New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Settled Science Update

the variables have always been present and the variables have always been changing, but the way heat expands into open space; the rate at which heat rises, has not changed... unless you break this law of physics.

I don't pass on talking points, I post my own opinions.

The fact that you don't have a real handle on the laws of physics does not mean that the scientists who do are wrong.
 
The fact that you don't have a real handle on the laws of physics does not mean that the scientists who do are wrong.
I merely asked you if you are attempting to break the law or aren't you? You are the one trying to have it both ways. You want to say heat is acting differently in the atmosphere without it doing so.

Heat is nothing more than molecules moving fast. Expansion is nothing more than the molecules moving at speed, bouncing into surrounding molecules. Once heat rises to the surface of the ocean it migrates into the atmosphere through evaporation. Once heat is rising in the atmosphere, via water vapor, it is going to collide into surrounding gas molecules, sure, but it isn't going to push back down into the ocean, it is going to rise up into the colder air of the atmosphere, where it can expand or cool down, and the water vapor will condense into rain or snow. None of that changes in the presence of CO2.

You desperately want to radiate heat back into the water through greenhouse gases. There is so little heat transfer in that process, it isn't worth mentioning. But whatever heat it does radiate back into the ocean is caught up immediately in evaporation; like you said earlier; it would create more evaporation, and off it goes into the upper atmosphere. CO2 doesn't result in global warming... global warming is a long term trend, after all the heat spikes and drops have been graphed for centuries, it isn't the result of interplay of chemicals in the atmosphere; the interplay of chemicals in the atmosphere has not changed, the laws of thermodynamics have not changed, carbon dioxide has been in the atmosphere as long as there has been an atmosphere; if it never resulted in global warming; which it obviously hasn't, it never will result in global warming; such predictions are nonsense, they can not possibly come true without changing the fundamental way that heat rises in the atmosphere.
 
this is so convoluted, it is like chasing a squirrel around a tree. You are not refuting that there was an 1100 mile ridge that pushed up on the ocean floor directly under the ice, or that it is still active?

Obviously there's a ridge there, and if there's a ridge there, it must have pushed up at some point. Also, portions of it are venting. What I'm saying is that you haven't presented the slightest evidence that the heat output of those vents is within even an order of magnitude of what would be needed to account for the meltage much less that a substantial portion of the heat from those vents actually reaches the ice. If you have evidence to support any of those ideas, just present it. None of the links you presented showed how much heat was being put out, total, by those vents, much less estimated what portion was reaching the surface. What we have been able to find are links where the actual scientists who are actively studying the ridge and the vents have dismissed the probability of it having played any substantial role in the melting.

Or maybe you really think that a tiny little 1100 mile crack in the earth's crust, spewing up 3000 degree Fahrenheit gas along an entire mountain ridge, would not represent any real volume of heat.

No. That's just the straw man you'd like to refute. But what's a "real volume of heat"? If the goal is to warm up a bathtub or even a sizable lake, I have no doubt the total heat output of that ridge is more than enough. I wouldn't even be surprised if the heat output today, relative to in earlier times when the ice wasn't retreating fast, was substantial relative to what would be needed to heat a bathtub or a lake. But we're not talking about a small-order task like that. We're talking about the heat needed to melt an average of 42,700 square kilometers of ice year after year for the last couple decades. The heat requirements for that are LITERALLY astronomical. It dwarfs the heat output from even the most dramatic volcanoes of modern times.

The actual entry point of Mt St Helens eruption was only one mile at the most, so plug in 1100 Mt St Helens eruptions into your quick math, and these are ongoing vents in the ocean floor, not a three day hiccup.

That would make perfect sense if what the ridge looked like was one Mt. St. Helens-size eruption after another, the entire way down the ridge, constantly. But, of course, that's not remotely what it looks like. The ridge may be 1100 miles long, but most of it is quiet. It looks like this:

AGAVE-07-001.jpg


It took work to find the actual vents, even after they located the most likely place along the ridge where vents might be located. This wasn't like finding 1100 exploding Mt. St. Helens end to end. It was like trying to find a needle in the haystack. Here's a video where they describe using water sampling to narrow down the most likely place along the ridge to find vents, and then using a robotic explorer to run a search pattern through that area until it found something.


