New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Secede Already?

Who's going to pay for all those military bases in the South, SOL? Locals?

If I were you Gordo I would worry less about this and more about what this Adminstration is going to do when states like Cali need to ask Texas for a bail out? Or just in general what this Adminstration is going to do when the entire country is well on the road (it is already) to being Stockton, CA.

Like it or not it's actually what you voted for: insolvency ..... get used to it
 
Well, presumably we would do it relatively peacefully. NO matter though we have them in lots of places we fought with once the fighting is over. The US government assuming it will still want/ need some military power - will have to have a place to keep some of their equipment.
 

I talked about this with a liberal buddy from Kentucky and he pointed out how badly it would suck for any reasonable people (and most racial and religious minorities) stranded in the Confederacy. They would either have to relocate their lives, or be stuck in a rapidly degenerating society.

It sure would be nice, though, to be liberated from the net fiscal drain that "Red America" represents. There is a measurable net flow of federal funds from blue states (which are disproportionately wealthy, and also less well positioned to claim tax deductions, and thus who pay at higher effective rates), to red states (which, since they're poorer, get more federal spending, and which also get more spending that isn't even tied to poverty, in places like Alaska).

Just picture, for example, if the Union Post Office were now liberated of the huge expense of having to provide mail service to people in far-flung rural areas. No more need to maintain mail planes and special ATVs for delivering mail in rural Alaska and Montana. Picture if Amtrak could just serve the densely populated Northeastern Corridor and parts of the West Coast, rather than having to run inefficient routes to places like Dallas, Flagstaff, and Nashville, where population density makes it impossible to maintain service at reasonable rates. Picture if Union highway money were used to maintain road that were heavily trafficked, rather than far-flung systems through the deep interior of the country, that have construction and maintenance costs vastly in excess of their actual usage.

If secession could happen, the Union would look much like the major countries of Western Europe, with a progressive, wealthy, urban population, where the Confederacy would look like nothing else in the first world -- a kind of weird hybrid of Israel, Chile, and Italy, I suppose.
 
Who pays for all the military bases the US has all over the rest of the world now? So, likely the Government would still decide to keep much of them operational. After all - how or where will they aquire the new land in the more congested areas of the north east to relocate them?

connie

The Northeast doesn't need more land. Population growth is relatively slow and population density is still well below what it is in most of the countries with the highest quality of life. For example, New York state has a population density of 415.3 per square mile. That's less than Switzerland, Luxembourg, the UK, Germany, Japan, Belgium, and the Netherlands, just to take a few examples. In fact, it isn't even close. The population of New York state could TRIPLE and it would still have fewer people per square mile than the Netherlands. And New York is one of the more densely populated blue states. Maine has a population density of 43 people per square mile.
 
Ohio is an agricultural state .Chinese are now filling the empty cars with Soy Beans shipping them back to China.

Yes it is, and I should have included Ohio in my list. But there are few states in the Union more agricultural than Iowa. I have NO idea why Trap is making this outlandish claim that the blue states would 'starve' without the red states. It's laughable.
 
"New Dixie" would collapse within a year. At the least, from inter-sectarian fights as they try to "out-pure" themselves.....e.g. those who would claim an individual has a right to own their own tank, versus a Red State Government that would be trying to prevent their State from collapsing into a warlordship.

Besides that GG, who is going to fed those red staters when they will no longer be able to collect their dole from the federal government? Heaven forbid they raise they own taxes to pay their own way. Jackie D will move out of Texas when he has to start paying for his own support instead of living off the government dole.
 
Well, for one thing, Texas and Alaska (both are "red" states) produce most of the nation's indigenous petroleum. The blue states might subsidize the red states, but most of it is highway money and the blue states would starve without the red state agribusiness. The reason our nation is one whole nation is that the "red" and "blue" states are better together than they would be apart.

