New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Question for Conservatives

I have never said that they had no business problems. I said that it is lame to blame all their business problems on Obama and take no personal responsibility. It is equally lame for you to tell me what I believe as you did a couple of posts above. You do not have a clue what I "believe."

No real business person blames their fortunes on someone else, they just go with the flow. In reality, Obama still has no experience in business even after almost four years as POTUS. Most of his time is spent campaigning as he is merely a mouth piece for the Democratic Party; It is the people he surrounded himself with along with the likes of Pelosi that have run the Country, he has no ideas of his own, which why he is such an incompetent leader, why he could not work with Republicans. His energy policies as well as picking industries to give bailouts to have had a negative affect. Even those things he touts, like GM are a failure as the company would be better off today had he not interceded.
 
I'm not too sure old Juan Trippe at Pan Am didn't have just a wee bit to do with, after all Howard was all hot and heavy into the Lockheed Connie, and those Boeing jets were faster and just a wee bit more capacious.

On that note, isn't it a shame there is only one commercial airplane company left, Boeing. At one time there were 3 majors in the Market Douglas, Lockheed and Boeing. Today Lockheed is strictly military, and you don't see the Douglas name out there, it has been subsumed by Boeing and is now strictly military as well.


So much for the aircraft industry.

Tai Pan

True of many industries, ever ask yourself why?
 
I'm not too sure old Juan Trippe at Pan Am didn't have just a wee bit to do with, after all Howard was all hot and heavy into the Lockheed Connie, and those Boeing jets were faster and just a wee bit more capacious.

Well there was an existant commercial air travel industry, but it was high end and Boeing's prior attempt to build a passenger longhaul aircraft was a financial loss. So Boeing was hesitant to build the 707. And it was high marginal tax rates that pushed it over the edge - because it was more advantageous to the large shareholders to have their stock appreciate in value and borrow agains those assets, than to take cash out in the form of dividends.

Yes as with all real world examples there are other factors in play, but the marginal tax rate adding a reinvestment push is a real and measurable one.
 
True of many industries, ever ask yourself why?

In the aviation sector, we simply had too much output capacity after WWII, for both light aircraft and major commercial aircraft. Some of these companies had to die on the vine, simply because the market wasn't there to support Lockheed, Douglas, McDonnell (used to be separate from Douglas), Republic, Convair, Chance Vaught, North American, etcetera all doing the same thing at the same time. Even the British were in the game with the DeHavilland Comet (arguably the most beautiful commercial passenger aircraft ever built, despite its early disasters). There was bound to be both losses and consolidations.

And that was before foreign innovation, vis Airbus, began having a big impact on the market. As a bit of an aviation bug, I don't willingly fly on Airbus products -- this is not because of a specific "buy U.S." loyalty, but because of Airbus' ongoing reputation for dropping parts onto city streets, disappearing over oceans, etc. (I felt the same way about the Lockheed L-1011).
 
Taipan wrote: I'm not too sure old Juan Trippe at Pan Am didn't have just a wee bit to do with, after all Howard was all hot and heavy into the Lockheed Connie, and those Boeing jets were faster and just a wee bit more capacious.

All well and good, but Trippe was not the first airline owner to go "all-jet." That was Hughes, or at least, Hughes' airline, TWA, which went to all jet service in 1967. It's a matter of debate if Hughes was still in operational control of the airline at that time, or if his spiral into his mental illness had taken over completely -- his last public photo for the airline was in 1958 or '59.
 
You keep forgetting to add the term NEW to Obama's claims and that was the gist of CNN busting Obama's endless lies.
Your CNN link does not "bust up lies" of any sort. It adds the broader GOP Talking points but it doesn't demonstrate any lies.

Obama always says new jobs, but those cannot be new jobs when the total only brings the nation up 400,000 in total over the number of jobs around in 2008
I see - so we did not go through 6 mo period of losing GDP at the rate of 9% Per annum
And we did not go through an 25+ month period Starting in 2007 of losing jobs at a rate that peaked at 820,000 jobs lost per month as Obama took office..

These after all were not jobs lost... just "jobs on hiatus".... and all those folks who used to work in the construction industries have been getting their OLD JOBS back... meanwhile in 2007 the fracking boom in PA and WY and NDak were all going strong...


