New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

School sentinels

Here's what you said, verbatim:

The vast majority of these shootings were in places that were posted as "gun free zones

So, tell me which shootings, in that list, exactly, were in places "posted as gun free zones"? If you'd like to admit you made an incorrect statement and change your claim now, that's fine. For example, if you want to say "the majority were in places where few people would be expected to be carrying concealed firearms," we can discuss that. But first, I need you to either back up the statement you actually made, or retract it.

Since it's a long list, let's just take the first ten:


Sandy Hook Elementary school
Office building
Army base
Movie theater
Cafe
Nursing classroom
Spa
Hair salon
International House of Pancakes restaurant
Safeway

Which of those, specifically, were "posted no-gun zones"? I'll give you the elementary school. I have no evidence that the office building, movie theater, cafe, nursing class room, spa, hair salon, IHOP, or Safeway had a posted no-gun policy. I've been to a lot of venues of that kind, and have never noticed a posted policy on the subject. I'm in an office building right now, and can tell you we have nothing posted on the subject.

Even if they did have a posted no-guns policy, none of those are places I'd expect to have any active screening for firearms, so if I were someone who was choosing a target based on wanting a place with no guns, those would certainly not be my choice. As for the army base, it has no-concealed-carry rules for non-MPs, but not a general no-firearms rule... there are firearms all over the place on military bases -- in people's homes and barracks, in the hands of MPs, at firing ranges, etc. So, if I were selecting targets by wanting to find a place where I was unlikely to encounter guns, it wouldn't be a military base, either.

The movie theater in Aurora CO, was posted, and while there were several others closer to where James Holmes lived, he chose that one. The military base issue we have already discussed; no one, (other than MP's) is carrying a loaded firearm on one while going about their daily business. At least some IHOP's prohibit firearms, but I don't know if that's corporate policy or not. The other venues you listed you say there is no evidence that they prohibit concealed carry; well you've shown no evidence that they don't and say you have never noticed the signs posted. That's why I suggested you speak to people who carry, they will have noticed the signs and can point them out to you. I'm not trying to convince you I'm right about this, Arkady, OK? It really doesn't matter if you believe what I'm saying.... it's still true.
 
The movie theater in Aurora CO, was posted, and while there were several others closer to where James Holmes lived, he chose that one. The military base issue we have already discussed; no one, (other than MP's) is carrying a loaded firearm on one while going about their daily business. At least some IHOP's prohibit firearms, but I don't know if that's corporate policy or not. The other venues you listed you say there is no evidence that they prohibit concealed carry; well you've shown no evidence that they don't and say you have never noticed the signs posted. That's why I suggested you speak to people who carry, they will have noticed the signs and can point them out to you. I'm not trying to convince you I'm right about this, Arkady, OK? It really doesn't matter if you believe what I'm saying.... it's still true.

I don't have to show evidence that they don't post, you have to show evidence that they do, since you're the one who asserted that the "vast majority" of these cases happen at locations that are posted no-guns zones. I'll take eight out of ten for vast majority.

If you're unable to back up the assertion in that way, we could just flip it around and look at the statements of the shooters (those that survived). How many of them cited "posted no-guns zones" as a factor in their selection of a target? Any?
 
I don't have to show evidence that they don't post, you have to show evidence that they do, since you're the one who asserted that the "vast majority" of these cases happen at locations that are posted no-guns zones. I'll take eight out of ten for vast majority.

If you're unable to back up the assertion in that way, we could just flip it around and look at the statements of the shooters (those that survived). How many of them cited "posted no-guns zones" as a factor in their selection of a target? Any?

Tell you what, don't take my word for it... http://www.nationalreview.com/articles/335739/facts-about-mass-shootings-john-fund
http://www.usatoday.com/story/opinion/2012/12/14/connecticut-school-shooting-gun-control/1770345/

Ok, let's look at those statements; first, how many of these guys survive their little rampage? 25% maybe? Of that, how many have made statements at all? Has Holmes made any statements? Any others? Of those who have made statements, has anyone flat-out asked them why they picked that spot?
 
