New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Settled Science Update

A little parable for you. Picture a ship at sea, with the water in the bilge rising fast. The ship's engineers tell the captain that he needs to have a hole in the hull patched, or find a way to pump the water out faster, or the ship will founder soon. The captain, being an utter imbecile, responds:

Water is an integral part of the circle of life. Without it, there would be no life on earth. It is part of the cycle between plants and animals. We are water based creatures; water is not a "pollutant", neither is sea water a pollutant; water has always resulted in more life, not less.​



Incorrect. Carbon dioxide has been producing global warming for many decades now.



There is a greenhouse effect in our atmosphere, and in the atmosphere of other planets we've studied. If it didn't exist, we'd all freeze solid every night, as the heat escaped directly into space. The physics of this are easy to understand and easy to demonstrate in experiments. CO2 (and some other gases) have a structure that causes resonating at infrared wavelengths. That means some of the infrared light that would have radiated directly into space instead gets transformed into kinetic molecular motion in the molecules of the atmosphere. The more greenhouse gases, the fewer photons of infrared radiation make it to space and the more of that energy goes to warm the atmosphere. The same thing keeps that heat, in the form of kinetic molecular motion, from exiting our atmosphere that keeps the air itself from doing so: gravity. Gravity holds those excited molecules around the Earth. Eventually that energy gets transformed back into infrared light and radiates out into space, but it's like a situation where you have a faucet emptying into a tub and a drain draining away from it. Restrict the flow of water out of the tub through the drain, and the water level will rise, even though eventually every bit of water that goes into it will leave it. Similarly, restrict the flow of infrared radiation way from the Earth, while the radiation coming in stays fairly constant, and the heat rises, even though eventually all that energy will leave into space. This isn't hard to understand. It's bizarre some people can't think their way through it.



You missed the point badly. Why is the water warmer? It's not volcanic activity on the Arctic ocean floor. No such activity has been observed, the pattern within the water column is inconsistent with the idea that the heat is radiating from the depths (there's less warming deep down than above), and we aren't measuring the changes in atmospheric chemistry or water chemistry that would show up with a big uptick in volcanic activity (e.g., CO2 isotopes associated with volcanoes as opposed to fossil fuels, plus other elements that are associated with volcanic outgassing). This is how science works. You're welcome to guess at alternative explanations for what we're seeing. But those hypotheses can be tested, by measuring various things. There's a particular pattern of data we'd expect to see if the polar ice was melting from global warming, and another pattern we'd expect to see if it was being melted geothermally. Turns out, the pattern of data is consistent with the AGW theory, not the geothermal one. It was worth looking into, but like all the other desperate attempts by the denialists, it was killed by the data. But, of course, mere real-world facts won't cause the know-nothing brigades to abandon their silly petty theory, even as the more serious climate change skeptics left it by the wayside long ago.
These are regional ideas trying to explain a global system.

An entire mountain range pushed up on the floor of the Arctic Ocean in the year 2000, so your non-stop corrections are nothing more than an attempt to bring us all back into ignorance. Scientists have since conceded that the ice melted due to water temps not air temps... exactly as I said to you a few years back. All this was posted at you. I guess if it contradicts your religion, you just discard... and go on preaching greenhouse theory.

Btw, high pressure zones doth not a glass ceiling make. The only thing that retains heat in the atmosphere is water... something on the scale of ...

water ...................... 95%
everything else ....... 5%
 
I don't know what you're saying. Does that mean you thought differently about it than you do now? In what ways were your thoughts then different from your thoughts now.

For me, the last few decades were a big deal. As a reminder:

upload_2017-4-25_11-19-53-png.35957


The way things looked in the mid-1980s, the global warming record just wasn't that clear -- the recent periods of cooling had been almost as many and frequent as the periods of warming, such that 1984 and 1944 had almost the same global temperature anomaly. But then things really changed. There were no more significant periods of cooling after that. Things oscillated from very rapid warming to a few years of fairly steady temps, to very rapid warming again. And the slope of the trend-line from the mid-80s onward was clearly much greater than it had been for the prior portion of the temperature record. That had a big impact on my beliefs. Did it have an impact on yours?


Didn't you already assign me a position? Why would I care to convince you of anything that runs contrary to your pre-fabricated paradigm?

Keep pushing the agenda relentlessly.......All unbelievers must be convinced.
 
Scientists have since conceded that the ice melted due to water temps not air temps

The water is warmer because the air has warmed around the globe. That's what the scientists believe. You want to imagine the existence of some un-observed vast uptick in geothermal heat under the pole, even though all the evidence we'd expect to see if that were the case just isn't there. We don't see deeper temps rising faster than shallower ones, as we would if the water column was heating from below. We see the opposite. We don't see an uptick in earthquakes in the area, as we would expect if there were more geothermal activity. We don't see the atmospheric and water chemistry changes we'd expect to see, if that were the case, either. What we see is just what we'd expect to see if the AGW theory were correct: we see warming in the vast majority of places around the globe, taking place across the course of decades, including ocean warming that's more intense near the surface (where being insulated by warmer air would make a difference), and less intense near the floor (where the heat change would be greatest if the heat were coming from below). You took your shot in the dark. The data proved it wrong. That's science for you. You can go on throwing all the emotion you want at that theory you desperately wish had been true. But that won't change the data.