Keep in mind that the scientists who actually went there, and spent months of their lives studying it, are convinced it hasn't played any significant part in the ice melting. If you can produce evidence that says they're wrong, do so.

Also, you seem to be under the impression that ridge just appeared. It didn't. It's was discovered in 1950 and has been there for something like 28 million hears (see 3:20 here:
) The only thing that happened recently is they found the ridge is more volcanically active than the old theories would have predicted. That doesn't mean it's more volcanically active, overall, than it was 100 years ago or a 1000 years ago, etc. It just means it's more volcanically active than we previously realized. So, not only would one need to show that the heat output is anything like what would be needed to melt that much ice, one would also need to show that's significantly higher heat output than in the past (otherwise, why did we have so much ice in polar regions before, compared to now?) A few recent volcanic eruptions there won't do that, since we don't know how many volcanic eruptions there were previously.

I can't fathom what you are thinking about warm water currents from surrounding oceans ... are you saying the ice cap was melted by those warm water currents instead of the geo-thermal activity?

Yes.

What temp do you think ocean water is at the Arctic Circle?
Depends where and when, obviously.

To take one example, consider Tromso, which is well within the Arctic Circle (latitude 69.65, compared to a little over 66 for the Arctic circle). Here's Tromso's record:

https://www.seatemperature.org/europe/norway/tromso-april.htm

As you'll see, it's currently averaging 4.6 degrees Celsius, which rises gradually to 11.3 degrees Celsius in August. That's 52.3 degrees Fahrenheit. That's brutally cold water by human standards, obviously, but it'll melt ice fast. To put it in perspective, right now we have water temperatures of 48 degrees Fahrenheit here in Boston, and we're not exactly fighting icebergs.

I can't imagine what you are thinking

No, but that can change. Do some remedial science reading. Get yourself a geophysics textbook and power through it. It needn't be anything terribly advanced. An intro text will do. Try this, for example:

https://www.amazon.com/Fundamentals...TF8&qid=1493422252&sr=8-2&keywords=geophysics

When your done, it should be easier for you to get where I'm coming from.

I can't imagine how in your head you have it calculated that heat in the air at the equator is descending into the water instead of rising up from it

You're confused. What's happening is that the sun is hitting open water (which has a very low albedo), and that's warming the water. That warm water from the equator is carried along oceanic currents towards the pole. How much heat it loses along the way has a great deal to do with how cold the water around the current is (since where the current meets colder surrounding water, heat will tend to flow from the current outward), as well as how cold the surrounding air is. Evaporation also factors in -- the drier the air, the faster the evaporation for a given heat level, and the more heat it loses in the process. Eventually, that warm current arrives north. The hotter it was when it started, and the warmer the water it passed along the way, and the warmer and moister the air it passed under, the warmer it will be at its end destination and the more ice it will melt. Meanwhile, the air currents will do much of the same -- carrying warmth from the equator northward, and the more warmth they retain when they get there, the more ice they'll melt (once they're above the freezing point, which they are for a significant chunk of the year)..
 
none came true and Gore still sold enough fools carbon offsets to by another Mansion
 
I merely asked you if you are attempting to break the law or aren't you? You are the one trying to have it both ways. You want to say heat is acting differently in the atmosphere without it doing so.

Heat is nothing more than molecules moving fast. Expansion is nothing more than the molecules moving at speed, bouncing into surrounding molecules. Once heat rises to the surface of the ocean it migrates into the atmosphere through evaporation. Once heat is rising in the atmosphere, via water vapor, it is going to collide into surrounding gas molecules, sure, but it isn't going to push back down into the ocean, it is going to rise up into the colder air of the atmosphere, where it can expand or cool down, and the water vapor will condense into rain or snow. None of that changes in the presence of CO2.