I don't think that addresses my point. Even if I were to agree that this would act as a deterrent to mass shooters, we're only talking about a very small statistical savings of life. ALL school killings only amount to an average of around 50 per year. Of those, the majority are not mass shootings. So, even if removing the "gun free zone" designation succeeded beyond all reasonable expectations, by cutting the death toll in half, that's only 25 lives saved. Meanwhile, you have, in the other direction, all the things I was talking about: accidents, teachers going off the deep end, students stealing the guns, etc. It would take very little for those things to outweigh the impact of such a miniscule number of lives saved. You could wind up, very easily, with an average of 25 kids saved from mass shooters per year, and ten times that many killed by the very guns you allowed into the schools to make them safer.

Also, I'm not sure there's any truth to this right-wing talking point that mass shooters "almost always" target places where they can be assured there won't be concealed firearms in the hands of their targets. First, the US is, by far, the leading nation when it comes to mass shootings, and yet we're FAR less likely to be seen as a "gun free zone" by the potential shooters. If the fear of targets with concealed firearms was a big factor in mass-shooting mentality, the US would have a lot fewer such shootings than our international peers, not a lot more.

Even within the US, the majority of these shootings take place in locations where there's no particular reason for a shooter to have thought they were gun-free -- places where there was no screening for guns, or even where there was no rule against carrying them.

See here:

http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2012/12/mass-shootings-mother-jones-full-data

In order of number of victims, the shootings occurred in the following places: a movie theater, a university, a restaurant, an army base, a restaurant, a high school, an elementary school, another elementary school, a high school, an air force base, a university, a rail road station, a securities trading company, a post office, a shopping center, a Safeway, an immigrant center, a high school, a defense contractor office building, a church, a middle school, an office building, a high school, an office building, a shopping mall, a pancake shop, a concert venue, a restaurant, a beer distribution office, a nursing home, a school, a church, an office building, a welding shop, a temple, a university, a shopping center, a post office, a hair salon, a private home hosting a party, an office, an office, city hall, a post office, a hotel, a cafe, a factory, a private apartment hosting a party, an office, another office, a maintenance yard, another office, a municipal trailer, a university, a nightclub, two more office buildings, a spa, a coffee shop, a restaurant, and an office building.

Most of those are places that seem no more likely than any randomly-selected location to be "gun free." They're places with no metal detectors or weapons scanning, and often they're places where there's not even a rule about carrying a gun. What unites these many disparate places are two main things:

(1) They're places where lots of people are congregated; and
(2) Many of them are places that a person can develop very strong negative feelings about, thanks to lengthy personal involvement (the shooter's own school or workplace).

There may be an occasional spree shooter looking for the "highest score," who specifically chooses his target because he thinks the targets will be less likely to be armed. But most are picking their targets because of a personal connection to the location or to someone there.

I think the right-wing talking point about "gun free zones" being targeted came about not because there's any real-world reason to think that's a major factor, but rather because it's a pro-gun argument, and they'll claim most anything if it's pro-gun, facts be damned.

Also you state that "the US is, by far, the leading nation when it comes to mass shootings", but the info available shows that isn't necessarily true about shootings, and it certainly isn't true regarding killings. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_rampage_killers
 
More states seeking to arm teachers..

http://schoolsofthought.blogs.cnn.c...tes-move-to-put-guns-in-classrooms/?hpt=hp_t1

Armed guards? maybe. But armed teachers? As the particle indicates..frought with risk



The USA, to the rest of the World, seems to have completely 'lost it'.

As you know I think all these mass murders are nothing more than psyops but even if they were real, if they were real one would think the atmosphere would be to find a way for bringing about a more peace loving place to bring up children so that their lives would be without need of worrying about protection against violence from 'their own' but instead of that, it seems from the outside, that what is happening is that fear, nah terror, is being instilled into children from the year dot, that and being used to being imprisoned.



Prison is all that your children have to look forward too?
 
Nah, it's all just an illusion. We don't actually have any guns here. We're just trying to fool the rest of the world into thinking that we're armed to the teeth and crazy so they won't come here and bother us.



When was the last time someone came and 'bothered you' Knight? Stop reading the papers and you'll all sleep better at night.
 
Back
Top