New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Question for Conservatives

Tai Pan

ps: I will write no more on this thread. It has deteriorated into ignorant pronouncements, followed by reasoned responses that have no more chance of making a dent in antediluvian thinking than an iron nail has of surviving a sulfuric acid bath.

Yours being the very last ignorant pronouncement. Congrats, you win a prize.
 
What does any of that have to do with the fiscal multiplier you were claiming in the thread I questioned. You have yet to explain how the worth of a dollar in the public sector is twice what it is in the private sector.

Apparently this magic is based entirely on faith, since there isn't a liberal yet who can explain it, even though many make the claim.
 
Where does Dominoes claim that taking 5 million out of their coffers doesn't affect any of these things.

A person of average intelligence would see 5 million taking out of a company and think "Hmmm, there's 5 million they can't use for Dominoes' stuff". Apparently liberals aren't quite that with it.
 
The ONLY difference is that if you are fired, it is "for cause" and you cannot collect unemployment. If you are laid off, the job ceases to exist. It is not counted as "unfilled positions".

Not the only difference at all. In a layoff, the company clearly is temporarily reducing capacity because of financial or market reasons. In a mass firing, the reduction is either a permanent reduction in capacity, or the company is going out of business entirely. You can draw unemployment in both instances, but you may have a job to return to in the former one.


No that's a redefinition. a job is a "new job" if it was not previously an "unfilled position". a "new job" is one in which there was no employment opportunity in the period immediately preceding the person being hired into it.

And mostly what we've seen as a result of the stimulus was people returning to unfilled positions -- not a creation of new jobs. A new job is one that didn't exist before.

That's simply newspeak. Because using that logic, when someone gets laid off, the "number of unfilled jobs" would increase. AND IT DOES NOT. Sorry wrong.

Not "newspeak" at all. A company that used to need 100 assemblers, facing the 2008 crash, cuts back to 25. It retains the "job slots" but they are unfilled until times improve. People coming into those jobs are not going into new jobs and no new jobs have been created -- unfilled positions are merely being filled.


yes it does. For the purposes of calculating ROI, Profits, Growth. For the purposes of invesstors investing capital, for banks lending capital it qualifies as growth. You are simply engaged in politically expedient redefinition. IOW you are making Sh!t up that has no actual economic basis.

I really don't care what investors do, but you're wrong. A company that has had two years of losses and then has six months of improved sales has not experienced growth.

but if a company cuts 100 jobs... it is now a smaller company. It has a smaller workforce that perhaps operates more efficiently but odds are it produces less.

No, Degs, the company that has done a layoff has not made itself a smaller company. It has a smaller workforce, temporarily, but is the same size company and when it fills those jobs, it is not experiencing "growth."
At SOME LATER POINT IN TIME.. when the company starts to grow. IT INCREASES THE NUMBER OF JOBS IT HAS... and it does so by hiring NEW EMPLOYEES.

When you get called back from a layoff, your employer isn't growing. This is especially true if the number of people recalled is smaller than the amount originally employed.

Someone who has spent $50 instead of $55 HAS SPENT LESS. The retailer EARNED LESS.

But the person who has spent $50 has not spent LESS Degs. The person who has spent $50 has spent $50. The person had the option of spending zero. The person has only spent less if the money was going to be spent on the same product, regardless of price.
 
Yours being the very last ignorant pronouncement. Congrats, you win a prize.

No one, however, has the art of "ignorant pronouncements" as perfected as you do Jack. Reply to my post with yet, another example of a masterful expression of your art that might even top your other posts in this thread.
 
That some representatives have ignored their responsibility to represent that people that elected them is immaterial.
except that in the VAST MAJORITY of cases, representatives have made decisions and choices based on THEIR DELIBRATIONS and not just their proxy voting for PART of their constituency.

So you're saying they're not supposed to represent their constituents.


No. They are supposed to represent the Best Interests of the constituency
.

I disagree, and I doubt you can find your belief as expressed in this statement codified anywhere. The entire point of having a representative democracy is that people of differing viewpoints can elect people who share their viewpoints, thereby advancing their views. If the elected official can ignore the constituency and simply willy-nilly do whatever he or she thinks is in their best interests, then there is on representation of the constituency.
 
Here you go again Jack........ criticizing that of which you have no knowledge and less understanding.

