New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Private Prosecutors

1) I'm asking a lawyer (you) a simple question, if a won civil case has ever precipitated the prosecution of a criminal case?

I'm not a criminal lawyer and don't know the answer to that. It's possible. But generally the civil case comes after a criminal case.... as with the OJ Simpson case, for example. And the standards are so different that I wouldn't think a win in a civil case would be seen as something that should precipitate a criminal case. It isn't just that the standards of proof are so different (i.e., beyond a reasonable doubt versus preponderance of the evidence). There are also different rules of evidence. For example, in most states you can't be forced to testify against a spouse in a criminal case but can in a civil case. So, if a civil case was won, at least in part, using evidence that wouldn't be available in the criminal case, that's not going to be much guide for how a criminal case will go.

2) Can a judge compel you to answer questions in a civil case unlike he can in a criminal case? Which seems to be the case because not answering questions can count against you when you plead the 5th.

I'm pretty sure that refusing to testify in a civil case wouldn't be admissible evidence in a criminal case.
 
I'm not a criminal lawyer and don't know the answer to that. It's possible. But generally the civil case comes after a criminal case.... as with the OJ Simpson case, for example. And the standards are so different that I wouldn't think a win in a civil case would be seen as something that should precipitate a criminal case. It isn't just that the standards of proof are so different (i.e., beyond a reasonable doubt versus preponderance of the evidence). There are also different rules of evidence. For example, in most states you can't be forced to testify against a spouse in a criminal case but can in a civil case. So, if a civil case was won, at least in part, using evidence that wouldn't be available in the criminal case, that's not going to be much guide for how a criminal case will go.



I'm pretty sure that refusing to testify in a civil case wouldn't be admissible evidence in a criminal case.
But a civil case would bring the facts to life within the judicial system and prosecutors may well react to that.

Anyways, the point being we do have private "prosecutors" already.
 
But a civil case would bring the facts to life within the judicial system and prosecutors may well react to that.

Anyways, the point being we do have private "prosecutors" already.
We have private plaintiff's attorneys, but that's not the same thing. They have no ability to put someone behind bars. And in the present case they are no solution to the problem at hand. Even if, say, the family of one of these men manages to win a wrongful death suit against the police, do you think there's even a snowball's chance in hell that a prosecutor is going to launch a prosecution against the cops on the basis of that? Perhaps in some outlandish scenario where the private plaintiff's lawyer discovers some smoking-gun evidence that somehow wasn't seen earlier (like a videotape proving Brown surrendered to Wilson and was gunned down in cold blood), but in any realistic scenario, the prosecutor's prejudices are going to remain the same. He's going to want to maintain good working relations with the police, and that means not making an honest effort to prosecute one of their number. A system allowing for the appointment of private prosecutors would get around that -- allowing the public prosecutors to retain their friendly relations with the police, while still making sure that the prosecutor on cases like this wasn't taking a politically-motivated dive in the courtroom.
 
We have private plaintiff's attorneys, but that's not the same thing. They have no ability to put someone behind bars. And in the present case they are no solution to the problem at hand. Even if, say, the family of one of these men manages to win a wrongful death suit against the police, do you think there's even a snowball's chance in hell that a prosecutor is going to launch a prosecution against the cops on the basis of that? Perhaps in some outlandish scenario where the private plaintiff's lawyer discovers some smoking-gun evidence that somehow wasn't seen earlier (like a videotape proving Brown surrendered to Wilson and was gunned down in cold blood), but in any realistic scenario, the prosecutor's prejudices are going to remain the same. He's going to want to maintain good working relations with the police, and that means not making an honest effort to prosecute one of their number. A system allowing for the appointment of private prosecutors would get around that -- allowing the public prosecutors to retain their friendly relations with the police, while still making sure that the prosecutor on cases like this wasn't taking a politically-motivated dive in the courtroom.
Well, short of a smoking gun revelation in civil court I'm not interested in the officers in the Garner or Browner cased being prosecuted. Your suggestion of private prosecutor really doesn't fly with me. It's like jurisdiction/judge shopping.

I think data collection of cop shootings and greater civilian over sight are the key. The police chief and sheriff should be answering to a 5 man board compromised of civilians with no ties to the police (political or economic) when writing a SOP manual and making decisions to commit to supporting an mrap or drone program.

