New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Secede Already?

Ummm you have to be kidding? California is on the road to Bankruptcy, please see Stockton. Illinois and NY with the Pension systems they are supporting will not be far behind (there are others basically look at any State with a large publice employee unions).

Why will it be hard without Texas...perhaps because they are one of the few States left we have that are actually solvent. Think of it as Germany to our soon to be European Union.

It's downright hilarious that you are comparing Texas to Germany. Germany has one of the best educational systems in the world; not the best, mind you, but VERY GOOD. Texas? It has the highest high-school dropout rate in America. And your knowledge of the budget situation in Texas is laughably wrong. Here are some facts for you to ponder:



By Chris Baltimore and Peter Henderson

AUSTIN, Texas/SACRAMENTO, California | Fri Feb 4, 2011 9:58am EST

(Reuters) - Texas Governor Rick Perry treated guests to a barbecue lunch paid for by a wealthy businessman. Supporters of California Governor Jerry Brown munched on hot dogs at a union-sponsored picnic.

The stark contrast in inaugural menus last month highlights the different approaches the two most populous U.S. states are taking to deal with massive budget deficits.

Perry, a Republican, campaigned on the strength of the Texas economy and made political hay of the fact the Lone Star state had avoided California's massive deficit, pegged at $25.4 billion through the upcoming budget year.

Now Texas faces a budget deficit estimated as high as $27 billion for the upcoming two-year cycle of 2012-2013. To close the gap, state legislators have proposed steep cuts in funding to education and welfare programs.

California and Texas are in similar budgetary dire straits following a painful U.S. recession that severely crimped state tax receipts and other critical revenue sources.

How the debate plays out in Austin and Sacramento will be watched closely by the $2.8 trillion U.S. municipal bond market, which states could tap to cover their shortfalls. California, which has the world's eighth-largest economy, is the market's biggest debt issuer.

The steps that Texas and California lawmakers take in coming months to control the damage will also test the nation's appetite for new taxation in the face of an anti-tax drive spearheaded by conservative Tea Party activists, who helped propel Republicans to big gains in last year's congressional elections.

"I think it's fair to call the upcoming fiscal year the most challenging budget year on record for states," said Nicholas Johnson, director of state fiscal projects at the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities.

States face a collective budget gap of $175 billion through 2013, even after closing gaps totaling $230 billion over the past two years, the National Governors Association said. Federal help from previous years is drying up.

Brown, a Democrat, wants to fill the gap with a combination of $12.5 billion in spending cuts and $12 billion in tax hikes, and seeks to ask voters for approval.

Brown is no stranger to tax fights. In 1978, during his earlier stint as governor, California voters passed Proposition 13, which constrained the state's ability to impose new taxes.

Texas has a long history of business-friendly policies and conservative tax policy -- the state has no income tax. It has traditionally ranked low among U.S. states in public funding for education and social programs.

TO TAX OR NOT TO TAX?

California's deficit is the largest of any of the 50 U.S. states in absolute dollar terms, but Texas' projected 2012 budget shortfall is equal to 31.5 percent of its 2011 budget, versus 29.3 percent for California, according to the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities.

Experts say Texas' budget has been under pressure for years. The state used about $6.4 billion in federal funds from the 2009 Recovery Act to fill a shortfall in its 2010-2011 budget cycle, but those funds will not be available in the 2012-2013 period.

In Texas, a conservative stronghold where Republicans hold a big majority in the Legislature, attempts to raise taxes to cover the shortfall are likely to fall flat.

Texas weathered a 2003 budget shortfall without raising taxes and "remained true to fiscal discipline while addressing budget challenges similar to those we face today," Perry told a business convention last month.

Texas has an ace up its sleeve -- a $9.4 billion "rainy day" fund the state has built up over the years, funded by a tax on the state's oil and natural gas production.

California voters may have some tolerance for higher taxes. Much depends on the ability of Brown, who was elected last November, to secure a special election to ask voters to extend tax hikes to narrow the budget gap.

Brown aims to root out waste and profligacy, such as cutting state officials' cell phone use, but he exudes belief in government as a positive force.

"Californians will be much more predisposed to raising taxes" than Texans, said Matt Murray, economics professor at the University of Tennessee in Knoxville. "Anything like that in Texas, I don't think it would even make it to the ballot."
 
I didn't think they needed more land. I wondered where they would have the land to relocate all the bases they will want to close, assuming they would want to close them. I don't think they have that kind of space. Now they did close some so I guess they could re-open them. But, part of why the bases are where they are is because the area was relatively uninhabited when the bases were located there, so as to have minimal impact ot the surrounding community. I enjoy VA beach for instance, but last year when Navy Jet crashed into an apartment complex there was a lot of questioning about whether or not bases should be so close to housing - even though the base was there first. And, this is VA - a southern very pro-military state. Can't imagine the wailing and gnashing of teeth that would occur if that was in a Northern state.

connie

Blue states already have lots of former military bases that were closed down for lack of continuing usefulness -- Loring Air Force Base and Brunswick Naval Air Station. There are others that have been partly turned over to civilian use because the military doesn't need all the land (like Hanscom Air Force Base). They could be re-militarized if necessary. And if we need more space, we've got plenty of sparsely populated land -- the coast of Maine and Oregon for the Navy, for example and places like upstate Maine, Western Mass, Upstate New York, and Eastern Washington for the Army and Air Force.

