New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Poverty

So, the key is making sure they never learn helplessness in the first place, so we need to start young with the efforts to make sure people aren't locked by the market into hopeless situations.

They learn it at home. They learn it from their church's where people like Al Sharp ton and Louis Farrakhan, tell them that they would have it all if ti weren't for whitey, its all his fault. If they actually objectively looked at the marketplace - they would know that none of that is the truth. But, they can't see past the ideology they are spoon fed from the left. Change what you tell them, start sending a more positive message - and you will change the perspective of the people. Some will always be a lost cause of course, but you will get most people turned around.
 
How's about we just peg taxes back at those Kennedy rates, and call it good?

I'm wondering why you think those rates would make it "good"? Do you think the government needs so much more money than it already gets? If so, why? Do you trust them (Democrat and Republican) to spend the money wisely?
 
I wonder if we have models of neighborhoods that have really turned around, that we could learn from. Most of them that occur to me were more a case of gentrification, where a new population pushed in to displace the old one (e.g., Brooklyn). But I wonder if there are "economic miracles" where a population that mostly remained in situ really managed to recover. If so, we could learn lessons from that.

Local to myself, we had the "Massachusetts Miracle." In the 70s, Massachusetts, which had relied on mills and other failing industries, looked like it was heading towards the same fate as rust-belt communities from Syracuse to Cleveland to Detroit. There was growing poverty and social dysfunction. But then the area completed a rare successful transition from that kind of manufacturing to the knowledge economy, with computer equipment, financial services, medical devices, pharmaceuticals, and universities forming the basis for prosperity. It might make sense to dig into what, specifically, people like Dukakis were doing differently to aid that transformation, as compared to a place like Detroit that tried to hold onto past glories and ended up in a deep rut.
We had something similar to that in Milwaukee about 20 years ago. Impoverished neighborhoods were being reclaimed and homes were being repaired and rebuilt by young workers starting out, because they could get these homes cheap. The reason these homes were on the market is that impoverished families took the money that they were getting from welfare and moving away due to neighborhood violence. Unfortunately, they were taking the violence with them when they left.

High crime areas pushed out into better neighborhoods, and the inner city became a haven for young families.
 
What are the racial makeup of the southern "Bible belt" states?

Maybe the south has never recovered from the Civil War?
The racial makeup is similar to New York and New Jersey, yet they don't have the same problems. And meanwhile lily-white Bible Belt states, like West Virginia, are a basket case.

Still, I think there's probably something to the idea that they never recovered from the Civil War. I just think the dynamics of that are complicated.

I have this theory that in places where the political/economic elite looks very different from the poor, physically, they tend to neglect the concerns of the poor, because there isn't that same kind of "there but for the grace of God..." attitude people will have when looking at a poor person hits closer to home.

I think they also tend to get led astray in ways they wouldn't if they thought of the poor as more like themselves.... for example, a white member of the elite who is surrounded by white poor people might scoff at the idea that if you provide them a safety net they'll use it as a hammock, because he thinks of them as fundamentally similar to himself, and he knows that's not how he'd act in their shoes. But a white member of the elite surrounded by black poor people may instinctive think of them as alien, so even though he knows he wouldn't take advantage that way, he will be more easily convinced that "those people" are different and must be treated with a firmer hand than he'd require.

I think this tends to result in people in some areas dealing with the problems of poverty through segregation -- either legal segregation, when that was allowed, or things like gated communities, private schools, unofficial racial zoning, etc. Rather than dealing with the problems, they try to make sure the problems can't get to them. And that just lets the problems fester and worsen. I think that happened a great deal in the former confederacy because there was a distinct black underclass, whereas in whiter poorer areas (including most of Europe and New England), people took a more active approach to having government address poverty, instead of just trying to keep it segregated.
 
Not at all. Explain the correlation between IQ and government assistance, I haven't heard of this before...
You can see it at the extremes pretty easily. Someone who is profoundly retarded will almost certainly be dependent on government assistance (or at least the assistance of others). Meanwhile, someone who is a supra-genius will generally end up well off even if starting in a very difficult place (since that genius will let him overcome difficulties that would hold the vast majority of people back, including being able to do things like win scholarships). In between those extremes is a smooth continuum. Fortunately, through early government assistance we can push people along that continuum a bit, by way of better healthcare, better nutrition, less pollution, lowering developmental stress, and providing enriching activities. Those interventions make it less likely that the people will be dependent later.
 
The government has done almost everything wrong in addressing poverty. Setting up government programs that morph into money sucking departments do nothing for the poor. If the government would kill about half their programs and top wasting money on programs like Head Start then they wouldn't have to tax so much and the economy would be way stronger and more people would be working.

