New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Question for Conservatives

I won't say "just reduce costs," butI think there are some approaches taht could have been taken. Just for openers, something should have been done about jobs first, instead of focusing on heatlh care while unemployment was still near 10 percent.

If that meant reducing taxes on companies, or providing other hiring incentives, then it should have been done.

Legally and constitutionally, I'm not certain how to apporach this, but we either need to reward companies who leave manufacturing in the states instead of going off shore, or penalize companies that go offshore. Part of the reason we're so deeply in debt to China is that you can't buy a waffle iron or an hand tool made anywhere else.

I think a reasonable person can argue Obama should have shelved healthcare for a while, to spend his political capital, first, on job creation. He had a limited honeymoon period, and he mostly used it up trying to get healthcare reform. However, consider several counterpoints:

(1) He did, in fact, address jobs at the same time. He pushed through the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act, which was the biggest job program in decades. I think it should have been structured very differently and should have been much larger, but the point is that it's not like he was ignoring the jobs issue while he worked on healthcare.

(2) Healthcare reform actually makes a lot of sense in the context of a recession, just by the nature of reform. Generally, the idea behind reform of any sort is that there's a lot of effort up-front to reorganize things, but then you save a lot more down the road, once the new system is in place. That extra effort, in the case of healthcare reform, should have been expected to add some jobs in the short-term, as the health industry and government did the prep work needed to transition to the new system, and then some labor-savings in the long-term, as the new, more efficient system replaced the old one. One can argue about whether this particular healthcare reform package did that, but at least in theory times like this are perfect times for reform, because we get job creation when it's most needed, then enough savings down the road to more than pay for it.

(3) The Dems have been trying to get much-needed healthcare reform for DECADES. Putting it off, yet again, due to a Republican-created economic crisis, was a lot to ask.

As for reducing taxes on companies, I don't think that would have helped even a little. Companies weren't suffering from a shortage of capital. When you look at how low borrowing costs are right now, a big part of the reason is that there's almost no competition for capital. Companies don't care to invest, even though they've got the money, because they ALREADY have capacity that's well in excess of current demand. Hand them more money and you just plump up their bank accounts and expand their dividends or executive bonuses, you don't get the economy rolling. Only when demand picks up will the companies invest. So, I think reducing taxes on companies would have been a big mistake. However, "providing other hiring incentives" could have been useful. But, Obama already did some things along those lines:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hiring_Incentives_to_Restore_Employment_Act

As for the rest of what you wrote, I think most orthodox conservatives would object to it, since it implies a need for protectionist trade policies. The problem with those is that they invite retaliatory protectionism from other countries, which becomes a negative self-reinforcing cycle. Sure, we protect domestic industry from foreign competition, but we also shut down foreign markets for American products. And it would result in higher inflation (prices go up when there aren't cheap foreign goods available), so it's a high-risk gambit, because if wages don't keep pace, people wind up poorer in practice. It also makes the US less competitive against global competitors. For example, if Toyota and Ford are both trying to sell cars to India, and Toyota is using dirt-cheap Chinese components in their cars, while Ford can only use expensive US components (or Chinese components made expensive by tariffs), who is going to win that market?

On free trade, I'm a fairly orthodox conservative, so I get very nervous whenever anyone wants to react to an economic slowdown by raising trade barriers. It has an extremely poor record, historically:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smoot–Hawley_Tariff_Act
 
Drumcollie,I'm looking for meaningful contributions. To the credit of some of your fellow posters, they've discussed actual ideas. You, on the other hand, just trotted out a pack of mostly-trivial criticisms of Obama, as well as some insanely off-topic items (the House of Representatives chooses their own Speaker; the president has no vote on the matter).
 
You've both hit on the sweet and sour point of our problem (USA). Arkady you gave a fair assessment of the Obama situation (2009) and anyone here should admit that the hole the US is in will take perhaps even a couple of decades to both recover (if possible) and evolve our job/trade/education platform.

On the spending issue, you're correct in the view that cutting it does create the unwanted ripple effect (economic) yet we are in a credit hole where adding more to our national credit card (debt) is just delaying the inevitable. I would almost advocate a zero based (budget/economic planning) exercise for our country (despite who wins in November). The government machine (bloat) is one area that needs to lose weight rapidly. The other is to put our elected officials in the same boat we are in (relative to benefits, etc). Of course that won't happen....