Sorry no. You are playing numbers games that are fundamentally dishonest. It is borderline a lie to pretend that Obama's metric for "new jobs" is the threshold BEFORE the crash..
 
Nope, it has to do with your crazy f**king president who thinks he can buy the election by stealing money from the producers and giving it away to people who vote for him.
Ps: Are you Peter Pan's brother?

Gee Jack ! You're getting as good as your candidate & his partner in chaos. Just who are these producers from whom the President is stealing money ? Corporate Profits are at record highs, corporate income tax at record lows. The top 1% of the nation is making more money and paying less in taxes than they have for more than 50 years. I'm sorry Jack, until you can back it with facts, you don't have a case. Frankly I haven't seen any posters in the Post Office with Obama's picture on them saying "WANTED FOR ARMED ROBBERY", but there should be some for Romney saying "WANTED FOR ATTEMPTED RAPE & ROBBERY OF THE MIDDLE CLASS"

Seriously Jack, I have some other posts this morning about Moses Mitt, a man so fixed in his own mind that in 48 hours he did a complete 360 on Health care, but I will save them for Republican who can do more by way of an answer than jump up and down and make baseless accusations - Thinkers as Gramps used to call them.


Tai Pan
 
Corporate Profits are at record highs, corporate income tax at record lows. The top 1% of the nation is making more money and paying less in taxes than they have for more than 50 years.
Did you see the link I gave elsewhere in this thread just this AM where Canada saw a DROP in corporate reinvestment rates when it reduced corporate tax rates?
 
I see - so we did not go through 6 mo period of losing GDP at the rate of 9% Per annum And we did not go through an 25+ month period Starting in 2007 of losing jobs at a rate that peaked at 820,000 jobs lost per month as Obama took office..
\

Degs, I'm sorry, but Cicero has a point. If a company laid off 100 workers after the crash in 2008, and has now re-hired 25 of them, those are not 25 "new" jobs, and they do not reflect "job growth" over the baseline -- as that baseline would be the 100 jobs that existed prior to the crash...


Sorry no. You are playing numbers games that are fundamentally dishonest. It is borderline a lie to pretend that Obama's metric for "new jobs" is the threshold BEFORE the crash..

That is precisely the baseline for job creation, much less job growth. We haven't experienced the latter, either, as jobs are not being created sufficient to match the number of new employees entering the workforce.
 
\

Degs, I'm sorry, but Cicero has a point. If a company laid off 100 workers after the crash in 2008, and has now re-hired 25 of them, those are not 25 "new" jobs,
How not? Those jobs NO LONGER EXISTED after the crash of 2008. Had no stimulus been done, they would not exist today.

Sorry no. You are playing numbers games that are fundamentally dishonest. It is borderline a lie to pretend that Obama's metric for "new jobs" is the threshold BEFORE the crash..
That is precisely the baseline for job creation, much less job growth.

No its not. That's the baseline for FULL RECOVERY... that's not the baseline for growth. Growth is a positive first derivative of the employment data curve over time. Nothing more, nothing less. Redefining "growth" is dishonest.

Consider this. A smart company prior to the crash would have held cash and not invested. And then laid off jobs as the crash occurred. at the BOTTOM of the crash it would be looking to see whether or not to continue to hold cash and lay off, or to start investing and generating a positive Return on Investment.

When an investor looks at a company to see if it is "growing" - they don't look at what the companies size once was, they look at the CURRENT and immediately recent DELTA in income over time [sup]dRevenue[/sup]/[sub]dt[/sub] and if the company has positive "Revenue Growth" the company is growing. Pitney Bowes PEAKED in 1999 http://finance.yahoo.com/echarts?s=...on;ohlcvalues=0;logscale=off;source=undefined; but that doesn't change that from 2003-2005 it also grew, even though it was at half of its peak 1999 valuation.

"GROW" and "INCREASE" and "CREATE" are RELATIVE words, not absolutes. and as a wordsmith you know better. But once again your BELIEFS are in conflict with what you know factually so you go with the beliefs.
 
Federal Spending on Non-Military expenditures has a Fiscal Multiplier of between 1.5 and 2.5 (depending on the spending and the state of the economy).
Howso?

