vatican are not allowed to be sold as a matter of decree, more or less. They are for the world or the people to enjoy and to connect with God in some way. There is not much gold in the Vatican, I dare say without knowing for sure. There are billions expended on the most needy of this world, via the charity of the Church. But as long as someone sees a glorious cathedral or a bishop in fine clothes. then they cynic will boast who rich and selfish the Church is. I wish them well when they receive their own judgment.
So do some people stay on charitable and church "handouts" "indefinitely". What's the difference between who's handing out, if one is trying to suggest that offering handouts produces some sort of dependency?
Are there "incentives" for CEO's to not want to pay more in taxes or take less in pay??? Why are they "worth it" and those at the bottom, especially those working two jobs, but at wages too low to get out from under poverty NOT worth a living wage? People want everyone to have children, yet when it comes to supporting those who have children, they suddenly back up and start claiming they can't afford that because they have plans to buy another mansion instead and "need" that money to "survive" all the "hardships" they face compared to those trying to feed their children on wages and benefits that those at the top keep shrinking for those at the bottom and middle. The more those at the bottom and middle give up, the more those at the top pocket the "savings".