You desperately want to radiate heat back into the water through greenhouse gases. There is so little heat transfer in that process, it isn't worth mentioning. But whatever heat it does radiate back into the ocean is caught up immediately in evaporation; like you said earlier; it would create more evaporation, and off it goes into the upper atmosphere. CO2 doesn't result in global warming... global warming is a long term trend, after all the heat spikes and drops have been graphed for centuries, it isn't the result of interplay of chemicals in the atmosphere; the interplay of chemicals in the atmosphere has not changed, the laws of thermodynamics have not changed, carbon dioxide has been in the atmosphere as long as there has been an atmosphere; if it never resulted in global warming; which it obviously hasn't, it never will result in global warming; such predictions are nonsense, they can not possibly come true without changing the fundamental way that heat rises in the atmosphere.

CO2 has always warmed the Earth, and the rapidly increasing concentrations of it are warming the Earth at a rapidly increasing rate.
 
Obviously there's a ridge there, and if there's a ridge there, it must have pushed up at some point. Also, portions of it are venting. What I'm saying is that you haven't presented the slightest evidence that the heat output of those vents is within even an order of magnitude of what would be needed to account for the meltage much less that a substantial portion of the heat from those vents actually reaches the ice. If you have evidence to support any of those ideas, just present it. None of the links you presented showed how much heat was being put out, total, by those vents, much less estimated what portion was reaching the surface. What we have been able to find are links where the actual scientists who are actively studying the ridge and the vents have dismissed the probability of it having played any substantial role in the melting.



No. That's just the straw man you'd like to refute. But what's a "real volume of heat"? If the goal is to warm up a bathtub or even a sizable lake, I have no doubt the total heat output of that ridge is more than enough. I wouldn't even be surprised if the heat output today, relative to in earlier times when the ice wasn't retreating fast, was substantial relative to what would be needed to heat a bathtub or a lake. But we're not talking about a small-order task like that. We're talking about the heat needed to melt an average of 42,700 square kilometers of ice year after year for the last couple decades. The heat requirements for that are LITERALLY astronomical. It dwarfs the heat output from even the most dramatic volcanoes of modern times.



That would make perfect sense if what the ridge looked like was one Mt. St. Helens-size eruption after another, the entire way down the ridge, constantly. But, of course, that's not remotely what it looks like. The ridge may be 1100 miles long, but most of it is quiet. It looks like this:

AGAVE-07-001.jpg


It took work to find the actual vents, even after they located the most likely place along the ridge where vents might be located. This wasn't like finding 1100 exploding Mt. St. Helens end to end. It was like trying to find a needle in the haystack. Here's a video where they describe using water sampling to narrow down the most likely place along the ridge to find vents, and then using a robotic explorer to run a search pattern through that area until it found something.


Keep in mind that the scientists who actually went there, and spent months of their lives studying it, are convinced it hasn't played any significant part in the ice melting. If you can produce evidence that says they're wrong, do so.

Also, you seem to be under the impression that ridge just appeared. It didn't. It's was discovered in 1950 and has been there for something like 28 million hears (see 3:20 here:
) The only thing that happened recently is they found the ridge is more volcanically active than the old theories would have predicted. That doesn't mean it's more volcanically active, overall, than it was 100 years ago or a 1000 years ago, etc. It just means it's more volcanically active than we previously realized. So, not only would one need to show that the heat output is anything like what would be needed to melt that much ice, one would also need to show that's significantly higher heat output than in the past (otherwise, why did we have so much ice in polar regions before, compared to now?) A few recent volcanic eruptions there won't do that, since we don't know how many volcanic eruptions there were previously.



Yes.

Depends where and when, obviously.

To take one example, consider Tromso, which is well within the Arctic Circle (latitude 69.65, compared to a little over 66 for the Arctic circle). Here's Tromso's record:

https://www.seatemperature.org/europe/norway/tromso-april.htm

As you'll see, it's currently averaging 4.6 degrees Celsius, which rises gradually to 11.3 degrees Celsius in August. That's 52.3 degrees Fahrenheit. That's brutally cold water by human standards, obviously, but it'll melt ice fast. To put it in perspective, right now we have water temperatures of 48 degrees Fahrenheit here in Boston, and we're not exactly fighting icebergs.