They need to stop immigration of unskilled workers, we have more than enough of them to fill the low level jobs. Half end up on welfare within 2 years of entering the US, so this will help in welfare cost reduction.

We need to quit rewording single mothers for having more children. The whole policy of how welfare is done needs changing.

The government is the main cause of poverty.
 
We had something similar to that in Milwaukee about 20 years ago. Impoverished neighborhoods were being reclaimed and homes were being repaired and rebuilt by young workers starting out, because they could get these homes cheap. The reason these homes were on the market is that impoverished families took the money that they were getting from welfare and moving away due to neighborhood violence. Unfortunately, they were taking the violence with them when they left.

High crime areas pushed out into better neighborhoods, and the inner city became a haven for young families.

You see - THAT is the problem no one actually wants to address. You can move people around but they bring their problems with them.

I always hear white flight blamed for the downfall of urban and near in suburbs. But, I think that if you believe that you are nothing more than a blatant racist.
Lets think about this... you have a nice neighborhood. Some black people move in, presumably, they are nice black people. They have jobs, want to care for their homes, provide their kids a nice place to live... JUST like the white people who left. Ok - so if they are the same and want the same things - then why did the neighborhood go down just because the white people left? Shouldn't all those good upstanding black citizens keep the neighborhood as nice and pristine as their white counterparts? If you believe the white people left, and then the black people couldn't keep it up - you are simply saying that the black people weren't up to the job of it. They couldn't do it, they were less than in some way than the white residents.

I don't believe this - I believe is not race but socieoecnomic. Lower class people - not only have a lot of bad habits themselves, but they have a lot of friends and family with even worse bad habits. Some poor people are able to move and leave all their baggage behind. Those who can do that - do manage to drastically change their living situation and their socioeconomic standing.

But, most move, and they bring all their baggage with them. Their druggie nephew they let sleep on the couch. They take in their sister who has the drunk husband, who comes over and raises hell when he is lit up causes a commotion and the police come, etc. Because the druggie nephew is around, then some of his buddies are around, and then soon, some stuff goes missing. Then a few people get tired of that kind of shit, see whats coming down the pike, and they sell out, the next round of people moving up - bring the same scenario with them, making it even worse, till more people leave, selling at even lower prices, then more people moving up bring the shit with them, and make it even worse. So pretty soon, no one even wants to be there.

Sure, the white people that let may have left for racist reasons. But, if the issue was merely black people coming in to the neighborhood, it shouldn't have changed. It only changed because not because the people were black but because the people who came in were from a completely different socioeconomic class. And they brought with them all the baggage and the drama of being from that class. But, no one will ever really address the how poverty is not only a money thing, but also a sociological and psychological thing. Until that is addressed, throwing more money at it may make the people less poor according to the dollars and the thresholds, but it will not change their living situation.

connie
 
They learn it at home. They learn it from their church's where people like Al Sharp ton and Louis Farrakhan

Could you link to some of those sermons? I've never heard a sermon by Sharpton, but I have heard a couple by Farrakhan and they were antithetical to the message you're attributing to him. Here's his most famous speech, delivered to nearly a million black men, and broadcast to countless more:

http://www-cgi.cnn.com/US/9510/megamarch/10-16/transcript/

The overall theme of the speech is summarized with this:

"We are standing on the sacrifice of the lives of those heroes, our great men and women that we today may accept the responsibility that life imposes upon each traveler who comes this way. We must accept the responsibility that God has put upon us, not only to be good husbands and fathers and builders of our community, but God is now calling upon the despised and the rejected to become the cornerstone and the builders of a new world. And so, our brief subject today is taken from the American Constitution. In these words, Toward a more union. Toward a more perfect union."​

The speech emphasized again and again the need for personal responsibility and for the black community to look to itself, and for black men, in particular, to look to themselves, to find out what went wrong and to fix it:

Who is it that has to atone?
(AUDIENCE): Me.

FARRAKHAN: Who went wrong?

(AUDIENCE): Me.

FARRAKHAN: Who got to fix it?

(AUDIENCE): Me.

FARRAKHAN: Who should we look to?

(AUDIENCE): Me.

FARRAKHAN: Yes! And then if you add, if you add another letter to "me" you get an "n". What does that say?

(AUDIENCE): Men.​

The speech ended with a call for a pledge:

FARRAKHAN: I, say your name, pledge from this day forward I will never abuse my wife by striking here, disrespecting her for she is the mother of my children and the producer of my future. I, say your name, pledge that from this day forward I will never engage in the abuse of children, little boys, or little girls for sexual gratification. But I will let them grow in peace to be strong men and women for the future of our people. I, say your name, will never again use the B word to describe my female, but particularly my own Black sister.