Btw, high pressure zones doth not a glass ceiling make. The only thing that retains heat in the atmosphere is water... something on the scale of ...

water ...................... 95%
everything else ....... 5%

You just contradicted yourself. You said the only thing that retains heat in the atmosphere is water, and then said that 5% of what retains heat in the atmosphere isn't water. It's like you can't even keep command of your BS from the beginning of a sentence to the end.
 
A little parable for you. Picture a ship at sea, with the water in the bilge rising fast. The ship's engineers tell the captain that he needs to have a hole in the hull patched, or find a way to pump the water out faster, or the ship will founder soon. The captain, being an utter imbecile, responds:

Water is an integral part of the circle of life. Without it, there would be no life on earth. It is part of the cycle between plants and animals. We are water based creatures; water is not a "pollutant", neither is sea water a pollutant; water has always resulted in more life, not less.​



Incorrect. Carbon dioxide has been producing global warming for many decades now.



There is a greenhouse effect in our atmosphere, and in the atmosphere of other planets we've studied. If it didn't exist, we'd all freeze solid every night, as the heat escaped directly into space. The physics of this are easy to understand and easy to demonstrate in experiments. CO2 (and some other gases) have a structure that causes resonating at infrared wavelengths. That means some of the infrared light that would have radiated directly into space instead gets transformed into kinetic molecular motion in the molecules of the atmosphere. The more greenhouse gases, the fewer photons of infrared radiation make it to space and the more of that energy goes to warm the atmosphere. The same thing keeps that heat, in the form of kinetic molecular motion, from exiting our atmosphere that keeps the air itself from doing so: gravity. Gravity holds those excited molecules around the Earth. Eventually that energy gets transformed back into infrared light and radiates out into space, but it's like a situation where you have a faucet emptying into a tub and a drain draining away from it. Restrict the flow of water out of the tub through the drain, and the water level will rise, even though eventually every bit of water that goes into it will leave it. Similarly, restrict the flow of infrared radiation way from the Earth, while the radiation coming in stays fairly constant, and the heat rises, even though eventually all that energy will leave into space. This isn't hard to understand. It's bizarre some people can't think their way through it.



You missed the point badly. Why is the water warmer? It's not volcanic activity on the Arctic ocean floor. No such activity has been observed, the pattern within the water column is inconsistent with the idea that the heat is radiating from the depths (there's less warming deep down than above), and we aren't measuring the changes in atmospheric chemistry or water chemistry that would show up with a big uptick in volcanic activity (e.g., CO2 isotopes associated with volcanoes as opposed to fossil fuels, plus other elements that are associated with volcanic outgassing). This is how science works. You're welcome to guess at alternative explanations for what we're seeing. But those hypotheses can be tested, by measuring various things. There's a particular pattern of data we'd expect to see if the polar ice was melting from global warming, and another pattern we'd expect to see if it was being melted geothermally. Turns out, the pattern of data is consistent with the AGW theory, not the geothermal one. It was worth looking into, but like all the other desperate attempts by the denialists, it was killed by the data. But, of course, mere real-world facts won't cause the know-nothing brigades to abandon their silly petty theory, even as the more serious climate change skeptics left it by the wayside long ago.

If your parable were an accurate reflection of our current reality, it would take place with the boat sitting in three feet of water the whole time.
 
The water is warmer because the air has warmed around the globe. That's what the scientists believe. You want to imagine the existence of some un-observed vast uptick in geothermal heat under the pole, even though all the evidence we'd expect to see if that were the case just isn't there. We don't see deeper temps rising faster than shallower ones, as we would if the water column was heating from below. We see the opposite. We don't see an uptick in earthquakes in the area, as we would expect if there were more geothermal activity. We don't see the atmospheric and water chemistry changes we'd expect to see, if that were the case, either. What we see is just what we'd expect to see if the AGW theory were correct: we see warming in the vast majority of places around the globe, taking place across the course of decades, including ocean warming that's more intense near the surface (where being insulated by warmer air would make a difference), and less intense near the floor (where the heat change would be greatest if the heat were coming from below). You took your shot in the dark. The data proved it wrong. That's science for you. You can go on throwing all the emotion you want at that theory you desperately wish had been true. But that won't change the data.



You just contradicted yourself. You said the only thing that retains heat in the atmosphere is water, and then said that 5% of what retains heat in the atmosphere isn't water. It's like you can't even keep command of your BS from the beginning of a sentence to the end.
alright, either you have gone senile, or forgotten everything, or you are just flat out lying.

Libs have a track record of doing this; keep telling the same lies over and over, if you get caught, ignore it, keep on lying, eventually, your lies will prevail.

I'm not going back and finding everything again for you, I will do one search and you get whatever, why should I bother? I've already done all this ten times with you and it never makes impact, you are a religious nut, reality means nothing to you, you will go on believing that Arctic air temps warmed the water (impossible; Arctic air temps average 20 degrees below freezing, Arctic air temps never melt any ice) ... and melted the ice cap!!!! Totally insane, completely ludicrous, but you will go on believing it, because it is your religion.

search: arctic ocean volcanic activity (Link)
 
The water is warmer because the air has warmed around the globe. That's what the scientists believe. You want to imagine the existence of some un-observed vast uptick in geothermal heat under the pole, even though all the evidence we'd expect to see if that were the case just isn't there. We don't see deeper temps rising faster than shallower ones, as we would if the water column was heating from below. We see the opposite. We don't see an uptick in earthquakes in the area, as we would expect if there were more geothermal activity. We don't see the atmospheric and water chemistry changes we'd expect to see, if that were the case, either. What we see is just what we'd expect to see if the AGW theory were correct: we see warming in the vast majority of places around the globe, taking place across the course of decades, including ocean warming that's more intense near the surface (where being insulated by warmer air would make a difference), and less intense near the floor (where the heat change would be greatest if the heat were coming from below). You took your shot in the dark. The data proved it wrong. That's science for you. You can go on throwing all the emotion you want at that theory you desperately wish had been true. But that won't change the data.



