New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Question for normal, rational Americans

StanH

Council Member
Let's suppose you lived in a country that had a massive supply of widgets. Widgets are in the process of being replaced by another widget.

You should:

a) Harvest all the widgets you can before widgets get replaced, creating tens of thousands, if not more high-paying jobs, increasing the tax base and decreasing dependence on foreign widgets.

or

b) Leave the widgets where they are in a time of low tax revenues, unsustainably high deficits and high unemployment.
 
Let's suppose you lived in a country that had a massive supply of widgets. Widgets are in the process of being replaced by another widget.

You should:

a) Harvest all the widgets you can before widgets get replaced, creating tens of thousands, if not more high-paying jobs, increasing the tax base and decreasing dependence on foreign widgets.

or

b) Leave the widgets where they are in a time of low tax revenues, unsustainably high deficits and high unemployment.

All that would be fine if conservatives did not support the foreign widgets and make sure the domestic widgets were overpriced by lowering the income of the middle class via "trickle down" economics...ie giving the top earners more % of their salaries in tax breaks.

Thx
 
Do you use foreign widgets?

As for the rest of the babbling, nothing to do with the topic.

All that would be fine if conservatives did not support the foreign widgets and make sure the domestic widgets were overpriced by lowering the income of the middle class via "trickle down" economics...ie giving the top earners more % of their salaries in tax breaks.

Thx
 
First, your question needs to be posed to EITHER normal Americans OR rational ones. They're not the same thing. Second, your question will need to be reworded, as it's not at all clear what you're asking.
 
I think I know what you're getting at, StanH, despite the unfortunate wording. But let's just talk specifics, since the specifics matter in this case. I assume you're referring to oil. The question is whether we should hurry up and tap our oil reserves now, or leave them in place for now, right?

Personally, I advocate a hybrid approach. We should be tapping our low-cost, low-environmental risk reserves now, but holding off on tapping our higher-cost, higher environmental risk reserves. From your language, I take it that your arguments in favor of tapping it all as soon as possible are these:

(1) Oil is going to be replaced by different energy sources, so if we don't tap our oil now, we may miss out on ever capitalizing on the value of that resource.

(2) Currently, we're in a time of economic distress, and so the economic activity created by tapping the oil now would be particularly appreciated in this economic climate, and perhaps not so much at future points, even if the oil retains its value in the future.

Here are the counter-arguments:

(1) Although oil is gradually going to be replaced as an energy source, there's no reason to think the process is going to proceed quickly. I think any reasonable best guess is that oil prices are likely to rise over the next generation, and, at most, only to decline slightly in the following generation. So, there's not a huge rush. I started making this exact same argument over a decade ago, when a barrel of oil cost well under $20 (something like $17). Today it costs over $100. I, for one, am quite glad we didn't dig up and burn off our own precious natural resources back then, when we could burn other people's oil for less than $20... just by letting that oil sit in the ground, in more than quintupled in value. Will it quintuple in value again if we leave it in the ground for another decade? I doubt it. But I think its value is more likely to rise than fall. Moreover, there is a floor on the price of oil, but not really a ceiling. Even if oil gets replaced by some other source for energy, it will retain value for other petrochemical uses. So, leaving our oil in the ground has theoretically unlimited upside value, and limited downside risk.

(2) Economically-obtainable oil is indisputably a diminishing resource. From that perspective, our natural oil deposits are like a giant, perfectly free, perfectly secure, environmentally stable strategic oil reserve. Even if there is a risk that oil prices will flat-line and all we'll have to show for our conservative decision to hold ours in reserve is some beautiful unspoiled wilderness, there's also a risk in the other direction, that oil prices will sky-rocket to the point that a nation that lacks access to oil will have a major national security risk on its hands. If that happens, we'll be quite happy to know we can always go and tap ANWR and the gulf.

(3) We're leaving the next generation horrendous long-term problems thanks to our short-term thinking. Massive government debt is part of that. So is global warming, species depletion, the emptying of major aquifers, the breeding of super-bacteria, etc. If we're going to leave them so many problems to sort out, it would be nice if we also left them some resources to tap in doing so. Right now we're still able to live a terrific lifestyle despite relatively high oil prices (real GDP per capita is at an all-time high in this country). There's simply not a pressing need to tap our oil immediately to further boost that all-time-high economic output. Our kids and grandkids might well be very grateful to us if we choose not to depleted our national resources even further to boost our economic output even more, and instead leave them that oil to use in addressing all the other messes we've left.

