New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Secede Already?

You're quite right, of course, and I have no dispute with your economic reasoning. It just bothers me that a person like Trapdoor, who even says he has lived in Iowa, can be so uninformed about the agricultural productivity of the blue states.

I did a quick (5 minute) "back of the envelope" calculation of how many people blue state agriculture could support. Counting just output of corn, rice, potatoes, and wheat, I found there enough calories being produced to allow for 2000 calories per person per day for a population of around 900 million. Obviously, in the real world some of that would be wasted producing meat for consumption, which is inefficient, but also in the real world there are plenty of other crops produced in blue states (pineapples in Hawaii, all manner of vegetables in California, maple syrup in Vermont), as well as access to many key fisheries. So, it seems likely that Blue America would remain a major net food exporter.
 
Iowa has sometimes been called 'The Food Capital of the World'. Here are a few facts about agriculture in Iowa: Iowa's main agricultural outputs are hogs, corn, soybeans, oats, cattle, eggs, and dairy products. Iowa is the nation's largest producer of ethanol and corn and some years is the largest grower of soybeans as well. In 2008, the 92,600 farms in Iowa produced 19% of the nation's corn, 17% of the soybeans, 30% of the hogs, and 14% of the eggs.[100]

More hogs are raised in Iowa than in any other state, and it is one of the top four states for beef cattle.

Iowa could just about feed all of the blue states, ON ITS OWN.

Illinois is another big one. It produces 93% as much corn as Iowa, plus a huge crop of wheat and even a significant crop of potatoes. Minnesota is another -- only half the corn crop of Iowa, but plenty of wheat. And there are a bunch of decent, second-tier blue state producers, like Wisconsin, Michigan, Ohio, and Pennsylvania. Even states we never think of as agricultural have plenty of farms. New Jersey makes 10,296,000 bushels of corn per years, 1,128,000 bushels of wheat, and 594,000 cwt of potatoes.

I haven't seen a comprehensive list of calorie output by state, but my back-of-the-envelope calculation makes Blue America look pretty impressive.

Just to take one example, Iowa corn, all alone, is 2,244,400,000 bushels, based on 2004 numbers. Online, I found an estimate of 88,480 kcal/bushel, for corn. Based on a diet of 2000 kcal/day/person average, that's enough calories, from Iowa corn alone, to feed over 272 million people -- more than the entire population of Blue America. That doesn't count any other foodstuffs made anywhere else in the Blue states. So, you're right that Iowa could feed all of the blue state on its own. Granted, you can't live on corn alone, and a lot of that corn would get eaten up making meat for consumption, but clearly the blue states would have agricultural output to burn.
 
Illinois is another big one. It produces 93% as much corn as Iowa, plus a huge crop of wheat and even a significant crop of potatoes. Minnesota is another -- only half the corn crop of Iowa, but plenty of wheat. And there are a bunch of decent, second-tier blue state producers, like Wisconsin, Michigan, Ohio, and Pennsylvania. Even states we never think of as agricultural have plenty of farms. New Jersey makes 10,296,000 bushels of corn per years, 1,128,000 bushels of wheat, and 594,000 cwt of potatoes.

I haven't seen a comprehensive list of calorie output by state, but my back-of-the-envelope calculation makes Blue America look pretty impressive.

Just to take one example, Iowa corn, all alone, is 2,244,400,000 bushels, based on 2004 numbers. Online, I found an estimate of 88,480 kcal/bushel, for corn. Based on a diet of 2000 kcal/day/person average, that's enough calories, from Iowa corn alone, to feed over 272 million people -- more than the entire population of Blue America. That doesn't count any other foodstuffs made anywhere else in the Blue states. So, you're right that Iowa could feed all of the blue state on its own. Granted, you can't live on corn alone, and a lot of that corn would get eaten up making meat for consumption, but clearly the blue states would have agricultural output to burn.

Yup. Wisconsin is justifiably famous for all the cheese and other dairy products it produces, and Michigan is renowned for all the late-season fruit it produces (apples, strawberries, blueberries, raspberries, etc.) And Washington and Oregon are also blue states with a lot of ag production.