What do you mean "how so"?

This is empirically measured data. and Military expenditures have Fiscal Multipliers of 0.28 - 1.0 (0.28 is new weapons system dev, 1.0 is staffing salaries). with an Average FM of 0.4-0.5 according to the conservative economists Barro and Redlick look it up http://www.economics.harvard.edu/faculty/barro/files/Barro+Redlick+paper+0210.pdf

This isn't anything new. This is fundamental economic analysis. Its how corporations make investment decisions. Tens of Trillions of dollars are invested and spent based on this sort of analysis. Its not anything new or controversial. Its only hired hacks in CATO, Hoover etc. that weasel word their way around this information.
 
How not? Those jobs NO LONGER EXISTED after the crash of 2008. Had no stimulus been done, they would not exist today.

The jobs may not have been filled -- that is different from saying they didn't exist. Being laid off is not the same thing as being fired.



No its not. That's the baseline for FULL RECOVERY... that's not the baseline for growth. Growth is a positive first derivative of the employment data curve over time. Nothing more, nothing less. Redefining "growth" is dishonest.

"New jobs," are what's created after all the pre-existing jobs have been filled. In other words, full recovery precedes creating new jobs.

Consider this. A smart company prior to the crash would have held cash and not invested. And then laid off jobs as the crash occurred. at the BOTTOM of the crash it would be looking to see whether or not to continue to hold cash and lay off, or to start investing and generating a positive Return on Investment.

Consider this, when that company laid off employees, it did not reduce the number of jobs. Any re-hires are not going into new positions, but re-filling pre-existing positions.
When an investor looks at a company to see if it is "growing" - they don't look at what the companies size once was, they look at the CURRENT and immediately recent DELTA in income over time [sup]dRevenue[/sup]/[sub]dt[/sub] and if the company has positive "Revenue Growth" the company is growing. Pitney Bowes PEAKED in 1999 http://finance.yahoo.com/echarts?s=...on;ohlcvalues=0;logscale=off;source=undefined; but that doesn't change that from 2003-2005 it also grew, even though it was at half of its peak 1999 valuation.

But the delta in the example doesn't reflect a company's growth, but a partial recovery toward the level it was at when it laid off employees. Growth is another thing.

"GROW" and "INCREASE" and "CREATE" are RELATIVE words, not absolutes. and as a wordsmith you know better. But once again your BELIEFS are in conflict with what you know factually so you go with the beliefs.

If a company cuts 100 jobs and re-fills 25 of them, it is not experiencing an increase in jobs, Degs. It has experienced a decrease of 75 jobs. No "new" jobs have been created, but some of the old ones have been filled. The logic you're using is the logic of someone who says they saved $5 by buying shoes for $50 when they were on a $5 off sale. No, that person has not "saved" five dollars -- they've spent $50. The company has not created 25 new jobs, it's lost 75.
 
Dave,

We are two business people with different perspectives. I agree that business people go with the flow. Successful business people are successful whoever the President is. But I disagree with your implication that Republicans generally or Romney specifically understand the public policy required to support economic growth better than Democrats generally or Obama specifically do. As to working with Republicans, it takes two to tango. In my opinion, the Republicans were never interested in compromise or bi-partisanship. Their primary purpose was to obstruct and undermine. That would continue if Romney were elected. Republicans are interested in imposing a radical Republican agenda on the nation and would demand unconditional surrender from all who disagree with them. My belief is that the Republican agenda would benefit only a narrow group at the top and be a blueprint for disaster for the middle class. It would also create environmental havoc, destroy the social safety net, and dismantle the ability for collective bargaining (and I think that collective bargaining helps keep business people honest and generally supports healthy economic growth.) Though I am a business person (and I can do fine in any environment), I do care about things like the environment and the social safety net. I do charitable work but I think that the government has an important role to play. I do not think that the private market is set up to address some issues. I think that Obama's energy policy is superior to the Republican "fossil fuel" dependent policies and I disagree about GM. The fact is that GM is a success and you guys cannot demonstrate that your solution would be even better.

So, you are entitled to your opinion. And I acknowledge your experience as a business person. We both have relevant points to make grounded in our business experience. My view remains that reelecting Obama will be better for the economy and the country over the next four years. I don't expect my perspective to change. I don't expect yours to change either. (I am also very competitive and I love to be on the winning team.)