No, but that can change. Do some remedial science reading. Get yourself a geophysics textbook and power through it. It needn't be anything terribly advanced. An intro text will do. Try this, for example:

https://www.amazon.com/Fundamentals...TF8&qid=1493422252&sr=8-2&keywords=geophysics

When your done, it should be easier for you to get where I'm coming from.



You're confused. What's happening is that the sun is hitting open water (which has a very low albedo), and that's warming the water. That warm water from the equator is carried along oceanic currents towards the pole. How much heat it loses along the way has a great deal to do with how cold the water around the current is (since where the current meets colder surrounding water, heat will tend to flow from the current outward), as well as how cold the surrounding air is. Evaporation also factors in -- the drier the air, the faster the evaporation for a given heat level, and the more heat it loses in the process. Eventually, that warm current arrives north. The hotter it was when it started, and the warmer the water it passed along the way, and the warmer and moister the air it passed under, the warmer it will be at its end destination and the more ice it will melt. Meanwhile, the air currents will do much of the same -- carrying warmth from the equator northward, and the more warmth they retain when they get there, the more ice they'll melt (once they're above the freezing point, which they are for a significant chunk of the year)..
Again, and God I love saying the same thing over and over and over and it still never registers. No one has measured what the heat output is on that 1100 mile long ridge. Especially no one has any idea how much heat was being vented during the period when the ice cap melted the most. Your biologist was saying that life forms have been there for 28 million years, unobserved. yeah, right, whatever, it isn't a geologist verifying that there was no activity in the past half century... again, how many links do I have to post before you admit that it has been a "hotbed of geo-thermal activity"? And no, some girl looking desperately for a vent in one location does not qualify as a verification of non-activity over the past 4 decades... get it through your head that it was directly because of all that activity that these scientists are now going there.

So here we go, just a few more hens teeth and I might be able to get a confession of faith from you. So now, you are all-in on ocean currents having brought warm(er) water to the polar regions, and you are finally agreeing with me that the ice melted from heat in the water, not air? I understand that you somehow think the water was heated by the air, which is exactly backwards, but you are agreeing that the ice caps were melted by heat in the water, not air?
 
Again, and God I love saying the same thing over and over and over and it still never registers. No one has measured what the heat output is on that 1100 mile long ridge. Especially no one has any idea how much heat was being vented during the period when the ice cap melted the most. Your biologist was saying that life forms have been there for 28 million years, unobserved. yeah, right, whatever, it isn't a geologist verifying that there was no activity in the past half century... again, how many links do I have to post before you admit that it has been a "hotbed of geo-thermal activity"? And no, some girl looking desperately for a vent in one location does not qualify as a verification of non-activity over the past 4 decades... get it through your head that it was directly because of all that activity that these scientists are now going there.

So here we go, just a few more hens teeth and I might be able to get a confession of faith from you. So now, you are all-in on ocean currents having brought warm(er) water to the polar regions, and you are finally agreeing with me that the ice melted from heat in the water, not air? I understand that you somehow think the water was heated by the air, which is exactly backwards, but you are agreeing that the ice caps were melted by heat in the water, not air?

You're ignoring the vast quantitative difference between a "hotbed of geological activity" of the magnitude that the evidence you've provided supports, and a "hotbed of geological activity" of the far greater magnitude needed to cause the kind of ice melting you're talking about and for which we'd expect to see very conspicuous evidence that is simply not there if checked.
 
You're ignoring the vast quantitative difference between a "hotbed of geological activity" of the magnitude that the evidence you've provided supports, and a "hotbed of geological activity" of the far greater magnitude needed to cause the kind of ice melting you're talking about and for which we'd expect to see very conspicuous evidence that is simply not there if checked.
I point blank addressed it; you are downplaying the importance of that activity, and pretending it was nothing, just so you can push your version of "science"... if your theory didn't require you to push lies, that would be a plus.

