New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

New "Post Rating" plugin feedback needed

I agree with Jen on this. Instead of posting a brand new post that just says something like "you are dumb" or an attack post you can now just click "dumb" instead of mucking up the thread with a response that has no real content.

That's my hope on the "dumb" response availability.
 
I do believe the new rating system is AWESOME! I just rec'd a "Dumb" rating. Made my day! Knowing a post of mine was rated "Dumb" by this specific poster means so much to me. Tears of joy ran down my cheeks. My old heart thumped just a little harder. Tis a good day!!!!!:D
 
How do you like the new "Post Rating" plugin?

Are there any ratings that you think should be removed?
We need a utility that enables us to "rate" ratings. :)

Seriously, though, I think everything has been said in this strand. I already see the stuff being used in a very petty way, but if that's what folks choose to do it's their business. Personally, I'll dole out the occasional "like" but I won't be giving any negatives. If I disagree or dislike something being said, I'll either ignore it or explain my views...depending on the assessed rationality/capacity of poster.

Appreciate all you do to make this forum better, SW.

Cheers!
 
How do you like the new "Post Rating" plugin?

Are there any ratings that you think should be removed?

Now with a few days of experience with the new ratings I can definitely say that Dumb should be removed. In fact why have negative responses at all ? If someone dislikes disagrees or thinks what you have to say is dumb. They should be forced to put those sentiments into words that give the individual being attacked an opportunity to respond to their detractor's opinions/insult.

Right now you have opened the door to one way attacks of a personal nature that add nothing to the conversation and will only increase the level of animosity.
 
only one is necessary..

if you like a post, ok..

everything else is fodder for the prom queens...
 
only one is necessary..

if you like a post, ok..

everything else is fodder for the prom queens...

I think the very least we need is "agree" and "disagree"
Who cares if we like a post?
Agree/ disagree is unemotional and definite.

But............I love the prom queen fodder............so I want to keep it all.:rolleyes:
 
Now with a few days of experience with the new ratings I can definitely say that Dumb should be removed. In fact why have negative responses at all ? If someone dislikes disagrees or thinks what you have to say is dumb. They should be forced to put those sentiments into words that give the individual being attacked an opportunity to respond to their detractor's opinions/insult.

Right now you have opened the door to one way attacks of a personal nature that add nothing to the conversation and will only increase the level of animosity.

Maybe those who give more than an occasional "dumb" rating will just be banned for a couple of days. Or maybe we will get rid of it if its being abused.
 

So the user with the most dumb ratings is NinaS.

So I went to NinaS profile and read the last post she got a dumb rating on. Here is the post:
"Bull fricken shit. It's harmful to kids to be frightened. How many nights did they lose sleep or have nightmares about that SOB who thought it cool to walk around saying "see my gun??" Why wouldn't they think someone that crazy might use it?? One mother said her son asked her if he was going to shoot them. And you think that's OKAY? Define HURT...fool."

NinaS and Freya were name calling each other which isn't allowed. How is this "dumb" rating incorrect when you post in a way that isn't allowed?

I'm sure there are ratings that are given that are not deserved but the first one I research while I wouldn't have given a dumb rating is actually just fine. You call someone a "fool" then you are probably making an enemy.
 
So the user with the most dumb ratings is NinaS.

So I went to NinaS profile and read the last post she got a dumb rating on. Here is the post:
"Bull fricken shit. It's harmful to kids to be frightened. How many nights did they lose sleep or have nightmares about that SOB who thought it cool to walk around saying "see my gun??" Why wouldn't they think someone that crazy might use it?? One mother said her son asked her if he was going to shoot them. And you think that's OKAY? Define HURT...fool."

NinaS and Freya were name calling each other which isn't allowed. How is this "dumb" rating incorrect when you post in a way that isn't allowed?

I'm sure there are ratings that are given that are not deserved but the first one I research while I wouldn't have given a dumb rating is actually just fine. You call someone a "fool" then you are probably making an enemy.

That's 1 of 116.

If a post isn't allowed, why is on the board?
 
So the user with the most dumb ratings is NinaS.

So I went to NinaS profile and read the last post she got a dumb rating on. Here is the post:
"Bull fricken shit. It's harmful to kids to be frightened. How many nights did they lose sleep or have nightmares about that SOB who thought it cool to walk around saying "see my gun??" Why wouldn't they think someone that crazy might use it?? One mother said her son asked her if he was going to shoot them. And you think that's OKAY? Define HURT...fool."

NinaS and Freya were name calling each other which isn't allowed. How is this "dumb" rating incorrect when you post in a way that isn't allowed?

I'm sure there are ratings that are given that are not deserved but the first one I research while I wouldn't have given a dumb rating is actually just fine. You call someone a "fool" then you are probably making an enemy.


