New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Progressives' favorite word...

Lukey

Senator
Free! Everything is "free" - "free" ways, "free" healthcare, "free" education...but, of course, nothing is really "free." That's just a convenient way of saying "I don't have to pay for it." That makes these "free" things the government supplies "free" in the same sense that the money the bank robber pulls out of the teller's hand is "free." Progressives love the word "free" because they like spending other people's money on the stuff they want, and don't want to be thought of as conniving "thieves." But that's essentially what they are, when they sell something as "free" that other people are going to get stuck with the lion's share of the bill for.

The first step was changing how roads were funded. In the 1930s, there were already privately owned toll roads in the East, and some public toll highways, like the Pennsylvania Turnpike, were under construction. But auto groups recognized that funding public roads through taxes on gasoline would allow highways to expand much more quickly.


They also decided to call these roads "free roads," a term that was later replaced by freeways. Norton argues that this naming shift was essential in persuading the federal government — and the public — to shift away from tolls. "It started with calling the roads drivers pay for 'toll roads,' and calling the ones that taxpayers pay for 'free roads,'" he says. "Of course, there's no such thing as a free road."


Those terms were officially enshrined in a 1939 congressional planning document called "Toll Roads and Free Roads" that roughly outlined what would become the Interstate system for the first time.


http://www.vox.com/2015/5/14/8605917/highways-interstate-cities-history

And then the unintended consequences like traffic, pollution and urban sprawl show up and they turn around and bitch about them, and, of course, demand even bigger government to save us from ourselves. Maybe if we hadn't made roads "free" we wouldn't use so much carbon based fuel, we'd have cleaner air, less climate change to worry about, better public transit and more efficient land use. Maybe if we'd just stop listening to the progressives, we'd all be better off down the road...
 
Free! Everything is "free" - "free" ways, "free" healthcare, "free" education...but, of course, nothing is really "free." That's just a convenient way of saying "I don't have to pay for it." That makes these "free" things the government supplies "free" in the same sense that the money the bank robber pulls out of the teller's hand is "free." Progressives love the word "free" because they like spending other people's money on the stuff they want, and don't want to be thought of as conniving "thieves." But that's essentially what they are, when they sell something as "free" that other people are going to get stuck with the lion's share of the bill for.

The first step was changing how roads were funded. In the 1930s, there were already privately owned toll roads in the East, and some public toll highways, like the Pennsylvania Turnpike, were under construction. But auto groups recognized that funding public roads through taxes on gasoline would allow highways to expand much more quickly.


They also decided to call these roads "free roads," a term that was later replaced by freeways. Norton argues that this naming shift was essential in persuading the federal government — and the public — to shift away from tolls. "It started with calling the roads drivers pay for 'toll roads,' and calling the ones that taxpayers pay for 'free roads,'" he says. "Of course, there's no such thing as a free road."


Those terms were officially enshrined in a 1939 congressional planning document called "Toll Roads and Free Roads" that roughly outlined what would become the Interstate system for the first time.


http://www.vox.com/2015/5/14/8605917/highways-interstate-cities-history

And then the unintended consequences like traffic, pollution and urban sprawl show up and they turn around and bitch about them, and, of course, demand even bigger government to save us from ourselves. Maybe if we hadn't made roads "free" we wouldn't use so much carbon based fuel, we'd have cleaner air, less climate change to worry about, better public transit and more efficient land use. Maybe if we'd just stop listening to the progressives, we'd all be better off down the road...


I lean more towards words like kerfuffle and cacophony.

Oddly enough, these words often describe the tenor of your posts.

The rise of roads, free and otherwise, the car culture, the "freedom" meme it embodies through the previously discussed road trip, (See the USA, In Your Chevrolet) and the demise of urban mass transit networks are all contributors to our problems.

No matter, it's all just a marxist plot...I mean...those evil founding fathers did use code words like union...
 
I lean more towards words like kerfuffle and cacophony.

Oddly enough, these words often describe the tenor of your posts.

The rise of roads, free and otherwise, the car culture, the "freedom" meme it embodies through the previously discussed road trip, (See the USA, In Your Chevrolet) and the demise of urban mass transit networks are all contributors to our problems.

No matter, it's all just a marxist plot...I mean...those evil founding fathers did use code words like union...

Touché, (and genuinely humorous) but I think you maybe missed (or ignored) my point...that we'd be better off if we stopped thinking of government provided stuff as "free." That when politicians start offering us something as "free" maybe we should decline the offer. Do you not agree that we'd be better off as a society today if we hadn't embraced the concept of "freeways?"
 
I lean more towards words like kerfuffle and cacophony.

Oddly enough, these words often describe the tenor of your posts.

The rise of roads, free and otherwise, the car culture, the "freedom" meme it embodies through the previously discussed road trip, (See the USA, In Your Chevrolet) and the demise of urban mass transit networks are all contributors to our problems.

No matter, it's all just a marxist plot...I mean...those evil founding fathers did use code words like union...

Keynesian!

