New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

New hostage policy study

middleview

President
Supporting Member
It seems the White House had formed an advisory panel to evaluate the current policy which makes it illegal for anyone to negotiate with terrorists. This policy would make it illegal for a family to pay a ransom to terrorists to get their loved ones freed.

I'm against negotiations with terrorists, since ISIL alone is making a lot of money through ransoms..as are the Somali pirates...but don't think a family should be facing criminal charges for trying to get their family members released.
 
It seems the White House had formed an advisory panel to evaluate the current policy which makes it illegal for anyone to negotiate with terrorists. This policy would make it illegal for a family to pay a ransom to terrorists to get their loved ones freed.

I'm against negotiations with terrorists, since ISIL alone is making a lot of money through ransoms..as are the Somali pirates...but don't think a family should be facing criminal charges for trying to get their family members released.

this is an outgrowth of the $250,000 ransom paid by Warren Weinstein's family for his release. They were duped. The terrorists took the money to fund their atrocities, but didn't release him. Perhaps they were embarassed that the take was so small, or they believed that jews are wealthy and should have paid more?

in any case, paying $250,000 for weinstein is arguably less damaging than trading 5 senior Al Qaeda leaders for Bowe Bergdahl . . .

the weinsteins are guilty of desperation and love. obama is guilty of bad decisions every day of the week . . .
 
this is an outgrowth of the $250,000 ransom paid by Warren Weinstein's family for his release. They were duped. The terrorists took the money to fund their atrocities, but didn't release him. Perhaps they were embarassed that the take was so small, or they believed that jews are wealthy and should have paid more?

in any case, paying $250,000 for weinstein is arguably less damaging than trading 5 senior Al Qaeda leaders for Bowe Bergdahl . . .

the weinsteins are guilty of desperation and love. obama is guilty of bad decisions every day of the week . . .

Sheesh....this stuff is pretty easy to check. The five Taliban are in the custody of the government of Qatar. They were not Al Qaeda. They were captured in 2002 and had been in Gitmo now for 12 years. Only one of them was even a military commander.
 
It seems the White House had formed an advisory panel to evaluate the current policy which makes it illegal for anyone to negotiate with terrorists. This policy would make it illegal for a family to pay a ransom to terrorists to get their loved ones freed.

I'm against negotiations with terrorists, since ISIL alone is making a lot of money through ransoms..as are the Somali pirates...but don't think a family should be facing criminal charges for trying to get their family members released.

I think if the Gov't wants to not negotiate, that is fine and they should not. But, if the individual families want to pay ransoms and have the means to do so then they should be able to do so. If they get taken.. the get taken. But, I understand the need to try.

connie
 
It seems the White House had formed an advisory panel to evaluate the current policy which makes it illegal for anyone to negotiate with terrorists. This policy would make it illegal for a family to pay a ransom to terrorists to get their loved ones freed.

I'm against negotiations with terrorists, since ISIL alone is making a lot of money through ransoms..as are the Somali pirates...but don't think a family should be facing criminal charges for trying to get their family members released.

it seems you'll be getting what you prefer. I'd guess the govt was trying to protect families from being ripped off and trying to stop the flow of cash to terrorists.

April 27, 2015
ABC News reported on Sunday that the Obama White House, now reviewing its policy regarding American hostages, will recommend that the federal government allow families to ransom their relatives, without threat of prosecution, if they can raise the money on their own. The U.S. government would continue to refuse all ransom payments.

http://www.cnsnews.com/news/article...-families-ransom-american-hostages-could-make
 
Sheesh....this stuff is pretty easy to check. The five Taliban are in the custody of the government of Qatar. They were not Al Qaeda. They were captured in 2002 and had been in Gitmo now for 12 years. Only one of them was even a military commander.

They are only being held there for one year. May or June will be one year. Besides, they're pretty free to do what they want there anyway....
"All five men received medical checks and they now live with their families in an accommodation facility in Doha," the Gulf source, who declined to be identified, told Reuters. "They can move around freely within the country."
Following the deal under which freed the last American soldier held in Afghanistan was freed, concerns have been expressed by some U.S. intelligence officials and congressional advisers over the role of the Gulf Arab state as a bridge between Washington and the world of radical Islam.
The Gulf official said the Taliban men, who have been granted Qatari residency permits, will not be treated like prisoners while in Doha and no U.S. officials will be involved in monitoring their movement while in the country.
"Under the deal they have to stay in Qatar for a year and then they will be allowed to travel outside the country... They can go back to Afghanistan if they want to," the official said.

http://www.reuters.com/article/2014/06/03/us-qatar-taliban-prisoners-idUSKBN0EE1AD20140603
 
They are only being held there for one year. May or June will be one year. Besides, they're pretty free to do what they want there anyway....
"All five men received medical checks and they now live with their families in an accommodation facility in Doha," the Gulf source, who declined to be identified, told Reuters. "They can move around freely within the country."
Following the deal under which freed the last American soldier held in Afghanistan was freed, concerns have been expressed by some U.S. intelligence officials and congressional advisers over the role of the Gulf Arab state as a bridge between Washington and the world of radical Islam.
The Gulf official said the Taliban men, who have been granted Qatari residency permits, will not be treated like prisoners while in Doha and no U.S. officials will be involved in monitoring their movement while in the country.
"Under the deal they have to stay in Qatar for a year and then they will be allowed to travel outside the country... They can go back to Afghanistan if they want to," the official said.

http://www.reuters.com/article/2014/06/03/us-qatar-taliban-prisoners-idUSKBN0EE1AD20140603

They were captured while we were at war with the Taliban. They were not accused of terrorist acts and were part of a civil war. How many years should they have been held prisoner?

At present they are still in Qatar.
 
Back
Top