New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Question for Conservatives

If I had made either claim, then you'd have a valid irritation. I didn't claim France was cutting back its welfare state dramatically -- I said it was cutting back its nationalized health care system dramatically.
OK... That is EVEN MORE WRONG. That's not happening.




You know, I'd actually forgotten the young people rioting in the streets over that. I guess it didn't happen.[/QUOTE]
 
Where does Dominoes claim that taking 5 million out of their coffers doesn't affect any of these things.
Where does Dominoes claim that these are costs THEY ARE NOT ALREADY PAYING? Notice how that is left out? notice how the word "ADDITIONAL" is left off the description of costs?

A person of average intelligence would see 5 million taking out of a company and think "Hmmm, there's 5 million they can't use for Dominoes' stuff". Apparently liberals aren't quite that with it.
Then a person of average intelligence is easily fooled. Becuase that $5million

  • probably IS being used for "Dominoes stuff" but they simply are complaining because they are Herman Cains old staff
  • would most likely be simply kept in cash and not used for anything. That's what corporations have been doing for the better part of 6 years. So why would that suddenly change?
 
Last night I said I wasn't going to reply to any more post in this thread, but buddy, you just opened you mouth and swallowed your ass. Since 1964 the Federal Government has had a Program called AMERICORPS-VISTA (Volunteers in Service to America. Part of that program allows mature adults to take a sabbatical from their usual career and devote a year to teaching in schools all across the country. Here's the web site: http://www.americorps.gov/about/programs/vista.asp So take off those $1000.00 Bruno Magli shoes, pack your suit case and get in a classroom.

Btw many thousands of teachers have their own small businesses, in real estate, insurance, auto repair and host of others, including restaurants, from fast food franchises to fine dining. Many contonue to teach will running these businesses. More succeed than you would even begin to believe.

So, man with a plan who can accomplish everything, put up or shut up. The ball is in your court. Do it and prove it, or stop talking nonsense.

taipan

By the way, I went to the website you posted about Vista. It looks like a great thing to perform some volunteer service but teaching is not one of those things. As a business person I could offer some of my experience and If I find they have some positive impact in my area I just might do that. It doesn't meet our little bet though.
 
You did disdain teachers. You said they required no more skill than secretaries. And thats very much disdaining them.

As for teachers starting companies - as you well know, starting a company basically requires you to make do with what you have and make lemonade out of lemons. That's basically what teachers do on a daily basis. Zero Safetynet? at the end of every school year that's what teachers face as well. As for gambling on your life savings? That's not a skill requirement, nor does that make a job "harder"... that's just a tolerance for risk.

Note also how you are generalizing about obesity from an invalidly small sample... and how you equate obesity with incompetence... bigotted much?


you may or may not be. But you likely would fail as a teacher.

You don't know much about secretaries do you?

By the way, being a teacher would be impossible for me to fail at, I'd be a natural.
 
You "heard" you "heard" you "heard".. how about bothering to investigate? hmm?

In NY they have enough subsitute teachers in the system that when ANY teacher gets accused of any sort of misconduct, they are IMMEDIATELY pulled from the class until the investigation completes. Like benching a police officer who has used a firearm in the line of duty. And the system is large enough - 75,000 teachers - that even if you had a 1% baddie rate, you wouold have 750 teachers per year, in such situations.

As for "a plan to test teachers ability"... well there are lots of "plans"... the question is whether it is a FAIR plan and an ACCURATE plan. Turns out Standardized testing SUCKS as such a plan.

Now as to teachers "can't get fired" WTF??? Of course they can get fired and often are. But the problem is that there simply are not enough teachers TO FILL THE JOBS, Why? Cuz the job sucks. It does not pay enough http://www.mckinseyonsociety.com/downloads/reports/Education/Closing_the_talent_gap.pdf all the while ignoramouses like you think it can be done by "secretaries" and "bank tellers".


Hmm so then why are the fiscal multipliers for government in things like education BETTER THAN private sector?

Really? is your brain that twisted. what I "heard" was a news report from John Stossel on several hundred NY teachers who no longer taught. They were pulled from classes for sexual misconduct and no longer allowed to teach but could not be fired. Still they received full pay and benefits.
 
No its not wrong. On a per capita basis.. GDP in Red States is mostly BELOW AVERAGE: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S._states_by_GDP




You can call me "dishonest" all you want. but I cite my sources.. So far you have simply name called and cited NOTHING.

Maybe your eyesight is fading. I told you exactly where I got my information, 24/7 WallStreet Journal which did a state by state comprehensive data comparison with all information obtained from the IRS. Cited were all those things you wrongly stated.
 
LeRoy: I would like to see a 'secretary' come to my school and teach the classes on Calculus II, Calculus III, Differential Equations, Number Theory, Advanced Microeconomics, and Current Events, that I am currently teaching.

I would find it deeply amusing to just take a day off and watch that.