;-)
 
in related news, the left (and the media) are debating whether "taxpayer" is racist/divisive word.

because, you know, so many people do NOT pay taxes these days.

here's a link:
http://hotair.com/archives/2015/03/23/new-trigger-warning-from-tnr-taxpayers/

Figures, they go to trying to change the language, rather than you know.. making sure everyone is paying a certain percentage of taxes. Then we would all be "taxpayers" instead of some of being a net tax taker.
 
"Progressives" don't shout "free"!.....ODS-ers and other assorted lint-pickers shout "free" when hating on progressives! To everyone else, it's about the things people want their functioning society to provide. For instance....do "conservatives" call for "FREE!" roads? and "FREE!" defense? and "FREE!" law enforcement?.......well...it sounds pretty silly when we put it that way, doesn't it?
 
Touché, (and genuinely humorous) but I think you maybe missed (or ignored) my point...that we'd be better off if we stopped thinking of government provided stuff as "free." That when politicians start offering us something as "free" maybe we should decline the offer. Do you not agree that we'd be better off as a society today if we hadn't embraced the concept of "freeways?"

No, I do not agree. Roads are the lifeblood of commerce. I'm not even positive that RRs were all private as the B&O seems to have begun as a consortium of folks and agencies that included the City Of Baltimore. That was constructed in order to compete with other ports and other engineering feats, such as the Erie Canal. Maryland also constructed the C&O Canal to further commerce. There are plenty of tolls on the highways near me. Indeed, there is much recent noise in Maryland because they just lowered the tolls.

I would prefer some other level of sensibility from our citizens. Sensibilities like living closer to work, denser work environments with core cities, a design that has worked for thousands of years...until the car made distances more easily conquered. Hence, sprawl. Then...more reasonable vehicles...as it makes no sense to drive a single individual 35 miles in a 7,000 vehicle that hold 7. This is tilting at windmill territory and I have ZERO INTEREST in have the state force people into behaviors. That said...taxes...seem a reasonable way to deal with the payment of roads issue. That idiot uses a LOT of gas...hence, pays considerable tax. I drive a small car, sparingly, hence, pay little in taxes. But I still pay the toll of I want to cross the bridge...

It simply is not practical to place tolls every...what, every mile? 5 miles? Where? On every road? Every entrance? Exit? Or just the high speed multi-lane restricted access roads? At the entry of a new jurisdiction?
 
"Progressives" don't shout "free"!.....ODS-ers and other assorted lint-pickers shout "free" when hating on progressives! To everyone else, it's about the things people want their functioning society to provide. For instance....do "conservatives" call for "FREE!" roads? and "FREE!" defense? and "FREE!" law enforcement?.......well...it sounds pretty silly when we put it that way, doesn't it?

http://www.pbs.org/newshour/rundown/community-college-tuition-top-theme-state-union-speech/

http://www.nerdwallet.com/blog/health/2013/11/05/free-preventative-care-obamacare/

http://www.nerdwallet.com/blog/health/2014/11/13/is-birth-control-free-obamacare/

I don't know any conservatives (or libertarians) that think of anything the government does or provides as "free."
 
No, I do not agree. Roads are the lifeblood of commerce. I'm not even positive that RRs were all private as the B&O seems to have begun as a consortium of folks and agencies that included the City Of Baltimore. That was constructed in order to compete with other ports and other engineering feats, such as the Erie Canal. Maryland also constructed the C&O Canal to further commerce. There are plenty of tolls on the highways near me. Indeed, there is much recent noise in Maryland because they just lowered the tolls.

I would prefer some other level of sensibility from our citizens. Sensibilities like living closer to work, denser work environments with core cities, a design that has worked for thousands of years...until the car made distances more easily conquered. Hence, sprawl. Then...more reasonable vehicles...as it makes no sense to drive a single individual 35 miles in a 7,000 vehicle that hold 7. This is tilting at windmill territory and I have ZERO INTEREST in have the state force people into behaviors. That said...taxes...seem a reasonable way to deal with the payment of roads issue. That idiot uses a LOT of gas...hence, pays considerable tax. I drive a small car, sparingly, hence, pay little in taxes. But I still pay the toll of I want to cross the bridge...

It simply is not practical to place tolls every...what, every mile? 5 miles? Where? On every road? Every entrance? Exit? Or just the high speed multi-lane restricted access roads? At the entry of a new jurisdiction?

So the roads should be "free" but the users "taxed" to discourage them from overusing this "free" public asset? Sounds like something a progressive would come up with. Excellent job comrade!
 
So the roads should be "free" but the users "taxed" to discourage them from overusing this "free" public asset? Sounds like something a progressive would come up with. Excellent job comrade!

So..you believe all roads should be toll roads, but failed to explain how that would work. Cool. I suppose that would be a great jobs program, unless of course, everyone simply used the EZ Pass.

Does the corollary also mean you believe gasoline taxes should be halted entirely in order to proceed with the Full Toll Road Plan?

Still...give it a shot. Tell us how and where all these tolls...because there are no longer "free" roads...will be instituted.
 