The bottom line is that it is just plain SILLY to claim that the blue states "wouldn't be able to feed themselves".
 
And, when WWIII erupts and supply lines are cut off - the rationing will begin? Will the starving happen then? How many people starved in Europe in WWII? If you happen to have a big enough garden and can produce enough food to feed your family - will you be OK with the Government seizing that to either feed the troops or distribute evenly?

Part of why this Country has the ag subsidies it does is to guard against the rationing and shortfalls experienced in past wartimes. Your attitude reminds me a bit of the fable of the ant and the grasshopper. It may seem unimportant and inefficient to you now. It may be that there are better ways to spend time and resources..... until winter comes... until you need those food stores and the ability to produce things you can't otherwise produce.

Of course - since you talked about the Dutch.... maybe we should talk about Hongerwinter? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dutch_famine_of_1944

connie

Frankly, most Americans could use a winter of rationing. The average American is around 23 pounds overweight. Using the conventional 3500 calories per pound of fat, that means that if the average person's diet were cut, due to rationing, by 700 calories per day, it would take him nearly four months just to reach the top end of the "normal weight" category.

Regardless, we wouldn't be in the position of the Dutch. We have vastly more arable land per capita than them, even in the blue states, plus convenient access to one of the most productive fisheries in the world. And assuming it wasn't Canada that declared war on us, we'd have local access to their massive food exports.

I realize there's a natural desire to see the red states as something other than dead weight pulling the rest of America down, but if you're going to make that case, agriculture just isn't the place to focus. Blue America can easily feed itself. As I pointed out in another post, the caloric output of Iowa corn, alone, could feed the entire population of Blue America and then some.
 
I think you and many of your compatriots simply can't fathom that people don't want to live like you. And, would actually be and ARE happier with a simpler existence. Yes, the roads in rural areas would be crap. Many of them dirt. And you know what - if you like living in a rural area - that won't bother you. You likely can't fathom living without police and fire stations at the ready only seconds away - but if you like living in a rural area - you accept that the fact that the only reason you even bother to call the fire department is to try to keep the fire from spreading. Not to save your home or rescue you. You accept and live with those risks.

You want to pass judgement on that and act like it is "less" in your eyes and I am sure it is. But, many people actually LIKE life like that. Are happy like that. And in many ways feel like others are pushing their way of life on them. There still would be the major highway structure and the less used roads would fall into disrepair. And, so what? There may be less snow removal - so what? You plan and prepare for that. You keep non-perishibles. You keep a week or more of fuel on hand for a generator. You look at getting solar or wind energy. You barely need landlines anymore since cell companies want to offer service for their customers wherever they may go. So, you have to go to town for your mail, or ask a neighbor to get it for you. That is how people did it for hundreds of years, and many would be happy to do it that way again. Most of it is junk anyway.

But, you see these are things people accept and know when they choose to live where it is rural. If you want all those city ammenities - you live in the city. The fact that a big disparity exists between the the rural and the city - only bothers you people in the cities. Who can't fathom why anyone would want to live like a poor redneck. And, while true poverty is never a happy state, the vast majority of people who live in rural areas who grow most of their own food, who maybe still make most of their own clothes - are actually - fairly content with their lot in life. Its honestly people like you - thinking you know what is best for them, that create half the problem and the necessities you think they need, then try to force those "necessities" on them.

connie

Wouldn't we BOTH be happier if we split? You can enjoy your dirt roads, your high teen pregnancy rates, your obesity epidemic, your constant shootings, etc. And if you like the rural lifestyle, have a blast with it! I don't judge that. I just don't want to SUBSIDIZE it. I don't want to pay more to mail a letter to an efficiently-served city, because there's a hidden subsidy flowing to those who mail letters out to the boondocks. I don't want to pay extra gas taxes to pave all those countless thousands of miles of poorly utilized rural highways. I don't want to be paying to build "bridges to nowhere" in places like Alaska. Etc.
 