I, say your name, pledge from this day forward that I will not poison my body with drugs or that which is destructive to my health and my well being. I, say your name, pledge from this day forward, I will support Black newspapers, Black radio, Black television. I will support Black artists, who clean up their acts to show respect for themselves and respect for their people, and respect for the ears of the human family.

I, say your name, will do all of this so help me God.​

I know that doesn't fit the version of Farrakhan served up by Fox News to its frightened white racist audience, but those are his words. But if you have some other sermons in mind, feel free to share them.
 
The government has done almost everything wrong in addressing poverty. Setting up government programs that morph into money sucking departments do nothing for the poor. If the government would kill about half their programs and top wasting money on programs like Head Start then they wouldn't have to tax so much and the economy would be way stronger and more people would be working.

They need to stop immigration of unskilled workers, we have more than enough of them to fill the low level jobs. Half end up on welfare within 2 years of entering the US, so this will help in welfare cost reduction.

We need to quit rewording single mothers for having more children. The whole policy of how welfare is done needs changing.

The government is the main cause of poverty.
If the government is the main cause of poverty, why was poverty so much worse when government was smaller, and why does poverty remain so much worse in all the major nations where government is smaller?
 
Could you link to some of those sermons. I've never heard a sermon by Sharpton, but I have heard a couple by Farrakhan and they were antithetical to the message you're attributing to him. Here's his most famous speech, delivered to nearly a million black men, and broadcast to countless more:

http://www-cgi.cnn.com/US/9510/megamarch/10-16/transcript/

The overall theme of the speech is summarized with this:

"We are standing on the sacrifice of the lives of those heroes, our great men and women that we today may accept the responsibility that life imposes upon each traveler who comes this way. We must accept the responsibility that God has put upon us, not only to be good husbands and fathers and builders of our community, but God is now calling upon the despised and the rejected to become the cornerstone and the builders of a new world. And so, our brief subject today is taken from the American Constitution. In these words, Toward a more union. Toward a more perfect union."​

The speech emphasized again and again the need for personal responsibility and for the black community to look to itself, and for black men, in particular, to look to themselves, to find out what went wrong and to fix it:

Who is it that has to atone?
(AUDIENCE): Me.

FARRAKHAN: Who went wrong?

(AUDIENCE): Me.

FARRAKHAN: Who got to fix it?

(AUDIENCE): Me.

FARRAKHAN: Who should we look to?

(AUDIENCE): Me.

FARRAKHAN: Yes! And then if you add, if you add another letter to "me" you get an "n". What does that say?

(AUDIENCE): Men.​

The speech ended with a call for a pledge:

FARRAKHAN: I, say your name, pledge from this day forward I will never abuse my wife by striking here, disrespecting her for she is the mother of my children and the producer of my future. I, say your name, pledge that from this day forward I will never engage in the abuse of children, little boys, or little girls for sexual gratification. But I will let them grow in peace to be strong men and women for the future of our people. I, say your name, will never again use the B word to describe my female, but particularly my own Black sister.

I, say your name, pledge from this day forward that I will not poison my body with drugs or that which is destructive to my health and my well being. I, say your name, pledge from this day forward, I will support Black newspapers, Black radio, Black television. I will support Black artists, who clean up their acts to show respect for themselves and respect for their people, and respect for the ears of the human family.

I, say your name, will do all of this so help me God.​

I know that doesn't fit the version of Farrakhan served up by Fox News to its frightened white racist audience, but those are his words. But if you have some other sermons in mind, feel free to share them.
Could you link to some of those sermons. I've never heard a sermon by Sharpton, but I have heard a couple by Farrakhan and they were antithetical to the message you're attributing to him. Here's his most famous speech, delivered to nearly a million black men, and broadcast to countless more:

http://www-cgi.cnn.com/US/9510/megamarch/10-16/transcript/

The overall theme of the speech is summarized with this:

"We are standing on the sacrifice of the lives of those heroes, our great men and women that we today may accept the responsibility that life imposes upon each traveler who comes this way. We must accept the responsibility that God has put upon us, not only to be good husbands and fathers and builders of our community, but God is now calling upon the despised and the rejected to become the cornerstone and the builders of a new world. And so, our brief subject today is taken from the American Constitution. In these words, Toward a more union. Toward a more perfect union."​

The speech emphasized again and again the need for personal responsibility and for the black community to look to itself, and for black men, in particular, to look to themselves, to find out what went wrong and to fix it:

Who is it that has to atone?
(AUDIENCE): Me.

