New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Obama to Close Gitmo

Are you capable of grasping the concept the Koreans needed no help from the US in 1945 when it came to dealing with refugees or holding free election which would have likely been won by communists? That chaos began when the US military occupied South Korea in spite of the resistance of an overwhelming majority of Koreans.

So the presence of a Russian army in the north was a good thing, but a handful of Americans was bad....

Got it.
 
Not having been there we can guess that the communists were far better organized and in a position to win a national election. The US arrived in the country at the end of 1945 and long after Soviet troops had arrived in the North.
Can you supply the correct answer to this question?
"5. In accordance with a wartime agreement that the USSR would enter the war with Japan following the German surrender, Soviet forces invaded Korea in August, advancing to the 38th parallel by August 10. They could easily have occupied the whole peninsula. What did they do?

"a. They accepted the Japanese surrender, provided arms to local communist forces led by Kim Il-sung, and withdrew within the year.

"b. They consulted with their American allies, who requested that they stop their advance at the 38th parallel, so that U.S. forces could in the next month occupy the rest of Korea. The Soviets agreed to the U.S. proposal.

"c. They proclaimed the Korean Soviet Republic and made plans for permanent incorporation into the USSR

http://www.counterpunch.org/2002/12/31/a-pop-quiz-on-korea/

"(BONUS QUESTION)

"Current South Korean public opinion polls indicate that the foreign country people most fear is

"a. the U.S.

"b. North Korea

"c. China

?

"Answers: 1 (a); 2 (c); 3 (b); 4 (b); 5 (b); 6 (a); 7 (b); 8 (a); 9 (b); 10 (c); 11 (c); 12 (b); 13 (a): 14 (c); 15 (b); 16 (a); 17 (a); 18 (c); 19 (a); 20 (a); 21 (b); 22 (a); 23 (a); 24 (b); 25 (a); 26 (c); 27 (c); 28 (c); 29 (a); 30 (a); 31 (b); 32 (a); 33 (c); bonus (a)"
 
The UN held elections in 1948. The Russians would not allow millions of Koreans to take part....that is the bottom line.
Hardly.
The PRK called for elections in 1945 when Japanese forces departed. Soviets were in favor and the US was not. Which superpower still has its troops stationed in occupied Korea?
 
Easy for you to say; however, things looked much better in North Korea in 1945:
"After the surrender of the Empire of Japan to the Allies, division at the 38th parallel marked the beginning of Soviet and American command over the North and South, respectively.

"U.S. forces landed at Incheon on September 8, 1945, and established a military government shortly thereafter.[9]

"The forces landing at Incheon were of the XXIV Corps of the U.S. Tenth Army.[10]

"They were commanded by Lt. General John R. Hodge, who then took charge of the government.[11] Four days before he arrived in Korea, Hodge told his officers that Korea 'was an enemy of the United States'.[2]

"On September 9, at a surrender ceremony, Hodge announced that the Japanese colonial government would remain intact, including its personnel and its governor-general. After a major outcry, Hodge replaced the governor-general with an American and removed all the Japanese bureau chiefs, though he, in turn, enlisted the former Japanese bureaucrats as advisors.[3]"
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Army_Military_Government_in_Korea#Background
At the same time in the north, Japanese bureaucrats were sent home, and all Koreans who collaborated with Japan's occupation were murdered. In the south, collaborators were welcomed into the police and military units being set up by US occupiers whose officers viewed Korea as "the enemy."

Things were so great that hundreds of thousands fled.
 
Why people fled to the oppressor?
Which economic class of people "fled to the oppressor?"

"In February 1946 a provisional government called the Provisional People's Committee was formed underKim Il-sung, who had spent the last years of the war training with Soviet troops in Manchuria...

"In March 1946 the provisional government instituted a sweeping land-reform program: land belonging to Japanese and collaborator landowners was divided and redistributed to poor farmers.[29]

'Organizing the many poor civilians and agricultural laborers under the people's committees, a nationwide mass campaign broke the control of the old landed classes.