(4) Over time, the environmental impact for extracting a given reserve of oil will tend to decline, as new technologies are brought online and perfected. Already, one can see that trend. If we'd tapped ANWR 50 years ago, the impact on the environment would certainly have been much, much worse than if we tapped ANWR today (thanks to things like horizontal drilling, allowing less surface disruption). It's only reasonable to think that if we tap ANWR 50 years from now, the impact on the environment will be much, much less than if we tapped it today. The same is true for tapping our Gulf reserves. It isn't hard to imagine that if a super-deep well blows its top in the Gulf 50 years from now we won't bumble around for months polluting the Gulf while we try to fix it: we'll have better technologies for capping the problem quickly and efficiently. Moreover, the actual COST, just in pure economic terms, of tapping a given resource will decline over time for similar reasons. So, when you do the cost/benefit analysis for tapping a given reserve (counting both economic and environmental costs), the cost end of that analysis with be dropping considerably over time -- even if the benefit end of the equation drops at an equal rate (from some hypothetical future reduction in the value of oil), we'll end up no worse off for having waited. Only if the benefit drops even more quickly than the cost would we be worse off.

(5) Setting aside the question of oil price per unit, the benefit of tapping a given unit of oil is likely to rise in the future, simply due to long-term improvements in efficiency -- both the efficiency of oil extraction and the efficiency of fuel use. For example, over time, vehicles have tended to get more fuel efficient per pound of vehicle, due to a bunch of innovations in engine design. The amount of gas you'd use to push a 3000 pound vehicle 60 miles in one hour was much higher in 1950 than today. It's only reasonable to expect the same trends to continue. So, we'll get more work (in the physics sense) out of our oil if we burn in in 60 years than if we burn it today. We're also likely to get more actual useable energy out of each reserve if we tap it in 60 years than if we tap it today. For example, consider how much progress has been made in tapping the natural gas that is often present with oil reserves -- once it was just flared off uselessly, adding to global warming but otherwise contributing nothing, whereas now it's a valuable commodity in its own right. Who knows just how much we'll waste of our reserves if we tap them now, that future generations will have clever ideas for using. When you again look at the cost/benefit analysis, you'll see that the trend will be for the analysis to improve over time, only this time on the benefit side.

In the end, I think there's only one decent argument for tapping those expensive and environmentally sensitive resources today, rather than holding off: the fear that if we don't, some great new technology will come along and make them obsolete. But, so what? If the worst thing that happens is that we get some brilliant new energy source that makes robust economic growth possible without decimating the environment, you won't see me crying about it, even if it does mean we had somewhat lower real GDP/capita numbers than we could have had for a few years. Besides, that scenario will come with at least some compensatory advantage to having failed to fully capitalize on our natural resources while we still had a chance: all that oil sitting in the ground will represent a HUGE amount of sequestered CO2, which otherwise would have been contributing to our greenhouse gas problem. If future generations are spending a ton of money and the output of their shiny new energy technologies trying to sequester CO2 from the atmosphere, in the face of looming ecological disaster, they'll be happy as hell that all that extra CO2 is locked harmlessly (and costlessly) under the Alaskan wilderness and in the Gulf, rather than making their job even harder.

To summarize, the downside risk of waiting just isn't that bad, when you think about it. By comparison, the downside risk of tapping those resources too early is horrifying. So, the genuinely conservative stance would be to hold those resources in reserve as an insurance policy, and instead to burn other people's oil. Like any insurance policy, definitionally, this insurance policy of holding onto many of our reserves might not pay off. But it's still wise to have insurance, in the face of so many serious risks.
 
Let's suppose you lived in a country that had a massive supply of widgets. Widgets are in the process of being replaced by another widget.

You should:

a) Harvest all the widgets you can before widgets get replaced, creating tens of thousands, if not more high-paying jobs, increasing the tax base and decreasing dependence on foreign widgets.

or

b) Leave the widgets where they are in a time of low tax revenues, unsustainably high deficits and high unemployment.

Translation: I'm trying to set you up with a strawman about free birth control, so I can scream at you.
 
I think I know what you're getting at, StanH, despite the unfortunate wording.

Excellent response, and it deserves a good effort from me. I'm going to do a quick hit and run on another topic, and promise to give you a response (hopefully) worthy of your efforts here later today.