Would you do that by raising revenues (such that it's money we do have), or by cutting spending? And if it's the latter, which spending, in particular? And, regardless, wouldn't just about EVERY major economist predict that cutting government spending, in the midst of a recession, would actually decrease economic growth, not increase it?
 
(1) He did, in fact, address jobs at the same time. He pushed through the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act, which was the biggest job program in decades. I think it should have been structured very differently and should have been much larger, but the point is that it's not like he was ignoring the jobs issue while he worked on healthcare.
And I frankly see the ARRA as a failure. It did not achieve its stated goals in terms of jobs creation. Have you forgotten Obama saying "There weren't as many shovel ready jobs as I thought?". Making it bigger would have merely created a bigger drain on the government coffers.

(2) Healthcare reform actually makes a lot of sense in the context of a recession, just by the nature of reform. Generally, the idea behind reform of any sort is that there's a lot of effort up-front to reorganize things, but then you save a lot more down the road, once the new system is in place
.

That's certainly an arguable position, but in this case, the reformers wanted to make the reforms withou paying any costs in either a financial or political capital sense -- so they put the real spending costs AFTER the upcoming election. In so doing, the real reforms (the insurance exchanges, etc.) haven't happend in any way that reforms the still-basically-stagnant economy.

(3) The Dems have been trying to get much-needed healthcare reform for DECADES. Putting it off, yet again, due to a Republican-created economic crisis, was a lot to ask.

And conservatives (I won't say Republicans, as the issue predates the polarization of the parties -- there were once both liberal Republicans and conservative Democrats) have been fighting it for an equal number of decades. Providing health care is not, in the conservative view, a duty of the government (nor is the government authorized to provide it via the Constitution). It doesn't matter whether there was a crisis going on, nor who created it.

As for reducing taxes on companies, I don't think that would have helped even a little. Companies weren't suffering from a shortage of capital. When you look at how low borrowing costs are right now, a big part of the reason is that there's almost no competition for capital. Companies don't care to invest, even though they've got the money, because they ALREADY have capacity that's well in excess of current demand. Hand them more money and you just plump up their bank accounts and expand their dividends or executive bonuses, you don't get the economy rolling. Only when demand picks up will the companies invest. So, I think reducing taxes on companies would have been a big mistake. However, "providing other hiring incentives" could have been useful. But, Obama already did some things along those lines:

Companies hire when they need more production. They need more production when they're more profitable. A reduction in taxes (which I didn't offer as an exclusive solution) helps them be more profitable. Obama's "hiring incentives" are part of the ARRA -- which as I said failed to achieve its stated goals. It is not merely Republicans and conservatives who point this out. It was only a short time after the the ARRA that Obama came back for more money because he saw that the first round was not doing as well as predicted -- but by then Mr. "I won," had taken his shellacking and couldn't get what he asked for -- Congress wouldn't send good money after bad.

As for the rest of what you wrote, I think most orthodox conservatives would object to it, since it implies a need for protectionist trade policies.

I never claimed to be an orthodox conservative. And I can't offer a legal or constitutional way to do what I suggested -- I'm not certain there's anything that can be done, at least by government, to stop the problem of shipping jobs offshore. There's a solution to the China issue, but it involves a time machine -- we never should have granted them most-favored-nation trade status. Now, we can't revoke it because we owe them too much money.
 
Choking business regulations coupled by crushing paper shuffling is part of the problem and Obama should have asked Congress to begin tackling that problem so as to make it somewhat easier for businesses [large, medium, small, and micro] to do business. Not a free ride, you understand, but ease off here and there.

Rather than pour money into green energy projects several decades away from the technological advancements needed to make their products competitive he should have poured the funds into massive infrastructure projects with the jobs going to the lowest bidder regardless of Politically Correct notions of leveling the playing field.

He should have openly asked business leaders outside of GE what they needed or wanted done and then passed that along to Congress as well.

Obama played ideologically based leftwing politics with the economy and the nation's financial structure and that's a major reason why he has failed as a president.

I think you can make a good case that we're living in the least government-regulated era in the last three quarters of a century. The list of major New Deal-era laws that have been eliminated or gutted is long (Glass-Steagal, PUHCA), and the last three decades have been a steady march of major industry deregulation (airlines, telecoms, energy, finance). I can't think of any major deregulation in that time that has been reversed, and there have been no comparably large instances of new regulation imposed in that time. There have been somewhat smaller pieces of major new regulation to respond to particular market failings (Sarbanes Oxley, to respond to the Enron-era bankruptcies and scandals, and more recently Dodd-Frank to respond to the financial meltdown), but none of that imposes anywhere near as much constriction on the economy as has been cleared away through recent decades of deregulation. So, I don't see that it could have had any major role in slowing this recovery.

