New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

More bipartisan ideas.

Arkady

President
There are a lot of things we aren't going to be cooperating on, since they involve fundamental disagreements in political philosophy: the proper size and role of government, the balance between federal and state power, etc. At best, be can find compromises on those things. But, on other matters, we should be able to find common goals. Yesterday I posted about one: staffing more of the government apolitically, based on skills and experience rather than partisan favors. Here are a couple others:

Election reform. It's a national embarrassment that some voters can walk right in and vote without delay, while some others waited in line for many hours to exercise that same right. We should address the inequities in voting methods and polling station staffing levels and equipment, so that nowhere are average wait times long enough to meaningfully deter voting.

We should also require auditable voting methods. I think the best is probably an electronic machine that prints out a paper ballot that the voter than puts in a ballot box. The electronic machine would then be able to contribute instant vote counts, sparing manpower and delay, but the paper ballots would act as a check on accuracy in a number of ways. Voters could see that their votes reflected what they intended to do, and a combination of statistical analyses and spot checks of paper ballots could figure out if there were any glitchy machines or systematic hacking. This should be done nationally, so that all voters get equal treatment.
 
Here's more discussion of the same concepts:

http://www.salon.com/2012/11/08/hey_obama_lets_actually_fix_elections/

He brings up an item I shouldn't have missed: districting. In this election, it appears that there were more Democratic votes than Republican ones in the House, and yet the Republicans won significantly more seats. That's because districting is currently largely in the hands of Republican state legislators, who gerrymandered shamelessly: packing as many liberal/minority votes as they could into a few urban districts, leaving Republicans with slim but reliable majorities in a lot more districts.

This, too, is ultimately a bipartisan issue. Though it's the Republicans who are currently abusing the system, if Democrats come to dominate the state legislatures, it could as easily be them gerrymandering. Picture, in a decade, as this nation becomes majority-minority, if Democratic legislatures start packing the white minority into oddly-shaped districts drawn around white neighborhoods, to allow Democrats to win House seats far in excess of the proportion of Democratic votes.

So, it would be good to have a reform bill that has districting done nationally, according to consistent and rational rules. As I've mentioned before, it could even be done via a computer program exercising a pretty simple algorithm on a data set that maps residents over a geography. Task some sociologists with coming up with a few candidate algorithms, debate their merits in Congress (which, to be cynical, would come down to each side running the algorithms and supporting the one that most benefits them), and then compromise with something in the middle, and use that in the future. This would free up legislatures in the future to deal with more substantive matters, rather than wasting a lot of time on the gerrymandering game every time a new Census is done.

Speaking of freeing up legislative time, another bipartisan effort could be to try to index more things to inflation -- like tax brackets, for example, This one would be popular with Republicans, since tax-bracket creep raises effective tax rates over time. But other indexing would be popular with Democrats -- like indexing the minimum wage to inflation. Congress would remain free to debate real changes to taxes, minimum wages, etc., but we wouldn't get the silliness of such matters drifting over time and then being suddenly readjusted, and we wouldn't have legislative time wasted on merely reflecting inflation-driven changes.
 
Here's more discussion of the same concepts:

http://www.salon.com/2012/11/08/hey_obama_lets_actually_fix_elections/

...if Democrats come to dominate the state legislatures, it could as easily be them gerrymandering. Picture, in a decade, as this nation becomes majority-minority, if Democratic legislatures start packing the white minority into oddly-shaped districts drawn around white neighborhoods, to allow Democrats to win House seats far in excess of the proportion of Democratic votes.
.

Maryland is an example of part of this, if not all. Democratic leadership drew insane districts that brought umbrage from many quarters. The lines simply make no sense whatsoever; Rorschach Tests on Peyote...disorienting and disconnected.

There were lawsuits and the drawn lines were placed on this year's ballot...and the current lines won. The result of the House election is the defeat of crazy uncle Roscoe Bartlett...and a 7-1 Dem delegation.

The statewide proportional aspect stills sways Dem...but conservative pockets have been placed in urban areas adjacent to DC and Baltimore using stretches of highway to connect unrelated blotches. A "reasonably" drawn state would likely send a 5-3 or 6-2 contingent to the Capitol.
 
Maryland is an example of part of this, if not all. Democratic leadership drew insane districts that brought umbrage from many quarters. The lines simply make no sense whatsoever; Rorschach Tests on Peyote...disorienting and disconnected.

There were lawsuits and the drawn lines were placed on this year's ballot...and the current lines won. The result of the House election is the defeat of crazy uncle Roscoe Bartlett...and a 7-1 Dem delegation.

The statewide proportional aspect stills sways Dem...but conservative pockets have been placed in urban areas adjacent to DC and Baltimore using stretches of highway to connect unrelated blotches. A "reasonably" drawn state would likely send a 5-3 or 6-2 contingent to the Capitol.

I'd love to see districting rationalized. I do, however, resist movements to "unilaterally disarm" in that race. We need districting done according to neutral rules consistently on a national basis, rather than one side or the other given up gerrymandering alone, and thus making the overall Congress even less representative.
 
To do this requires a Constitutional Amendment... Good luck with that.

I'm not sure that's true:

"Section. 4.
The Times, Places and Manner of holding Elections for Senators and Representatives, shall be prescribed in each State by the Legislature thereof; but the Congress may at any time by Law make or alter such Regulations, except as to the Places of chusing Senators."

That sure seems to give Congress the ability to override the states with regard to manner of electing House members.
 
