New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Should DC be a state?

middleview

President
Supporting Member
I just realized that there are as many people living in Alaska as there are in DC...

Why is it not a state?
 
Both Puerto Rico and DC should be states. Both are composed of American citizens and the people there are entitled to the same representation as everyone else.

The reason that this hasn't already happened is because of bigoted republicans. Republicans cannot win fair elections and the last thing they want to see is more brown people voting. They'll twist themselves into pretzels trying to come up with arguments that aren't racist or bigoted to make the case they these places do not deserve statehood.
 
Last edited:
Both Puerto Rico and DC should be states. Both are composed of American citizens and the people there are entitled to the same representation as everyone else.

The reason that this hasn't already happened is because of bigoted republicans. Republicans cannot win fair elections and the last thing they want to see is more brown people voting. They'll twist themselves into pretzels trying to come up with arguments that aren't racist or bigoted to make the case they these places do not deserve statehood.
I think Puerto Rico should be independent, but either way it should be up to the people there.
 
I think it was Jesse Jackson that said D.C. suffered from the “four toos”: too Black, too liberal, too urban, and too Democratic for conservatives to agree to statehood.
 
I think Puerto Rico should be independent, but either way it should be up to the people there.

The people of Puerto Rico have voted that they would like to become a state. I'd be fine with it if they wished to become an independent country. That choice should be theirs and not a bunch of bigoted republicans.
 
The people of Puerto Rico have voted that they would like to become a state. I'd be fine with it if they wished to become an independent country. That choice should be theirs and not a bunch of bigoted republicans.
The UN Committee on Decolonization considers a vote on the status of a colony illegitimate unless the military forces of the metropolis don't occupy the colony and all political prisoners have been released. There also hasn't been an up-or-down vote on independence, one that many might vote in who boycotted the 2020 referendum. But it sounds like we're on the same page, and it's up to the Puerto Ricans to decide what happens to Puerto Rico.
 
I just realized that there are as many people living in Alaska as there are in DC...

Why is it not a state?
If you didn't fall asleep in class when you were in gubbmint screwell you would have learned that DC was never meant to be a state and people were never supposed to live there. But I digress.
 
If you didn't fall asleep in class when you were in gubbmint screwell you would have learned that DC was never meant to be a state and people were never supposed to live there. But I digress.

I went to catholic schools. So where did you read that someone thought people were never supposed to live there? The current facts, contrary to what someone thought in 1790 are that the population of DC is equal to or greater than 7 states.

The purpose back then was simply that there was no national army and each state contributed their militia in the time of need...or at least that was the plan. For the federal government to be dependent on a state for military defense was the problem.
That is no longer the case.
 
D.C. should not be a state unless there is an amendment to the Constitution to allow it. The constitution provided for the current location as it was feared there would be jealousy among the states if the federal capitol was located inside a particular state.
 
I just realized that there are as many people living in Alaska as there are in DC...

Why is it not a state?
It's not a state because it's in the Constitution not to be so. The founders felt that if nation's capitol were "inside a state" our Congressional leaders would be unduly beholden to it rather than the nation at large and all states as they should. It's not a conspiracy against Washington, DC.
 
It's not a state because it's in the Constitution not to be so. The founders felt that if nation's capitol were "inside a state" our Congressional leaders would be unduly beholden to it rather than the nation at large and all states as they should. It's not a conspiracy against Washington, DC.
New York and Philadelphia were both capitals under the Constitution. It appears the Founders didn’t mean what you claim they did when they wrote it.
 
It's not a state because it's in the Constitution not to be so. The founders felt that if nation's capitol were "inside a state" our Congressional leaders would be unduly beholden to it rather than the nation at large and all states as they should. It's not a conspiracy against Washington, DC.
It's within two states right now and no one is saying that congress is unduly beholden to Virginia and Maryland. The difference would be that the people who live there would have their own representation within the federal govt instead of none.
 
It's within two states right now and no one is saying that congress is unduly beholden to Virginia and Maryland. The difference would be that the people who live there would have their own representation within the federal govt instead of none.

It's not IN a state......not something close by. You know....a BORDER where the state ends. Can you not stop the lies and distortions. The founders didn't want it INSIDE a state because the founders didn't want Congressional leaders beholden to that state rather than the nation. You realize that state Capitals are not located in other states, right? Being inside a state could make it beholden to such.
 
Last edited:
It's not IN a state......not something close by. You know....a BORDER where the state ends. Can you not stop the lies and distortions. The founders didn't want it INSIDE a state because the founders didn't want Congressional leaders beholden to that state rather than the nation. You realize that state Capitols are not located in other states, right? Being inside a state could make it beholden to such.
Yeah ? I suppose the founders didn't want a lot of things that have come to pass over the centuries. Congress wouldn't be any more beholden to a state of DC than they are now to MD and VA.
 
Yeah ? I suppose the founders didn't want a lot of things that have come to pass over the centuries. Congress wouldn't be any more beholden to a state of DC than they are now to MD and VA.
Actually being PART of a state wouldn't make one beholden to it? Can we move Oregon's and Washington's Capitols to inside the state boundaries of Idaho, too? No need to worry about Idaho trying to influence and legislate those capitols in their state now, is there?
 
Last edited:
New York and Philadelphia were both capitals under the Constitution. It appears the Founders didn’t mean what you claim they did when they wrote it.
So they saw the experiment didn't work. You realizing now they are far wiser than you?
 
Back
Top