I'm still trying to get Arkady to come clean and choose a method - settle on a process that he thinks melted the ice cap. Cuz when I argued this with him years ago, he totally argued that the ice cap melted from air temps in the Arctic, he totally argued that greenhouse gases in the Arctic were melting the ice cap and he had all his facts lined up proving that this was how it happened and the same argument... that all the scientists say so... and he was still posting that way at the beginning of this thread until I pointed out that I was right all along, that it was heat in the water (not heat in the air) that melted the ice cap. But now he's still trying to say... that heat in the water... didn't come, couldn't come from an 1100 mile ridge that pushed up under the ice cap, no, then greenhouse gases can't still be blamed somehow for the melting of the ice cap... and you lose the main reason people dreamed up this theory; like I said, it was a swing and a miss, a really wrong explanation for what melted the Arctic ice cap; that's all it ever was.
 
Last edited:
No one has measured what the heat output is on that 1100 mile long ridge.

Yes. And yet, like the other denialists, you've fixated on that as an explanation for the melting. Funny, isn't it?

Especially no one has any idea how much heat was being vented during the period when the ice cap melted the most

It's been melting pretty consistently year after year.

Figure3_0301.png

It's not like it was stable, then declined rapidly, then was stable again, in which case we'd be looking hard for what was happening in that period of rapid decline. Instead, as with most glaciers, it's been receding for a long time and continues to do so. This is consistent with a pattern of global warming that's showing up in the large majority of places on the planet.

Your biologist was saying that life forms have been there for 28 million years, unobserved

He's talking specifically about species specialized for deep-sea vent dwelling. They've been evolving there for 28 million years, meaning that there have been vents there for that whole time. Maybe there is more activity there now than before. Maybe not. But clearly this isn't a ridge that suddenly pushed up a few years ago. Its an ancient feature that we recently discovered was more volcanically active than we'd realized.

how many links do I have to post before you admit that it has been a "hotbed of geo-thermal activity"?

I"m not denying it has been. I'm pointing out that you haven't shared any information that shows that there's been a large uptick in the geo-thermal output there coinciding with the decades of polar ice decline, much less that the level of the increase in heat output (if an increase even exists) is anywhere close to what would be needed to heat that much ice, nor that a substantial portion of that heat is actually reaching the surface in the area of that ice.

And no, some girl looking desperately for a vent in one location does not qualify as a verification of non-activity over the past 4 decades

You lost track of the argument. I'll help. You were pointing out that there'd be enough energy there to melt the ice if we had a perpetual Mount St. Helen's-size volcanic eruption every mile along the entire length of the ridge. That might be. But the point is that's not what's happening. The vast majority of that ridge is quiet, such that you actually have to search hard for active vents. Do those occasional vents put out enough heat to account for the literally astronomical task of melting that much ice at that pace? If you have evidence suggesting so, just share it.

So now, you are all-in on ocean currents having brought warm(er) water to the polar regions, and you are finally agreeing with me that the ice melted from heat in the water, not air?

You're hilarious. You're stating facts that I always acknowledged, and that are common knowledge for anyone with even a little science education, and acting like you're the one who convinced me of them. The idea that ocean currents bring equatorial warmth to the poles is something I picked up in elementary school at some point. It's the kind of thing they cover about the time you realize that New York City is further south than Barcelona, and London is at the same latitude as the Hudson Bay, and you try to figure out why their climates don't reflect that.

I understand that you somehow think the water was heated by the air

If that's what you think, reread. Yes, some heat gets transferred into the water from the air at times when the air is warmer than the water. That's just physics. But the primary mechanism I discussed was sunlight hitting the oceans directly and warming them.

As for whether the ice caps were melted by heat in the air or the water, again, obviously, it's both. Any time the air is warmer than the freezing temperature, it's going to be melting some ice (and even when it's below freezing, if it's warmer than the ice it's going to be warming the ice up and making it easier to melt later). But the heat content of water is much greater than air, so my understanding is the lion's share of heating is done by the water, not the air.
 
Last edited:
You're ignoring the vast quantitative difference between a "hotbed of geological activity" of the magnitude that the evidence you've provided supports, and a "hotbed of geological activity" of the far greater magnitude needed to cause the kind of ice melting you're talking about and for which we'd expect to see very conspicuous evidence that is simply not there if checked.
Exactly. The heat requirement for melting that much ice is mind-blowing -- it's a level that's a small order for the sun, but it dwarfs any observed geothermal heat output from known local phenomena. A sufficiently large number of non-stop Krakatoa-style eruptions would put out that kind of heat, but that's not what's happening nor is there any sign that something on that magnitude has happened at any point in recent history.
 