Thanks.
 
I have two thoughts on your post.

One, Dispite the noise you're hearing from the conservative side, no one in the oil industry is in any hurry to actually tap ANWR, or offshore oil. What they ARE in a hurry to do, is have Congress sell leases to these Federally controlled resources at giveaway prices. This, IMHO was the main reason for the speculative bubble of 2008. Gas prices rose steadily through the spring and summer of that year. Along with oil the rise in the volume of right wing calls for opening up these reserves grew, much if it organied by poltical entities financed by oil companies. Everyone knew that the incoming Democratic adminstration was going to be far less inclined to give away leases than the Bush adminstration had been. But this meant that the legislation had to be through Congress before the August recess, because no real business would be done after the major party conventions. The GOP gambit failed, and Congress recessed without opening up ANWR.

And the price of oil suddenly and mysteriously collapsed.

Two, your post contained too many facts, too many large words and far too much reading for the likes of StanH.
 
StanH implied two decent arguments for his position. I just think they're outweighed by arguments on the other side. Picture setting up a simple pro/con analysis, with the pros of tapping now on one side, and the cons on the other. If I can speak for StanH, I think the two Pros he'd list are:

There's a risk that the real price of oil will fall, so we'll lose value by waiting.
There's a risk that the unemployment rate and other economic indicators will improve, so that if we tap in the future the economic impact will be less appreciated than it would be at this moment.

Those are two perfectly decent Pros. But you don't even have to break a sweat to provide their exact opposites on the Con side:

There's a risk that the real price of oil will rise, so we'd gain value by waiting.
There's a risk that the unemployment rate and other economic indicators will worsen, so that if we tap in the future the economic impact will be more appreciated than it would be at this moment.

I'd argue the con scenario is much more likely on the first item, at least, but regardless of the probability one ascribes to each, it's easy to see that those pros and cons pretty much wipe each other out in the analysis. Meanwhile, nearly everything else from my post consisted of ADDITIONAL cons, for the analysis. And most of those additional cons aren't things one can honestly and sanely just flip around the way I did for his pros. For example, I argued that the environmental impact of oil drilling in the future is likely to be lower than today. It's hard to believe anyone doubts that, given the constant technological improvements in the field that make surface disruptions less extensive and the risk of leaks and spills lower. But, either way, asserting the opposite (that the environmental impact is likely to get greater, due to the loss of key technologies) is just plain silly. So, you wind up with a much longer and more compelling list of cons.
 
Let's suppose you lived in a country that had a massive supply of widgets. Widgets are in the process of being replaced by another widget.

You should:

a) Harvest all the widgets you can before widgets get replaced, creating tens of thousands, if not more high-paying jobs, increasing the tax base and decreasing dependence on foreign widgets.

or

b) Leave the widgets where they are in a time of low tax revenues, unsustainably high deficits and high unemployment.

"Mu"


Well actually this one is not quite "mu" but

Insufficient information to reach a meaningful answer.
 
"Mu"


Well actually this one is not quite "mu" but

Insufficient information to reach a meaningful answer.

For example

Petroleum based Oil is being replaced by other energy sources. But there are still many things that petroleum chemistry is a quintessential strategic component for. So you want to insure a long term reserve of it

And in the long run since we are past peak oil, as a resource it will continue to increase in startegic value.

So you are better off buying overseas oil NOW and postponing the domestic job creation because in doing so, you make yourself LESS vulnerable to the impact of the widget replacement, than if you quickly build all the widgets you have resources for and have to rely on foreign widgets in the future.


OTOH if you are talking about T Shirts, it makes sense to continue ot make thme domestically until it is cheaper to buy them from the PRC



So you have not provided enough information to make an informed choice.
 
Obama would start new production of the old technology and when it fails... add another factory making the same old unworkable technology.
Obama = How To Waste A Presidency.
 
First place to start is to not ship half the widgets out of the country.

Let's suppose you lived in a country that had a massive supply of widgets. Widgets are in the process of being replaced by another widget.

You should:

a) Harvest all the widgets you can before widgets get replaced, creating tens of thousands, if not more high-paying jobs, increasing the tax base and decreasing dependence on foreign widgets.

or

b) Leave the widgets where they are in a time of low tax revenues, unsustainably high deficits and high unemployment.
 
Back
Top