I did go to private school, then public college, thence private university. The people who educated me were scholars, not just teachers. They loved learning and knowledge for its own sake and imparted the same to me and most of my friends who were similarly educated. A gifted educator is a precious gem, who deserves fair pay and the respect to his/her accomplishments. Some of these people spoke multiple languages, had traveled all over the work, and had accomplished jobs in the private or governmental sector as well. I remember one History professor, who was US Embassy Attache in Franco's Spain, prior to and during World War II. He lived diplomacy on the front lines during that period of time. When he spoke of that period, it wasn't someone who learned about it in books, he was actually there. He experienced it first hand. You don't get that kind of an opportunity every day. How about studying under a professor like Stephen Ambrose? Founder of the D-Day museum and author of a number of books including a biography of Eisenhower that is still recognized today as authoritative, except perhaps by revanchist historians who are so busy rewriting history, they only know what they have invented.

To quote John Boehner: "No, No,No, No, NO........."

You have to be in a classroom to understand the dynamics: social, educational, emotional, and physical. You have to be there to see the joy on a kid's face and the pride on his teacher's, when some who has been labeled a poor student takes those steps to the front of the class to receive maybe the first prize for academic achievement he has ever known. And you have to be there when a kid who was considered hopeless, walks across a stage to get his diploma. If you haven't been there, you don't know, and you never will.

You won't understand teachers who take money out of their own pockets to pay for supplies for kids whose parents can't afford them and whose state doesn't feel are worth supplying in sufficient quantity.

It's the 150th anniversary of the beginning of the Civil War and I live in a city whose history is alive with it. I ask why are students here aren't being taken to battle sites, historic homes, and the Battery where it all began, and exposed and taught about the events and the individuals and the roles they played. Not all of it's "nice" some of it is downright disgusting, but it is real, it is alive. It vibrates along King Street, Meeting Street. at the plantations that ring the city, on the Battery, and in the museums. Ask any history or civics teacher if he or she would love to give this opportunity to his students, and then ask them why they can't.

Most teachers are a national treasure, and they desire respect, fair pay, good working conditions and the tool they need in the classroom to do the job they are capable of doing. They shouldn't have to be out of the streets striking for wages of benefits we should be more than happy to give them. I despise those who pay lip service to this profession, all the while plotting to pile on more work and responsibility without incumbent compensation.

I've said all I want to say about this subject, and I fully realize that there is no convincing some people that education is the key to success no matter the chosen life path. But its ok with me if you want change over to the idea that everything is practice until you get it right. Hell if doctors and lawyers can get away with it, they are the only two professions I know of that refer to their professions as practices, I guess everyone can, at least in the Republican world of owners and serfs.

Tai Pan

ps: I will write no more on this thread. It has deteriorated into ignorant pronouncements, followed by reasoned responses that have no more chance of making a dent in antediluvian thinking than an iron nail has of surviving a sulfuric acid bath.

When I was at the university, we all, in my major, used to joke about education majors not being the sharpest crayons in the box, but your essay in this thread is very well written and reminds me of the great, formative roles some of my teachers and professors have had in my life. I commend you on this excellent essay.

Too bad this essay's length is too great for Dallas' limited attention span, plus its not having pictures (like of yellow dinosaurs) causes it to not keep his attention anyway.
 
I would venture to guess Dave that without teachers that you would be illiterate and innumerate. Few people teach themselves to read, write, or do numbers. BTW, I thought that you did not like to work for other people or have your own work evaluated. If that is the case, you would probably be an utter flop as a teacher. (Telling teachers that they should start a business is just a bunch of BS. You were the one that compared them to bank tellers and secretaries.)

There are elementary school teachers, middle school teachers, high-school teachers and each face different sorts of challenges - none of them easy. The fact that you disdain teachers seems to reveal a disdain for education generally. I disagree with you. Maybe, it is because in the businesses that I started, a good education was a necessity for employees.

I'd do it in an instant. Take one of those teachers, have them quit their job and start a business, any kind, using their own money. Who would you think has the better chance of success?
 
I would venture to guess Dave that without teachers that you would be illiterate and innumerate. Few people teach themselves to read, write, or do numbers. BTW, I thought that you did not like to work for other people or have your own work evaluated. If that is the case, you would probably be an utter flop as a teacher. (Telling teachers that they should start a business is just a bunch of BS. You were the one that compared them to bank tellers and secretaries.)

There are elementary school teachers, middle school teachers, high-school teachers and each face different sorts of challenges - none of them easy. The fact that you disdain teachers seems to reveal a disdain for education generally. I disagree with you. Maybe, it is because in the businesses that I started, a good education was a necessity for employees.

Take most MBAs and have them start a business and the teacher will do better.