I point blank addressed it; you are downplaying the importance of that activity, and pretending it was nothing

Nobody is claiming it was nothing. There's just no reason to believe it was even within a couple orders of magnitude of what would be needed for melting all that ice.

I'm still trying to get Arkady to come clean and choose a method

No. What you're doing is floundering helplessly with your inability to understand simple physics. Obviously, anything touching the ice that's warmer than the freezing temperature will tend to melt the ice. That can include both air and water. Yes, the air in the Arctic is sometimes above freezing, and when that happens, it will tend to melt the ice from above. And warm water currents will tend to melt it from below. And even with the extreme angle of illumination, the sun also has a direct impact -- put a thermometer in the shade and one in the sun and you'll see a big difference, even up there. In June, in the daytime, the solar irradiance received at the North Pole is 322 W per square meter -- about what you'd get in mid-coast America in December. And along the Arctic circle, total solar irradiance can get up over 900 W per square meter in June.
 
Yes. And yet, like the other denialists, you've fixated on that as an explanation for the melting. Funny, isn't it?



It's been melting pretty consistently year after year.

Figure3_0301.png

It's not like it was stable, then declined rapidly, then was stable again, in which case we'd be looking hard for what was happening in that period of rapid decline. Instead, as with most glaciers, it's been receding for a long time and continues to do so. This is consistent with a pattern of global warming that's showing up in the large majority of places on the planet.



He's talking specifically about species specialized for deep-sea vent dwelling. They've been evolving there for 28 million years, meaning that there have been vents there for that whole time. Maybe there is more activity there now than before. Maybe not. But clearly this isn't a ridge that suddenly pushed up a few years ago. Its an ancient feature that we recently discovered was more volcanically active than we'd realized.



I"m not denying it has been. I'm pointing out that you haven't shared any information that shows that there's been a large uptick in the geo-thermal output there coinciding with the decades of polar ice decline, much less that the level of the increase in heat output (if an increase even exists) is anywhere close to what would be needed to heat that much ice, nor that a substantial portion of that heat is actually reaching the surface in the area of that ice.



You lost track of the argument. I'll help. You were pointing out that there'd be enough energy there to melt the ice if we had a perpetual Mount St. Helen's-size volcanic eruption every mile along the entire length of the ridge. That might be. But the point is that's not what's happening. The vast majority of that ridge is quiet, such that you actually have to search hard for active vents. Do those occasional vents put out enough heat to account for the literally astronomical task of melting that much ice at that pace? If you have evidence suggesting so, just share it.



You're hilarious. You're stating facts that I always acknowledged, and that are common knowledge for anyone with even a little science education, and acting like you're the one who convinced me of them. The idea that ocean currents bring equatorial warmth to the poles is something I picked up in elementary school at some point. It's the kind of thing they cover about the time you realize that New York City is further south than Barcelona, and London is at the same latitude as the Hudson Bay, and you try to figure out why their climates don't reflect that.



If that's what you think, reread. Yes, some heat gets transferred into the water from the air at times when the air is warmer than the water. That's just physics. But the primary mechanism I discussed was sunlight hitting the oceans directly and warming them.

As for whether the ice caps were melted by heat in the air or the water, again, obviously, it's both. Any time the air is warmer than the freezing temperature, it's going to be melting some ice (and even when it's below freezing, if it's warmer than the ice it's going to be warming the ice up and making it easier to melt later). But the heat content of water is much greater than air, so my understanding is the lion's share of heating is done by the water, not the air.

Hmm ... looks like there is a seasonal periodicity to ice melt / ice increase.
 
A look back at what they said, and who said it:

Wisconsin Senator Gaylord Nelson, the father of Earth Day said before the first Earth Day in 1970 that “the secretary of the Smithsonian Institute believes that in 25 years, somewhere between 75 and 80 percent of all the species of living animals will be extinct.”

Not to be outdone, Life Magazine reported that same year that “Scientists have solid experimental and theoretical evidence to support…the following predictions: In a decade, urban dwellers will have to wear gas masks to survive air pollution…by 1985 air pollution will have reduced the amount of sunlight reaching earth by one half….”

