Arkady
President
I won't say "just reduce costs," butI think there are some approaches taht could have been taken. Just for openers, something should have been done about jobs first, instead of focusing on heatlh care while unemployment was still near 10 percent.
If that meant reducing taxes on companies, or providing other hiring incentives, then it should have been done.
Legally and constitutionally, I'm not certain how to apporach this, but we either need to reward companies who leave manufacturing in the states instead of going off shore, or penalize companies that go offshore. Part of the reason we're so deeply in debt to China is that you can't buy a waffle iron or an hand tool made anywhere else.
I think a reasonable person can argue Obama should have shelved healthcare for a while, to spend his political capital, first, on job creation. He had a limited honeymoon period, and he mostly used it up trying to get healthcare reform. However, consider several counterpoints:
(1) He did, in fact, address jobs at the same time. He pushed through the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act, which was the biggest job program in decades. I think it should have been structured very differently and should have been much larger, but the point is that it's not like he was ignoring the jobs issue while he worked on healthcare.
(2) Healthcare reform actually makes a lot of sense in the context of a recession, just by the nature of reform. Generally, the idea behind reform of any sort is that there's a lot of effort up-front to reorganize things, but then you save a lot more down the road, once the new system is in place. That extra effort, in the case of healthcare reform, should have been expected to add some jobs in the short-term, as the health industry and government did the prep work needed to transition to the new system, and then some labor-savings in the long-term, as the new, more efficient system replaced the old one. One can argue about whether this particular healthcare reform package did that, but at least in theory times like this are perfect times for reform, because we get job creation when it's most needed, then enough savings down the road to more than pay for it.
(3) The Dems have been trying to get much-needed healthcare reform for DECADES. Putting it off, yet again, due to a Republican-created economic crisis, was a lot to ask.
As for reducing taxes on companies, I don't think that would have helped even a little. Companies weren't suffering from a shortage of capital. When you look at how low borrowing costs are right now, a big part of the reason is that there's almost no competition for capital. Companies don't care to invest, even though they've got the money, because they ALREADY have capacity that's well in excess of current demand. Hand them more money and you just plump up their bank accounts and expand their dividends or executive bonuses, you don't get the economy rolling. Only when demand picks up will the companies invest. So, I think reducing taxes on companies would have been a big mistake. However, "providing other hiring incentives" could have been useful. But, Obama already did some things along those lines:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hiring_Incentives_to_Restore_Employment_Act
As for the rest of what you wrote, I think most orthodox conservatives would object to it, since it implies a need for protectionist trade policies. The problem with those is that they invite retaliatory protectionism from other countries, which becomes a negative self-reinforcing cycle. Sure, we protect domestic industry from foreign competition, but we also shut down foreign markets for American products. And it would result in higher inflation (prices go up when there aren't cheap foreign goods available), so it's a high-risk gambit, because if wages don't keep pace, people wind up poorer in practice. It also makes the US less competitive against global competitors. For example, if Toyota and Ford are both trying to sell cars to India, and Toyota is using dirt-cheap Chinese components in their cars, while Ford can only use expensive US components (or Chinese components made expensive by tariffs), who is going to win that market?
On free trade, I'm a fairly orthodox conservative, so I get very nervous whenever anyone wants to react to an economic slowdown by raising trade barriers. It has an extremely poor record, historically:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smoot–Hawley_Tariff_Act