Essentially MOST TEACHERS are already running their own businesses or business divisions. They have a budget to deal with that is inadequate - they have multiple customers (Admin, Teachers, kids) - they are responsible for creating and executing their own business plan (Lesson plan) - that it has to fit into a standardized framework is no different than a Gemeral Manager of a division having to meet a P&L and the corporate strategy and messaging.

The ONLY reason many current teachers would not be that good at running their own buisness is that they have been beaten up down and sideways by folks like Dave about their "incompetence" that their belief in themselves is broken.

The reality is that I would go work at a startup organized by a teacher LONG BEFORE I'd go work at one organized by an MBA.. why? Beause teachers are the MASTERS of improvisation and "doing with what you have"... Which is the quintessence of "startup mode".

Sorry Dave - your notionof teaching is just ignorant. Perhaps we should blame your teachers.


Teachers are no more than secreataries... go volunteer as a 5th grade teacher.. see how long you last. Fvcking maroon...
 
I would venture to guess Dave that without teachers that you would be illiterate and innumerate. Few people teach themselves to read, write, or do numbers. BTW, I thought that you did not like to work for other people or have your own work evaluated. If that is the case, you would probably be an utter flop as a teacher. (Telling teachers that they should start a business is just a bunch of BS. You were the one that compared them to bank tellers and secretaries.)

There are elementary school teachers, middle school teachers, high-school teachers and each face different sorts of challenges - none of them easy. The fact that you disdain teachers seems to reveal a disdain for education generally. I disagree with you. Maybe, it is because in the businesses that I started, a good education was a necessity for employees.

My brother is an MBA high school teacher, you act as if we hadn't gone to school and don't know the inner workings. I don't disdain teachers, I disdain the rhetoric that you guys throw out there as if no one else has a difficult job. I challenge them to start a company with 10 employees or more and experience what it's like to operate with a zero safety net and the chance of losing their life savings. I watched those Chicago teachers and was surprised to see at least 90% of them obese waddling around doing their demand thing on the news. They could barley speak decently.

You're right, I don't like to work for others but I could and be damned good at it.
 
I would venture to guess Dave that without teachers that you would be illiterate and innumerate. Few people teach themselves to read, write, or do numbers. BTW, I thought that you did not like to work for other people or have your own work evaluated. If that is the case, you would probably be an utter flop as a teacher. (Telling teachers that they should start a business is just a bunch of BS. You were the one that compared them to bank tellers and secretaries.)

There are elementary school teachers, middle school teachers, high-school teachers and each face different sorts of challenges - none of them easy. The fact that you disdain teachers seems to reveal a disdain for education generally. I disagree with you. Maybe, it is because in the businesses that I started, a good education was a necessity for employees.

My brother is an MBA high school teacher, you act as if we hadn't gone to school and don't know the inner workings. I don't disdain teachers, I disdain the rhetoric that you guys throw out there as if no one else has a difficult job. I challenge them to start a company with 10 employees or more and experience what it's like to operate with a zero safety net and the chance of losing their life savings. I watched those Chicago teachers and was surprised to see at least 90% of them obese waddling around doing their demand thing on the news. They could barley speak decently.

You're right, I don't like to work for others but I could and be damned good at it.
 
Actually, if I remember correctly, Dave started a small business that has seen respectable growth but does not have a college degree. I know several small business people who fit this profile including my younger brother, Bill Gates, and Steve Jobs. The difference between my younger brother, Gates, Jobs and Dave is that none of them would dis education the way that Dave seemed to do or compare teachers to bank tellers. And all three of them know that their businesses would not have been successful without a highly trained workforce.

As to MBAs, well I do have an MBA but I was not successful because I had an MBA and I know plenty of MBAs who are essentially "private bureaucrats" who are not particularly creative or decisive.

Anyway, I certainly don't begrudge Dave his success. I applaud it. I just think that his desire to generalize to the world from his own personal experience is faulty. One thing that education does provide is critical thinking skills that help people avoid overgeneralizing from their own experience. A good education is a great help for thinking outside the box.


Take most MBAs and have them start a business and the teacher will do better.

Essentially MOST TEACHERS are already running their own businesses or business divisions. They have a budget to deal with that is inadequate - they have multiple customers (Admin, Teachers, kids) - they are responsible for creating and executing their own business plan (Lesson plan) - that it has to fit into a standardized framework is no different than a Gemeral Manager of a division having to meet a P&L and the corporate strategy and messaging.

The ONLY reason many current teachers would not be that good at running their own buisness is that they have been beaten up down and sideways by folks like Dave about their "incompetence" that their belief in themselves is broken.

