Arkady
President
In discussions of my earlier post, recounting an incident when someone aimed a gun at me when I'd accidentally trespassed on his rural property, a few people argued that such behavior is understandable in a rural setting, where people are essentially on their own against danger. I didn't dispute that argument at the time, since I've never lived anywhere truly rural. The more I've thought about it, though, the less sense it makes. I'm sure such an attitude was justified in an era when you lived in constant fear that the Comanches would come ridin' over yonder horizon and steal away with your young 'uns, but we live in a time when rural residents are the safest among us when it comes to the threat of violent crime.
The most dangerous setting I've ever lived in was Boston in the early 90s -- back at the end of the disastrous Reagan/Bush era, when violent crime in this country had reached an all-time peak. Boston wasn't particularly bad, as far as American cities went, but with a murder rate of 24.9, it wasn't exactly a safe haven. To put that in perspective, Eagle County, Colorado (home of the paranoid gun-brandisher from my story) has had two murders in the last eight years, which works out to a murder rate averaging 5.4. That's not particularly peaceful by rural standards, but it's vastly safer than a typical city. So, it actually makes LESS sense for someone in a rural setting to react as if being quick on the draw is the only thing standing between him and a violent demise at the hands of his fellow man. If anyone can afford to be laid back about personal security, it's someone living out in the countryside.
The contrary attitude seems to be part of a wider paranoid mindset of rural people. I first started thinking about that shortly after 9/11. The anthrax attacks had just happened, and I saw a news story about a run on tarp and duct tape by people who wanted to be able to seal their homes against the threat. The people being interviewed were in a one-horse town in West Nowheresville, somewhere out in the Heartland. It just seemed bizarre. Half my friends and relatives lived in Boston, New York, and DC, yet nobody was particularly worried about the terrorist threat -- which, after all, remained a vanishingly tiny component of overall mortality, even in those towns that were unquestionably on the terrorists' radar. Yet here were people in areas al Qaeda had never heard of and wouldn't waste limited resources on if they had, going out of their way to protect themselves against an attack that would never, in a million years, be aimed at them. Sure, those duct-tape-wielding paranoids didn't represent the typical people in those areas, but it was just a more extreme expression of a generally heightened rural paranoia. At the time, my rural relatives were, bizarrely, far more preoccupied by the threat than those who lived in the cross-hairs, and far more likely to take part in the panicked stampede into the Iraq War, drummed up by scaremongering propaganda about mushroom clouds.
That obsession over tiny risks seems all the stranger when you think of the lack of interest so common in rural America for things that make a meaningful difference in mortality. Watching someone hoard a stash of guns, gold, and survival seeds into his home-made fallout shelter, while he packs on the heart-attack fat and smokes his pack of Marlboros per day, is just plain disorienting. For someone in rural South Dakota to fret about street crime or the threat posed by Iran, while he rides around helmet-less on his Harley, is insane.
You could make an argument that the paranoid style of thought in rural America factors into other fear-based political policies, like the opposition to gay marriage. You'd think that big cities would be the epicenter of resistance to gay rights, since they're the front-lines of the "gay lifestyle" (as conservatives like to call it). In cities, especially big, cosmopolitan, coastal cities, the gay presence is big enough that if they were a personal or cultural threat, the heterosexuals in those areas would be the ones most at risk of having their kids corrupted or their marriages debased, or whatever the hell it is the anti-gay forces are worried about. Yet, you find the most vocal anti-gay demagoguery in places far from any stronghold of that "gay threat" -- places like Kansas, not San Francisco or Manhattan.
So, I'm left wondering why that kind of paranoia is more common in rural areas. Does isolation mean less exposure to the unknown, resulting in a stronger fear response when the unknown is encountered? Does the homogeneity of rural life sensitize a person to the threat of "the other"? I don't know. There's a famous treatise on right-wing mentality called "The Paranoid Style in American Politics" that I've always been meaning to read. Has anyone here read it? I'm wondering if it deals at all with the paranoia of rural residents.
The most dangerous setting I've ever lived in was Boston in the early 90s -- back at the end of the disastrous Reagan/Bush era, when violent crime in this country had reached an all-time peak. Boston wasn't particularly bad, as far as American cities went, but with a murder rate of 24.9, it wasn't exactly a safe haven. To put that in perspective, Eagle County, Colorado (home of the paranoid gun-brandisher from my story) has had two murders in the last eight years, which works out to a murder rate averaging 5.4. That's not particularly peaceful by rural standards, but it's vastly safer than a typical city. So, it actually makes LESS sense for someone in a rural setting to react as if being quick on the draw is the only thing standing between him and a violent demise at the hands of his fellow man. If anyone can afford to be laid back about personal security, it's someone living out in the countryside.
The contrary attitude seems to be part of a wider paranoid mindset of rural people. I first started thinking about that shortly after 9/11. The anthrax attacks had just happened, and I saw a news story about a run on tarp and duct tape by people who wanted to be able to seal their homes against the threat. The people being interviewed were in a one-horse town in West Nowheresville, somewhere out in the Heartland. It just seemed bizarre. Half my friends and relatives lived in Boston, New York, and DC, yet nobody was particularly worried about the terrorist threat -- which, after all, remained a vanishingly tiny component of overall mortality, even in those towns that were unquestionably on the terrorists' radar. Yet here were people in areas al Qaeda had never heard of and wouldn't waste limited resources on if they had, going out of their way to protect themselves against an attack that would never, in a million years, be aimed at them. Sure, those duct-tape-wielding paranoids didn't represent the typical people in those areas, but it was just a more extreme expression of a generally heightened rural paranoia. At the time, my rural relatives were, bizarrely, far more preoccupied by the threat than those who lived in the cross-hairs, and far more likely to take part in the panicked stampede into the Iraq War, drummed up by scaremongering propaganda about mushroom clouds.
That obsession over tiny risks seems all the stranger when you think of the lack of interest so common in rural America for things that make a meaningful difference in mortality. Watching someone hoard a stash of guns, gold, and survival seeds into his home-made fallout shelter, while he packs on the heart-attack fat and smokes his pack of Marlboros per day, is just plain disorienting. For someone in rural South Dakota to fret about street crime or the threat posed by Iran, while he rides around helmet-less on his Harley, is insane.
You could make an argument that the paranoid style of thought in rural America factors into other fear-based political policies, like the opposition to gay marriage. You'd think that big cities would be the epicenter of resistance to gay rights, since they're the front-lines of the "gay lifestyle" (as conservatives like to call it). In cities, especially big, cosmopolitan, coastal cities, the gay presence is big enough that if they were a personal or cultural threat, the heterosexuals in those areas would be the ones most at risk of having their kids corrupted or their marriages debased, or whatever the hell it is the anti-gay forces are worried about. Yet, you find the most vocal anti-gay demagoguery in places far from any stronghold of that "gay threat" -- places like Kansas, not San Francisco or Manhattan.
So, I'm left wondering why that kind of paranoia is more common in rural areas. Does isolation mean less exposure to the unknown, resulting in a stronger fear response when the unknown is encountered? Does the homogeneity of rural life sensitize a person to the threat of "the other"? I don't know. There's a famous treatise on right-wing mentality called "The Paranoid Style in American Politics" that I've always been meaning to read. Has anyone here read it? I'm wondering if it deals at all with the paranoia of rural residents.