So..you believe all roads should be toll roads, but failed to explain how that would work. Cool. I suppose that would be a great jobs program, unless of course, everyone simply used the EZ Pass.

Does the corollary also mean you believe gasoline taxes should be halted entirely in order to proceed with the Full Toll Road Plan?

Still...give it a shot. Tell us how and where all these tolls...because there are no longer "free" roads...will be instituted.

Not all roads, just the interstate and intrastate highways. The users would have to work that out with the owners. EZ Pass makes it easier now but if the user of a road was willing to pay a fee that covered the costs of employing toll collectors, that's capitalism.
 

That you can cut 'n paste an example of someone actually employing the word "free", misses my gist entirely. Tell me, how does a "conservative" propose that we citizens pay for roads, defense, and law enforcement? Does that conservative suggest we should all cut monthly checks for those benefits?

OR maybe...is this simply about differing views around what society should and shouldn't provide, and a few nincompoops "buzz-phrasing" the word "free", out of ignorance or intended deceit?
 
Not all roads, just the interstate and intrastate highways. The users would have to work that out with the owners. EZ Pass makes it easier now but if the user of a road was willing to pay a fee that covered the costs of employing toll collectors, that's capitalism.

Odd...that's what we have in my neck of the woods. The collection points tend to be the big bridges...as they are tough to avoid.


It's not as if we don't have toll roads...

http://beta.costtodrive.com/us-tolls/
 
in related news, the left (and the media) are debating whether "taxpayer" is racist/divisive word.

because, you know, so many people do NOT pay taxes these days.

here's a link:
http://hotair.com/archives/2015/03/23/new-trigger-warning-from-tnr-taxpayers/
I've never met anyone who doesn't pay taxes. Could you provide an example? I'd like to ask that person how he manages to get store clerks to back out the sales tax whenever he makes a purchase. I'd imagine that automated gas pumps are particularly hard to get not to apply tax to a sale.
 
I've never met anyone who doesn't pay taxes. Could you provide an example? I'd like to ask that person how he manages to get store clerks to back out the sales tax whenever he makes a purchase. I'd imagine that automated gas pumps are particularly hard to get not to apply tax to a sale.

Ask someone using an EBT card, and see if they thank you for paying their taxes.
 
Ask someone using an EBT card, and see if they thank you for paying their taxes.
Taxes are only not charged for SNAP-eligible purchases. I have never met anyone who manages to buy nothing other than SNAP-eligible purchases, so my assumption is that everyone I know -- at least those old enough to actually spend money, is a taxpayer. In addition, people who work mostly pay taxes. Even those in the bottom quintile pay payroll taxes, which, even after you net out refundable tax credits, end up averaging around 1.9% for the bottom quintile:

http://www.taxpolicycenter.org/taxfacts/displayafact.cfm?Docid=456

And that's just federal tax, not counting what they have to pay to the state, county, locality, etc.

So, other than very young children, we're almost all taxpayers.
 
Free! Everything is "free" - "free" ways, "free" healthcare, "free" education...but, of course, nothing is really "free."

Amen , nothing is free. Life. liberty and pursuit of happiness used to be. No more.

Ironically those who buy into the "free" this or that are those who would rather be owned.

It's no different than slavery. And we all know, or should know, which political party championed slavery. That's why I get a kick out of folks who have for 50 years chanted, "We will overcome" and haven't yet figured out who it is they have to overcome?
 
That you can cut 'n paste an example of someone actually employing the word "free", misses my gist entirely. Tell me, how does a "conservative" propose that we citizens pay for roads, defense, and law enforcement? Does that conservative suggest we should all cut monthly checks for those benefits?

OR maybe...is this simply about differing views around what society should and shouldn't provide, and a few nincompoops "buzz-phrasing" the word "free", out of ignorance or intended deceit?

The gist is that politicians sell us stuff as "free" and then send us (or at least some of us) the bill. It's part of the overgrowth of government effect that creates infrastructure that they then don't fund repairs of, preferring to use all the current revenue to build more projects (and get more political favors from developers and construction companies) and to provide lavish pay and benefit packages to an ever growing army of public workers (and get more political patronage that way as well). This is why I view the entire political process as corrupt - it is! And what isn't corrupt is generally incompetent. Which is why I favor as small a government as possible. Make people who want stuff, or use stuff or destroy or pollute stuff pay...and leave the rest of us alone.
 
Odd...that's what we have in my neck of the woods. The collection points tend to be the big bridges...as they are tough to avoid.


It's not as if we don't have toll roads...

http://beta.costtodrive.com/us-tolls/

We have the PA turnpike here and it's a toll road. If enough people want a road or bridge to someplace then it will be built (that's how the turnpike got made), otherwise we would have to get along without it. Think of all the problems sprawl has created for us. We'd be much better off if the nation was dotted with a few dozen large, city based population centers and the rest vast swaths of sparsely populated semi wilderness. We'd use less energy, we'd have less pollution and we'd better be able to fund social welfare programs in large densely populated cities.
 
Back
Top