But considering the US spends five times as much on its military as the next-most-militarized nation, and about three times as much as a share of GDP as a typical wealthy nation, we could cut our military in half, without much work. So, I'm not convinced we'd need anywhere near as many bases as we currently have. Many of them are essentially just political pork. With a more sensibly sized military, of the kind you'd likely see in a Blue State America (enough to deter all aggression and to run small scale foreign interventions.... roughly on par, as a share of GDP, with what the UK has), we'd probably be closing military bases here, not opening them.
 
Possibly but the new country would be ripe for the picking. I would be much more concerned about your defense. Not to mention - clearly the left isn't above warmongering on their own. We are still doing plenty of it under a President who won the Nobel peace prize.... so I wouldn't be so convinced. Not to mention big heavy defense hitters would still be hoping for their slice of the pie....its not just red states that keep the defense budget high.

connie
 
Not yet, LR. But in the winter you can go to the beach or the snow, or both in the same day...you don't have that option. Didn't you just get 18 inches of snow? Yesterday was in the 80s here, Saturday was 96.
 
I think you and many of your compatriots simply can't fathom that people don't want to live like you. And, would actually be and ARE happier with a simpler existence. Yes, the roads in rural areas would be crap. Many of them dirt. And you know what - if you like living in a rural area - that won't bother you. You likely can't fathom living without police and fire stations at the ready only seconds away - but if you like living in a rural area - you accept that the fact that the only reason you even bother to call the fire department is to try to keep the fire from spreading. Not to save your home or rescue you. You accept and live with those risks.

You want to pass judgement on that and act like it is "less" in your eyes and I am sure it is. But, many people actually LIKE life like that. Are happy like that. And in many ways feel like others are pushing their way of life on them. There still would be the major highway structure and the less used roads would fall into disrepair. And, so what? There may be less snow removal - so what? You plan and prepare for that. You keep non-perishibles. You keep a week or more of fuel on hand for a generator. You look at getting solar or wind energy. You barely need landlines anymore since cell companies want to offer service for their customers wherever they may go. So, you have to go to town for your mail, or ask a neighbor to get it for you. That is how people did it for hundreds of years, and many would be happy to do it that way again. Most of it is junk anyway.

But, you see these are things people accept and know when they choose to live where it is rural. If you want all those city ammenities - you live in the city. The fact that a big disparity exists between the the rural and the city - only bothers you people in the cities. Who can't fathom why anyone would want to live like a poor redneck. And, while true poverty is never a happy state, the vast majority of people who live in rural areas who grow most of their own food, who maybe still make most of their own clothes - are actually - fairly content with their lot in life. Its honestly people like you - thinking you know what is best for them, that create half the problem and the necessities you think they need, then try to force those "necessities" on them.

connie
 
Not yet, LR. But in the winter you can go to the beach or the snow, or both in the same day...you don't have that option. Didn't you just get 18 inches of snow? Yesterday was in the 80s here, Saturday was 96.

It's beautiful here today. This year, for whatever weird meteorological reasons, we got almost all our snow in April, and on the first day of May. We had very little snow from October through March! And we probably won't get any more this year, until late in the year. I am hoping we have a cooler summer than we did last summer. Last summer was a SCORCHER!
 
Possibly but the new country would be ripe for the picking. I would be much more concerned about your defense. Not to mention - clearly the left isn't above warmongering on their own. We are still doing plenty of it under a President who won the Nobel peace prize.... so I wouldn't be so convinced. Not to mention big heavy defense hitters would still be hoping for their slice of the pie....its not just red states that keep the defense budget high.

connie

Ripe for the picking?!? By WHO??? The Canadians? Vikings from Iceland? WHO??
 
Whoever. You really think that there wouldn't be substantial risk or that this blue utopia wouldn't draw someone's ire? Who knows.. maybe China. They have millions of unmarried young men. I have heard them referred to as cannon fodder...... At any rate - you would have all that much more to protect.... you really think so many people would think it wasn't worth protecting at least to the levels previously mainatianed...doubtful.

connie
 
Whoever. You really think that there wouldn't be substantial risk or that this blue utopia wouldn't draw someone's ire? Who knows.. maybe China. They have millions of unmarried young men. I have heard them referred to as cannon fodder...... At any rate - you would have all that much more to protect.... you really think so many people would think it wasn't worth protecting at least to the levels previously mainatianed...doubtful.

connie

It is possible there might be a military confrontation between the United States and China in the future. I certainly HOPE not, but as a realist, must acknowledge the possibility. But they would have to mad to attempt an actual invasion of the United States, even if it is just a segment of the country left over after a split between the red states and the blue states. As Arkady has endlessly pointed out, we could cut our military spending by half and STILL be spending far more than any other country. China included. On top of that, our technology is still substantially more advanced than China's, and we should certainly work to ensure that we maintain that technological lead. In THAT battle, the red states are actually holding us back, due to their profound and pronounced educational weaknesses.
 