For the record, as far as getting someone behind bars goes I know how it works. :0)
 
I'm not proposing nationalizing it. I'm proposing reforming at the state level, since that's politically more viable. Nationalizing it would, of course, be more efficient, but since it's not politically viable, I'm not proposing that.

But is that not what you're doing by taking the district procecutor out of it and having a national organization get involved?
 
No. I want a defense attorney, too, even at the grand jury stage. Sorry I wasn't clear on that. I understand that the rules would need to be worked out to accommodate that defense role in cases where there was a private prosecutor, but it seems like something that could be handled fairly easily. As I mentioned, I want an adversarial process, where the prosecutor is putting together the best honest case that can be made for indictment/conviction, and the defense lawyer is putting together the best honest case that can be made in the other direction, the judge is in a neutral role policing the standards of criminal procedure and providing neutral jury instructions, and the grand jury/jury is also in a neutral role, deciding whether the standard of proof has been satisfied.

That would make more sense then. Then you have at least a couple of perspectives for the grand jury to contemplate. However, during the grand jury phase, there is only supposed to be hard evidence and witness testimony. I'm afraid a biased procecutor would invite supposition. Although I think your plan is workable, I don't think it's any less bias and subject to corruption as the current system.
 
Well, short of a smoking gun revelation in civil court I'm not interested in the officers in the Garner or Browner cased being prosecuted.

Understood. I, on the other hand, don't think there should be some higher "smoking gun" standard for police prosecutions. I believe they should face prosecutors as motivated as the rest of us do.
 
But is that not what you're doing by taking the district procecutor out of it and having a national organization get involved?
No. It would still be a state judge, a local jury, a state court, and state rules of procedure, with appeals up through the state appeals courts, and state prison if there's a conviction. It could even end up being a local prosecutor. It just wouldn't be a public prosecutor motivated to take a dive in the case.
 
That would make more sense then. Then you have at least a couple of perspectives for the grand jury to contemplate. However, during the grand jury phase, there is only supposed to be hard evidence and witness testimony. I'm afraid a biased procecutor would invite supposition. Although I think your plan is workable, I don't think it's any less bias and subject to corruption as the current system.
I think it would be considerably less corrupt. In the current system, all that's needed for a clearly guilty man to go free is a friendly prosecutor willing to act as a de facto defense attorney, in a setting where there is nobody willing to make the case for guilt.
 
Understood. I, on the other hand, don't think there should be some higher "smoking gun" standard for police prosecutions. I believe they should face prosecutors as motivated as the rest of us do.
Each case is different and in these two a smoking gun is not a higher standard for the police.
 
No. It would still be a state judge, a local jury, a state court, and state rules of procedure, with appeals up through the state appeals courts, and state prison if there's a conviction. It could even end up being a local prosecutor. It just wouldn't be a public prosecutor motivated to take a dive in the case.

So your automatic assumption is that the procecutors are taking a dive. As opposed to a procecutor pushing for an indictment.

My experience is that 9 out of 10 times, the state representatives are less corrupt than the national representatives. And nationalizing the process is exactly what you're proposing. The minute you allow national greavance organizations to run the procecution of state employees based on nothing more than a mock scenario, you're nationalizing the process.

I doubt very much that these biased procecutors will settle with unfavorable outcomes, any more than they are settling now.
 
I think it would be considerably less corrupt. In the current system, all that's needed for a clearly guilty man to go free is a friendly prosecutor willing to act as a de facto defense attorney, in a setting where there is nobody willing to make the case for guilt.

And in your scenario, we would have to mock a greavance in order to find the right greavance group to go to. So ALL such incidents will have to be civil rights issues of one kind or another.

No corruption there.
 
So your automatic assumption is that the procecutors are taking a dive. As opposed to a procecutor pushing for an indictment.

My experience is that 9 out of 10 times, the state representatives are less corrupt than the national representatives. And nationalizing the process is exactly what you're proposing. The minute you allow national greavance organizations to run the procecution of state employees based on nothing more than a mock scenario, you're nationalizing the process.

I doubt very much that these biased procecutors will settle with unfavorable outcomes, any more than they are settling now.
My experience is state officials are far more corrupt than national ones, and local ones far more corrupt than state ones. Nixon looks upright next to Huey Long who looks like a straight arrow next to Boss Tweed.
 
And in your scenario, we would have to mock a greavance in order to find the right greavance group to go to. So ALL such incidents will have to be civil rights issues of one kind or another.

No corruption there.
No clue what you're saying.
 
Back
Top