New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Question for Conservatives

Obama edited video in the Martin case? He doctored a 911 call? He had signs made up for Tea Party rallies to make them look racist? Man, the guy gets around, doesn't he?!

The question I posed was what should Obama have done differently to get the economy growing more robustly. If you have any answers, please feel free to offer them.
 
[Shrug] You are a true believer and I'm not going to try and convince you that your perspective is wrong. You asked and I told you.

So let's switch it around and go with it your way. Obama is an ideal president despite his zero meaningful amount of national level experience before becoming president and no other president could possibly have done any better in that office under these circumstances. He must be doing so badly now in polling numbers just because citizens are fickle creatures.

It's not black and white. He can be a flawed president who made dumb mistakes due in part to his minimal national experience, and yet still the best man for the job. I have a long list of criticisms about Obama. I don't need to worship someone to vote for him. But what I'm trying to figure out in this thread is whether Republicans have any decent ideas for things Obama could have done to get the economy growing more robustly.
 
Mr. Arkady,

Two big things. The first would have been instead of ram rodding though the partisan, one sided Health Care bill, he should have made improving the economy his first order of business. Like it or not, one thihg is clear about it. In a bad economy, business are unwilling to take on additional risk. In essence, he was forcing business to back off and not hire.

The second would have been to negotiate and work with the other political party. By telling them that "elections have consequences" and refusing to accept any input from them when he controlled both houses of congress, he was doomed to turnabout is fair play when he envitably lost the house by a huge majority.

He did make improving the economy his first order of business. ARRA (the stimulus bill) was 2009. Healthcare was 2010.

As for the contention that it was a partisan, one-sided health bill, it was, in fact, almost identical to the plan the conservative think tank, The Heritage Foundation, had promoted, and that the Republican standard-bearer, Mitt Romney had pushed through in Massachusetts. It was also, without any serious doubt, the most conservative health system currently in place in any major wealthy nation in the world. I can see a liberal calling it "one-sided," since it was basically a one-sided right-wing solution, which rejected out of hand the various things liberals were calling for (e.g., "Medicare for All," or at least a "public option," or instituting tight price controls, like the Japanese, or taking the profit motive away from the health insurers the way the Swiss and Germans do). But I can't see what the conservatives have to complain about: he adopted their own plan almost exactly.

As for Obama's alleged unwillingness to work with the other side, nothing could be further from the truth. In addition to his conservative health care plan, he pushed through extra tax cuts, to win over conservatives, and boosted military spending. During the debt ceiling standoff, he offered up a compromise that included four times as much in the way of spending cuts as it had for revenue enhancement -- and the Republicans STILL rejected it. When Obama's offering up compromises that favor the opposition 4-to-1 and they still don't compromise, it's absurd to suggest it's his fault.

My own criticism of Obama is the opposite. He wasted HUGE amounts of time trying to get at least some token Republican buy-in for his healthcare plan, which was never going to be forthcoming. He should have crammed it down their throat and moved on, but he's addicted to his self-image as a guy who is eager to compromise, so even in the absence of a single reasonable person on the other side of the table, he'll negotiate against himself just in the hopes of enticing them into a dialogue. It's pathetic. I've never seen a Democrat this eager to give the Republicans almost anything to get their buy-in.
 
Tried a little capitalism...

How, particularly? Apparently the extra tax cuts he pushed through and his signing an extension of the Bush tax cuts didn't do it for you. Nor, apparently, did his stimulus package, which flowed the majority of its funds through the capitalist system (government investment in private, for-profit corporate projects), rather than using New Deal-style government works projects, through which the government itself would hire people and build stuff. So, what exactly did you have in mind?

My own criticisms of Obama are the opposite. I think he wasted a lot of money on economically inert tax cuts (a lack of demand, not a lack of capital, was the problem, so tax cuts did nothing useful). And I think he wasted a lot of time and money flowing stimulus money through corporate hand-outs, rather than creating things like the WPA and Civilian Conservation Corps, the way FDR did. I also think it was a big mistake to hand tons of money over to the states, so they could forego needed tax increases, instead of funding federal-level spending that could have been much more efficient, thanks to economies of scale. And, of course, I think it was a mistake not to claw back some of the ill-gotten gains of bank executives and shareholders, to help fund the bailout.... and also a mistake to try to fix the mortgage crisis by super-saturating the banks with capital, rather than providing direct relief to consumer debtors (and direct low-interest lending to encourage new home purchases). But all of that would have been a move in the direction of socialism, and Obama is nothing if not a dyed in the wool capitalist, so he swept such options right off the table.
 