FARRAKHAN: Who went wrong?

(AUDIENCE): Me.

FARRAKHAN: Who got to fix it?

(AUDIENCE): Me.

FARRAKHAN: Who should we look to?

(AUDIENCE): Me.

FARRAKHAN: Yes! And then if you add, if you add another letter to "me" you get an "n". What does that say?

(AUDIENCE): Men.​

The speech ended with a call for a pledge:

FARRAKHAN: I, say your name, pledge from this day forward I will never abuse my wife by striking here, disrespecting her for she is the mother of my children and the producer of my future. I, say your name, pledge that from this day forward I will never engage in the abuse of children, little boys, or little girls for sexual gratification. But I will let them grow in peace to be strong men and women for the future of our people. I, say your name, will never again use the B word to describe my female, but particularly my own Black sister.

I, say your name, pledge from this day forward that I will not poison my body with drugs or that which is destructive to my health and my well being. I, say your name, pledge from this day forward, I will support Black newspapers, Black radio, Black television. I will support Black artists, who clean up their acts to show respect for themselves and respect for their people, and respect for the ears of the human family.

I, say your name, will do all of this so help me God.​

I know that doesn't fit the version of Farrakhan served up by Fox News to its frightened white racist audience, but those are his words. But if you have some other sermons in mind, feel free to share them.


I don't watch Fox news so I have no idea what they show their viewers. I have however seen him on the news many, many times. And, generally he is bitching about something white people did. That is even perpetuated in the shit my kids brought home from black history month ( or really better termed White Guilt month) . When you spend generations telling people they won't suceed, don't be surprised when they don't.

Anyway - here is link with some of Farakhan's best quotes.
http://yellowhammernews.com/faithan...n-quotes-anticipation-return-alabama-weekend/

connie
 
I don't watch Fox news so I have no idea what they show their viewers. I have however seen him on the news many, many times. And, generally he is bitching about something white people did. That is even perpetuated in the shit my kids brought home from black history month ( or really better termed White Guilt month) . When you spend generations telling people they won't suceed, don't be surprised when they don't.

Anyway - here is link with some of Farakhan's best quotes.
http://yellowhammernews.com/faithan...n-quotes-anticipation-return-alabama-weekend/

connie
So, could you link me to one of the sermons you object to, or are you just guessing about their contents based on some out-of-context alleged quotations from a right-wing blog?
 
So, could you link me to one of the sermons you object to, or are you just guessing about their contents based on some out-of-context alleged quotations from a right-wing blog?

Out of context? Please - did he say them or not? Are you alleging he did not. I have never listed to sermon all the way through and I don't care to. I have seen enough of him on the news on talk shows as a guest to have his number. I googled racist quotes and there were literally hundreds. The fact that he ever uttered one of those things is enough to disgust me. If you want to make the case he isn't that bad have at it. I won't buy it.

connie
 
They have never stopped spending. National debt has increased every year. Year in and year out.

No shit. Successful organizations grow to suit their ever-increasing size. It's a pretty godamned simple logic thing. "Man bites dog" would be if we decreased spending in concert with growing need, population, and economic reality.
 
I'm wondering why you think those rates would make it "good"? Do you think the government needs so much more money than it already gets? If so, why? Do you trust them (Democrat and Republican) to spend the money wisely?

You're the one who dragged JFK into this one. YOU figure it out.
 
You see - THAT is the problem no one actually wants to address. You can move people around but they bring their problems with them.

I always hear white flight blamed for the downfall of urban and near in suburbs. But, I think that if you believe that you are nothing more than a blatant racist.
Lets think about this... you have a nice neighborhood. Some black people move in, presumably, they are nice black people. They have jobs, want to care for their homes, provide their kids a nice place to live... JUST like the white people who left. Ok - so if they are the same and want the same things - then why did the neighborhood go down just because the white people left? Shouldn't all those good upstanding black citizens keep the neighborhood as nice and pristine as their white counterparts? If you believe the white people left, and then the black people couldn't keep it up - you are simply saying that the black people weren't up to the job of it. They couldn't do it, they were less than in some way than the white residents.

I don't believe this - I believe is not race but socieoecnomic. Lower class people - not only have a lot of bad habits themselves, but they have a lot of friends and family with even worse bad habits. Some poor people are able to move and leave all their baggage behind. Those who can do that - do manage to drastically change their living situation and their socioeconomic standing.

