Well, you're argument is certainly novel.
I think you may be misapprehending the concept. (I think) You're thinking that I'm saying some sort of direct replacement for marijuana will rush in to fill the void. Sort of like...if we were to suddenly legalize potato chips, a black market in pretzels would develop. But..that's not what I'm suggesting. It's more like....if we legalized potato chips, a black market in knock-off purses might develop.
Although...your apparent certitude that legalizing marijuana wouldn't engender new markets in some other mind-altering substance, is probably naive. But...your apparent certitude that the "element" currently trafficking in marijuana would just up and retire from the black market bidness model, definitely IS naive.
And once again......why is it SO important for us to "legalize" something that for all intents and purposes and consumed as we might hope that it'd be consumed, already IS legal?
I don't believe I've ever heard anyone suggest that marijuana should remain illegal because, after all, the black marketeers have to have
something to peddle and marijuana is fairly benign.
I have to say, though, that your argument strikes me as being both rather weak and fairly pernicious.
To begin, and correct me if I've misunderstood, you seem to assume that there's a certain "black market demand" that's more or less fixed and thus if one thing doesn't fill it, then another thing will. If that is your assumption, well, it seems wrong.
Now, it does make sense that racketeers will always be with us and of course racketeers will always be looking for a lucrative black market niche to fill. Sure. But surely the market has to exist in order to be exploited. There a huge market for marijuana because a lot of people enjoy using it regularly. But your average marijuana user isn't necessarily likely to switch to some other illegal habit simply because pot is legalized.
"Well, I was going to spark a bowl this evening, but ever since they legalized it, I just don't get the same thrill. What to do...? What to do...? Oh, I know! I'll find myself a nice, underage prostitute instead! Oh yeah, that's
so illegal. Man, this is going to be great!"
I don't see it.
I agree with you that legalizing pot isn't all that likely to provide the state with an enormous financial windfall. But I do think it's likely to have a net positive effect on the state's coffers. I guess we'll see about that.
I also agree that legalizing and regulating pot isn't likely to do away with the black market all together. We still have a black market in alcohol, after all. But that market and it's negative effects on society is miniscule compared to what it was during Prohibition. Right? Why would it be any different for marijuana?
Finally, I disagree that there's little point in legalizing marijuana because it's already legal for all intents and purposes. First, the degree to which it is "effectively" legal varies a lot depending on where one lives. Second, it's not just the reckless and the foolish who fall afoul of the prohibition, it's the unlucky as well. And it's not just a matter of getting in trouble with the law. Workers lose or fail to land a job simply because a drug test shows that they've used an illegal drug. Adult college students are suspended, lose scholarships, and collect permanent blemishes on their records. And so on...
Fact is, if one believes the drug is relatively harmless, then people who've done nothing harmful are being unfairly hurt by this prohibition. If one wishes to argue that this cost is worth it, then one is obliged to lay out a concrete balance sheet, in my opinion. Vague speculation about possible harms won't do.
Cheers.