Arkady
President
You're quite right, of course, and I have no dispute with your economic reasoning. It just bothers me that a person like Trapdoor, who even says he has lived in Iowa, can be so uninformed about the agricultural productivity of the blue states.
I did a quick (5 minute) "back of the envelope" calculation of how many people blue state agriculture could support. Counting just output of corn, rice, potatoes, and wheat, I found there enough calories being produced to allow for 2000 calories per person per day for a population of around 900 million. Obviously, in the real world some of that would be wasted producing meat for consumption, which is inefficient, but also in the real world there are plenty of other crops produced in blue states (pineapples in Hawaii, all manner of vegetables in California, maple syrup in Vermont), as well as access to many key fisheries. So, it seems likely that Blue America would remain a major net food exporter.