I got two dumbs, so far for this:


Tired, banal nonsense.

Mr. Alinsky, who died in 1972 at age 63, was a Chicago-born social-movement organizer whose success has been praised by Democrats and Republicans alike. He was grudgingly admired by conservative hero William F. Buckley Jr., who called him "very close to being an organizational genius." Former House Majority Leader Dick Armey, a Republican, gives copies of Mr. Alinsky's book "Rules for Radicals" to tea-party leaders.
 
That's 1 of 116.

If a post isn't allowed, why is on the board?

Because there are 700 posts a day and I never read that one and it wasn't reported.

Just because we can't read every post (in fact we only read about 5% or less) doesn't mean its ok to break the rules. Would you agree?
 
So the user with the most dumb ratings is NinaS.

So I went to NinaS profile and read the last post she got a dumb rating on. Here is the post:
"Bull fricken shit. It's harmful to kids to be frightened. How many nights did they lose sleep or have nightmares about that SOB who thought it cool to walk around saying "see my gun??" Why wouldn't they think someone that crazy might use it?? One mother said her son asked her if he was going to shoot them. And you think that's OKAY? Define HURT...fool."

NinaS and Freya were name calling each other which isn't allowed. How is this "dumb" rating incorrect when you post in a way that isn't allowed?

I'm sure there are ratings that are given that are not deserved but the first one I research while I wouldn't have given a dumb rating is actually just fine. You call someone a "fool" then you are probably making an enemy.

Two more for this:


Yes...and by knowing your enemy, you utilize the same tactics in the book.

...Mr. Brandon called the effort to associate Mr. Obama with Mr. Alinsky "a double-edged sword." While Mr. Alinsky was an avowed liberal Democrat, "his tactics when it comes to grass-roots organizing are incredibly effective," Mr. Brandon said.

He cited the group's sending of tea-party activists to town-hall meetings. "When the first five people step up to the microphone to challenge a congressman,'' he said, "it completely changes the dynamic of the town hall—he spends all of his time defending himself."...


http://online.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424052970204624204577177272926154002


Note: Justfuckingawful calling Mr. Alinsky a pedophile, is using Alinsky's tactics.
 
I got two dumbs, so far for this:


Tired, banal nonsense.

Mr. Alinsky, who died in 1972 at age 63, was a Chicago-born social-movement organizer whose success has been praised by Democrats and Republicans alike. He was grudgingly admired by conservative hero William F. Buckley Jr., who called him "very close to being an organizational genius." Former House Majority Leader Dick Armey, a Republican, gives copies of Mr. Alinsky's book "Rules for Radicals" to tea-party leaders.


Here is your last post you got a dumb rating on:

"Hey lookie...You got a "dumb" rating!!! Justfuckingawful got 2 agrees and a like!"

How is this a quality post? It has swearing in it. It adds nothing to the topic. It has no content. In a perfect world if we had 100 moderators this would be deleted. So who cares if it gets a dumb rating, it is a useless post. Like a bunch of 3rd graders.
 
Because there are 700 posts a day and I never read that one and it wasn't reported.

Just because we can't read every post (in fact we only read about 5% or less) doesn't mean its ok to break the rules. Would you agree?


You want feedback and you're getting it. I provided a link that shows the abuse in re: the dumb rating.

You can read every post if you wanted to; 5% of 700 is 35. Really? Management reads just 35 posts a day?

Regardless, if a post is not allowed on the board, it's absurd to defend it getting ratings.
 
tactics.[/QUOTE]
Here is your last post you got a dumb rating on:

"Hey lookie...You got a "dumb" rating!!! Justfuckingawful got 2 agrees and a like!"

How is this a quality post? It has swearing in it. It adds nothing to the topic. It has no content. In a perfect world if we had 100 moderators this would be deleted. So who cares if it gets a dumb rating, it is a useless post. Like a bunch of 3rd graders.

It has content. It speaks of the ridiculous rating system you implemented and its abuse.

In addition...it refers to post where a person is accused of being a pedophile.
 
You want feedback and you're getting it. I provided a link that shows the abuse in re: the dumb rating.

You can read every post if you wanted to; 5% of 700 is 35. Really? Management reads just 35 posts a day?

Regardless, if a post is not allowed on the board, it's absurd to defend it getting ratings.

Yes, I read about 35 a day on average.

The link you gave was to the top users with "dumb" ratings. So I investigated. I clicked on the top person NinaS, went to her last post that she got a dumb rating on, and found it to be a post that isn't even allowed here at PJ because it had swearing and name calling in it.

You said: "Regardless, if a post is not allowed on the board, it's absurd to defend it getting ratings." I don't understand this at all. If someone calls you a name I'm pretty sure you don't have a problem getting a dumb rating on that post or from that person you called a name. After all what adult calls another person a name on the internet?
 
Back
Top