Regardless, aren't you worried that taking down even more regulation will encourage exactly the kinds of behavior we just suffered from? That trading in exotic financial instruments, like credit default swaps and collateralized debt obligations, operated in a hole in the regulatory framework, creating a shadow banking system, and it was the collapse of that banking system that brought down the global economy. If we further expand that hold in our regulatory protections, shouldn't we expect even more problems in the future? I mean, it's not like the regulations were just imposed by perverse bureaucrats with too much time on their hands. They were imposed in response to specific problems.... many of which had led to the Great Depression. Do we want to go back to an era of bank-runs and soup lines?

I agree with the idea of spending money on massive infrastructure projects, which are going to be a lot more labor intensive (and thus job-creating) than boutique investments in green energy, even if that does pay dividends down the line. I also am sympathetic to removing the normal P.C. government rules, for the duration of the crisis, to get the lowest bidders and best people and companies in place, without regard to whether they're women, minorities, veterans, etc. And certainly every effort should be made to get around the pork-barrel tendency for funds to flow to mostly small states with over-representation in Congress, rather than to wherever they'll have the most economic bang for their buck. No "bridges to nowhere" at a time like this. But, to be fair to Obama, how much can he really do about that, other than make an occasional veto? And vetoes are of questionable use at a time when ANY spending is better than no spending, since the economy needs government picking up the slack until private sector demand returns.

As for the idea that he should have asked business leaders outside of GE what they needed or wanted done, he did. This is a guy with major financial players throughout his administration (sometimes it seems like the Goldman Sachs administration), and with friendly ties to both Silicon Valley and Detroit.

I don't have a clue, by the way, about what "ideologically based leftwing politics" you're talking about. From my perspective (and according to the Voteview mathematical analysis), he's been a center-left politician... less left-wing than Clinton, and not particularly ideological (as evidenced, for example, with his adopting a right-wing healthcare reform -- the one designed by the conservative Heritage Foundation and first implemented by Mitt Romney).
 
The government machine (bloat) is one area that needs to lose weight rapidly. The other is to put our elected officials in the same boat we are in (relative to benefits, etc). Of course that won't happen....

I'd agree that we need to decrease bloat, but it seems the Republicans are never interested at addressing the most bloated area of the budget. The single-largest area of discretionary spending is defense. We spend more than six times as much as the next-closest country, and more than twice what all our potential adversaries combined spend. Has there ever been a country in the whole history of the world that spent as much, relative to its contemporaries, as we do? Ever? And it's been a long time since the Pentagon saw any serious belt tightening (the last really major cuts were after the Vietnam War). If you want to find significant bloat, that's where to look. In a $700 billion military budget, you'll find lots and lots of waste. Instead, it seems like the Republicans want to nickel-and-dime small programs to death, many with negative returns (cut disease prevention today, pay even more tomorrow), and then they wonder why they never seem to make any serious progress against overall spending levels.

As for putting elected officials in the same boat with us, in terms of benefits, it's certainly a very appealing idea to me emotionally. But here's the potential problem. To get really high-quality people to run for office, you need to provide decent benefits, because those people can get phenomenal benefits outside of government (as lawyers, business execs, professors, etc.) Sure, there would be some patriotic folks who'd subject their families to relatively low pay, lousy insurance, and poor retirement benefits, for the opportunity to serve the country, but you're certainly making the alternatives look a lot more tempting to them. And so, if you clamp down too much on elected officials, in terms of pay and benefits, you'll find that more and more you're getting only the kind of official for whom pay and benefits are immaterial. There are two main groups that fall under that category: (1) the super-rich folks for whom that compensation is a trifle, anyway, and (2) the corrupt people who are looking to get their real money by selling political favors, or to go through the revolving door to become a lobbyist and get rich trading on their political connections. The second group is terrible for our country, and the first group would be terrible if we didn't also have people with a closer grasp of the lives and challenges of middle-class Americans.
 
Let's be very straightforward for a moment. Do you really believe we have the best (high quality) people running for office from any party?