Thanks Arkady....Those are a good place to start. I don't see why there isn't a nationwide standard and uniformity as to how to vote. The founders of this nation, while concerned about things like too much powerin the hands of any one individual or specific group, even discrimination and prejudice by majority and concerned with uniform taxation where federal taxation was concerned, didn't seem to address voting.

It is interesting if one reads Montesquieu (Charles-Louis de Secondat, baron de La Brède et de Montesquieu) and his philosophies and theories about government, he repeats quite often that virtue is a necessary requirement for a republic or a republican type of government. I think many confuse the definitions of republican and democratic because of opposing political parties and don't understand how they are not mutually exclusive and do not mean opposite things as much as one defined the qualifications (or disqualifications) for those who would be elected to leadership by some form of democratic means.

Although in many ways, the founders of this nation appeared to be very wary of the negative sides of human nature, yet at the same time seemed anxious to design a government that in spite of human nature or despite human nature, would free humans to essentially have all manner of say about how they would be governed. They knew the obvious as did ancient philosophers they studied, that not all humans agree and thus some form of deciding factor needed to be instituted that all people would agree to, thus the best way I think perhaps anyone can think of, which would be what the majority choose. Our Constitution seems to essentially be about the shape and form of that government, but also about caveats to a pure democracy and how, as they recognized, especially as a result of centuries of bloody religious wars and persecution, how a pure democracy and majority rule can also be very prejudice, unfair and unjust to those who fall into minorities of the population by virtue of things they have little control over changing, like the color of their skin (or eyes or hair or whatever physical feature) their inherited religion, their gender and another feature resulting from genetic disposition. Although they were of an age where women and other than free white males were considered full citizens or qualifying human beings with regard to government and choosing government, they were also in discussion of the question of slavery which seemed to present more of a conundrum in the Americas based on climate zones and the invention of the cotton gin by Eli Whitney. It took us more than half a century and a civil war to come to a final decision about which men were truly created equal and we still have remnants of prejudice around almost 150 years hence.


It would certainly seem reasonable and more expedient to have a equal standard or uniform means of voting and counting votes and your described outline seems worth considering very much. Like all things, there shouldn't be an expectation of perfection or flawless implementation and operation, but it sure seems to be a progression from the consistent and persistent problems we have seen in some states if not nationwide. Certainly the resulting "solution" for the 2000 "election" appeared to have been based on just that concern. Hold up an election result by law suits and injunctions about vote counts and methods of voting and counting and other things, like the calendar and time come into play forcing a high court decision based on available time remaining for an agreeable solution. If you have a SCOTUS with aligned political philosophies that are 5-4 in one's favor, the calendar and time delay in coming to a workable and agreeable solution as to how to count and recount votes works to one's advantage where a SCOTUS decision is required. That "election" will be forever debated and in large part because of a lack of uniform rules and a simple back up reference put in place at the front end of the process.

The process and administration of redistricting would seem to be balanced out in terms of equal vulnerabilty/opportunity for all parties. There appear to be some means to push advantage in one's favor inequitably and unjustly if a political party were to be so inclined. I think the complexities of how it is done allow for confusion and that confusion allows for corruption although I do see the founder's efforts and thoughts to come up with some form of equal representation.

All in all, perhaps all members of Congress should be required to attend a politically mutally agreed to course in review of the founding of this nation and some agreed to philosophical purpose and meaning for the design of our government and the Constitution. In that way, there many be some recognition of what a lot of people see as the founder's consistent theme of balance and not just balances of power and influence, but balances between the individual and society or smaller divisions against larger divisions such as towns, municipalities, cities, county, state, regional and national and ultimately the balance of the United States as a nation with the the larger whole, all nations of the world.

There seems little way to get around it, but to find some totally remote piece of the world, which is not yet formally "owned" or claimed by anyone or any entity and eek out an existence all by one's lonesome. Other than that, survival is not only about how to obtain food, shelter and other basics for ourselves, but how to cooperate and get along with all manner of other people looking to do the same thing, regardless of the grouping or division levels or sizes.

Instead or working together it would appear we have put a lot of energy into how to compete and beat out one another, possibly the result of a world closing in on itself and being overwhelmed by over population and the sheer numbers of individual wants and desires all clashing in some manner against and competing with all others.
 
Well you seem to be saying that if you take away the state's ability to monitor its own elections and its own redistricting, that it will suddenly all become fair and equitable.
 
Well you seem to be saying that if you take away the state's ability to monitor its own elections and its own redistricting, that it will suddenly all become fair and equitable.

So if there were more democratic votes cast in house races nationwide and yet the republicans won a large majority of races, in your mind is that fail and equitable?
 
Arkady, redistricting has twoessetials, communities of interest and number of people in each district being as close to eqaul as possible. This can be done with computer programs and take the politics completely out of it. I worked for a county in 1990 and the person in charge of the redistricting for the county after the 1990 census used such a program and not only did it work well, but there wre no arguments about the new districts as both paties had agreed to the program and to the communities of interest. He said at the time there were programs available for state to use, but of course our state was in the hands of one party and they did the redistricting which ened up in court. SO there is a rational way of doing this, but the party in power probably won't let that happen.
 
Well you seem to be saying that if you take away the state's ability to monitor its own elections and its own redistricting, that it will suddenly all become fair and equitable.

I'm saying that if the parties can agree on a single algorithm to apply consistently in every state, every cycle, it will be more equitable. Some of the equities that would get removed favor Republicans. Other favor Democrats. Removing them would favor America.
 
Back
Top