You just contradicted yourself. You said the only thing that retains heat in the atmosphere is water, and then said that 5% of what retains heat in the atmosphere isn't water. It's like you can't even keep command of your BS from the beginning of a sentence to the end.

exactly wrong -

"global warming" was supposed to lead to melting ice caps, cooling the ocean, and possibly interfering with important ocean currents like the gulf stream.

so far, this is YET ANOTHER prediction which has failed to come true.
 
alright, either you have gone senile, or forgotten everything, or you are just flat out lying.

Libs have a track record of doing this; keep telling the same lies over and over, if you get caught, ignore it, keep on lying, eventually, your lies will prevail.

I'm not going back and finding everything again for you, I will do one search and you get whatever, why should I bother? I've already done all this ten times with you and it never makes impact, you are a religious nut, reality means nothing to you, you will go on believing that Arctic air temps warmed the water (impossible; Arctic air temps average 20 degrees below freezing, Arctic air temps never melt any ice) ... and melted the ice cap!!!! Totally insane, completely ludicrous, but you will go on believing it, because it is your religion.

search: arctic ocean volcanic activity (Link)
Nobody is denying there are volcanoes under the arctic. The point is there's no evidence they're what's causing any significant share of the melting, or even that such activity has increased.

Take a look at the first two links that comes up in your Google Search. It's a right wing blog run by a self-publishing crackpot who spends his days warning of a coming ice age. The blogger isn't a climatologist, oceanographer, geophysicist, vulcanologist, or any other kind of scientist. He's just a flake with an amateurish Internet site. Cranks like that are commonplace, and in the Internet age, they can get their messages out better than in the old days when they mostly wandered around public parks yelling their conspiracy theories at strangers.

Now, scroll down you link of results until you get to something by a news source anyone's actually heard of linking to comments from an esteemed scientist about the volcano/ice link:

https://dotearth.blogs.nytimes.com/...oes-under-arctic-sea-ice/comment-page-9/?_r=0

Peter Winsor, Wood Hole Oceanographic Institution: .... So, heat is released from volcanic activity, both from explosive larger events and more broad diffusive events, and in addition, from background geothermal heating. None of these will have any impact on the Arctic sea ice as the heat is trapped in the deep ocean and is unable to communicate with the upper ocean and sea ice. However, heat store in the Atlantic Layer (temperature maxima at ~300 m) and in waters of Pacific origin (maxima at ~50 m depth in the western Arctic) are prime candidates for releasing heat to the underside of the Arctic ice.

Jamie Morison, University of Washington:
It occurs to me that we have primary evidence that heat from the bottom is not reaching the ice. Temperature profiles from virtually everywhere in the Arctic Ocean display a maximum temperature at a depth from 200-400 [meters]. This is associated with the Atlantic Water entering the basin from the Norwegian Sea. Fundamental laws of physics require that below the depth of this maximum, the heat flux is downward. Very near the bottom temperatures have been found to increase with depth indicating a small upward heat flux from geothermal sources, which help to heat only the very deepest water.... The heat flux above the Atlantic temperature maximum is upward. The rate of this flux of Atlantic Water heat flux is variable depending on depth of the maximum and overlying stratification (stratification is controlled by salinity in the Arctic Ocean). Treshnikov estimated it from Atlantic Water heat content to be a couple of Watt/m2 in much of the Euarasian Basin. It is smaller farther from Fram Strait and greater near Fram Strait. How this flux changes is potentially very important to the ice cover. Changes in geothermal heat flux are not.​

Jeff Severinghaus, Scripps Institution of Oceanography: ....the average heat added from volcanoes to the ocean is of order 0.1 Watt per square meter. But the heat added (or removed) to the ocean from the sun and atmosphere is of order 100 Watt per square meter. So it is very hard for volcanoes to compete.​

As is so often the case with these alternate theories, you wind up having to choose which to believe: a large number of highly accomplished scientists actually engaged in studying the phenomenon in question, or whether to believe some non-scientist with a web page full of crackpot theories. The right-wing know-nothings reliably choose the latter.

If you follow up on the "experts" those crackpot bloggers quote, you'll find that they nearly always fit a particular profile. They're pretty much never leading scientists in their field, much less ones actively researching the questions being addressed. Instead, they're generally retirees or semi-retirees, spending their days seeking attention with armchair quarterbacking of the professionals engaged in the work. The most frequent profile is a retired petroleum geologist -- some graying dude with an undergrad or masters degree in geology from a non-competitive university, obtained back in the 60s or 70s. These aren't experts in the topic at hand, by any stretch of the imagination. They're just bored old people speculating about something they read in the paper, who provide convenient quotations for the bloggers to use, since at least they're nominally scientists. The "scientists" may be "published," but only in the sense that they hand their garbage papers to some joke outlet like junkscience.com which exists to put a shoddy academic veneer on political propaganda.
 