Stanford biologist Paul Ehrlich, the celebrated author of The Climate Bomb, wrote in 1971 that "by the year 2000 the United Kingdom will be simply a small group of impoverished islands, inhabited by some 70 million hungry people … If I were a gambler, I would take even money that England will not exist in the year 2000.”

In 1975 Newsweek ran a now-infamous article entitled “The Cooling World,” which cited several climate scientists in concluding that “the central fact is that…the earth’s climate seems to be cooling down…If the climate change is as profound as some of the pessimists fear, the resulting famines could be catastrophic.”

Global famine was a popular prediction in the 70’s. North Texas State professor Pete Gunter summed up the prevailing sentiment when he wrote in “The Lving Wilderness” that by “by the year 2000...the entire world, with the exception of Western Europe, North America, and Australia, will be in famine.”

In 1986, NASA scientist James Hansen testified before Congress that “global temperatures should be nearly 2 degrees higher in 20 years, ‘which is about the warmest the earth has been in the last 100,000 years.’”

Two years later, Dr. Hansen told an interviewer that in 20 years, the area below his New York City office would be completely changed, most notably that “the West Side Highway [which runs along the Hudson River] will be under water.”

Even the great Carl Sagan predicted in 1990 that “the planet could face an ‘ecological and agricultural catastrophe’ by the next decade if global warming trends continue.”

That same year, Dr. Michael Oppenheimer with The Environmental Defense Fund wrote:

By 1995, the greenhouse effect would be desolating the heartlands of North America and Eurasia with horrific drought, causing crop failures and food riots…”(By 1996) The Platte River of Nebraska would be dry, while a continent-wide black blizzard of prairie topsoil will stop traffic on interstates, strip paint from houses and shut down computers…The Mexican police will round up illegal American migrants surging into Mexico seeking work as field hands.

As recently as the last decade, both Dr. Hansen and Peter Wadhams, the head of the Polar Ocean Physics Group at the University of Cambridge, believe “that the Arctic is likely to become ice-free...as early as 2015.”

That’s actually two years later than Al Gore predicted in 2007, 2008, and 2009, when he cited what he called a scientific consensus to claim that the North Pole would be “ice free by 2013.”

That’s good, because Pentagon scientists sure weren’t in 2003, when their report “An Abrupt Climate Change Scenario and its Implications for United States National Security” warned that within 10 years, “it was not implausible” that parts of California would be flooded, parts of the Netherlands would be uninhabitable, and an unprecedented rise in hurricanes, tsunamis, and tornadoes would spark wars across the globe as people fought for increasingly scarce resources.

Not to be outdone, scientists with the United Nations Environment Programme warned in 2005 that man-made global warming would so decimate coastal areas as well as the Caribbean and Pacific islands that there would be upwards of 50 million “climate refugees by 2010.”

Of course, none of these scientific predictions—from Earth Day straight through today—have ever actually been right, but more predictions keep coming...along with more admonitions that the science is settled.


http://newstalk1130.iheart.com/onai...rief-history-of-fantastically-wrong-15767677/


I can't wait for the next round of predictions....:>)


Amazing.....

What is Algore to do?
 
Have a carbon offset Super Sale ASAP

And do CarbonCredit Stamps (like those S&H Greenstamps supermarkets used to do) but with Algore...you'd fill in the book then go get some carbon neutral gift (eco-conscious Lib chicks could get a solar powered Vibrator).

hqdefault.jpg
 
Last edited:
Yes. And yet, like the other denialists, you've fixated on that as an explanation for the melting. Funny, isn't it?



It's been melting pretty consistently year after year.

Figure3_0301.png

It's not like it was stable, then declined rapidly, then was stable again, in which case we'd be looking hard for what was happening in that period of rapid decline. Instead, as with most glaciers, it's been receding for a long time and continues to do so. This is consistent with a pattern of global warming that's showing up in the large majority of places on the planet.



