I had to agree with this.
Going through some of the threads this morning, I found one lib poster that had clicked "dumb" on almost every conservatives posts, and "like" or "agree" on every liberal post. But considering this person, I'm not surprised. Some will abuse it, but I think your statement was correct...."
Likely if you get a lot of ratings of dumb it's because you make points that the 'other side' can't reply to and so resorts to clicking 'dumb' or 'dislike' as a substitute for substantive rebuttal".
I'm not saying I'll never use it myself, if I think something said IS really dumb, then I will...

But I won't use it just because I don't care for the person posting it.