No real business person blames their fortunes on someone else, they just go with the flow. In reality, Obama still has no experience in business even after almost four years as POTUS. Most of his time is spent campaigning as he is merely a mouth piece for the Democratic Party; It is the people he surrounded himself with along with the likes of Pelosi that have run the Country, he has no ideas of his own, which why he is such an incompetent leader, why he could not work with Republicans. His energy policies as well as picking industries to give bailouts to have had a negative affect. Even those things he touts, like GM are a failure as the company would be better off today had he not interceded.
 
. But I disagree with your implication that Republicans generally or Romney specifically understand the public policy required to support economic growth better than Democrats generally or Obama specifically do

Actually the evidence is specifically to the contrary. As I pointed out with a link to Canada's experiences with cutting Corporate taxes this actually leads to a REDUCTION in corporate reinvestment and an INCREASE in profit taking. Now from a Businesman's perspective, lower corporate taxes are good because it means it is easier for you to show a larger profit. But a Businessman's perspective is limited to THEIR OWN COMPANY and not optimizing the economy as a whole.

Romney not only does not have much of this broader perspective - but where he did, he showed a BAD TRACK RECORD. He would not have been re-elected as Governor of MA precisely because he made things WORSE economically.

Furthermore economics is one of those interesting realms where what makes sense at the individual level, is often adverse at the macro level. Consider retained earnings. It makes sense for companies in downturns to hoard cash and not invest until positive ROIs are guaranteed. But at a macro level this is BAD FOR THE ECONOMY and also in the longer term bad for the individual company since the longer the downturn the less long term profits and the higher the risk of bankruptcy.

Romney has demonstrated that he simply does not understand this distinction.


. As to working with Republicans, it takes two to tango. In my opinion, the Republicans were never interested in compromise or bi-partisanship. Their primary purpose was to obstruct and undermine.
Its more than just "opinion". IN the midst of the greates fiscal crash in human history, Mitch McConnel - the leader of the GOP Senate Minority - openly stated that the number one priority of the GOP in the senate was..
NOT to help turn the economy around
NOT to increase job growth
NOT to do what is good for the nation

BUT simply to make the first African American President "A One Term President".


No one in that situation could have worked with the Reublicans. At all.
 
Dave,

We are two business people with different perspectives. I agree that business people go with the flow. Successful business people are successful whoever the President is. But I disagree with your implication that Republicans generally or Romney specifically understand the public policy required to support economic growth better than Democrats generally or Obama specifically do. As to working with Republicans, it takes two to tango. In my opinion, the Republicans were never interested in compromise or bi-partisanship. Their primary purpose was to obstruct and undermine. That would continue if Romney were elected. Republicans are interested in imposing a radical Republican agenda on the nation and would demand unconditional surrender from all who disagree with them. My belief is that the Republican agenda would benefit only a narrow group at the top and be a blueprint for disaster for the middle class. It would also create environmental havoc, destroy the social safety net, and dismantle the ability for collective bargaining (and I think that collective bargaining helps keep business people honest and generally supports healthy economic growth.) Though I am a business person (and I can do fine in any environment), I do care about things like the environment and the social safety net. I do charitable work but I think that the government has an important role to play. I do not think that the private market is set up to address some issues. I think that Obama's energy policy is superior to the Republican "fossil fuel" dependent policies and I disagree about GM. The fact is that GM is a success and you guys cannot demonstrate that your solution would be even better.

So, you are entitled to your opinion. And I acknowledge your experience as a business person. We both have relevant points to make grounded in our business experience. My view remains that reelecting Obama will be better for the economy and the country over the next four years. I don't expect my perspective to change. I don't expect yours to change either. (I am also very competitive and I love to be on the winning team.)

We can agree to disagree. When speaking of an individual who understands what it takes to spur economic growth, no one has performed that specific function yet. There has been a lot of experimentation with both good and poor results, which still is unknown due to the situation at that time and the general perception of society.

As business people, we both know that it is the individuals of our country that will eventually pull us out of this economic decline and not the government. As we speak right now such persons are working and designing ways to overcome hurdles and develop ways to prosper. Regulations make it more difficult to do that, regulations are the unfair advantage that mega corporations use against the newcomer or small business person because they can afford it.

