New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Obama to Close Gitmo

Damn....I tried...by saying that going to Congress was not an issue of executive overreach...



Substantive you say?
It's truly sad that you cannot ever own what you write and that the genuinely human trait of simply expressing a mistake is impossible for you. Frankly, that's even more sad than the fact that you had to reach for a scores-old legacy policy that Obama has not overturned ("War on Drugs") to find disagreement with him as opposed to any of his initiatives.

I hope you grow out of this some day. :)
 
Is there anyone here at PJ that wants the USA to build a prison in their community and house the terrorists from Guantanimo?

1. There are terrorists in GITMO. They should be tried and sentenced if found guilty and I don't mind if they are imprisoned here in Colorado.
2. There are prisoners captured on the battlefield in Afghanistan or Iraq. I think they should be returned to those countries when fighting there ends. Until then they should be imprisoned in military prisons in the US.

$4 million per prisoner at Gitmo is nuts. And if a bunch of Al Qaeda or ISIS want to show up in Florence to free them....it should be pretty entertaining.
 
It's truly sad that you cannot ever own what you write and that the genuinely human trait of simply expressing a mistake is impossible for you. Frankly, that's even more sad than the fact that you had to reach for a scores-old legacy policy that Obama has not overturned ("War on Drugs") to find disagreement with him as opposed to any of his initiatives.

I hope you grow out of this some day. :)

I do love your lectures...especially when your efforts are entirely unsubstantial.

Maybe one day you'll grow out of them.
 
I do love your lectures...especially when your efforts are entirely unsubstantial.

Maybe one day you'll grow out of them.
Is that index finger arthritic yet? All that pointing can't be good.

Anyhoo - thanks for yet another demonstration that you can't discuss or relate to others in anything resembling an honest manner. The good news is that it remains a personal growth opportunity. Have a nice day.
 
Is that index finger arthritic yet? All that pointing can't be good.

Anyhoo - thanks for yet another demonstration that you can't discuss or relate to others in anything resembling an honest manner. The good news is that it remains a personal growth opportunity. Have a nice day.

You really are hysterical, as in funny. You work very hard to denigrate people. It's not an endearing trait.

I disagree with the President...and you lie about it. This, to you, is "being an adult". Truly funny stuff...
 
I'm guessing this is an "it was on my checklist so I'll technically do it to say I did it" move by Obama. He claimed he would be proactive and then didn't touch the issue of Gitmo for years. Plus, I'm confident whatever happened at Gitmo will continue to happen wherever these people go. It's a mere technicality.

However, I'm against Gitmo. I can hope our use of torture decreases, even if I won't hold my breath.
 
Well old Baracky is at it yet again. I guess he has a pen and a cell phone and he just does whatever comes to his sick demented Marxist socialist little mind. He has no regard for the law nor our Constitution. This nut case is unbelievable.
It's a real scandal it took him this long to make good on one of his key campaign promises of 2008. But better late than never I guess.

Closing Gitmo isn't really the issue, though. Whether we're housing prisoners at Gitmo, or some supermax in the states, or some black site half-way around the world, or handing them over to foreign proxies to jail for us, the issue is whether or not we're being true to the Constitution, which requires that the government not deprive anyone of liberty without due process of law. As long as we're imprisoning people without a proper trial, we're betraying our Constitution, whether we do that here or abroad, directly or through proxies.
 
So the answer is no.
There's no need to build a prison since we already have plenty. You are free to read into that whatever you like.

The bigger problem isn't related to security but to Constitutional rights. Once they set foot on US soil, they're covered by the Constitution. No more torture.

On the subject of rights, it strikes me as odd that the RWNJs have a conniption over sticking a Hellfire missile up the ass of a terrorist in enemy territory but who is a US citizen, yet don't like the idea of treating enemy combatants with Constitutional rights.
 
There's no need to build a prison since we already have plenty. You are free to read into that whatever you like.

The bigger problem isn't related to security but to Constitutional rights. Once they set foot on US soil, they're covered by the Constitution. No more torture.

On the subject of rights, it strikes me as odd that the RWNJs have a conniption over sticking a Hellfire missile up the ass of a terrorist in enemy territory but who is a US citizen, yet don't like the idea of treating enemy combatants with Constitutional rights.

These are terrorists that fight on behalf of no nation. They are in limbo because they chose to be.
 
These are terrorists that fight on behalf of no nation. They are in limbo because they chose to be.
Are you saying that if they are brought to the US they aren't covered by our Constitution?
 
I am saying not one US citizen wants them on the mainland.
There's a bunch of Democrats who do. ;)

If it was up to me, I'd put them all on a plane across the Atlantic, but only enough fuel to get halfway there.
 
There's no need to build a prison since we already have plenty. You are free to read into that whatever you like.

The bigger problem isn't related to security but to Constitutional rights. Once they set foot on US soil, they're covered by the Constitution. No more torture.