Last edited:
exactly wrong -

"global warming" was supposed to lead to melting ice caps, cooling the ocean, and possibly interfering with important ocean currents like the gulf stream.

so far, this is YET ANOTHER prediction which has failed to come true.
Wrong. You're desperately lost here. Global warming was never supposed to lead to cooling of the ocean. Yes, in theory, it could lead to some spots being cooler, if changes in salinity slow currents and thus result in more heat being concentrated near the equator. But the expectation was always that average ocean temperatures would rise, playing a big part in rising sea levels. And of course, they have been warming, just as predicted.

I urge you to pick up a copy of the latest IPCC report..... or, really, any of the major IPCC reports. You haven't even begun to do the most remedial reading yet, and you can't hope to discuss this sensibly until you do. At least do yourself the favor of reading the executive summary.
 
Wrong. You're desperately lost here. Global warming was never supposed to lead to cooling of the ocean. Yes, in theory, it could lead to some spots being cooler, if changes in salinity slow currents and thus result in more heat being concentrated near the equator. But the expectation was always that average ocean temperatures would rise, playing a big part in rising sea levels. And of course, they have been warming, just as predicted.

I urge you to pick up a copy of the latest IPCC report..... or, really, any of the major IPCC reports. You haven't even begun to do the most remedial reading yet, and you can't hope to discuss this sensibly until you do. At least do yourself the favor of reading the executive summary.
debating with the uniformed an unread is like shooting fish in barrel.

here's your last link of the day ark. I'm through arguing with true believer morons.

http://www.sciencemag.org/news/2016/06/crippled-atlantic-conveyor-triggered-ice-age-climate-change
 
Nobody is denying there are volcanoes under the arctic. The point is there's no evidence they're what's causing any significant share of the melting, or even that such activity has increased.

Take a look at the first two links that comes up in your Google Search. It's a right wing blog run by a self-publishing crackpot who spends his days warning of a coming ice age. The blogger isn't a climatologist, oceanographer, geophysicist, vulcanologist, or any other kind of scientist. He's just a flake with an amateurish Internet site. Cranks like that are commonplace, and in the Internet age, they can get their messages out better than in the old days when they mostly wandered around public parks yelling their conspiracy theories at strangers.

Now, scroll down you link of results until you get to something by a news source anyone's actually heard of linking to comments from an esteemed scientist about the volcano/ice link:

https://dotearth.blogs.nytimes.com/...oes-under-arctic-sea-ice/comment-page-9/?_r=0

Peter Winsor, Wood Hole Oceanographic Institution: .... So, heat is released from volcanic activity, both from explosive larger events and more broad diffusive events, and in addition, from background geothermal heating. None of these will have any impact on the Arctic sea ice as the heat is trapped in the deep ocean and is unable to communicate with the upper ocean and sea ice. However, heat store in the Atlantic Layer (temperature maxima at ~300 m) and in waters of Pacific origin (maxima at ~50 m depth in the western Arctic) are prime candidates for releasing heat to the underside of the Arctic ice.

Jamie Morison, University of Washington:
It occurs to me that we have primary evidence that heat from the bottom is not reaching the ice. Temperature profiles from virtually everywhere in the Arctic Ocean display a maximum temperature at a depth from 200-400 [meters]. This is associated with the Atlantic Water entering the basin from the Norwegian Sea. Fundamental laws of physics require that below the depth of this maximum, the heat flux is downward. Very near the bottom temperatures have been found to increase with depth indicating a small upward heat flux from geothermal sources, which help to heat only the very deepest water.... The heat flux above the Atlantic temperature maximum is upward. The rate of this flux of Atlantic Water heat flux is variable depending on depth of the maximum and overlying stratification (stratification is controlled by salinity in the Arctic Ocean). Treshnikov estimated it from Atlantic Water heat content to be a couple of Watt/m2 in much of the Euarasian Basin. It is smaller farther from Fram Strait and greater near Fram Strait. How this flux changes is potentially very important to the ice cover. Changes in geothermal heat flux are not.​

Jeff Severinghaus, Scripps Institution of Oceanography: ....the average heat added from volcanoes to the ocean is of order 0.1 Watt per square meter. But the heat added (or removed) to the ocean from the sun and atmosphere is of order 100 Watt per square meter. So it is very hard for volcanoes to compete.​

As is so often the case with these alternate theories, you wind up having to choose which to believe: a large number of highly accomplished scientists actually engaged in studying the phenomenon in question, or whether to believe some non-scientist with a web page full of crackpot theories. The right-wing know-nothings reliably choose the latter.