Let's be very straightforward for a moment. Do you really believe we have the best (high quality) people running for office from any party?
Yes. I think there is variance of course - and when one party has a strong candidate, the other party runs strong candidates elsewhere. Obama is a strong and high quality candidate. He faces many challenges, racism not the least of it. http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1540-5907.2011.00577.x/abstract http://www.people.fas.harvard.edu/~sstephen/papers/RacialAnimusAndVotingSethStephensDavidowitz.pdf

Now is Ryan the best the GOP can offer? I dont' think so. He didn't even manage a B+ GPA at a 4th tier Univ.

Is Romney the best the GOP has? Well to the extent that the GOP position requires a repudiation of mainstream economic theory - yes I'd say he is. Because as long as the Tea Party dominates the GOP, rational folks like Christine Todd-Whitman are not going to be able to make it to the fore

Term limits... term limits and line item veto.
And we have seen what a catastrophe term limits have been in California. Since term limits have been established, CA has essentially been unable to pass a consistent budget.

Line Item Veto - would make things worse. Because what it means is that any sort of political compromise hammered out by the MAJORITY ELECTED REPRESENTATIVES of the people - is null and void. It inherently encourages everything including the kitchen sink be dumped into the budget and to be tied together so that vetoing one part destroys another... or just in hopes of hiding stuff in one line not seen by the POTUS' veto pen.


Sorry, the problem is not people who don't represent the interests of the constituents. If anything it is the OPPOSITE. it is representatives who CATER to their constituents regardless of how poorly thought they are. The whole focus on THE DEBT is a prime example of this. Yes the deficit spending needs to be addressed. NO addressing it in a recovery IS A BAD IDEA.

But - because the Tea Party Caucus is SO responsive to its constituencies - albeit largely a distorted representation of them since many come from districts that have AT LEAST 40% Dems in them - there is no negotiation possible.
 
We should have had government get out of the way and let the economy heal. The problem wasn't a systemic problem with the economy, but the bursting of a housing bubble that was decades in the making. Obama took advantage of the situation to impose regulations that are making it hard for business to pull themselves back on track.

Obama has taken the "Catholic Nun with a large ruler" mentality to the economy, and it's hard to run an economy that way.

Which Obama-imposed regulations, exactly, do you think are making it hard for business to pull themselves back on track?

As for the idea of government getting out of the way and letting the economy heal, we tried that the last time there was a financial meltdown this bad, back in 1929. That time, the recession that started with the meltdown continued unabated for 43 months (compared to 18 months for the Bush recession that ended in Obama's sixth month in office). The "just get out of the way" method culminated in about 25% unemployment, and many Americans quite literally starving to death. Eventually, in 1933, the government decided that "get out of the way and let things heal" was idiotic, and we went the opposite direction, touching off a period with some of the strongest job creation and GDP growth ever recorded. It's odd that you'd want to emulate Hoover, not Roosevelt, given that history.
 
Y
Sorry, the problem is not people who don't represent the interests of the constituents. If anything it is the OPPOSITE. it is representatives who CATER to their constituents regardless of how poorly thought they are. The whole focus on THE DEBT is a prime example of this. Yes the deficit spending needs to be addressed. NO addressing it in a recovery IS A BAD IDEA.

But - because the Tea Party Caucus is SO responsive to its constituencies - albeit largely a distorted representation of them since many come from districts that have AT LEAST 40% Dems in them - there is no negotiation possible.

So you're saying representatives should not ACT in a representational way? What part of our system of government do you LIKE, Degs?
 
Unlike a lot of Obama supporters, I'll admit that this economic recovery had been weaker than was necessary, even in light of the absolute mess Bush left. I do, of course, let Obama off the hook for 2009, because I think there was almost nothing he could have done to stop the hemorrhaging faster than he did, given the nature of the crisis (it wasn't a standard business-cycle contraction, like most modern recessions, it was a financial meltdown, like the recession that caused the Great Depression, and like some of the economy-obliterating panics of the 1800s). 2009 was a lost cause, even with the best of policies.

Respectfully I disagree. The stimulus was "insufficient" because of the politics of the circumstances were such that no bigger stimulus could get passed. And this was largely because of the GOP/Tea Party mantra of "The Debt Is The Problem" (remember the nonsense about balancing your checkbook?).

FDR managed 5% GDP Growth the first year he took office and accelerated it to 8.1% steady state for the next 3 years. Had we stared with about a $1.3 Trillion stimulus and maintained an additional $1 trillion stimulus into 2010 and then ramped it down to $500b in 2011, and about $300B in 2012, we would have aded $2.8T in debt, but we would have generated $800B in additioanl Tax revenue, $4.2 Trillion in GDP and dropped unemployment to 6%. Which itself would have saved about an addtional $500B in unemployment costs.

So our net increase in debt would be about $1.3-$1.5 T... but we would have an economy growing at about 4% GDP.

