New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Obama to Close Gitmo

Those people fled the north after the US military prevented elections in 1945 that we supported by millions of Koreans from one end of the peninsula to the other.

Hundreds of thousands of Koreans fled to the part of the peninsula controlled by the US because of the US preventing something from happening that they wanted to see happen?
 
Hundreds of thousands of Koreans fled to the part of the peninsula controlled by the US because of the US preventing something from happening that they wanted to see happen?
Never try to understand a political partisan. You'd be better off just banging your head against a wall. At least then you can choose when to stop. ;)

bang-head-on-wall.gif
 
So the US, supporting the UN supervised election in 1948, is responsible for the North Korean invasion in 1950...Meanwhile the Soviets appointed the government in the North.....

So while the Soviets armed the North, the US did not arm the South....the North invaded and you blame the US....
I'm not blaming the PRK...
"The People's Republic of Korea (PRK) was a short-lived provisional government that was organized with the aim to take over control of Korea shortly after the surrender of the Empire of Japan at the end of World War II. It operated as a government from late August to early September 1945 until the United States Army Military Government in Korea was established in the southern portion of the Korean Peninsula by the United States of America. After that it operated unofficially, and in opposition to the United States Army Military Government, until it was forcibly dissolved in January 1946..."

I'm not clear why you continually reference a "show" election in 1948

Program[edit]
The program of the PRK was presented in its September 14 twenty-seven point program. The program included: 'the confiscation without compensation of lands held by the Japanese and collaborators; free distribution of that land to the peasants; rent limits on the non-redistributed land; nationalization of such major industries as mining, transportation, banking, and communication; state supervision of small and mid-sized companies; …guaranteed basic human rights and freedoms, including those of speech, press, assembly, and faith; universal suffrage to adults over the age of eighteen; equality for women; labor law reforms including an eight-hour day, a minimum wage, and prohibition of child labor; and 'establishment of close relations with the United States, USSR, England (ed. should be the United Kingdom), and China, and positive opposition to any foreign influences interfering with the domestic affairs of the state.'[2][3]"
Hundreds of thousands of Koreans fled to the part of the peninsula controlled by the US because of the US preventing something from happening that they wanted to see happen?
Exactly.
"The program of the PRK was presented in its September 14 twenty-seven point program. The program included: 'the confiscation without compensation of lands held by the Japanese and collaborators; free distribution of that land to the peasants; rent limits on the nonredistributed land; nationalization of such major industries as mining, transportation, banking, and communication; state supervision of small and mid-sized companies; …guaranteed basic human rights and freedoms, including those of speech, press, assembly, and faith; universal suffrage to adults over the age of eighteen; equality for women; labor law reforms including an eight-hour day, a minimum wage, and prohibition of child labor; and 'establishment of close relations with the United States, USSR, England (ed. should be the United Kingdom), and China, and positive opposition to any foreign influences interfering with the domestic affairs of the state.'"[2][3]
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/People's_Republic_of_Korea#Program
 
Exactly.
"The program of the PRK was presented in its September 14 twenty-seven point program. The program included: 'the confiscation without compensation of lands held by the Japanese and collaborators; free distribution of that land to the peasants; rent limits on the nonredistributed land; nationalization of such major industries as mining, transportation, banking, and communication; state supervision of small and mid-sized companies; …guaranteed basic human rights and freedoms, including those of speech, press, assembly, and faith; universal suffrage to adults over the age of eighteen; equality for women; labor law reforms including an eight-hour day, a minimum wage, and prohibition of child labor; and 'establishment of close relations with the United States, USSR, England (ed. should be the United Kingdom), and China, and positive opposition to any foreign influences interfering with the domestic affairs of the state.'"

So they didn't like the PRK and chose to flee to the US controlled area.
 
So they didn't like the PRK and chose to flee to the US controlled area.
We'll never know the answer to that question since the US disbanded the PRK and refused to allow any elections to take place long before "hundreds of thousands of Koreans fled to the part of the peninsula controlled (occupied) by the US." Why do you suppose Americans thought they had the right to deny self-determination to millions of Koreans in 1945?
 
We'll never know the answer to that question since the US disbanded the PRK and refused to allow any elections to take place long before "hundreds of thousands of Koreans fled to the part of the peninsula controlled (occupied) by the US." Why do you suppose Americans thought they had the right to deny self-determination to millions of Koreans in 1945?

Why are you dodging the question? You brought up the PRK in response to a comment about people fleeing.
 
Why are you dodging the question of why the US denied millions of Koreans the right of self-determination in 1945?

You didn't ask me that question, you made a statement. But, if you are now asking my answer is Geography.

EDIT: I see you did ask right at the end of all of those words that didn't answer the question asked of you.
 
Last edited:
Why are you dodging the question of why the US denied millions of Koreans the right of self-determination in 1945?