I believe that my sister a former secretary could easily take you up on that. She quit working to raise her family but prior she did quite well. She does have an MBA in Finance, but aside from that she is a math genius. Many companies have offered her six figures to get back in the working mode.
 
I believe that my sister a former secretary could easily take you up on that. She quit working to raise her family but prior she did quite well. She does have an MBA in Finance, but aside from that she is a math genius. Many companies have offered her six figures to get back in the working mode.

LeRoy: She had an MBA in finance and was working as a secretary? Isn't that like someone with a Ph.D. in astrophysics driving a taxi?
 
Interesting... it is ok to disparage secretaries but not teachers....... I agree.. I have known several well educated, very intelligent secretaries. Maybe they weren't all math geniuses, but they may have had their own areas of schooling where they would have excelled. I don't think my HS English teacher could have gone and taught Calculus II, anymore than my Calc teacher could have taught Survey of American lit. We all have our strengths and weaknesses.
 
Secretaries aren't being disparaged. But since you can get a secretarial job with just a HS education, the skill level ain't that high. Sure - executive Admins are a different ball of wax. BTW you'd be surprised at what a good teach can teach.
 
Maybe your eyesight is fading. I told you exactly where I got my information, 24/7 WallStreet Journal which did a state by state comprehensive data comparison with all information obtained from the IRS. Cited were all those things you wrongly stated.
You offered no link. If the data really was there, you'd provide a link. And since you are not offering the ACTUAL DATA but YOUR INTERPRETATION ONLY, then we don't have any reason to believe your analysis is accurate. We've seen it be off enough times before.

And since the data I cited ALSO comes from the IRS... and mine is VERIFIABLE and REVIEWABLE.. yours - well it don't score.
 
I'll take you up on that. In two years I'm going to let others take over my role here. Now to be fair, this is not a one way street, either you or if you can find a teacher, get out and start a company. We will see what we will see.

These many thousands of teachers with small companies are who? How do you know these people? are they friends.

Then you have my applause for doing it and I am sure you will bring a wealth of practical and valuable wisdom to those you teach. I've held for years that only when you combine knowledge with experience can you get the right balance in a classroom. My health no longer allows me to actively do such an activity, I have CHF with its host of parasitical complaints along with insulin dependent diabetes, there are some mornings that I wake up only to spend the whole day in bed.

You ask about some of those teachers I spoke of. Just a few examples if you will but I have a myriad of others. One of which I am particularly proud (because I had something to do with it ) is a guy my age who taught Civics in middle school, in Metairie, La. He had an inheritance from his father of some rather small real estate parcels. I suggested to him that he build a couple of small strip shopping centers, he now owns 15 worth more than 25m and producing revenue in excess of 400K net per year. He runs those himself and still teaches and coaches. Another is a friend who came from an old New Orleans restaurant family. He taught biology and also coached basketball. He took over the family restaurant (at 35) when his parents died and it is still a recognized New Orleans institution, famous for some of its antique creole dishes. He is now retired from teaching but still shows up every day and runs this New Orleans landmark.

Another an ex-nun btw, with a doctorate in psychology, setup a chain of early childhood development and daycare outlets, she retired 5 years ago from active involvement in educations after serving for the last 5 years of her education career as dean of admissions for an accredited college. She still nets over $4m a year from the childcare and development centers she established
and volunteers as a court appointed psychologist in juvenile cases. For the record she actively taught for 35 years in all levels from elementary to post graduate and is one of my dearest and most cherished friends. I did one hell of a lot of ocean container leasing with her husband, and ex-priest, in my international transport days. He was an ex-Jesuit, who taught for 15 years and then left the priesthood for business.

These are just a couple of examples, I could give you many more. Which btw, is why I challenged you the way I did. That secretary you speak of, may surprise you, she may have a degree in Political Science, History, Economics,or any other discipline, and not had the opportunity to pursue a career for reasons beyond her control. I've seen it happen, round pegs in square holes who find a perfect fit. Believe me with a degree in secondary ed/history, and a masters in theology, I had less business in international trade and transportation, that a horse does in ophthalmic surgery.

I hope you can reach out and touch those you will meet in a classroom, and give generously of the experience and knowledge you have. But please show them how to use the discipline of what you teach imparts. To educate, to bring out of darkness, means more than ever, to teach how to THINK, cogently, clearly, and with reason rather than reacting emotion to the situation around you.

Now as to your challenge, I do not get out as much as I used to, but in fairness I have given you examples of successes already achieved. I don't have the access I once had (transportation and travel is problematic) but if you consider this a fair exchange, I throw your challenge open to the board and ask them if they know currently active or those willing to accept your challenge. The only reason I say this is because I would be a poor "recruiter" if you will, given that I am mostly housebound these days. You can check this with MaryAnne or Gramps if you like, they have known me on the boards for years.