He's talking specifically about species specialized for deep-sea vent dwelling. They've been evolving there for 28 million years, meaning that there have been vents there for that whole time. Maybe there is more activity there now than before. Maybe not. But clearly this isn't a ridge that suddenly pushed up a few years ago. Its an ancient feature that we recently discovered was more volcanically active than we'd realized.



I"m not denying it has been. I'm pointing out that you haven't shared any information that shows that there's been a large uptick in the geo-thermal output there coinciding with the decades of polar ice decline, much less that the level of the increase in heat output (if an increase even exists) is anywhere close to what would be needed to heat that much ice, nor that a substantial portion of that heat is actually reaching the surface in the area of that ice.



You lost track of the argument. I'll help. You were pointing out that there'd be enough energy there to melt the ice if we had a perpetual Mount St. Helen's-size volcanic eruption every mile along the entire length of the ridge. That might be. But the point is that's not what's happening. The vast majority of that ridge is quiet, such that you actually have to search hard for active vents. Do those occasional vents put out enough heat to account for the literally astronomical task of melting that much ice at that pace? If you have evidence suggesting so, just share it.



You're hilarious. You're stating facts that I always acknowledged, and that are common knowledge for anyone with even a little science education, and acting like you're the one who convinced me of them. The idea that ocean currents bring equatorial warmth to the poles is something I picked up in elementary school at some point. It's the kind of thing they cover about the time you realize that New York City is further south than Barcelona, and London is at the same latitude as the Hudson Bay, and you try to figure out why their climates don't reflect that.



If that's what you think, reread. Yes, some heat gets transferred into the water from the air at times when the air is warmer than the water. That's just physics. But the primary mechanism I discussed was sunlight hitting the oceans directly and warming them.

As for whether the ice caps were melted by heat in the air or the water, again, obviously, it's both. Any time the air is warmer than the freezing temperature, it's going to be melting some ice (and even when it's below freezing, if it's warmer than the ice it's going to be warming the ice up and making it easier to melt later). But the heat content of water is much greater than air, so my understanding is the lion's share of heating is done by the water, not the air.
holy sh*t, Arkady, what did you just admit? You don't believe the lie either? Yes the oceans are warmed by sunlight, but that's not what your theory says, yes the heat from the sun evaporates ocean water, but that's not what your theory says, yes, the heat from the water is transferred into the air through evaporation, but that's not what your theory says... are you feeling okay?
 
Nobody is claiming it was nothing. There's just no reason to believe it was even within a couple orders of magnitude of what would be needed for melting all that ice.



No. What you're doing is floundering helplessly with your inability to understand simple physics. Obviously, anything touching the ice that's warmer than the freezing temperature will tend to melt the ice. That can include both air and water. Yes, the air in the Arctic is sometimes above freezing, and when that happens, it will tend to melt the ice from above. And warm water currents will tend to melt it from below. And even with the extreme angle of illumination, the sun also has a direct impact -- put a thermometer in the shade and one in the sun and you'll see a big difference, even up there. In June, in the daytime, the solar irradiance received at the North Pole is 322 W per square meter -- about what you'd get in mid-coast America in December. And along the Arctic circle, total solar irradiance can get up over 900 W per square meter in June.
There's a wonderful reason to believe geo-thermal activity kicked up; the ice cap melted. In fact, you can measure what it took to melt the ice cap (like you did in earlier posts) and that will effectively show you what the uptick in geo-thermal activity was... so bloody easy, if you didn't have this completely insane greenhouse gas claim, demanding that all the ice was melted by carbon dioxide. No ice was melted by carbon dioxide, carbon dioxide doesn't melt ice any differently than the other 99.5% of the atmosphere; if the air temps were 40 degrees below freezing on average, there was zero NET melting due to carbon dioxide; quite the opposite; the air temps were adding to the ice cap, not depleting it. So, what was depleting the ice cap? answer: geo-thermal/volcanic activity.

I've only said that 100 or more times now, been saying it for years, and it is still true. You can come out of that cult science and come back to real world science... you can join us here in the sane world where heat rises and ice is melted by blast furnace temps, not sub-zero temps... won't you join us?

Alan Jackson - Softly and Tenderly live (Text/lyrics)
 
Last edited:
Back
Top