The reality is that I would go work at a startup organized by a teacher LONG BEFORE I'd go work at one organized by an MBA.. why? Beause teachers are the MASTERS of improvisation and "doing with what you have"... Which is the quintessence of "startup mode".

Sorry Dave - your notionof teaching is just ignorant. Perhaps we should blame your teachers.


Teachers are no more than secreataries... go volunteer as a 5th grade teacher.. see how long you last. Fvcking maroon...
 
Take most MBAs and have them start a business and the teacher will do better.

Essentially MOST TEACHERS are already running their own businesses or business divisions. They have a budget to deal with that is inadequate - they have multiple customers (Admin, Teachers, kids) - they are responsible for creating and executing their own business plan (Lesson plan) - that it has to fit into a standardized framework is no different than a Gemeral Manager of a division having to meet a P&L and the corporate strategy and messaging.

The ONLY reason many current teachers would not be that good at running their own buisness is that they have been beaten up down and sideways by folks like Dave about their "incompetence" that their belief in themselves is broken.

The reality is that I would go work at a startup organized by a teacher LONG BEFORE I'd go work at one organized by an MBA.. why? Beause teachers are the MASTERS of improvisation and "doing with what you have"... Which is the quintessence of "startup mode".

Sorry Dave - your notionof teaching is just ignorant. Perhaps we should blame your teachers.


Teachers are no more than secreataries... go volunteer as a 5th grade teacher.. see how long you last. Fvcking maroon...

Maroon? What's the matter Degs? that time of the month?
 
I am sorry Dave. You do come across as someone who has disdain for teachers (and secretaries and bank tellers for that matter.)

BTW, no one compared teachers to small business people except you. You were the one who took a potshot at them. Starting a small business is tough. One advantage that I might have had over you is that with my education, I did have skills that I could fall back on if my businesses had failed. Furthermore, my education has made it easier for me to do part-time consulting work. It is both my experience AND my education that get me clients. (And I do have small business people as clients.)


My brother is an MBA high school teacher, you act as if we hadn't gone to school and don't know the inner workings. I don't disdain teachers, I disdain the rhetoric that you guys throw out there as if no one else has a difficult job. I challenge them to start a company with 10 employees or more and experience what it's like to operate with a zero safety net and the chance of losing their life savings. I watched those Chicago teachers and was surprised to see at least 90% of them obese waddling around doing their demand thing on the news. They could barley speak decently.

You're right, I don't like to work for others but I could and be damned good at it.
 
I am sorry Dave. You do come across as someone who has disdain for teachers (and secretaries and bank tellers for that matter.)

BTW, no one compared teachers to small business people except you. You were the one who took a potshot at them. Starting a small business is tough. One advantage that I might have had over you is that with my education, I did have skills that I could fall back on if my businesses had failed. Furthermore, my education has made it easier for me to do part-time consulting work. It is both my experience AND my education that get me clients. (And I do have small business people as clients.)

Okay, let's get this straight. I've said it before, I have great respect for anyone who achieves an MBA and especially a Phd. As far as comparison, I think someone told me I couldn't do a teachers job.

The real subject here is teachers unions and there ability to control politicians as well as our education system and we are talking about elementary levels up to the twelfth grade. If we are going to be honest we have to say that our education system is a failure and getting worse. Our argument or discussion is the why? I say it is the unions and fact that they sustain poor quality teachers, my experience is that there is one good teacher for ten poor ones. I have seen private school teachers who make a lot less than government employees and do a better job. You can site all kinds of reasons for this but the bottom line is what it is. I truly believe that if the government would get out of the education business and outsource it to private companies it would be better for society as a whole and cost 10% of what it does now.

I agree that your degree does allow you something to fall back on and provides you some advantages, but then maybe that is why I require a certain dogmatic stance to not fail.

By the way I have respect for all people that work, even flipping hamburgers. I would venture to say that some secretaries have far more abilities than many professions, have you ever watched a legal or corporate secretary running the show?
 
Okay, let's get this straight. I've said it before, I have great respect for anyone who achieves an MBA and especially a Phd. As far as comparison, I think someone told me I couldn't do a teachers job.

I looked back in the linear mode. It looks like you compared teachers to bank tellers in post #283. If anyone compared you to a teacher, it was after you posted that comparison. You did compare teachers to bank tellers initially.

The real subject here is teachers unions and there ability to control politicians as well as our education system and we are talking about elementary levels up to the twelfth grade. If we are going to be honest we have to say that our education system is a failure and getting worse.