When we talk of social nets and the environment, we all want to take care of those areas as we should. When we leave it to government it becomes a political football and what the government touches becomes inefficient. We need a fine balance of government and the private sector, not one way or the other. When that balance is lost, when politics gets involved we see teachers in Chicago, the highest paid in the nation, go on strike to get even more than a mere $80,000 per year plus unbelievable benefits and pensions. something you probably could not give your own employees. Now they are in a battle with their own when their own understands it is not economically feasible to sustain the direction they want to go. Yet we have not heard a word from our President on this matter, he did have a lot to say about Wisconsin.
 
We can agree to disagree. When speaking of an individual who understands what it takes to spur economic growth, no one has performed that specific function yet. There has been a lot of experimentation with both good and poor results, which still is unknown due to the situation at that time and the general perception of society.
That's simply not true... the Jobs REcovery act worked. We needed a second one. The GOP filbustered any attempt to pass one precisely because it would have worked and then the GOP would have had nothing to run on against Obama.

As business people, we both know that it is the individuals of our country that will eventually pull us out of this economic decline and not the government.
No we do not. While the majority of the economic activity is indivudual non-governmental transactions, that's not the same as what the driving force for the economic TRENDS are. In a Liquidity/Demand Trap which is what we are in now - eventually you CAN crawl out of it without government intervention. Its how the economy operated through about 1890. The problem is that this approach increases the duration of the recovery BY A FACTOR OF EIGHT on average (and yes this is not an "average" crash). And it makes for a much much much more fragile recovery.

And no it is not "regulations" that make this more difficult. Not when the "regulatory burden" (remember that contract enforcement and private property protections are PART of "regulations") in total adds up to less than 11% of GDP.

When we leave it to government it becomes a political football and what the government touches becomes inefficient.
And this simply is not true. For example. the Fiscal Multiplier (economic efficiency) of private sector infrastructure construction is 1.5.. and the FM for Public sector infrastructure construction IS ALSO 1.5... That's The Government "touching" something and being EQUALLY EFFICIENT.


[quiote] When that balance is lost, when politics gets involved we see teachers in Chicago, the highest paid in the nation, go on strike to get even more than a mere $80,000 per year plus unbelievable benefits and pensions. [/quote]
Hmm how much would it cost you to hire an employee with the following resume:

  • Masters degree or better
  • 15+ years industry experience
  • Independent worker
  • Self-starter, works well in ambiguous circumstances
  • Strong communications skills
  • strong conflict negotiator
  • consistently delivers under-budget
  • independently takes responsibility to take work home as necessary

I suspect it would cost you more than $80k.
 
  • Masters degree or better
  • 15+ years industry experience
  • Independent worker
  • Self-starter, works well in ambiguous circumstances
  • Strong communications skills
  • strong conflict negotiator
  • consistently delivers under-budget
  • independently takes responsibility to take work home as necessary

I suspect it would cost you more than $80k.

Good point. That basically describes me, except I have one extra year of schooling, and one fewer year of industry experience. With me, it would cost you around twice that, base, plus the possibility of an annual bonus in the 30% range, along with benefits that are roughly in the same ballpark as the teacher get. However, I'd be willing to give up the bonus entirely to have more free time in the summer.

Anyway, in the legal field it's hard to even get someone right out of law school for that kind of money, much less someone with 15 years of experience. People with advanced degrees and strong communication skills are expensive.
 
  • Masters degree or better
  • 15+ years industry experience
  • Independent worker
  • Self-starter, works well in ambiguous circumstances
  • Strong communications skills
  • strong conflict negotiator
  • consistently delivers under-budget
  • independently takes responsibility to take work home as necessary

I suspect it would cost you more than $80k.

To be fair, I'm sure you get get people cheaper. But, ultimately, you get what you pay for. These aren't draftees. They have choices. If you worsen the deal for them, you'll get worse quality people willing to fill those roles. If you better the deal for them, you'll get better quality people. People who think teachers currently get paid too much are basically people who think that our current teachers are too high in quality -- that education of our young people is an area where we can afford to cut some more corners.
 
Back
Top