New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Showing my math.

Arkady

President
Showing my math.

I keep trying to get the Republicans to see the simple mathematical impossibility of Romney's tax plan being revenue neutral, and I keep failing to get even the slightest engagement on the numbers. So, this time I'll show my math, in case it's laziness that's preventing engagement. This way you don't need to do any math yourself. In a prior post I crunched the numbers for a wide range of incomes, but since I'll be showing my work here, I'll use just one. Here are the data sources:


http://www.moneychimp.com/features/tax_brackets.htm
http://www.forbes.com/sites/baldwin/...-deductions/2/

We'll crunch the number for a household with an adjusted gross income of $1 million, as a married couple filing jointly (we could choose some other high dollar figure and do single people, or assume children, but the results will be similar).

Currently, at that level, taxes work out like this:

Taxable income between: Rate: Tax:
$0 $17,400 10% $1,740.00
$17,400 $70,700 15% $7,995.00
$70,700 $142,700 25% $18,000.00
$142,700 $217,450 28% $20,930.00
$217,450 $388,350 33% $56,397.00
$388,350 $1,000,000 35% $214,077.50
Total: $319,139.50

It's easy math. Just take the number from column B, subtract the number in column A, and multiply by the rate for that bracket, which is column C, and you get the tax owed for that bracket, which is column D. Then sum all the rates owed for each bracket and you get the total tax owed: $319,139,50.

Currently, average itemized deductions for a household with $1 million in adjusted gross income are $79,307 for taxes, $32,215 for interest, and $25,603 for donations. Add those three numbers together and you get $137,125. In other words, that taxpayer's UNADJUSTED gross income was actually $1,137,125, but he got to reduce it to $1 million with deductions. Romney has floated a lot of different vague schemes for capping deductions, but the most recent one is capping them at $25,000. So, $1,137,125 minus $25,000 would mean that under the new system adjusted gross income would be $1,112,125.

Taxable income between: Rate: 20% discounted tax rate Tax:
$0 $17,400 10% 8% $1,392.00
$17,400 $70,700 15% 12% $6,396.00
$70,700 $142,700 25% 20% $14,400.00
$142,700 $217,450 28% 22% $16,744.00
$217,450 $388,350 33% 26% $45,117.60
$388,350 $1,112,125 35% 28% $202,657.00
Total: $286,706.60

Again, it's easy math. Just take the number from column B, subtract the number in column A, and multiply by the rate for that bracket, which is column D this time (computed by multiplying column C by 0.8, to reflect Romney's 20% reduction in rates), and you get the tax owed for that bracket, which is column E. Note that this time the last number in column B is higher, reflecting the larger tax base created by Romney's $25,000 cap on deductions. Then sum all the rates owed for each bracket and you get the total tax owed: $286,706.60.

So, for this millionaire, taxes will fall from $319,139.50 under the current system to $286,706.60 under the new system. Subtract the two, and you've got $32,432.90 in tax reduction at that level... which, will mean either a $32,432.90 increase in the deficit, or a $32,432.90 unspecified cut in government spending, or a $32,432.90 increase in taxes for the rest of us.

I used $1 million, but the tax savings are actually vastly greater for those, like Romney, who are vastly richer than that. If you're an average taxpayer with a Romneyesque income of $20 million per year, you'll be saving $716,652.94 per year thanks to the change he's proposing.... which, of course, makes it pretty easy to see why'd he'd propose it.
 
OK. So even doing all the math for you wasn't enough to get a single person willing to engage on the actual numbers. I think it's very telling that the conservatives prefer to stick to grand, vague rhetoric, rather than specific numerical policy analysis. Deep down you right-wingers must realize the numbers don't favor your theories.
 
Yeah... Good luck getting a Republican to respond.

Congressman Broun already warned them about that demonic "Arithmetic". ;)
 
I'll help...

Romney can't do all that he proposes and remain revenue neutral, nor avoid taxing households with income below $200,000

I'll go a step further... no one.. will be able to avoid taxing households with income below 200k for much longer. no one.

remember...rhetoric only survives scrutiny until the rhithmetic is done.


hi ho..philfish.. awaaaaay....
 
I'll help...

Romney can't do all that he proposes and remain revenue neutral, nor avoid taxing households with income below $200,000

I'll go a step further... no one.. will be able to avoid taxing households with income below 200k for much longer. no one.

remember...rhetoric only survives scrutiny until the rhithmetic is done.


hi ho..philfish.. awaaaaay....


Oh no! Does that mean that I'll have to start paying taxes?

God forbid!!! ;)
 
dunno. do you want to pay taxes?