Best of luck.

Tai Pan
 
By the way, I went to the website you posted about Vista. It looks like a great thing to perform some volunteer service but teaching is not one of those things. As a business person I could offer some of my experience and If I find they have some positive impact in my area I just might do that. It doesn't meet our little bet though.

You have to go a little further than just that webpage to discover the process. In essence you define what you can offer to the program, and how you want to do it withing their parameters. In essence you write your own syllabus. In your case it might be entrepreneurship.

Sorry I missed this earlier.

Tai Pan
 
LeRoy: She had an MBA in finance and was working as a secretary? Isn't that like someone with a Ph.D. in astrophysics driving a taxi?

In your arrogance you like to believe that women are second class, that a secretary is like a barefoot pregnant wife who only follows the directions of her "teacher". You need to get a grip on reality. Depending on the company and the Executive you work for a secretary may actually run the operations, knowing every detail, person, and strength of each department. Have you heard of secretary of State?
 
An executive admin is a very different job with very different quals than a "secretary"... the term "secretary" in today's workplace typically refers to a very entry level position that requires skills sufficient to answer a phone, use phone and email, and be able to enter receipts into an accounting system.

Someone running the operations of a small company will typically have the title "office Manager" (and I'll take a teacher over an office mgr any day - hell the startup I'm doing consulting for right now would do better if it had a couple of art teachers working there instead of "UX Designers" - but not my call)

And someone responsible for administrative assstance for a department will be called a Departmental Admin Asst.

And someone responsible only for a handful of execs or one exec will be called an Executive Assistant or in some cases Executive Biz mgr.

But Secretary? Its not arrogant to see it as someone with a HS diploma and a 2 credit class in using Microsoft Office.



The term "Secretary of State" etc. is an archaic use of the term "secretary" - kinda like referring to your laptop as your "secretary" since it performs the same functions as the old "travelling desk" that used to be called "A Secretary"...
 
In your arrogance you like to believe that women are second class, that a secretary is like a barefoot pregnant wife who only follows the directions of her "teacher". You need to get a grip on reality. Depending on the company and the Executive you work for a secretary may actually run the operations, knowing every detail, person, and strength of each department. Have you heard of secretary of State?

LeRoy: With idiocy like this, comparing a garden-variety secretary to the Secretary of State, you think you would "be a natural as a teacher"?? It is to laugh.

There is no doubt that many secretaries are highly competent in their position. I did not suggest otherwise. Nothing in my post---NOTHING---can be construed as regarding women as second class.

Most secretarial positions do NOT require even a bachelor's degree, let alone a Master's degree in finance. We have secretaries at our school: they have nothing more than high school diplomas. In sharp contrast, teachers are REQUIRED to have a college degree; increasingly, they are required to have a Master's degree. We have several teachers at our school with Ph.D. degrees.

How many secretaries do you know with a Ph.D.??
 
In your arrogance you like to believe that women are second class, that a secretary is like a barefoot pregnant wife who only follows the directions of her "teacher". You need to get a grip on reality. Depending on the company and the Executive you work for a secretary may actually run the operations, knowing every detail, person, and strength of each department. Have you heard of secretary of State?

LeRoy: With idiocy like this, comparing a garden-variety secretary to the Secretary of State, you think you would "be a natural as a teacher"?? It is to laugh.

There is no doubt that many secretaries are highly competent in their position. I did not suggest otherwise. Nothing in my post---NOTHING---can be construed as regarding women as second class.

Most secretarial positions do NOT require even a bachelor's degree, let alone a Master's degree in finance. We have secretaries at our school: they have nothing more than high school diplomas. In sharp contrast, teachers are REQUIRED to have a college degree; increasingly, they are required to have a Master's degree. We have several teachers at our school with Ph.D. degrees.

How many secretaries do you know with a Ph.D.??
 
Dave,

Just to point out, initially, you compared teachers to secretaries and bank tellers. I think that adding bank tellers made it appear that you felt that secretaries did not have much skill. It sounded like you didn't think that bank tellers had much skill either.

BTW, you also said that teachers don't do course development and just deliver a "script." I think that understates what a teacher is responsible for. Even if there is "scripting" and there is some, the interpretation that the teacher puts on the script is very important. Teachers are as much performers as actors are. However, rather than trying to tell a story, they are trying to teach a lesson. That is a challenge.


In your arrogance you like to believe that women are second class, that a secretary is like a barefoot pregnant wife who only follows the directions of her "teacher". You need to get a grip on reality. Depending on the company and the Executive you work for a secretary may actually run the operations, knowing every detail, person, and strength of each department. Have you heard of secretary of State?
 
LeRoy: And the comparison of teachers to either secretaries or bank tellers is just plain stupid. Neither secretaries nor bank tellers need a college education. Teachers are increasingly expected to have a Master's degree, or at the very least be working towards one.
 
Back
Top