The reality is that the GOP leadership RECOGNIZED THIS.... and hence the filibusters that we saw associated with any successive stimulus attempts after August 2009 gave them a Cloture Proof minority.

There really was a case of mendacity here. For political gain against someone they felt was an Invalid President.
 
Companies hire when they need more production. They need more production when they're more profitable.

That's a fundamental misunderstanding. My business needs more production when it perceives demand outstripping the capacity to meet demand. A company isn't going to build a new factory just because profits are up. It's going to build it if the current factory can't make enough widgets to meet the orders they expect to be getting in the coming years.

In fact, corporate profit growth has been very good enough recent years. Extraordinary, in fact, which is why stock market performance under Obama exceeds stock market performance under any other modern president. But a company has a choice of what to do with those profits. It can use them to pay down debt, or to accumulate cash, or it can dividend them out to shareholders, or increase bonuses for senior execs.... or it can hire new people and invest in new infrastructure. Those last two options only make sense if current manpower and infrastructure are seen as being inadequate to meet demand in the near future.
 
So you're saying representatives should not ACT in a representational way? What part of our system of government do you LIKE, Degs?
Representatives historically have not acted in a direct representational manner. The very point of an APPOINTED Senate - as it was originally concieved. was to insure that the Senate was populated with "Solid, Thinking Leaders".

In fact the notion of "tyrranny of the majority" was part of what representational government was seeking to avoid by putting in DELIBRATION into the process. For example when Jackson won the WH on a populist ticket. JQ Adams opined "I fear for the Republic, the rabble have taken the White House"...

Well today - the rabble - who don't understand about liquidity traps and Sovereign vs. personal debt and international monetary economics.. are demanding "balanced budgets" and punishing representatives, who upon learning the facts - decide to do something different.

it comes down to the question of what are representatives supposed to represent:

  • The BEST INTERESTS of the constituency?
    or
  • The basest knee jerk BELIEFS of the constituency?

Given that most representatives actually represent a rather pluralistic constituency and not just the "first past the post" voting majority - it strikes me that good governance requires the former. And that actually is the way it used to be.
 
And I can't offer a legal or constitutional way to do what I suggested

There's a way that's both legal and Constitutional. Simply withdraw from the WTO and NAFTA (with Congressional approval), and erect steep tariffs. Jobs get off-shored because labor is cheaper in the third world. But if the savings from cheaper labor abroad are more than offset by the higher costs of tariffs, to get access to the US consumer market, people will keep those jobs here if they want to sell to the American consumer. I oppose that for a number of reasons (the reciprocal trade barriers would kill exports, prices would rise faster than wages, and you'd still lose half those jobs to automation, anyway), but it would be perfectly legal.

There's a modified solution that would get around the problems. The US would need to get together with Canada, Australia, Japan, and the EU, to create a single trade block, with coordinated trade policy and no tariffs among us. Then we would collectively raise trade barriers against everyone outside that block, with multiple tariff levels, linked to desired behaviors among those countries (observing environmental and IP laws, protecting labor and human rights, and moving towards pluralism and democracy). The idea would be to capture the benefits of trade with the third world, without letting the third world play us wealthy nations off against each other (if you want access to ANY of our consumer markets, you have to play ball). And the big picture would be to ratchet up our requirements for low-tariff trade, gradually over time, so that the third world was brought up to our standards, rather than us racing to the bottom to compete with them. The move would be timed so that where real efficiencies could be found through off-shoring, that would be allowed, but where the cost savings are minor, there'd be enough tariffs to keep people from pulling the trigger, so workers aren't displaced for trivial profit enhancements. And, meanwhile, the tariffs collected could be used to fund job retraining and severance benefits, so those workers who did get displaced could be eased into new work in some other field.
 
Unlike a lot of Obama supporters, I'll admit that this economic recovery had been weaker than was necessary, even in light of the absolute mess Bush left. I do, of course, let Obama off the hook for 2009, because I think there was almost nothing he could have done to stop the hemorrhaging faster than he did, given the nature of the crisis (it wasn't a standard business-cycle contraction, like most modern recessions, it was a financial meltdown, like the recession that caused the Great Depression, and like some of the economy-obliterating panics of the 1800s). 2009 was a lost cause, even with the best of policies. But, I believe it was possible to have us restored to robust economic growth and normal job creation before now, and so I fault Obama for not having done so. I'll grant he had very limited options after the Republicans took over Congress and dedicated themselves completely to gridlock. But there are things Obama could have done in '09 and '10 that would have had us much farther along the recovery road today.

If people are interested, I'm happy to provide my thoughts, in detail, about what he could have done differently. But that's not the point of this post. Instead, I'm curious what the conservatives, who are his fiercest critics, think he should have done differently.

