New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Should DC be a state?

So they saw the experiment didn't work. You realizing now they are far wiser than you?
I mean, we are also talking about a time when the federal system was an important mechanism for balancing competing interests and not an obsolete relic of a bygone era that only serves to give entrenched special interests more power at the expense of democracy. The point is that there is nothing in the Constitution that prohibits the national capital from being within a state’s borders, as it was for the first 11 years under the Constitution.
 
I mean, we are also talking about a time when the federal system was an important mechanism for balancing competing interests and not an obsolete relic of a bygone era that only serves to give entrenched special interests more power at the expense of democracy. The point is that there is nothing in the Constitution that prohibits the national capital from being within a state’s borders, as it was for the first 11 years under the Constitution.
Philadelphia was never meant to be a long term Capital. It was a temporary location (and always intended to be so) until the states could come to an agreement. The compromise of 1790 is when Washington DC was chosen. The land was also cut out of neighboring states so that Washington DC would be independent from the jurisdiction and influence of a single state. The reasons this was done then apply now. Having the nation's capital reside inside a state's boundaries subjects it to undue influence of that one state. Federal interests....and only federal interests....should be influencing the federal government. You can disagree all you want but that doesn't make your position tenable. The founders certainly had a convincing argument....and as proven through experience.....why this had to be so.

Now if the surrounding area was red you would be opposing it until you were red in the face. In light of all this hypocrisy, the status quo remains and will remain.
 
Last edited:
Philadelphia was never meant to be a long term Capital. It was a temporary location (and always intended to be so) until the states could come to an agreement. The compromise of 1790 is when Washington DC was chosen. The land was also cut out of neighboring states so that Washington DC would be independent from the jurisdiction and influence of a single state. The reasons this was done then apply now. Having the nation's capital reside inside a state's boundaries subjects it to undue influence of that one state. Federal interests....and only federal interests....should be influencing the federal government. You can disagree all you want but that doesn't make your position tenable. The founders certainly had a convincing argument....and as proven through experience.....why this had to be so.

Now if the surrounding area was red you would be opposing it until you were red in the face. In light of all this, the status quo remains and will remain.
Nope, I support an equal right of all citizens to elect a government regardless of how they vote. If one state having disproportionate influence (despite having a small population that is largely excluded from power by race and class) is a concern, we could always amend the Constitution to eliminate state sovereignty and establish a unitary national government, which would also give the people more power and the special interests less.
 
Nope, I support an equal right of all citizens to elect a government regardless of how they vote. If one state having disproportionate influence (despite having a small population that is largely excluded from power by race and class) is a concern, we could always amend the Constitution to eliminate state sovereignty and establish a unitary national government, which would also give the people more power and the special interests less.
I'm not interested in your gibberish. Why Washington DC is not a state nor ever should be is clear here. Game over.
 
I'm not interested in your gibberish. Why Washington DC is not a state nor ever should be is clear here. Game over.
Why it is not a state is eminently clear. It has nothing to do with the forgotten rivalries among Virginia, South Carolina, Massachusetts, Pennsylvania, and New York in the decades before they were all ruled by the same trusts, and everything to do with suppressing the opportunity to have government by the consent of the governed when the governed are urban and Black.
 
Actually being PART of a state wouldn't make one beholden to it? Can we move Oregon's and Washington's Capitols to inside the state boundaries of Idaho, too? No need to worry about Idaho trying to influence and legislate those capitols in their state now, is there?
It is already inside the boundaries of two states. The difference between you claim question about Oregon and Washington is moot because Washington DC will still be within the boundaries of the United States and not some other country.
 
Back
Top