Wouldn't we BOTH be happier if we split? You can enjoy your dirt roads, your high teen pregnancy rates, your obesity epidemic, your constant shootings, etc. And if you like the rural lifestyle, have a blast with it! I don't judge that. I just don't want to SUBSIDIZE it. I don't want to pay more to mail a letter to an efficiently-served city, because there's a hidden subsidy flowing to those who mail letters out to the boondocks. I don't want to pay extra gas taxes to pave all those countless thousands of miles of poorly utilized rural highways. I don't want to be paying to build "bridges to nowhere" in places like Alaska. Etc.

Red-state denizens are just blissfully unaware of just how rapidly life would become much worse for them, if we actually did split along these lines. They are quite sincere in their thinking that they get no subsidies at all, but instead persistently believe it is THEY who are subsidizing the urban centers.
 
So your answer is - we can all loose some weight so food shortages and hunger would be no big deal? Really? And, how much do you want to bet the Dutch never thought it would happen to them. We are talking. about times of war and occupation. How many fishermen are going to be going out while submarines and destroyers are surrounding the coast?

Additionally, you assume that the ares you count as blue would likely remain that way and that you wouldn't have the influx of additional "refugees" from the south, and influx of additional illegal immigrants fleeing the south, etc. All those people take space to live and space to house and additional land to feed. Yes, you could feed yourselves. For a while - and assuming no major breakdown in supply chains or crops and lack of variety of crops.
 
So your answer is - we can all loose some weight so food shortages and hunger would be no big deal? Really? And, how much do you want to bet the Dutch never thought it would happen to them. We are talking. about times of war and occupation. How many fishermen are going to be going out while submarines and destroyers are surrounding the coast?

Additionally, you assume that the ares you count as blue would likely remain that way and that you wouldn't have the influx of additional "refugees" from the south, and influx of additional illegal immigrants fleeing the south, etc. All those people take space to live and space to house and additional land to feed. Yes, you could feed yourselves. For a while - and assuming no major breakdown in supply chains or crops and lack of variety of crops.

Your first paragraph is a truly paranoid scenario. We have FAR more submarines and destroyers than ANY other nation, or even coalition of nations. So how would that come about, that we would be blockaded by submarines and destroyers??

But you're probably right that the northern blue states would have to deal with a flood of desperate refugees fleeing the terrible conditions that would quickly arise in the newly independent South.
 
So your answer is - we can all loose some weight so food shortages and hunger would be no big deal? Really? And, how much do you want to bet the Dutch never thought it would happen to them. We are talking. about times of war and occupation. How many fishermen are going to be going out while submarines and destroyers are surrounding the coast?

Additionally, you assume that the ares you count as blue would likely remain that way and that you wouldn't have the influx of additional "refugees" from the south, and influx of additional illegal immigrants fleeing the south, etc. All those people take space to live and space to house and additional land to feed. Yes, you could feed yourselves. For a while - and assuming no major breakdown in supply chains or crops and lack of variety of crops.

Yes, in theory, any nation can be reduced to starvation if we assume the right chain of events. In this case, we're assuming that some currently-non-existent military superpower arises and decides to attack Blue America, despite Blue America's overwhelming conventional military, network of allies, and vast nuclear arsenal. Then we're assuming that all of the states that could single-handedly feed Blue America leave its union and, for whatever reason, engage in an embargo against food exports to Blue America, and that the coasts are effectively shut down to fishing, and that we can't get grain shipments from neighboring Canada, for some reason, and that these problems outlast the substantial fat stores of your average American. I'll grant that if all that happened, we'd have a problem. In the same sense, will you grant that if Red America falls into the sea, anyone who doesn't have a boat will drown?

There are countries that should reasonably worry about their ability to feed themselves if things fall apart -- countries with a very high ratio of population to arable land, and nearby hostile superpowers with vastly larger militaries than their own (the situation the Netherlands were in leading up to WWII). That doesn't describe the US or the hypothetical Blue America, though.
 