I really don't think so. Our congress is completely stagnated with people who definitely don't represent the interests of their constituents and seem to be focused on whoever their backroom sponsors are and padding their own pockets and egos.

Term limits... term limits and line item veto. For all the griping about Obama, if he or any president hopes to be successful, the stagnation and bloat hiding at capital hill (congress) needs to be addressed.

Now.. back to my mocha (starbucks). I'm addicted.

I'd agree that we need to decrease bloat, but it seems the Republicans are never interested at addressing the most bloated area of the budget. The single-largest area of discretionary spending is defense. We spend more than six times as much as the next-closest country, and more than twice what all our potential adversaries combined spend. Has there ever been a country in the whole history of the world that spent as much, relative to its contemporaries, as we do? Ever? And it's been a long time since the Pentagon saw any serious belt tightening (the last really major cuts were after the Vietnam War). If you want to find significant bloat, that's where to look. In a $700 billion military budget, you'll find lots and lots of waste. Instead, it seems like the Republicans want to nickel-and-dime small programs to death, many with negative returns (cut disease prevention today, pay even more tomorrow), and then they wonder why they never seem to make any serious progress against overall spending levels.

As for putting elected officials in the same boat with us, in terms of benefits, it's certainly a very appealing idea to me emotionally. But here's the potential problem. To get really high-quality people to run for office, you need to provide decent benefits, because those people can get phenomenal benefits outside of government (as lawyers, business execs, professors, etc.) Sure, there would be some patriotic folks who'd subject their families to relatively low pay, lousy insurance, and poor retirement benefits, for the opportunity to serve the country, but you're certainly making the alternatives look a lot more tempting to them. And so, if you clamp down too much on elected officials, in terms of pay and benefits, you'll find that more and more you're getting only the kind of official for whom pay and benefits are immaterial. There are two main groups that fall under that category: (1) the super-rich folks for whom that compensation is a trifle, anyway, and (2) the corrupt people who are looking to get their real money by selling political favors, or to go through the revolving door to become a lobbyist and get rich trading on their political connections. The second group is terrible for our country, and the first group would be terrible if we didn't also have people with a closer grasp of the lives and challenges of middle-class Americans.
 
Mr. Arkady,

Two big things. The first would have been instead of ram rodding though the partisan, one sided Health Care bill, he should have made improving the economy his first order of business. Like it or not, one thihg is clear about it. In a bad economy, business are unwilling to take on additional risk. In essence, he was forcing business to back off and not hire.

The second would have been to negotiate and work with the other political party. By telling them that "elections have consequences" and refusing to accept any input from them when he controlled both houses of congress, he was doomed to turnabout is fair play when he envitably lost the house by a huge majority.
 
Is there anybody on the Right who actually expects a "President Romney" to make massive spending cuts?

Anybody????
 
Is there anybody on the Right who actually expects a "President Romney" to make massive spending cuts?

Anybody????

LeRoy: I am not on the Right, but I think Rmoney and Ryan actually WOULD make massive spending cuts. To education, to infrastructure, to scientific research, to NASA, to food stamps, to Medicaid, and you could kiss Planned Parenthood and Public Broadcasting goodbye. They would need to do all that, to fund their desired massive increase in defense spending.

And America would become a 'failed state'. And a very dangerous one, at that.
 
Mr. Arkady,

Two big things. The first would have been instead of ram rodding though the partisan, one sided Health Care bill, he should have made improving the economy his first order of business. Like it or not, one thihg is clear about it. In a bad economy, business are unwilling to take on additional risk. In essence, he was forcing business to back off and not hire.

The second would have been to negotiate and work with the other political party. By telling them that "elections have consequences" and refusing to accept any input from them when he controlled both houses of congress, he was doomed to turnabout is fair play when he envitably lost the house by a huge majority.

LeRoy: So there's NO connection between health care and the economy?!? They're, like, TOTALLY unrelated???

Mr. Obama certainly tried negotiating with the other party. Their response was "It's our way or the highway" and "Our number one priority is to ensure that you are a one-term President". Not very good negotiating positions. To put it mildly.
 
[Shrug] You are a true believer and I'm not going to try and convince you that your perspective is wrong. You asked and I told you.

So let's switch it around and go with it your way. Obama is an ideal president despite his zero meaningful amount of national level experience before becoming president and no other president could possibly have done any better in that office under these circumstances. He must be doing so badly now in polling numbers just because citizens are fickle creatures.
 