On the subject of rights, it strikes me as odd that the RWNJs have a conniption over sticking a Hellfire missile up the ass of a terrorist in enemy territory but who is a US citizen, yet don't like the idea of treating enemy combatants with Constitutional rights.
If you read the Constitution, nowhere does it say that it's limited to US soil. It's written to restrict what the government is allowed to do, without distinction as to where. For example, it simply says cruel and unusual punishment shall not be inflicted. I'd read that as saying the government isn't allowed to torture anyone anywhere.

It's not just that one amendment where this issue comes up. If our government is free to do whatever it wants outside our borders, the implications are ugly. For example, it's then free to search and seize any of your data that's outside the US (and given the way the Internet works, that could be just about anything), without any warrant. It can also take from you any assets you have outside of the US, without giving you any compensation. And it could, for example, promote an establishment of religion, so long as it only did so beyond our borders (e.g., making US tax dollars available to promote a preferred religion abroad). And if you step foot outside the country, you'd have no rights at all. For example, they could pass a law making it illegal to say anything negative about Obama while outside the US, and if you do so, you could be thrown in jail, because your first amendment rights only apply while you're here.

I'd prefer to take the view that the Constitution limits what our government is allowed to do everywhere.
 
Pretending your country is not the greatest purveyor of violence in the world will not prevent the terror it inflicts in places like Vietnam, Iraq, Afghanistan, and Cuba from coming home to roost one day.

http://cubajournal.blogspot.com/2012/11/the-cuba-issue-in-howard-zinns-peoples.html
Bitching about a country you hate while reaping the fruits of it by living there is the height of hypocrisy. Do you pay taxes? If so, you are willingly supporting "the greatest purveyor of violence in the world".
 
The Hero of Islam has sent his plan to Congress. However it is against the law to transfer known terrorists to US soil. His plan is vague and without specific substance. 96 detainees remain at Gitmo, 35 of these individuals are deemed extremely dangerous, 46 remain under investigation, the remained will be cut loose by Goat Boy. They will most likely return to the battlefield to kill more Americans and spread terror. The hero of Islam wants the detention facility closed to keep a campaign promise he made. I guess his promise takes precedent over national security and the safety of the American public. Yet again it proves which side our left wing leaders are actually on. Their political agenda comes first and the safety of America is down the toilet. You Rock Goat Boy.
What law is broken by transferring prisoners from Gitmo to a federal prison in the US?
 
Is there anyone here at PJ that wants the USA to build a prison in their community and house the terrorists from Guantanimo?

The most likely prison is Supermax in Florence Colorado...and I have no problem with bringing them here.
 
Bitching about a country you hate while reaping the fruits of it by living there is the height of hypocrisy. Do you pay taxes? If so, you are willingly supporting "the greatest purveyor of violence in the world".
Why are you trying to pretend the country I was born in (accident of birth) has not been responsible for some of the worst war crimes of the last two hundred years? Are you honestly of the opinion the terror we've visited on other people. from Korea to Kandahar, will not come home to roost? Maybe you'e feeling a little guilty for your role in state sponsored terrorism?:)
 
Why are you trying to pretend the country I was born in (accident of birth) has not been responsible for some of the worst war crimes of the last two hundred years? Are you honestly of the opinion the terror we've visited on other people. from Korea to Kandahar, will not come home to roost? Maybe you'e feeling a little guilty for your role in state sponsored terrorism?:)
IIRC, you're in your sixties. Do you pay taxes or not? If yes, then that is no accident. You willingly supported the same country you claim to be a terrorist nation.
 
The most likely prison is Supermax in Florence Colorado...and I have no problem with bringing them here.
Think it can't get any worse?
"SEN. MARCO RUBIO: Not only are we not going to close Guantánamo, when I’m president, if we capture a terrorist alive, they’re not getting a court hearing in Manhattan, they’re not going to be sent to Nevada. They’re going to Guantánamo, and we’re going to find out everything they know."
Some of these cons don't seem to realize we already have them among us as this following DemocracyNow interview with Amy Goodman reveals:

http://www.democracynow.org/2016/2/24/will_obama_s_guantanamo_plan_close

"AMY GOODMAN: Ken Gude, I wanted to ask you about this letter that was signed by 40 sheriffs in Colorado who wrote to the White House to oppose any plan to move the detainees from Guantánamo to prisons in Colorado. I think there’s some speculation that most of the prisons used would be in Colorado.

"KEN GUDE:
Yeah, well, I think one thing that those sheriffs probably aren’t aware of is that there’s more than a dozen very high-profile international terrorists already in Colorado prisons, some of the most dangerous terrorists that the United States has ever captured—Ramzi Yousef, the man who was responsible for the first World Trade Center bombing attempt in 1993; one former Guantánamo detainee, Ahmed Ghailani, who was convicted in a New York courtroom of his role in the 1998 East Africa embassy bombings; four of Ghailani’s co-conspirators in that attack; Zacarias Moussaoui, who was captured before 9/11 and was—at the time, at least—thought to be the 20th hijacker; Richard Reid, who was—tried to blow up an inbound airliner into the United States with a bomb in his shoes.

"These guys are already in prisons in Colorado, or at least in one prison in Colorado, the penitentiary at Florence."
 
Back
Top