That is fine. But, its not the people in rural communities forcing that on us. You want to stop subsidizing it. Do so. That is fine with me. But, you all can't help yourselves as far as simply leaving people alone. You don't want to subsidize rural mail delivery. Stop it. The people will adapt. But, when we talk about stopping that - we get whining from the left - oh how are the poor and indigent ever to get their mail. So, really - who is creating that problem.. you all. You can leave them to their own devices to get their mail and they will - like people did for decades beforehand. You can stop building bridges to no-where.

And, as far as gas tax - if all you are oding is local communting you are likely not contributing all that much. Gas taxes - at least in my state also go to public transit. So, I give you this - you stop using the gas tax for public transit - which those of us who commute from rural areas have no interest in - and we'll reduce the amount of tax that anyone has to pay for gas.

connie
 
First of all - you assume the blue north would maintain its entire miltary and that none of those resources would be stretched thin with the disbanding of the union. Secondly, part of what the let howls about continually is reducing the military - so if you reduce your military - you are likely not to have the biggest military anymore. All we ever hear is how we overspend and need to reduce the military.... so when you do that - you may not be in control.

Aside from that -they don't necessarily need to actually have a blockade to enduce panic. It would only take one or two entering Blue State space to freak out those people who would otherwise be out there fishing and it could potentially have an impact.

Aside form that, like I said, I am sure the Dutch never thought that would happen to them..... so... never say never.

connie
 
Red-state denizens are just blissfully unaware of just how rapidly life would become much worse for them, if we actually did split along these lines. They are quite sincere in their thinking that they get no subsidies at all, but instead persistently believe it is THEY who are subsidizing the urban centers.

It does remind me a bit of how deluded the Southerners were in the years leading up to the Civil War. They simply didn't have a handle on how much of the industrial capacity and economic might of the United States were in the Union, which would make a Civil War un-winnable for them. They'd consumed too much of their own propaganda to see the situation clearly. Well, this is similar. Most of what is "world class" about the United States (the great universities, research institutions, stock exchanges, factories, etc.) exists in Blue America. Red America largely focuses on cheap-labor economics, in which it is essentially competing with third world countries, with some help from preferential access to Blue State consumers, and subsidies from Blue State taxpayers.
 
That is fine. But, its not the people in rural communities forcing that on us. You want to stop subsidizing it. Do so. That is fine with me. But, you all can't help yourselves as far as simply leaving people alone. You don't want to subsidize rural mail delivery. Stop it. The people will adapt. But, when we talk about stopping that - we get whining from the left - oh how are the poor and indigent ever to get their mail. So, really - who is creating that problem.. you all. You can leave them to their own devices to get their mail and they will - like people did for decades beforehand. You can stop building bridges to no-where.

This is a truly remarkable argument. You say that the subsidies to the red states and the rural areas would end if we simply said 'Stop it!'. I am sorry, but this is nonsense. The subsidies continue, not because the blue-state urban dwellers are somehow 'content' with the situation, but because the rural red states have outsized representation in our Congress, due both to gerrymandering and even more so to the very nature of our government, whereby a rural and low-populated state like North Dakota gets JUST AS MUCH representation in the Senate as highly urban and densely populated New York. THAT is why the subsidies continue.
 
That is fine. But, its not the people in rural communities forcing that on us. You want to stop subsidizing it. Do so. That is fine with me. But, you all can't help yourselves as far as simply leaving people alone. You don't want to subsidize rural mail delivery. Stop it. The people will adapt. But, when we talk about stopping that - we get whining from the left - oh how are the poor and indigent ever to get their mail. So, really - who is creating that problem.. you all. You can leave them to their own devices to get their mail and they will - like people did for decades beforehand. You can stop building bridges to no-where.