The blue states would simply buy the cheapest available food on the global market, rather than being forced to buy red-state food at a markup, by way of protective tariffs and agricultural subsidies. It would be CHEAPER to feed the blue states after secession than before, not more expensive. As for petroleum costs, it's a global market. Red state producers are allowed to sell their products, today, to anyone in the world at the best price they can find. So it's not like blue state buyers get some sort of sweetheart deal on that oil because of their political union with the red state producers.

Try to think through how blue state oil prices could possibly go up as a result of the red states splitting off. As long as the red states are producing the same amount, and selling it into the global market, the blue state prices will remain the same. The only way blue state prices would rise is if red states, like Opec in the 70s, were to cut production intentionally, in order to drive the price up. But red state oil production is a lot smaller than Opec production, so it would have less of an impact, and the hit would be felt far more strongly in the red states (deprived of a major source of income) than the blue states (facing somewhat higher fuel prices). How likely do you think it is that red staters would put up with their government telling them they aren't allowed to produce and sell as much oil to the highest bidder as they can?
 
Besides that GG, who is going to fed those red staters when they will no longer be able to collect their dole from the federal government? Heaven forbid they raise they own taxes to pay their own way. Jackie D will move out of Texas when he has to start paying for his own support instead of living off the government dole.

Where would he move to? There's a New Mexico, but there's no New Texas.
 
The blue states would simply buy the cheapest available food on the global market, rather than being forced to buy red-state food at a markup, by way of protective tariffs and agricultural subsidies. It would be CHEAPER to feed the blue states after secession than before, not more expensive. As for petroleum costs, it's a global market. Red state producers are allowed to sell their products, today, to anyone in the world at the best price they can find. So it's not like blue state buyers get some sort of sweetheart deal on that oil because of their political union with the red state producers.

Try to think through how blue state oil prices could possibly go up as a result of the red states splitting off. As long as the red states are producing the same amount, and selling it into the global market, the blue state prices will remain the same. The only way blue state prices would rise is if red states, like Opec in the 70s, were to cut production intentionally, in order to drive the price up. But red state oil production is a lot smaller than Opec production, so it would have less of an impact, and the hit would be felt far more strongly in the red states (deprived of a major source of income) than the blue states (facing somewhat higher fuel prices). How likely do you think it is that red staters would put up with their government telling them they aren't allowed to produce and sell as much oil to the highest bidder as they can?

The blue states produce MORE than enough food to feed both all the blue states, and then some. Much of the food that the U.S. produces for export comes from the blue states that are heavily agricultural. Much of the corn and soybeans produced in Iowa, for example, are exported.
 
We've had this conversation before. There are plenty of blue states that have enormous agricultural production: California, Iowa, Minnesota, Wisconsin, Illinois, Michigan, Pennsylvania, Hawaii, just for starters. It is nothing less than ABSURD to suppose the blue states would 'starve' without the red states.

Besides, it's a global food market. Red states would either have to sell that food to blue states or sell it to the global market (it's not like they're going to just give up on farming that arable land). If they sell to the global market, the relative supply and demand shifts, and other global sources won't be able to demand as much, driving down those prices for consumers. Any added transport costs may increase prices a bit, but blue states aren't going to starve. They're just going to buy food at the best price available internationally, rather than favoring red-state products by way of tariff advantages and farm subsidies.
 
Great read, MaryAnne! Thanks!

I'm all for it. I'd move, of course.
 
The blue states produce MORE than enough food to feed both all the blue states, and then some. Much of the food that the U.S. produces for export comes from the blue states that are heavily agricultural. Much of the corn and soybeans produced in Iowa, for example, are exported.

Yes, I assume that the blue states could easily feed themselves. But even if we were like some wealthy countries, which simply lack the arable land to feed themselves, or which have the arable land but don't bother... so what? Do the Dutch look like they're starving? Do the Japanese? The Germans? The Norwegians? Many of the countries with the highest quality of life don't produce enough food to feed themselves. Most of them could do so, if they wanted to dedicate enough of their national manpower to the process, but agricultural labor is relatively low in value, so often a country is better off focusing on producing higher-value goods and services (say, BMWs), and selling those to buy food from countries that can't compete on the higher-value goods. Even if the Blue States stopped producing as much food as they were eating, that wouldn't mean we would go hungry. It just means we'd found more profitable things to do with our land and manpower than producing food.
 
