fairsheet
Senator
Well yes, again, it is more or less impossible to disentangle cause and effect when examining the history of cultural conquest, expansion, and decline. If you believe Jared Diamond's hypotheses, which make a lot of sense, then latitude shapes a culture's destiny as much as anything else. So you may very well be right that the apparent Desert Religion run of success is due more to historical accident than anything else. Certainly there have been belligerent, militaristic, expansionist cultures that embraced some variation of Forest Religions. In addition to the examples you cited, let's not overlook the Mongol empire – perhaps the largest, most ruthless empire the world has yet seen.
And yet...
In general those expansive Forest Religion empires were built by extremely capable and charismatic individuals who frequently managed to leverage some relatively newly-developed technological advantage. Moreover, those empires tended to be relatively short lived, with a somewhat ephemeral cultural influence and legacy. The Mongols conquered China and the near east, but they were fairly rapidly absorbed by the local cultures they ruled over, more or less. The northmen were similarly assimilated, more or less. Ashoka the Great didn't turn the Indian subcontinent permanently Buddhist, ironically enough.
Then again, the Mughals didn't come close to turning India wholly to Islam either. Some tasks are beyond even a singular deity, I guess. And European Christian culture hasn't yet proven itself to be notably more influential over time in Asia than any other foreign import.
So, who knows? I think a culture – and religion – that tends toward incorporation will survive and thrive over time as compared to a culture and religion that tends toward conversion and domination. It's a somewhat artificial distinction, I admit, because every culture encompasses both tendencies. But predominance matters often enough, don't you think?
Cheers.
I'm not familiar with Mr. Diamond's thesis. At least I don't think I am. But, I do know that anthropologists have riffed on the CONTRAST between latitude and longitude. For instance, some surmise that the old world evolved so differently from the new world, because the old world ran mostly east-west and the new world ran mostly north-south.
The thinking is that people's living at the same latitudes tend to confront more similar situations. It's completely different for people living at the same longitudes. Therefore, the east-westers are much more likely to achieve critical mass - in its umpteen different forms. A Frenchman living at the same latitude as a Chinese man, confronts a very similar environment. That's not the case for the Mayan and Inuit living at the same longitude. I can see how this might be at least tangential to the issue of religion.