But, most move, and they bring all their baggage with them. Their druggie nephew they let sleep on the couch. They take in their sister who has the drunk husband, who comes over and raises hell when he is lit up causes a commotion and the police come, etc. Because the druggie nephew is around, then some of his buddies are around, and then soon, some stuff goes missing. Then a few people get tired of that kind of shit, see whats coming down the pike, and they sell out, the next round of people moving up - bring the same scenario with them, making it even worse, till more people leave, selling at even lower prices, then more people moving up bring the shit with them, and make it even worse. So pretty soon, no one even wants to be there.

Sure, the white people that let may have left for racist reasons. But, if the issue was merely black people coming in to the neighborhood, it shouldn't have changed. It only changed because not because the people were black but because the people who came in were from a completely different socioeconomic class. And they brought with them all the baggage and the drama of being from that class. But, no one will ever really address the how poverty is not only a money thing, but also a sociological and psychological thing. Until that is addressed, throwing more money at it may make the people less poor according to the dollars and the thresholds, but it will not change their living situation.

connie
And it isn't necessarily that the people who flee from inner-city violence are themselves bad people. But the violence isn't happening by magic. People in the inner-city are perpetrating it. When these families move out of the area to avoid it, often they are bringing the problem with them.
 
No shit. Successful organizations grow to suit their ever-increasing size. It's a pretty godamned simple logic thing. "Man bites dog" would be if we decreased spending in concert with growing need, population, and economic reality.

Yeah, you jumped off the deep end for me in this post? What!?!
 
Could you link to some of those sermons? I've never heard a sermon by Sharpton, but I have heard a couple by Farrakhan and they were antithetical to the message you're attributing to him. Here's his most famous speech, delivered to nearly a million black men, and broadcast to countless more:

http://www-cgi.cnn.com/US/9510/megamarch/10-16/transcript/

The overall theme of the speech is summarized with this:

"We are standing on the sacrifice of the lives of those heroes, our great men and women that we today may accept the responsibility that life imposes upon each traveler who comes this way. We must accept the responsibility that God has put upon us, not only to be good husbands and fathers and builders of our community, but God is now calling upon the despised and the rejected to become the cornerstone and the builders of a new world. And so, our brief subject today is taken from the American Constitution. In these words, Toward a more union. Toward a more perfect union."​

The speech emphasized again and again the need for personal responsibility and for the black community to look to itself, and for black men, in particular, to look to themselves, to find out what went wrong and to fix it:

Who is it that has to atone?
(AUDIENCE): Me.

FARRAKHAN: Who went wrong?

(AUDIENCE): Me.

FARRAKHAN: Who got to fix it?

(AUDIENCE): Me.

FARRAKHAN: Who should we look to?

(AUDIENCE): Me.

FARRAKHAN: Yes! And then if you add, if you add another letter to "me" you get an "n". What does that say?

(AUDIENCE): Men.​

The speech ended with a call for a pledge:

FARRAKHAN: I, say your name, pledge from this day forward I will never abuse my wife by striking here, disrespecting her for she is the mother of my children and the producer of my future. I, say your name, pledge that from this day forward I will never engage in the abuse of children, little boys, or little girls for sexual gratification. But I will let them grow in peace to be strong men and women for the future of our people. I, say your name, will never again use the B word to describe my female, but particularly my own Black sister.

I, say your name, pledge from this day forward that I will not poison my body with drugs or that which is destructive to my health and my well being. I, say your name, pledge from this day forward, I will support Black newspapers, Black radio, Black television. I will support Black artists, who clean up their acts to show respect for themselves and respect for their people, and respect for the ears of the human family.

I, say your name, will do all of this so help me God.​

I know that doesn't fit the version of Farrakhan served up by Fox News to its frightened white racist audience, but those are his words. But if you have some other sermons in mind, feel free to share them.
Farrakhan has good days and bad. Has for decades.
 
This may sound like the bigotry of the lapsed Catholic, but I think there's something culturally diseased in Protestantism -- at least the Baptist/Methodist/Pentecostal charismatic variety you find throughout the Bible Belt (as opposed to the Anglicans, Episcopalians, Lutherans, and Mormons). It seems that wherever that mode of Protestantism is culturally dominant, you get poverty, lousy educational performance, obesity, rampant racism, sexism, homophobia, violence, teen pregnancy, divorce, etc. Maybe letting more Catholic immigrants into those areas, from Latin America, would help to fix the culture.

Doesn't explain the problem with Latin America. The catholic church has long taken the blame for the doldrums there. It is what precipitated liberation theology on the part of some Catholic priests. Besides the Charismatics have rarely been in charge of anything so it is hard to blame them.
 
Back
Top