Should he have pushed through even more tax cuts than he already did? If so, wouldn't that have resulted in even bigger deficits? And, given the fact that the corporations and the rich are already sitting on piles of money they don't care to invest, due to poor demand growth, how would handing them even more cash have helped? Moreover, doesn't the fact that we had some of the lowest taxes in our modern history, for the eight sub-par economic years leading up to the economic catastrophe, give you pause about the economic efficacy of that method?

The other frequent go-to policy for Republicans is deregulation, but that one's also hard to understand in the current context. We just suffered an economic collapse triggered by the "shadow banking system" -- a system of unregulated and under-regulated financial relationships, using exotic instruments that multiplied and spread economic risk throughout the global system. At best, pushing through more deregulation is like telling an alcoholic to take another drink to calm his hangover.

So, what else should Obama have done, from the conservative perspective?

We had ample notice of the impending problem even while Bush was still in office. The problem then as it still exists today is that the "peoples" equity disappeared. People with interest only loans with balloon payments could not refinance because their status did not go up and the increase in home prices got stagnant. This caused banks to lose their assets and people to lose homes causing prices to continually drop.

Government could have stopped this in the beginning by offering programs to keep people in their homes, like a one time hundred year mortgage for their existing mortgage. Fanny or Freddy could have purchased those hundred year mortgages. At the same time they would have to impose regulation regarding the way banks and other institutions bundled mortgages and placed them in the stock market. This would have allowed people to afford the homes they had and at least keep home values stable. The downward economic spiral would have never happened.

Of course they would have to cease the way they mortgaged homes which started the problem and become more conservative in loans. Then we would have only had a normal downturn cycle in the economy.
 
I'm not sure if you're objecting to the notion that 2009 was a lost cause even with the best of policies. If so, then I think the comparison to 1933 might be a bit off base just because 1933 was already nearly four years removed from the triggering financial crisis, so the situation was more ripe for immediate improvement.... all that was needed was a sizable smack by government and the return to robust growth was almost instant. I just have a feeling that even if we'd had FDR in 2009, and a Congress made up of people willing to give us 1933-style stimulus, we still wouldn't have seen robust growth as quickly as we did in the New Deal. But I do think it would have shown up before now.

But, of course, we had neither an FDR-style president (Obama does not seem to have fought terribly hard for more liberal policies, and certainly didn't use the bully pulpit effectively if he was fighting behind the scenes), nor an FDR-style Congress (Obama was dealing with a lot of limp-wristed Democrats in Congress who were either uncomfortable with massive stimulus, or who were uncomfortable shoving it forcibly down the throats of the Republican minority).

As for the filibuster, if it was done as a budget item, they wouldn't have needed a cloture minority, they could have managed it through reconciliation. That would take political guts, of course, but with unified Democrats, they could have done it. Plus, I think if Obama had been more aggressive, he might have scared some Republicans into getting in line with a cloture vote. Picture him spending a week doing a very public county-by-county tour of the economic depression in Maine, while calling daily for Senators Collins and Snowe to join him in coming to Maine's aid. It would be hard to stand up to that, for a pair of Senators whose ability to get elected in New England is tied to their image as moderates willing to break with their party. It was simply a matter of making it seem riskier, to them, to stick with the GOP and face centrist wrath, than to go with the president and face possible Tea Party challenges. Obama never dared make them sweat that way.
 
I think those are strong proposals. I would modify that just a bit, though. I'm still a little annoyed by the idea of government swooping in and rescuing dumb people from their own mistakes. If someone leveraged his home to the hilt to finance consumer spending, why should the ordinary taxpayer save him from his mistake? Even aside from the moral hazard issue, there's the fact that this involves lots of people who couldn't even afford homes essentially subsidizing the consumer lifestyles of reckless richer people who could afford homes.

So, I'd look to have two government-financed programs. One would be something like you're talking about (e.g.., 100-year refinances), but only for those who didn't do anything particularly dumb (e.g., those who wound up over their head because of a job loss, illness, or other economic shift they shouldn't necessarily have planned for), while those who acted particularly stupidly would be allowed to lose their homes. But then the second program would be designed to prevent a cascading devaluation of home prices caused by mass foreclosures against those dumb folks. It would make 100-year mortgages available to first-time buyers, but would only be available for those buying existing homes. That would bring in a lot of new buyers, especially the poor and working class people and young people who couldn't afford houses during the run-up in real estate, and they'd mop up the excess housing stock, so we didn't get a glut that further depressed values. If there weren't enough of them to do that, I'd also consider 100-year mortgages for first-time second-home buyers who were otherwise financially sound (if someone is going to swoop in and pick up a vacation home or investment property, I'd rather it be someone who didn't contribute to the housing bubble and meltdown).
 
Back
Top