The election was UN supervised in 1948 and you call it a sham. The Russians did not hold elections in the North....but it seems you think that was OK. Why didn't the Russians allow the North (or the communists in the South) to participate in the elections?
 
We'll never know the answer to that question since the US disbanded the PRK and refused to allow any elections to take place long before "hundreds of thousands of Koreans fled to the part of the peninsula controlled (occupied) by the US." Why do you suppose Americans thought they had the right to deny self-determination to millions of Koreans in 1945?

I don't understand why you don't see that the 400,000 people were exercising their right to self determination by fleeing to the South.

The UN supervised elections in the South. The Russians didn't allow elections in the North.
 
The election was UN supervised in 1948 and you call it a sham. The Russians did not hold elections in the North....but it seems you think that was OK. Why didn't the Russians allow the North (or the communists in the South) to participate in the elections?

Because two wrongs make a right middleview.
 
I don't understand why you don't see that the 400,000 people were exercising their right to self determination by fleeing to the South.

The UN supervised elections in the South. The Russians didn't allow elections in the North.

The UN = The League of Nations and is as corrupt as every other World Institution --- just 'cos its got a big name doesn't mean it is OK.

The US fought a winning battle to the Korean border with China and was told to pull back -why?
 
You didn't ask me that question, you made a statement. But, if you are now asking my answer is Geography.

EDIT: I see you did ask right at the end of all of those words that didn't answer the question asked of you.
Korean geography or American geography?
"On August 10, 1945 two young officers – Dean Rusk and Charles Bonesteel– were assigned to define an American occupation zone.

"Working on extremely short notice and completely unprepared, they used a National Geographic map to decide on the 38th parallel. They chose it because it divided the country approximately in half but would place the capital Seoul under American control.

"No experts on Korea were consulted.

"The two men were unaware that forty years before, Japan and Russia had discussed sharing Korea along the same parallel. Rusk later said that had he known, he 'almost surely' would have chosen a different line.[8][9]"
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Division_of_Korea#US_occupation_of_South_Korea
 
Korean geography or American geography?
"On August 10, 1945 two young officers – Dean Rusk and Charles Bonesteel– were assigned to define an American occupation zone.

"Working on extremely short notice and completely unprepared, they used a National Geographic map to decide on the 38th parallel. They chose it because it divided the country approximately in half but would place the capital Seoul under American control.

"No experts on Korea were consulted.

"The two men were unaware that forty years before, Japan and Russia had discussed sharing Korea along the same parallel. Rusk later said that had he known, he 'almost surely' would have chosen a different line.[8][9]"
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Division_of_Korea#US_occupation_of_South_Korea

You ever going to get around to explaining the statement you've been asked about?
 
The UN = The League of Nations and is as corrupt as every other World Institution --- just 'cos its got a big name doesn't mean it is OK.

The US fought a winning battle to the Korean border with China and was told to pull back -why?

They weren't told to pull back. The Chinese Army forced a retreat with about a million "volunteers".
 
The election was UN supervised in 1948 and you call it a sham. The Russians did not hold elections in the North....but it seems you think that was OK. Why didn't the Russians allow the North (or the communists in the South) to participate in the elections?
Korean independence and unity was denied by the US in 1945 by preventing the right of self-determination to all Koreans from one end of the peninsula to the other. Three years later, the US and its Korean puppets put forth a sham election that took place under US military occupation so there was little reason for the Russians or Koreans living north of the 38th parallel to pay the slightest attention.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Army_Military_Government_in_Korea#Background

"The short-lived People's Republic of Korea had been established in August (1945), in consultation with Japanese authorities, and quickly spread throughout the country.[5] The U.S. Military Government outlawed it in the South shortly after their arrival.[6] The leader of the People's Republic, Yeo Un-hyeong, stepped down and formed the Working People's Party.[7] The U.S. administration also refused to recognize the members of the Provisional Government of the Republic of Korea, led by Kim Ku, who were obliged to enter the country as private citizens.[8"
 
Korean independence and unity was denied by the US in 1945 by preventing the right of self-determination to all Koreans from one end of the peninsula to the other. Three years later, the US and its Korean puppets put forth a sham election that took place under US military occupation so there was little reason for the Russians or Koreans living north of the 38th parallel to pay the slightest attention.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Army_Military_Government_in_Korea#Background

"The short-lived People's Republic of Korea had been established in August (1945), in consultation with Japanese authorities, and quickly spread throughout the country.[5] The U.S. Military Government outlawed it in the South shortly after their arrival.[6] The leader of the People's Republic, Yeo Un-hyeong, stepped down and formed the Working People's Party.[7] The U.S. administration also refused to recognize the members of the Provisional Government of the Republic of Korea, led by Kim Ku, who were obliged to enter the country as private citizens.[8"

The question still stands, why did people flee to the South?
 
Back
Top