If you follow up on the "experts" those crackpot bloggers quote, you'll find that they nearly always fit a particular profile. They're pretty much never leading scientists in their field, much less ones actively researching the questions being addressed. Instead, they're generally retirees or semi-retirees, spending their days seeking attention with armchair quarterbacking of the professionals engaged in the work. The most frequent profile is a retired petroleum geologist -- some graying dude with an undergrad or masters degree in geology from a non-competitive university, obtained back in the 60s or 70s. These aren't experts in the topic at hand, by any stretch of the imagination. They're just bored old people speculating about something they read in the paper, who provide convenient quotations for the bloggers to use, since at least they're nominally scientists. The "scientists" may be "published," but only in the sense that they hand their garbage papers to some joke outlet like junkscience.com which exists to put a shoddy academic veneer on political propaganda.
refuse to click on the Links? Afraid these are the same climate scientists who thought it was climate change and learned from real science they were wrong... something you steadfastly refuse to do?

maybe I can copy/paste the articles into these posts, will you read them if I do that for you?



logo.png


WRITTEN BY JAMES KAMIS, GUEST POST ON AUGUST 26, 2016. POSTED IN LATEST NEWS

Geologically Warmed Ocean is Melting Arctic Sea Ice – Not Climate Change
mid-arctic-rift.jpg

Figure 1.) In the 12 months up to July 14, 2016, 43 earthquakes with a magnitude of 4 or higher on the Richter scale occurred along the Mid-Arctic Rift / Fault, mostly at a depth of 10 km (6.214 miles). (see here).

Above-average melting of the Arctic Sea Ice in the years 2007, 2012, and 2015 is here contended to be directly related to increased heat and chemically charged fluid flow from the 3,500-mile long seafloor Mid-Arctic Rift / Fault System and not atmospheric global warming.


This contention is backed by large amounts reliable data and research from varying sources; earthquake frequency and magnitude data, atmospheric methane concentration maps, and most importantly just released research that proves the Mid-Arctic Rift / Fault System (Figure 1) acts as a giant seawater heating and circulating system. In a broader sense the notion that deep ocean seafloor geological forces can influence or drive above average Polar Ice Cap melting rates fits perfectly into the basic tenets of the Plate Climatology Theory.

Details substantiating these contentions are as follows.

Let’s begin by discussing the most telling, game changing, and newest piece of information. A study by the Helmholtz Centre for Polar Marine Research which proves that the Mid-Arctic Rift / Fault trend is a giant seawater circulating system that captures, super-heats, chemically charges, and then expulses massive volumes of this seawater into the overlying Arctic Ocean (see here and quote below).

“Until now, scientists thought that serpentinite only forms near fault zones and near the surface. “Our data now suggest that water circulates through extensive areas of the young oceanic lithosphere and is bound in the rock. This releases heat and methane, for example, to a degree not previously foreseen,” says Vera Schlindwein.”

“Oceanographers are interested in heat influx and trace gasses in the water column in such areas, which were previously thought to be non-volcanic and “cold”. Biologists are interested in the increased outflow of methane and sulfide on the sea floor that is to be expected in many areas and that represents an important basis of life for deep-sea organisms.”

This realization is game changing because it verifies that significant volumes of geologically heated seawater are in fact being pumped onto the base of the Arctic Sea Ice, especially directly above the fault trend. This contradicts traditional / consensus assumptions that deep ocean seafloor geological fluid emission volumes are insignificant, and therefore not worthy of consideration when constructing Arctic Sea Ice Melt computer models. Quite obviously climate scientists now need to properly integrate the effect of geological forces into all future Arctic Sea ice computer models. Importantly the existence of giant deep ocean fault related seawater circulating systems was postulated three years ago in previous Climate Change Dispatch articles (see here, here, and here).

Next, let’s discuss how frequently and for what duration the giant Mid-Arctic Rift / Fault Circulating System is active. Is it always active or just once in awhile? Data is sparse however it is likely that small segments are always active, while larger segments are only active for short time periods. For instance, during the last 12 months, a 2,000-mile portion of the system has experienced 43 earthquakes (Figure 1) and pulsed a huge concentration of methane gas into the atmosphere (Figure 2). The earthquake activity and atmospheric methane pulse strongly indicate that this large segment of the circulating system has been, and still is actively emitting significant amounts of sea ice melting and super-heated seawater into the Arctic Ocean.


~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ continued ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
 
Last edited:
refuse to click on the Links? Afraid these are the same climate scientists who thought it was climate change and learned from real science they were wrong... something you steadfastly refuse to do?

maybe I can copy/paste the articles into these posts, will you read them if I do that for you?

logo.png


WRITTEN BY JAMES KAMIS, GUEST POST ON AUGUST 26, 2016. POSTED IN LATEST NEWS

Geologically Warmed Ocean is Melting Arctic Sea Ice – Not Climate Change
mid-arctic-rift.jpg

Figure 1.) In the 12 months up to July 14, 2016, 43 earthquakes with a magnitude of 4 or higher on the Richter scale occurred along the Mid-Arctic Rift / Fault, mostly at a depth of 10 km (6.214 miles). (see here).

Above-average melting of the Arctic Sea Ice in the years 2007, 2012, and 2015 is here contended to be directly related to increased heat and chemically charged fluid flow from the 3,500-mile long seafloor Mid-Arctic Rift / Fault System and not atmospheric global warming.


This contention is backed by large amounts reliable data and research from varying sources; earthquake frequency and magnitude data, atmospheric methane concentration maps, and most importantly just released research that proves the Mid-Arctic Rift / Fault System (Figure 1) acts as a giant seawater heating and circulating system. In a broader sense the notion that deep ocean seafloor geological forces can influence or drive above average Polar Ice Cap melting rates fits perfectly into the basic tenets of the Plate Climatology Theory.

Details substantiating these contentions are as follows.