"Landlords were allowed to keep only the same amount of land as poor civilians who had once rented their land, thereby making for a far more equal distribution of land.

"The North Korean land reform was achieved in a less violent way than in China or in Vietnam.

"Official American sources[which?] stated: "From all accounts, the former village leaders were eliminated as a political force without resort to bloodshed, but extreme care was taken to preclude their return to power."[30]

"The farmers responded positively; many collaborators and former landowners fled to the south, where some of them obtained positions in the new South Korean government.

"According to the U.S. military government, 400,000 northern Koreans went south as refugees
.[31]

"Key industries were nationalized.

"The economic situation was nearly as difficult in the north as it was in the south, as the Japanese had concentrated agriculture in the south and heavy industry in the north.

"Soviet forces departed in 1948."[32]

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Division_of_Korea#Soviet_occupation_of_North_Korea
 
Starting when?

This what zealotry does. You were so eager to pin the blame for a mass migration on the United States of America you didn't stop to think once about what you were saying leaving you in a position where you had to answer questions with questions or just pretend you didn't understand simple questions.
 
The Soviet army was there at the request of the US, remember? Why do you suppose the Soviets are gone and US forces are not?
The US forces left in 1948. They would not be there now if not for the invasion of South Korea, with Russian help and Chinese troops in 1950.

Just when did the US request the Russian occupation of Northern Korea?
 
Hardly.
The PRK called for elections in 1945 when Japanese forces departed. Soviets were in favor and the US was not. Which superpower still has its troops stationed in occupied Korea?

Hardly? The Russians would not allow an election under UN supervision in 1948. Why was that?

the United States scuttled an earlier plan to provide US$500 million over five years for South Korean development. It then submitted the Korean problem to the United Nations (UN) in September 1947. In November the UN General Assembly recognized Korea's claim to independence and made preparations for the establishment of a government and the withdrawal of occupation forces. The United Nations Temporary Commission on Korea arrived to supervise the election of a national assembly, which was held in May 1948. The Soviet Union, however, objected to the UN resolution and refused to admit the commission to the Soviet-controlled zone in the north. It was becoming increasingly clear that two separate regimes would be established on the peninsula.

http://countrystudies.us/south-korea/9.htm
 
Last edited:
Can you supply the correct answer to this question?
"5. In accordance with a wartime agreement that the USSR would enter the war with Japan following the German surrender, Soviet forces invaded Korea in August, advancing to the 38th parallel by August 10. They could easily have occupied the whole peninsula. What did they do?

"a. They accepted the Japanese surrender, provided arms to local communist forces led by Kim Il-sung, and withdrew within the year.

"b. They consulted with their American allies, who requested that they stop their advance at the 38th parallel, so that U.S. forces could in the next month occupy the rest of Korea. The Soviets agreed to the U.S. proposal.

"c. They proclaimed the Korean Soviet Republic and made plans for permanent incorporation into the USSR

http://www.counterpunch.org/2002/12/31/a-pop-quiz-on-korea/

"(BONUS QUESTION)

"Current South Korean public opinion polls indicate that the foreign country people most fear is

"a. the U.S.

"b. North Korea

"c. China

?

"Answers: 1 (a); 2 (c); 3 (b); 4 (b); 5 (b); 6 (a); 7 (b); 8 (a); 9 (b); 10 (c); 11 (c); 12 (b); 13 (a): 14 (c); 15 (b); 16 (a); 17 (a); 18 (c); 19 (a); 20 (a); 21 (b); 22 (a); 23 (a); 24 (b); 25 (a); 26 (c); 27 (c); 28 (c); 29 (a); 30 (a); 31 (b); 32 (a); 33 (c); bonus (a)"

http://www.japantoday.com/category/...s-japan-more-than-n-korea-gallup-poll-reveals