We should have had government get out of the way and let the economy heal. The problem wasn't a systemic problem with the economy, but the bursting of a housing bubble that was decades in the making. Obama took advantage of the situation to impose regulations that are making it hard for business to pull themselves back on track.

Obama has taken the "Catholic Nun with a large ruler" mentality to the economy, and it's hard to run an economy that way.
 
Would you do that by raising revenues (such that it's money we do have), or by cutting spending? And if it's the latter, which spending, in particular? And, regardless, wouldn't just about EVERY major economist predict that cutting government spending, in the midst of a recession, would actually decrease economic growth, not increase it?

wow what planet are you on? I know lefty is a sopend junkie but that has to stop its likean unhealthy disease

57. Doctor shortages created by Obamacare

58. Sky rocketing Healthcare

59, Democratic tax more solution to debt rather thn curb spending

60. calling your Women "sluts" and not being man enough to say it is wrong.

61. Speaking ill of Isreal

62. Not including God in DNC platform and saying it wasnt taken out then ammending platform to add god to platform

63. Not recocognizing Jerusalem as capital of Israel and lying about this and ammending platform afterwards

64. asking for four more years of same...Obama not solving problems

65. David Weiner

66. Wu

67. Bankrupt California cities

68. Higher tax rates in Democrat states

69. Liberal media bias

70. Island tipping over

71. Sheila Jackson Lee

72. Safe haven cities for immigrants

73. extending bush tax cuts while calling them wrong

74. the coming housing bubble...part deaux

75. Bill Maher

76. Rachel Maddow increasing viewership 100 percent...I watched errr lefty not having top 10 rated news show

77. Nightsticks at Philadelphia polling station

78. Losing credit rating

79. Limiting sizeof cola drinks in NYC

80. Not getting govt hands off my body

81. Not get Lech Walesa polish labour movement leader to support Obama..instead Romney

82. Not being honest about medicare and the money taken from it

83. Voting against Social security individual accounts rather leaving SS in a general fund.

84. Not having a democrat congressional budget plan

85. failing to support Haiti on a continuos basis

86. No creating oil independence using shale and other technology

87. hating women for being conservative

88. hating women for being white and conservative

89. saying FACTS MATTER then not giving all facts or real facts

90. The fairness doctrine

91. Discriminating against people,...classism

92. waiting over a month to be outraged over Trayvon Martin case

93. Doctoring 911 call in Trayvon Martin case

94. Editing video in Martin case

95. Promising not to get it done in one year or one term......Chicago acceptance speech

96. swearing in ceremony problems

97. Obama asking reporter to not use definition of word in interview

98. Not Acknowledging southern democrats for what they were democrats

99. Having an accused rapist as Keynote speaker during the Democrat created "Republican War on Women"

100. Democrat rants on Tea Party

101. Having signs made up and showing up at Tea party rallies to make people look like racist.
 
Let's be very straightforward for a moment. Do you really believe we have the best (high quality) people running for office from any party?

I really don't think so. Our congress is completely stagnated with people who definitely don't represent the interests of their constituents and seem to be focused on whoever their backroom sponsors are and padding their own pockets and egos.

Term limits... term limits and line item veto. For all the griping about Obama, if he or any president hopes to be successful, the stagnation and bloat hiding at capital hill (congress) needs to be addressed.

Now.. back to my mocha (starbucks). I'm addicted.

No, I don't think we have the best people. I just think we might have worse people if we made government employment less attractive to non-corrupt middle-class people (those for whom salary and benefits are meaningful considerations).

Term limits could conceivably create a similar set of issues. If you can be a member of Congress for much of your working life, then hopefully your mind is mostly on your legacy -- doing enough good for the country that you'll be remembered well in history, and esteemed among those whose opinions you value. Or, barring that, your focus will at least be on serving your constituents well enough that you get to keep your job. But if you know for sure you can only be a member of Congress very briefly, no matter how well you serve your constituents, there's a risk that your real focus will be on where you're going to find your next paycheck when you reach your term limit. Then who you'll really be serving are your potential future employers. If I have a choice of someone to keep an eye on the banks, for example, I'd rather have someone who wants to keep voters in his district happy than someone who wants to make a few banking CEOs happy so they give him the golden parachute when term limits push him out of the plane.

As for the line item veto, I recently explained why I thought that was a bad idea, so I won't repeat that here unless you missed it.
 
Back
Top