Let’s begin by discussing the most telling, game changing, and newest piece of information. A study by the Helmholtz Centre for Polar Marine Research which proves that the Mid-Arctic Rift / Fault trend is a giant seawater circulating system that captures, super-heats, chemically charges, and then expulses massive volumes of this seawater into the overlying Arctic Ocean (see here and quote below).

“Until now, scientists thought that serpentinite only forms near fault zones and near the surface. “Our data now suggest that water circulates through extensive areas of the young oceanic lithosphere and is bound in the rock. This releases heat and methane, for example, to a degree not previously foreseen,” says Vera Schlindwein.”

“Oceanographers are interested in heat influx and trace gasses in the water column in such areas, which were previously thought to be non-volcanic and “cold”. Biologists are interested in the increased outflow of methane and sulfide on the sea floor that is to be expected in many areas and that represents an important basis of life for deep-sea organisms.”

This realization is game changing because it verifies that significant volumes of geologically heated seawater are in fact being pumped onto the base of the Arctic Sea Ice, especially directly above the fault trend. This contradicts traditional / consensus assumptions that deep ocean seafloor geological fluid emission volumes are insignificant, and therefore not worthy of consideration when constructing Arctic Sea Ice Melt computer models. Quite obviously climate scientists now need to properly integrate the effect of geological forces into all future Arctic Sea ice computer models. Importantly the existence of giant deep ocean fault related seawater circulating systems was postulated three years ago in previous Climate Change Dispatch articles (see here, here, and here).

Next, let’s discuss how frequently and for what duration the giant Mid-Arctic Rift / Fault Circulating System is active. Is it always active or just once in awhile? Data is sparse however it is likely that small segments are always active, while larger segments are only active for short time periods. For instance, during the last 12 months, a 2,000-mile portion of the system has experienced 43 earthquakes (Figure 1) and pulsed a huge concentration of methane gas into the atmosphere (Figure 2). The earthquake activity and atmospheric methane pulse strongly indicate that this large segment of the circulating system has been, and still is actively emitting significant amounts of sea ice melting and super-heated seawater into the Arctic Ocean.


~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ continued ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
It works like this.

Past research studies, most notably by Woods Hole Oceanographic Institute, have proved that earthquake activity along the Mid-Arctic Rift / Fault System is associated with significant amounts of volcanic activity such as deep ocean seafloor; lava flows, hydrothermal vents (chemical emitting hot springs), and underwater volcanoes (see here and quote below).

“A major part of Earth’s volcanism happens at the so-called mid-ocean ridges and, therefore, completely undetected on the seafloor. There, the continental plates drift apart; liquid magma intrudes into the gap and constantly forms new seafloor through countless volcanic eruptions. Accompanied by smaller earthquakes, which go unregistered on land, lava flows onto the seafloor. These unspectacular eruptions usually last for only a few days or weeks.”

Additional confirmation that this giant deep ocean geological heat emitting circulating system exists and is currently active comes from another data source, the National Aeronautics and Atmospheric Administration methane reading satellites (Figure 2). Granted that the Figure 2 map is very difficult to read and understand, however, it is well worth the time to do so as the authors of the Arctic News blog did in their recent posting (see here). The satellite readings clearly show the presence of a long and linear high concentration methane anomaly in the atmosphere directly above the entire fault trend (green highlighted line) on an active earthquake day July 16, 2016.


This linear methane trend is the result of earthquake-induced seawater heat pulse along the fault that warms methane containing rock layers adjacent to the fault. The warmed water acts to melt the frozen methane and then release it into the open fault fractures. The methane bubbles move upward along the fractures into the overlying ocean and then vertically upward into the atmosphere.


methane_levels.jpg

Figure 2: High methane levels (bright pink highlights) on July 16, 2016, along the Mid-Arctic Rift / Fault (bright green line) that crosses the entire Arctic Ocean. (see here)

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ continued ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
 
It works like this.

Past research studies, most notably by Woods Hole Oceanographic Institute, have proved that earthquake activity along the Mid-Arctic Rift / Fault System is associated with significant amounts of volcanic activity such as deep ocean seafloor; lava flows, hydrothermal vents (chemical emitting hot springs), and underwater volcanoes (see here and quote below).

“A major part of Earth’s volcanism happens at the so-called mid-ocean ridges and, therefore, completely undetected on the seafloor. There, the continental plates drift apart; liquid magma intrudes into the gap and constantly forms new seafloor through countless volcanic eruptions. Accompanied by smaller earthquakes, which go unregistered on land, lava flows onto the seafloor. These unspectacular eruptions usually last for only a few days or weeks.”

Additional confirmation that this giant deep ocean geological heat emitting circulating system exists and is currently active comes from another data source, the National Aeronautics and Atmospheric Administration methane reading satellites (Figure 2). Granted that the Figure 2 map is very difficult to read and understand, however, it is well worth the time to do so as the authors of the Arctic News blog did in their recent posting (see here). The satellite readings clearly show the presence of a long and linear high concentration methane anomaly in the atmosphere directly above the entire fault trend (green highlighted line) on an active earthquake day July 16, 2016.