Here are the 2012 results compared with 2002 in parenthesis (translated from Japanese):
■ South Korea’s Top 5 Least Favorite Countries
1. Japan – 44.1% (33.4% in 2002)
2. China – 19.1% (4.6%)
3. North Korea – 11.7% (17.3%)
4. America – 4.8% (18%)
5. Iraq – 0.7% (0.7%)
■ South Korea’s Top 5 Favorite Countries
1. America – 21.5% (16.5% in 2002)
2. Australia – 19% (12.5%)
3. Switzerland – 8% (8.8%)
4. Canada – 7.4% (6.6%)
5. England – 5.1% (3%)

in a November 2011 Gallup Poll, 57% of South Koreans approved of U.S. leadership, with 22% disapproving; by contrast, only 30% of South Koreans approved of China's leadership.
 
The US forces left in 1948. They would not be there now if not for the invasion of South Korea, with Russian help and Chinese troops in 1950.

Just when did the US request the Russian occupation of Northern Korea?
"At the Tehran Conference in November 1943 and the Yalta Conference in February 1945, the Soviet Union promised to join its allies in the Pacific War within three months of victory in Europe. On August 8, 1945, after three months to the day, the Soviet Union declared war on Japan.[7] Soviet troops advanced rapidly, and the US government became anxious that they would occupy the whole of Korea."
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Division_of_Korea#End_of_World_War_II
Would I be wasting bandwidth to mention the Koreans never asked for US help reunifying a country that was ancient before Europeans first came to the North America?
 
"At the Tehran Conference in November 1943 and the Yalta Conference in February 1945, the Soviet Union promised to join its allies in the Pacific War within three months of victory in Europe. On August 8, 1945, after three months to the day, the Soviet Union declared war on Japan.[7] Soviet troops advanced rapidly, and the US government became anxious that they would occupy the whole of Korea."
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Division_of_Korea#End_of_World_War_II
Would I be wasting bandwidth to mention the Koreans never asked for US help reunifying a country that was ancient before Europeans first came to the North America?

When did the US ask for Russian forces to occupy North Korea? When did Koreans ask for Russian help?

In any case you have wandered pretty far from your original assertion that the US was responsible for millions of Koreans killed. The North Koreans started a war. Not the US.
The US had a handful of advisors in Korea....I have read it was about 50 men. The South was not prepared for war, the North was. The Russians helped the North plan the invasion and the Chinese offered reinforcements if things didn't go well....but you blame the US.
 
In any case you have wandered pretty far from your original assertion that the US was responsible for millions of Koreans killed. The North Koreans started a war. Not the US.
The US started the Korean War when it occupied South Korea in 1945. The PRK was fully capable of organizing elections that would have resulted in a unified Korea operating under its 27 point program. The US government prevented that from happening and five years later, North Koreans rose up against the American occupation of their country. btw, US bombs killed one of every three Korean civilians living north of the 38th parallel. That was done primarily to reassure US civilians their economy would not slip back into depression after the WWII stimulus ran out.
 
The US started the Korean War when it occupied South Korea in 1945. The PRK was fully capable of organizing elections that would have resulted in a unified Korea operating under its 27 point program. The US government prevented that from happening and five years later, North Koreans rose up against the American occupation of their country. btw, US bombs killed one of every three Korean civilians living north of the 38th parallel. That was done primarily to reassure US civilians their economy would not slip back into depression after the WWII stimulus ran out.

So the US had no troops in the country in 1950. Did not arm the South sufficiently to prevent an invasion, much less invade the North. Did support the UN monitored election in 1948, which could have united the country if the entire country had participated, but the Russians wouldn't allow it....You, of course, find fault with the US, but not the Russians who helped plan the invasion nor the Chinese who's guarantee of reinforcements encouraged the north to invade....

We are done here. Your unflinching and blind support for the side that actually started the war is amazing. That you are completely unwilling to criticize the absolute worst dictatorship on the planet today. No point in further discussion on the subject.
 
We are done here. Your unflinching and blind support for the side that actually started the war is amazing. That you are completely unwilling to criticize the absolute worst dictatorship on the planet today. No point in further discussion on the subject.

Would you call this...zealotry?
 
Back
Top