Both of my kids went to public schools and have done very well. (They could have gone to private schools.) Now, admittedly, my kids also went to a public school in an upper-income area in Seattle. So I don't think that our education system is a failure for most middle and upper class kids whether the schools are public or private. "No child left behind" is about making a good education available to everybody. That is tough. There is always room for improvement.

Our argument or discussion is the why? I say it is the unions and fact that they sustain poor quality teachers, my experience is that there is one good teacher for ten poor ones. I have seen private school teachers who make a lot less than government employees and do a better job.

My experience is that private school teachers salaries are pegged to public school teacher salaries. They do not get paid a lot less (and working environment is often less difficult.)

Public School Teacher Salaries

Private School Teacher Salaries

You can site all kinds of reasons for this but the bottom line is what it is. I truly believe that if the government would get out of the education business and outsource it to private companies it would be better for society as a whole and cost 10% of what it does now.

10%? I hope that you do not really believe that. Public education is generally in the hands of local governments and the states. I would be very skeptical of farming out education to for-profit companies as a general solution.

I agree that your degree does allow you something to fall back on and provides you some advantages, but then maybe that is why I require a certain dogmatic stance to not fail.

Only you know that. I am not going to speculate.

By the way I have respect for all people that work, even flipping hamburgers. I would venture to say that some secretaries have far more abilities than many professions, have you ever watched a legal or corporate secretary running the show?

My wife is an "secretary" turned office administrator. Her office would fall apart without her.
 
I did compare bank tellers to teachers. Some tellers would be better some would not, some teacher shouldn't be teaching and they can't get fired. I heard that there is quite a number of New York City teachers who are not allowed in the class room due to various reasons but report for duty, do nothing and get a full salary. This morning in the Los Angeles area, LAUSD has provided a plan to test a teachers ability in order to make sure they are up to par. They stated that they have to provide it to the Union and get approval, that would not happen with a private company.

Government is a catch 22, they do not have to be profitable but require money to operate. Rather than budget they raise taxes, this is the cause of inefficiency. They have automatic pay raises as if the economy is forever strong. There is so much waste and bad policy that things done through government is far more expensive than the watchful private industry. Today in California, pay policy has outstripped revenues, lack of respect for the taxpayer has caught up with almost every large city. Government employees want more while knowing there is no more, but don't care. This is the case in Chicago.
 
I'd do it in an instant. Take one of those teachers, have them quit their job and start a business, any kind, using their own money. Who would you think has the better chance of success?

Last night I said I wasn't going to reply to any more post in this thread, but buddy, you just opened you mouth and swallowed your ass. Since 1964 the Federal Government has had a Program called AMERICORPS-VISTA (Volunteers in Service to America. Part of that program allows mature adults to take a sabbatical from their usual career and devote a year to teaching in schools all across the country. Here's the web site: http://www.americorps.gov/about/programs/vista.asp So take off those $1000.00 Bruno Magli shoes, pack your suit case and get in a classroom.

Btw many thousands of teachers have their own small businesses, in real estate, insurance, auto repair and host of others, including restaurants, from fast food franchises to fine dining. Many contonue to teach will running these businesses. More succeed than you would even begin to believe.

So, man with a plan who can accomplish everything, put up or shut up. The ball is in your court. Do it and prove it, or stop talking nonsense.

taipan
 
Yours being the very last ignorant pronouncement. Congrats, you win a prize.


What the matter Jack, the old Tai Pan getting to you. Your not as easy as you were on Slate, but you're not only still takeable, you're still predictable. Never address an issue or dispute facts instead, and your posts haven't changed much since your days on Slate. obfuscate, agitate, embellish, confuse and deny. Same Jack, same posts.

You need to revisit google on the taipan, think you've forgotten that he's no American eastern diamondback.

Sorry Jack, but your post, herein quoted, puts the icing on the cupcake of ignorance.

Tai Pan
 
Well, if Obama is reelected, you will esperience what it means.
See Jack even YOU are starting to move towards Julian Castro's way of expressing ideas!!

Now if you are referring to a "robbing of rights"... Well there is a difference between THEORETICAL RIGHTS - the USSR's Constitution had STRONGER free speech protections than the USA's Constitution.... but the were not meaningfully exerciseable.

That's essentially what the election of Romney promises... lots of theoretical rights that you Jack, nor the average person will have much access to.

OTOH Obama HAS ALREADY increased the access to exercising of rights to thousands if not millions of people that did not have that access before. Hardly a "robbing" of any rights.
 
Back
Top