Hell no! I want a free ride. As a matter of fact, I think I'll go and change my party affiliation to GOP today. [Unwelcome language removed] being part of a society. I am an island!

[video=youtube;My9I8q-iJCI]http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=My9I8q-iJCI[/video]
 
You left out cutting medicare, medicaid and social security down to the nub, the ultimate goal to abolish them completely. Look for the republicans to gut all government departments except defense.
 
I'll help...

Romney can't do all that he proposes and remain revenue neutral, nor avoid taxing households with income below $200,000

I'll go a step further... no one.. will be able to avoid taxing households with income below 200k for much longer. no one.

remember...rhetoric only survives scrutiny until the rhithmetic is done.


hi ho..philfish.. awaaaaay....

It's at least mathematically possible to balance the budget without raising taxes on those earning below $200k per year.... just highly impractical. For starters, cut the military budget by half a trillion bucks (which would still leave us with the best-funded military on the planet). Then hike taxes on the rich severely (to something like the modern norm of 70% on the top bracket). Then go back to having investment income treated as regular income for tax purposes (which, for the very rich, would effectively increase its tax rate from 15% to 70%). And do the same for inheritance. Crunch the numbers on that, with an assumption of realistically decent GDP growth and realistically restrained domestic budget growth, and you can reach balance within a few years.

I'm not saying there's any real political hope of that happening. But at least it's not a mathematical absurdity, like Romney's plan.
 
Class warfare doesn't work, maybe a war on woman? Oh that doesn't work either.. Obama should go hang with his hip hop buddies and stay off TV. His polls get uglier every day.
 
Class warfare doesn't work, maybe a war on woman? Oh that doesn't work either.. Obama should go hang with his hip hop buddies and stay off TV. His polls get uglier every day.

Warren Buffett: Oh, there's class warfare, all right. But it's MY class, the rich, who are waging war. And we're winning.

LeRoy: And then there are the useful idiots, who aren't even aware that a war is being waged against them.......
 
nobody will escape an increased tax burden.

when the fiscal cliff negotiation comes...(i'm gonna take a stab and say..after the election..).. there'll be choices. take the fica cut... survives or ends? i'm guessing ends. in which case the middle and especially the lowest brackets take the hit...markedly worse on the lower..to be sure.

sure, mathematically possible on >200k. but, do you think we'll get a 70% hit? no way. so in reality that solution wont hold. and thats only one factor. budget restraint? not hardly too. we may see defense cuts.. but .5 trill. really? i'd say maybe. but again, if not, the math wont play out..
 
How was Obama's math on his promise to cut the deficit in half?

It was predicated on unrealistic assumptions of economic growth, quicker exit from Iraq, and letting the Bush tax cuts expire for the rich. It wasn't mathematically absurd, it was just overly ambitious, politically.
 
A few comments on all this:

-We heard all we needed to hear in the last debate when Mitt first said (I paraphrase), "Pick a number, any number. How about $25K? Then, you throw that $25k in a bucket!' And a little later he said..."Of COURSE the math works!"

-And...Have ya ever pondered how the Clintonians came up with a top rate of 39.6%.....not 39% - not 40%....but, 39 point SIX? What was up with THAT? It's simple. The math drove that number, not the other way around. ANYtime a politician spews the tax cut number FIRST, then promises to make the math fit that number, you know he's lying.
 
Well done. The follow up is that even if the numbers were identical after the change in policy, how in the world would that create jobs or extra demand? If by closing loopholes you get the same tax revenue, what changed?
 
Well done. The follow up is that even if the numbers were identical after the change in policy, how in the world would that create jobs or extra demand? If by closing loopholes you get the same tax revenue, what changed?

You raise (imho) THE fundamental point in all this, Woolley. Why are we even TALKING about all this, if the net is (supposedly) exactly what it is before? I will say though....that a valid case CAN be made that reducing a rate here and closing a deduction there, will lead to increased economic activity that won't just overcome the rate cut, but exceed it. That's the traditional "fiscal conservative" case and I'll argue that on a case-by-case basis, it's not entirely invalid.

And for the most part, that was the case Li'l George forwarded in the context of HIS taxcuts. It turned out that Li'l George was wrong, but at least he went through the motions of forwarding the case.

Mitt's going about this very differently though. First of all, he's making no effort whatsoever, to explain HOW is tax regimes might grow economic activity. He's simply insisting that we must take it on faith, 'cuz he's a bidnessman. And second...he's not even promising that his tax regimes will INcrease revenue. In fact, he goes out of his way to emphasize that they won't increase revenue...instead, they'll keep them the "same". And of course, that goes to the influence of CATO/Norquistism, in which revenue increases are at least as anathema, as are rate increases.
 
Back
Top