You're quite right, of course, and I have no dispute with your economic reasoning. It just bothers me that a person like Trapdoor, who even says he has lived in Iowa, can be so uninformed about the agricultural productivity of the blue states.

I currently live in Iowa. I don't deny that there is some agribusiness conducted in blue states, but not the majority of it.
 
I currently live in Iowa. I don't deny that there is some agribusiness conducted in blue states, but not the majority of it.

Iowa has sometimes been called 'The Food Capital of the World'. Here are a few facts about agriculture in Iowa: Iowa's main agricultural outputs are hogs, corn, soybeans, oats, cattle, eggs, and dairy products. Iowa is the nation's largest producer of ethanol and corn and some years is the largest grower of soybeans as well. In 2008, the 92,600 farms in Iowa produced 19% of the nation's corn, 17% of the soybeans, 30% of the hogs, and 14% of the eggs.[100]

More hogs are raised in Iowa than in any other state, and it is one of the top four states for beef cattle.

Iowa could just about feed all of the blue states, ON ITS OWN.
 
Funny that yours is the only "liberal" sentiment in evidence in the strand. Liberals, it seems, aren't so liberal.

:)
 
Everybody is an extremist. Just ask any two guys who disagree. We're all fringeoids.
 
Possibly but the new country would be ripe for the picking. I would be much more concerned about your defense. Not to mention - clearly the left isn't above warmongering on their own. We are still doing plenty of it under a President who won the Nobel peace prize.... so I wouldn't be so convinced. Not to mention big heavy defense hitters would still be hoping for their slice of the pie....its not just red states that keep the defense budget high.

connie

Ripe for the picking by whom? Let's say China, since it has the biggest military in the world, after the US. So let's say Blue America ends up with a quarter of the military spending of the former USA (a cut in half just by nature of the splitting of the country, then another cut in half by way of a policy decision to reduce the hyper-militarization of the economy). In that case, Blue America would spend around $171 billion on defense, which would give it a spending edge even on China. It would remain the highest-spending military on earth (other than Red America, perhaps).

It would aksi remain a major nuclear power -- with a quarter our current arsenal, that would still be around 2000 nukes, including about 540 of them on active standby. In the face of overt aggression, Blue America would have the ability to flatten every major city of any aggressor within minutes. So, overt aggression is highly unlikely. And that's not even to consider the fact that Blue America would be closely allied, in mutual defense agreements, with nearly every other significant military on Earth (Germany, the UK, Japan, Canada, etc.... and, presumably, Red America).

Of course, it's possible that although China wouldn't be suicidal enough to actually invade Blue America, it might go after some foreign interest of the US -- e.g., invading Taiwan. But that's a possibility regardless of what our military spending levels are. The calculation is the same: would America and its many allies be willing to go into all-out war over that particular interest? And, in the case of China, pissing America off enough to trigger an embargo against Chinese products would be economic suicide, given what a huge portion of the Chinese economy depends on exports to the US. And economic suicide might be political suicide and literal suicide for China's leaders, whose position is dependent on the continued growth of prosperity in China. So, military considerations aside, China's reluctant to push us too far. They know that embargoing them would hurt us, too, so they know we'll bend quite a bit, but a trade war would ultimately hurt them more than us, so they have never pushed hard enough to trigger one.

As for the rest of your point, I agree that there are plenty of blue-staters who are fond of our military welfare budget, so it might be unrealistic to think we could cut military spending that much. But, traditionally, many of the most enthusiastic hawks are southerners, so I think it would change the political calculus considerably.
 
It is possible there might be a military confrontation between the United States and China in the future. I certainly HOPE not, but as a realist, must acknowledge the possibility. But they would have to mad to attempt an actual invasion of the United States, even if it is just a segment of the country left over after a split between the red states and the blue states. As Arkady has endlessly pointed out, we could cut our military spending by half and STILL be spending far more than any other country. China included. On top of that, our technology is still substantially more advanced than China's, and we should certainly work to ensure that we maintain that technological lead. In THAT battle, the red states are actually holding us back, due to their profound and pronounced educational weaknesses.

Yep. Even if we didn't just nuke China in response to an invasion, we outclass them by such an enormous margin on the high seas and in the air that they couldn't get an invasion fleet to our shores without losing pretty much all of it, and anything that did land would instantly be cut off from any supply lines.
 
Back
Top