New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Simple question on 14th Amendment...

"Norm" speaks to how most all countries treat a matter. Mexico could say, "those anchor babies aren't ours." Who'd stop them? You and your international laws?
Why should I give a flying [Unwelcome language removed] what other countries do?

In this case, if the parents are Mexican nationals, deporting them to Mexico is covered by International law.

Remember this kid?
AP_elian_gonzales_raid_01_jef_150421_4x3_992.jpg


The resolution was resolved according to International Law, not international norms.
 
As you know, it does not "state" that - that is the "rewrite" you wingers are now advancing to reverse the way the 14th Amendment has always been applied. And you hope you can get some judicial activist judges to agree to your rewrite. Highly doubtful though - your proposed rewrite is too extreme.

In practical terms, given the Trump/GOP jihad against Hispanics, and changing demographics, the GOP may never win the presidency again.

And that's a good thing.

;-)

Anyone who thinks the children born of foreigners in this country illegally should automatically be US citizens is either stupid or evil. Which are you?
 
Anyone who thinks the children born of foreigners in this country illegally should automatically be US citizens is either stupid or evil. Which are you?

It's neither stupid nor evil to apply the words of the 14th Amendment as written and as applied since 1868. What's bizarre is participating in a movement to rewrite it.

Your handlers are making you crazy.

;-)
 
It's neither stupid nor evil to apply the words of the 14th Amendment as written and as applied since 1868. What's bizarre is participating in a movement to rewrite it.

Your handlers are making you crazy.

;-)

There was no illegal immigration in 1868. There is now. Illegal immigrants now fit under the restrictions as outlined in the 14th Amendment with respect to foreigners. If "subject to the jurisdiction of" doesn't mean people here legally (only) then why even bother to put the words in there?
 
There was no illegal immigration in 1868. There is now. Illegal immigrants now fit under the restrictions as outlined in the 14th Amendment with respect to foreigners. If "subject to the jurisdiction of" doesn't mean people here legally (only) then why even bother to put the words in there?

As you know, I answered that question already. Those words were put there to exclude those over whom the US did not have jurisdiction, such as diplomats.

Do you have anything new to say in support of your oddball position?
 
Amendment XIV

Section 1.

All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the state wherein they reside. .

Except for the fact that children born in the United States are already citizens and subjects of the jurisdiction from where there parents came, unless of course the parents have been naturalized as American citizens.

The United States cannot kidnap them.
 
You haven't showed any of that yet.

The fact you've dropped your argument about parents and international law in favor of personal insults shows you certainly have no honesty, integrity nor the humility to admit you are wrong.
 
Back
Top