"New Dixie" would collapse within a year. At the least, from inter-sectarian fights as they try to "out-pure" themselves.....e.g. those who would claim an individual has a right to own their own tank, versus a Red State Government that would be trying to prevent their State from collapsing into a warlordship.

That's definitely one possibility. The other is that they'd have to get real: that once they saw the failure of their ideology when tried in a pure form, they'd need to reconsider their convictions.... sort of a flip side of radical socialists who only saw the problems of their belief system when the commune they'd set up started to decline because nobody had any incentive to work. There are probably a lot of conservative red staters who are only true believers because reality hasn't been allowed to intrude on their utopian vision.
 
Hey, why not? Vermont has been threatening to secede for as long as I can remember. Oddly enough, they are also one of the most gun friendly states in the US.
 
Yes, I assume that the blue states could easily feed themselves. But even if we were like some wealthy countries, which simply lack the arable land to feed themselves, or which have the arable land but don't bother... so what? Do the Dutch look like they're starving? Do the Japanese? The Germans? The Norwegians? Many of the countries with the highest quality of life don't produce enough food to feed themselves. Most of them could do so, if they wanted to dedicate enough of their national manpower to the process, but agricultural labor is relatively low in value, so often a country is better off focusing on producing higher-value goods and services (say, BMWs), and selling those to buy food from countries that can't compete on the higher-value goods. Even if the Blue States stopped producing as much food as they were eating, that wouldn't mean we would go hungry. It just means we'd found more profitable things to do with our land and manpower than producing food.

You're quite right, of course, and I have no dispute with your economic reasoning. It just bothers me that a person like Trapdoor, who even says he has lived in Iowa, can be so uninformed about the agricultural productivity of the blue states.
 
And, when WWIII erupts and supply lines are cut off - the rationing will begin? Will the starving happen then? How many people starved in Europe in WWII? If you happen to have a big enough garden and can produce enough food to feed your family - will you be OK with the Government seizing that to either feed the troops or distribute evenly?

Part of why this Country has the ag subsidies it does is to guard against the rationing and shortfalls experienced in past wartimes. Your attitude reminds me a bit of the fable of the ant and the grasshopper. It may seem unimportant and inefficient to you now. It may be that there are better ways to spend time and resources..... until winter comes... until you need those food stores and the ability to produce things you can't otherwise produce.

Of course - since you talked about the Dutch.... maybe we should talk about Hongerwinter? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dutch_famine_of_1944

connie
 
If the United States were to split into the blue states and the red states, the blue states like California, Illinois, and New York, would no longer have to subsidize those red states that collect far more from the federal government than they send in.

Why would it be "hard to do without Texas"???

Ummm you have to be kidding? California is on the road to Bankruptcy, please see Stockton. Illinois and NY with the Pension systems they are supporting will not be far behind (there are others basically look at any State with a large publice employee unions).

Why will it be hard without Texas...perhaps because they are one of the few States left we have that are actually solvent. Think of it as Germany to our soon to be European Union.
 
I didn't think they needed more land. I wondered where they would have the land to relocate all the bases they will want to close, assuming they would want to close them. I don't think they have that kind of space. Now they did close some so I guess they could re-open them. But, part of why the bases are where they are is because the area was relatively uninhabited when the bases were located there, so as to have minimal impact ot the surrounding community. I enjoy VA beach for instance, but last year when Navy Jet crashed into an apartment complex there was a lot of questioning about whether or not bases should be so close to housing - even though the base was there first. And, this is VA - a southern very pro-military state. Can't imagine the wailing and gnashing of teeth that would occur if that was in a Northern state.

connie
 
Back
Top