New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Simple question on 14th Amendment...

Nope. Gold-bug right-wingers have been giving me that same advice since Obama was sworn in, and I routinely ignore it. Sometimes that means that I ride the market down for a while. But more often it means I ride it up, and it has averaged out to excellent returns overall. The last time I moved most of my investments out of US securities was in the Bush era, when I was betting that bad leadership in this country would result in US stocks being outperformed by other investment classes.

Fortunately, a big chunk of my money is in a company stock where I get a 15% discount to purchase, so I've got a lot of give before I'm even back to ground zero.

Good luck with that...
 
Over a century ago, the Supreme Court correctly confirmed this restricted interpretation of citizenship in the so-called 'Slaughter-House cases' [83 US 36 (1873)] and in [112 US 94 (1884)]. In Elk v.Wilkins, the phrase 'subject to its jurisdiction' excluded from its operation 'children of ministers, consuls, and citizens of foreign states born within the United States.' In Elk, the American Indian claimant was considered not an American citizen because the law required him to be 'not merely subject in some respect or degree to the jurisdiction of the United States, but completely subject to their political jurisdiction and owing them direct and immediate allegiance.'

http://www.cairco.org/issues/anchor-babies

And?
 

And that was the beginning of efforts to limit the interpretation that any baby born of foreign visitors in the US is a US citizen. The Amendment doesn't have to be changed or repealed - it just needs to be interpreted as written. It merely states that babies born of naturalized or descendants of naturalized citizens are automatically citizens. Duh!
 
And that was the beginning of efforts to limit the interpretation that any baby born of foreign visitors in the US is a US citizen. The Amendment doesn't have to be changed or repealed - it just needs to be interpreted as written. It merely states that babies born of naturalized or descendants of naturalized citizens are automatically citizens. Duh!

As you know, it does not "state" that - that is the "rewrite" you wingers are now advancing to reverse the way the 14th Amendment has always been applied. And you hope you can get some judicial activist judges to agree to your rewrite. Highly doubtful though - your proposed rewrite is too extreme.

In practical terms, given the Trump/GOP jihad against Hispanics, and changing demographics, the GOP may never win the presidency again.

And that's a good thing.

;-)
 
As you know, it does not "state" that - that is the "rewrite" you wingers are now advancing to reverse the way the 14th Amendment has always been applied. And you hope you can get some judicial activist judges to agree to your rewrite. Highly doubtful though - your proposed rewrite is too extreme.

In practical terms, given the Trump/GOP jihad against Hispanics, and changing demographics, the GOP may never win the presidency again.

And that's a good thing.

;-)
Reverse? Hardly. It's about declaring the true intent of the 14th. And that it allows for congress to declare that illegal alien parents cannot produce anchor babies with U.S. citizenship if congress redefines those circumstances.
 
Reverse? Hardly. It's about declaring the true intent of the 14th. And that it allows for congress to declare that illegal alien parents cannot produce anchor babies with U.S. citizenship if congress redefines those circumstances.

Yes, reverse.

Dunno if your handlers have told you this, but the 14th Amendment has always been applied to provide citizenship to people born here, and you wingers don't like that, so you hope to find some activist judges to reverse that. And it's a pipe dream to think that any such bill will ever be signed into law.
 
Reverse? Hardly. It's about declaring the true intent of the 14th. And that it allows for congress to declare that illegal alien parents cannot produce anchor babies with U.S. citizenship if congress redefines those circumstances.
"Wingers" like Bugsy have used that same line "It's about declaring the true intent of the 2nd." Pure bullshit, of course, since it negates a century and a half of US law.
 
Yes, reverse.

Dunno if your handlers have told you this, but the 14th Amendment has always been applied to provide citizenship to people born here, and you wingers don't like that, so you hope to find some activist judges to reverse that. And it's a pipe dream to think that any such bill will ever be signed into law.

You're as dumb as a door knob if you read the top post and still don't get it. Clearly the 14th applies to people the U.S. had 'jurisdiction' over and Indians were excluded because they belonged to foreign nations. Much like illegal alien Mexicans of today. That means congress can determine the status of naturalization of the children born here to illegal aliens.
 
You're as dumb as a door knob if you read the top post and still don't get it. Clearly the 14th applies to people the U.S. had 'jurisdiction' over and Indians were excluded because they belonged to foreign nations. Much like illegal alien Mexicans of today. That means congress can determine the status of naturalization of the children born here to illegal aliens.

I dispelled all that jive already.

Children of illegal aliens born here are not born within other sovereign places/nations, nor are they children of diplomats. They are clearly subject to the jurisdiction of the USA, no matter how much you wingers want to contort and distort that word.

Mark Levin, for example, says "jurisdiction" means "allegiance." A laughable rewrite of the words actually used in the 14th Amendment.
 
I dispelled all that jive already.

Children of illegal aliens born here are not born within other sovereign places/nations, nor are they children of diplomats. They are clearly subject to the jurisdiction of the USA, no matter how much you wingers want to contort and distort that word.

Mark Levin, for example, says "jurisdiction" means "allegiance." A laughable rewrite of the words actually used in the 14th Amendment.
You are wrong. You've dispelled nothing. You've exerted erroneous opinion.
 
You are wrong. You've dispelled nothing. You've exerted erroneous opinion.

It's not an opinion - it's a matter of reading words. Since 1868, they have been read and applied. You want the words rewritten to meet your political goals. Ain't gonna happen.

Read 'em and weep....

Amendment XIV

Section 1.

All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the state wherein they reside. No state shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any state deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.
 
Huh? You seem to have the positions backwards.
I'm not understanding you here. ???
Wingers like Bugsy have been saying for decades that the Second Amendment means something it clearly doesn't. They want to, as RE suggested with the 14th, "reinterpret" a Constitutional amendment to mean what they want it to mean by ignoring over a century and a half of legal rulings and law.
 
Wingers like Bugsy have been saying for decades that the Second Amendment means something it clearly doesn't. They want to, as RE suggested with the 14th, "reinterpret" a Constitutional amendment to mean what they want it to mean by ignoring over a century and a half of legal rulings and law.
I guess we agree that congress can determine what to do with anchor babies because the 14th Amendment allows it as originally written. :0)
 
It's not an opinion - it's a matter of reading words. Since 1868, they have been read and applied. You want the words rewritten to meet your political goals. Ain't gonna happen.

Read 'em and weep....

Amendment XIV

Section 1.

All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the state wherein they reside. No state shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any state deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.

Key in on the red highlighted text. The words "subject to jurisdiction thereof" are there to make an exception of Indians who belonged to Indian nations. Illegal aliens are not subject to the jurisdiction being spoken of much like Indians at the time were not.
 
Congress can say that somebody who was born here, was not born here?

Our new Orwellian political era.

;-)

The international norm is that your citizens who have children abroad are of your nationality. So Mexican kids born to illegal aliens in this country are Mexican citizens.
 
Back
Top