This linear methane trend is the result of earthquake-induced seawater heat pulse along the fault that warms methane containing rock layers adjacent to the fault. The warmed water acts to melt the frozen methane and then release it into the open fault fractures. The methane bubbles move upward along the fractures into the overlying ocean and then vertically upward into the atmosphere.


methane_levels.jpg

Figure 2: High methane levels (bright pink highlights) on July 16, 2016, along the Mid-Arctic Rift / Fault (bright green line) that crosses the entire Arctic Ocean. (see here)

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ continued ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Next, Iceland Volcanic activity has greatly increased during the last twelve months. Iceland lies at the southern end of the Mid-Arctic Rift / Fault System and is the only land-based portion of the fault. Volcanic activity here is monitored, however, the remaining deep ocean portions of the fault system are poorly monitored. Increased volcanic activity on Iceland is here contended to be an excellent visual confirmation that a large segment of the Mid-Arctic Rift / Fault System is currently active.


Finally, let’s compare Average Monthly Arctic Sea Ice Extent vs. periods of increased geological activity along the Mid-Arctic Rift / Fault System (Figure 3). This graph illustrates that two time periods of very high melt rate stand out, 2007 and 2012. Research by Woods Hole Oceanographic Institute as mentioned above clearly shows that a Mid-Arctic Rift / Fault System was volcanically active in the 2007 time frame and other research show that the system was also earthquake active in the 2012 time frame (see here).


arctic_sea_ice_extent.jpg


Figure 3: Average Monthly Arctic Sea Ice Extent vs. periods of increased geological activity along the Mid-Arctic Rift / Fault System


In conclusion, worldwide atmospheric temperatures and CO2 concentrations have risen at modest and constant rates for many years at what can be characterized as normal post ice age values. Arctic Sea Ice Melting rates during the 1978 to 2005 time period correlated well with a post ice age warming earth, however starting in 2006 things changed. This disconnect is here explained as convincing evidence that another natural force is at work during this time period, specifically Geological Sea Ice Melting Forces.


James Edward Kamis is a Geologist and AAPG member of 42 years with a B.S. and M.S. in geology who has always been fascinated by the connection between Geology and Climate. More than 11 years of research / observation have convinced him that the Earth’s Heat Flow Engine, which drives the outer crustal plates, is also an important driver of the Earth’s climate. The Plate Climatology Theory (plateclimatology.com) was recently presented at the annual 2016 American Metrological Society Conference in New Orleans, LA. (see here)


REFERENCES


http://arctic-news.blogspot.com/2016/07/high-methane-levels-follow-earthquake-in-arctic-ocean.html


https://www.carbonbrief.org/natural...pace-of-arctic-summer-sea-ice-loss-study-says


http://www.colorado.edu/today/2015/...tic-sea-ice-loss-expected-be-bumpy-short-term


https://www.whoi.edu/page.do?pid=7545&tid=3622&cid=44586


http://climatechangedispatch.com/gi...lts-actively-move-emit-methane-and-emit-heat/


http://nsidc.org/arcticseaicenews/2015/09/


https://www.carbonbrief.org/five-charts-that-show-how-arctic-and-antarctic-sea-ice-is-faring-in-2015


http://phys.org/news/2016-06-earthquakes-ultraslow-mid-ocean-ridges.html


https://www.whoi.edu/page.do?pid=7545&tid=3622&cid=44586


https://theextinctionprotocol.wordp...arthquakes-strike-near-north-and-south-poles/
 
A look back at what they said, and who said it:

Wisconsin Senator Gaylord Nelson, the father of Earth Day said before the first Earth Day in 1970 that “the secretary of the Smithsonian Institute believes that in 25 years, somewhere between 75 and 80 percent of all the species of living animals will be extinct.”

Not to be outdone, Life Magazine reported that same year that “Scientists have solid experimental and theoretical evidence to support…the following predictions: In a decade, urban dwellers will have to wear gas masks to survive air pollution…by 1985 air pollution will have reduced the amount of sunlight reaching earth by one half….”

Stanford biologist Paul Ehrlich, the celebrated author of The Climate Bomb, wrote in 1971 that "by the year 2000 the United Kingdom will be simply a small group of impoverished islands, inhabited by some 70 million hungry people … If I were a gambler, I would take even money that England will not exist in the year 2000.”

In 1975 Newsweek ran a now-infamous article entitled “The Cooling World,” which cited several climate scientists in concluding that “the central fact is that…the earth’s climate seems to be cooling down…If the climate change is as profound as some of the pessimists fear, the resulting famines could be catastrophic.”

Global famine was a popular prediction in the 70’s. North Texas State professor Pete Gunter summed up the prevailing sentiment when he wrote in “The Lving Wilderness” that by “by the year 2000...the entire world, with the exception of Western Europe, North America, and Australia, will be in famine.”

In 1986, NASA scientist James Hansen testified before Congress that “global temperatures should be nearly 2 degrees higher in 20 years, ‘which is about the warmest the earth has been in the last 100,000 years.’”

Two years later, Dr. Hansen told an interviewer that in 20 years, the area below his New York City office would be completely changed, most notably that “the West Side Highway [which runs along the Hudson River] will be under water.”

Even the great Carl Sagan predicted in 1990 that “the planet could face an ‘ecological and agricultural catastrophe’ by the next decade if global warming trends continue.”

That same year, Dr. Michael Oppenheimer with The Environmental Defense Fund wrote:

By 1995, the greenhouse effect would be desolating the heartlands of North America and Eurasia with horrific drought, causing crop failures and food riots…”(By 1996) The Platte River of Nebraska would be dry, while a continent-wide black blizzard of prairie topsoil will stop traffic on interstates, strip paint from houses and shut down computers…The Mexican police will round up illegal American migrants surging into Mexico seeking work as field hands.