And, as far as gas tax - if all you are oding is local communting you are likely not contributing all that much. Gas taxes - at least in my state also go to public transit. So, I give you this - you stop using the gas tax for public transit - which those of us who commute from rural areas have no interest in - and we'll reduce the amount of tax that anyone has to pay for gas.

connie

We work hard to stop these subsidies to entitled red staters, and sometimes we succeed. For example, consider the infamous "bridge to nowhere." It was going to cost $400 million, to serve an island with 50 residents in Ketchikan, Alaska. It would have been a bridge on a scale with the Brooklyn Bridge and the Golden Gate bridge, with almost no traffic -- roughly the same traffic in a year that the Golden Gate bridge has in three days. It was a spectacularly inefficient use of federal dollars, but Alaska has vastly disproportionate voting power, thanks to the way our Senate and electoral college are set up, so it almost happened. Do you remember Ted Stevens's tantrum when challenged over it? Alaskans are so accustomed to seeing a ton of extra money flowing their way from Washington that they acted like it was an outrage that their pissant little island wouldn't have a federally-funded bridge that elsewhere in the country would need to be serving hundreds of thousands for justification. That's part of a process that results in Alaskans leaching over $7000 of net federal money, per capita.

Fortunately, the forces of reason won that "earmark" fight against the entitled red staters. But we lose a lot of other fights of that sort. Take Amtrak, for example. It is often branded a liberal boondoggle because it's a money losing form of mass transit. But the reason it loses money is that it's required, by the federal government, to serve a lot of mostly-red-state rural areas, rather than focusing on its profitable high-traffic corridors in the blue states.

Check out the table here:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_taxation_and_spending_by_state

Check out how blue the top of the list is, and how red the bottom of the list is. Thanks to the disproportionate representation of red states in Congress, and the shamelessness of Ted-Stevens-style red-state pork-barrelers, and all sorts of tax breaks tailor made for red states (such as farm subsidies, and child tax credits that reward breeders), the overall flow of funds is from Blue America to Red America.
 
This is a truly remarkable argument. You say that the subsidies to the red states and the rural areas would end if we simply said 'Stop it!'. I am sorry, but this is nonsense. The subsidies continue, not because the blue-state urban dwellers are somehow 'content' with the situation, but because the rural red states have outsized representation in our Congress, due both to gerrymandering and even more so to the very nature of our government, whereby a rural and low-populated state like North Dakota gets JUST AS MUCH representation in the Senate as highly urban and densely populated New York. THAT is why the subsidies continue.

Yep. If you do the math, it's astounding. For example, Wyoming has two Senators for about 570,000 people, while California has two for about 37,700,000 people. That gives one Wyoming resident the voting power in the Senate of 66 Californians. And it's not just the Senate. Because of how the Electoral College works, this gives Wyoming residents a vastly disproportionate say in who is president, too (each state has a number of electors equal to its members of the House plus the Senate, so the disproportionate representation of the Senate shows up again that way) Each Wyoming resident has nearly the voting power of four Californians when it comes tot he presidency. Hell, Wyoming even makes out in the House, since it's effectively rounded up to one House member, even though it has fewer residents that would justify one elsewhere (the average, nationally, is over 700,000 residents per House member, and Wyoming gets one with only 570,000 residents).

With the deck stacked so heavily in favor of the small states, in our system, of course they'll get the goodies. And this goes a long way towards explain why US cities are an absolute shame compared to cities in other wealthy nations (which are cleaner, have better mass transit, superior amenities, and much, much lower crime rates). Our whole system is rigged in favor of neglecting the interests of our urban dwellers, who, simply by way of clustering in a large population, get less voting power.
 
First of all - you assume the blue north would maintain its entire miltary and that none of those resources would be stretched thin with the disbanding of the union. Secondly, part of what the let howls about continually is reducing the military - so if you reduce your military - you are likely not to have the biggest military anymore. All we ever hear is how we overspend and need to reduce the military.... so when you do that - you may not be in control.

Aside from that -they don't necessarily need to actually have a blockade to enduce panic. It would only take one or two entering Blue State space to freak out those people who would otherwise be out there fishing and it could potentially have an impact.

Aside form that, like I said, I am sure the Dutch never thought that would happen to them..... so... never say never.

connie

As I pointed out, we could cut our military to one-quarter of what it currently is and STILL outspend any other nation on earth. As for the effect on fishing, I don't think it would be huge. In WWII, German U-boats were regularly spotted off the coast of the US, but fishing continued.
 
Back
Top