As recently as the last decade, both Dr. Hansen and Peter Wadhams, the head of the Polar Ocean Physics Group at the University of Cambridge, believe “that the Arctic is likely to become ice-free...as early as 2015.”

That’s actually two years later than Al Gore predicted in 2007, 2008, and 2009, when he cited what he called a scientific consensus to claim that the North Pole would be “ice free by 2013.”

That’s good, because Pentagon scientists sure weren’t in 2003, when their report “An Abrupt Climate Change Scenario and its Implications for United States National Security” warned that within 10 years, “it was not implausible” that parts of California would be flooded, parts of the Netherlands would be uninhabitable, and an unprecedented rise in hurricanes, tsunamis, and tornadoes would spark wars across the globe as people fought for increasingly scarce resources.

Not to be outdone, scientists with the United Nations Environment Programme warned in 2005 that man-made global warming would so decimate coastal areas as well as the Caribbean and Pacific islands that there would be upwards of 50 million “climate refugees by 2010.”

Of course, none of these scientific predictions—from Earth Day straight through today—have ever actually been right, but more predictions keep coming...along with more admonitions that the science is settled.


http://newstalk1130.iheart.com/onai...rief-history-of-fantastically-wrong-15767677/


I can't wait for the next round of predictions....:>)

Good thing we averted some of those scenarios via environmental legislation, huh?
 
as the enclosed link clearly shows -

85% of the "record highs" (all 50 states) happened before 1950.

and half of the "record lows" (again, all 50 states), happened after 1950

some tidbits:

- America's all time high - 134 degrees - july 1913, death valley California
- America's record low - minus 80 degrees - January 1971, prospect creek Alaska
- Alaska's all time high - June 1915 - 100 degrees, fort Yukon
- Hawaii's all time low - January 1975, moana kea, 15 degrees
- lower 48 states all time low - January 1954 - minus 70 - rogers pass, Montana
- Montana's all time high - 117 degrees - july 1937, medicine lake

and so on and so forth

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/U.S._state_temperature_extremes

And since the United States is the same as a globe, a short-term cooling trend in the United States clearly implies long-term global cooling.
 
You discussed one, at great length, as always. I posted several, which of course you dismissed out of hand. This is what passes as intellectual honesty for you.

The climate does change, always has and always will. A certain political party tells us that it is very bad now, and that we are doomed unless we - Surprise! - give money and power to them. They know best, and they have charts and graphs to show that they know best. Never question their charts and graphs, ever.

Now, if something they asserted proves not be be true, don't worry about that -The science is settled. That is the nature of science after all - Start with the conclusion, accept only facts that support the conclusion, and then it is settled and should never be revisited. The important thing is make sure the right people are in charge and have the power. Oh, and funding, lots and lots of funding, can't forget about that. And while the science is settled, the problem (that we're all doomed unless the right people are in charge) never goes away. Not ever. Funding and power in perpetuity.

That, of course, is good enough for you. Any dissenters are labeled as "Deniers" (that fits conveniently on a bumper sticker) and are marginalized as dangerous heretics - The infallible graphs and charts prove that they are.

Very important to remind people that if they do not get in line and conform to what that certain political party says they must do unquestioningly, that they are horrible ignorant people that hate the earth. Their place is to obey and nod in assent. The science is settled, because they say so.

It is not "a certain political party" warning about the dangers of global warming, but rather virtually every scientific body in every country in the world.
 
when global warming alarmists serve up convoluted "regression" explanations, it's best to return to the basics -

- NYC is not under water
- Florida has not been flooded
- Venice and the Netherlands are doing just fine
- winter snows are not "a thing of the past". in fact, Britain and California have had unexpected record setting snowfalls recently

Florida hasn't been flooded? Record setting snowfalls weren't predicted by models?
 
CO2 is an integral part of the circle of life. Without it, there would be no life on earth. With it, oxygen makes the cycle between plants and animals. We are carbon based creatures, carbon is not a "pollutant", neither is it a "heat pollutant", neither is heat a pollutant; global warming has always resulted in more life, not less. Carbon Dioxide has never produced global warming, there is no greenhouse effect in our atmosphere because there is no barrier to heat rising in our atmosphere... this is the most unscientific idiotic spew of nonsense ever to come from "scientists"... even worse than the "space time wrinkles in matter" ... at least the physical theorists weren't proposing taxes to pay for their nonsense.

The Greenhouse theory was a complete swing and a miss at explaining why the ice cap was melting in the Arctic circle. It turned out, the heat was coming from the water, not the air. The heat in the air was also coming from the water. The real source of the heat? volcanic activity on the floor of the Arctic ocean. We now know the theory is wrong, we always knew it made no sense, but now we know it was wrong and made no sense. Nothing stops heat from rising in the atmosphere; the atmosphere cools the earth's surface, adding carbon dioxide to the atmosphere doesn't change how that works; it is all about this wonderful program of water evaporating, rising into the atmosphere, cooling, and coming back as rain, it's a great program, it cools the earth, and as long as there is still water in the oceans, it still works.

Basic physics says that without the greenhouse effect the Earth would be as cold as the moon.
 
Back
Top