New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Simple question on 14th Amendment...

That's by and large false of course - most illegals either work, or go to school, or get medical attention, or any number of other things that bring them to the attention of the government. We know most of them are here.

But whether or not we know they are here, they are within the jurisdiction of the US, and the US has jurisdiction over them. They cannot act here with impunity.

Again, you reveal the depths to which GOP cultists will say dopey shit to flack for your cult.

No one can "act with impunity" - not even Indians or ambassadors and foreign agents. And they were all specifically excluded. That's (obviously) not what the language was referring to - it meant they were registered with the authorities and here with the intention to stay. There was, of course, no immigration restrictions at the time the Amendment was passed. As those restrictions were enacted, it's quite obvious that the illegal "foreigner" who is still under their home nation's FULL jurisdiction, the restriction would also apply to these aliens who are not registered with the US government. It's simple common sense (which is why it escapes you).
 
No one can "act with impunity" - not even Indians or ambassadors and foreign agents. And they were all specifically excluded. That's (obviously) not what the language was referring to - it meant they were registered with the authorities and here with the intention to stay. There was, of course, no immigration restrictions at the time the Amendment was passed. As those restrictions were enacted, it's quite obvious that the illegal "foreigner" who is still under their home nation's FULL jurisdiction, the restriction would also apply to these aliens who are not registered with the US government. It's simple common sense (which is why it escapes you).

You seek to dissemble around the issue.

Bottom line: Children born here are subject to the jurisdiction of the US and, under the plain language of the 14th Amendment, are citizens. You do not contend that such children (or adults, when they come of age) are not subject to the jurisdiction of the US, and it would be insane to do so.

You don't like the language of the 14th Amendment. You wish it read differently.

Tough break.

;-)
 
Like most lawyers I can read. Can you?
I can, but it appears you are not a lawyer.
Foul.

You've used that before. Minus creativity points, again.
Nice dodge attempt, but clearly it's true regardless if you like it or not.

Zechariah 8:16These are the things that you shall do: Speak the truth to one another; render in your gates judgments that are true and make for peace
 
You seek to dissemble around the issue.

Bottom line: Children born here are subject to the jurisdiction of the US and, under the plain language of the 14th Amendment, are citizens. You do not contend that such children (or adults, when they come of age) are not subject to the jurisdiction of the US, and it would be insane to do so.

You don't like the language of the 14th Amendment. You wish it read differently.

Tough break.

;-)

Under your definition EVERYBODY is under US "jurisdiction" while here in the US and so the statement in the Amendment is superfluous. Why even include it? Clearly foreign born pirates, foreign born fugitive undesirables and Indians all fit within your interpretation and would be eligible for birth right citizenship. The words mean nothing at all unless those people are to be excluded. The drafters put that language in for a reason and that reason is consistent with a reading that would exclude illegal aliens.
 
Under your definition EVERYBODY is under US "jurisdiction" while here in the US and so the statement in the Amendment is superfluous. Why even include it? Clearly foreign born pirates, foreign born fugitive undesirables and Indians all fit within your interpretation and would be eligible for birth right citizenship. The words mean nothing at all unless those people are to be excluded. The drafters put that language in for a reason and that reason is consistent with a reading that would exclude illegal aliens.

More dissembling. I already addressed your baseless point, as you know.

Again, when the 14th Amendment was drafted, some people in the US were beyond the jurisdiction of the US, including diplomats and Indians, as reservations were seen as sovereign nations. Those legal principles continue to this day, albeit in modified form.

Hate radio host Mark Levin argues that the word jurisdiction really means allegiance. Do you agree with that attempted rewrite of the 14th Amendment?
 
More dissembling. I already addressed your baseless point, as you know.

Again, when the 14th Amendment was drafted, some people in the US were beyond the jurisdiction of the US, including diplomats and Indians, as reservations were seen as sovereign nations. Those legal principles continue to this day, albeit in modified form.

Hate radio host Mark Levin argues that the word jurisdiction really means allegiance. Do you agree with that attempted rewrite of the 14th Amendment?

And as you know, that is complete BS. If you are suggesting the Indians were not every bit as subject to US jurisdiction as foreign visitors, then you simply are an unserious participant in this debate.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indian_Removal_Act
 
The Indian Removal Act empowered Jackson to negotiate with Indian tribes to relocate them and take their land. It's more like the Treaty of Versailles than the Civil Rights Act of 1964. It certainly didn't treat the Indians as citizens of the United States and subject our laws on their own land.
 
And as you know, that is complete BS. If you are suggesting the Indians were not every bit as subject to US jurisdiction as foreign visitors, then you simply are an unserious participant in this debate.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indian_Removal_Act

Nah, you're just more interested in dissembling than having an honest debate.

You ignored what I said about diplomats, and make no point about Indians, while pretending that you have one. Your taste for dissembling makes you right at home in the GOP.
 
The Indian Removal Act empowered Jackson to negotiate with Indian tribes to relocate them and take their land. It's more like the Treaty of Versailles than the Civil Rights Act of 1964. It certainly didn't treat the Indians as citizens of the United States and subject our laws on their own land.

He would also admit the Indian sovereignty if he were honest. But he's not.
 
Political extremists are never honest nor do they admit error.

That's a rather ridiculous statement.

First, the term "political extremist" - it's too subjective to have any real meaning. In any event, plenty of the most politically extreme people imaginable are honest and would admit error when error is demonstrated.

The most dishonest people, and those least likely to admit error, are those who view their party as a cult. The no. 1 goal of such people is defending their cult and its leaders. If they have to sacrifice their own intellectual honesty and integrity to boost their cult leaders, they are happy to do it. They view their cult as being of primary importance.
 
That's a rather ridiculous statement.

First, the term "political extremist" - it's too subjective to have any real meaning. In any event, plenty of the most politically extreme people imaginable are honest and would admit error when error is demonstrated.

The most dishonest people, and those least likely to admit error, are those who view their party as a cult. The no. 1 goal of such people is defending their cult and its leaders. If they have to sacrifice their own intellectual honesty and integrity to boost their cult leaders, they are happy to do it. They view their cult as being of primary importance.
Only to a political extremist.

From a Left Wing source:
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/wray-...cs-debating-the-nuts-and-bolts_b_1914307.html
The results were clear. As described in a forthcoming issue of the journalPsychological Science, those who simply listed reasons for their positions -- articulating their values -- were less shaken in their views. They continued to think they understood the policies in their complexity, and, notably, they remained extreme in their passion for their positions. In a final version of the study, volunteers who were forced to confront their inadequate knowledge actually gave less money to the cause, suggesting that with their extremism attenuated, they actually acted more moderately.
 
Only to a political extremist.

From a Left Wing source:
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/wray-...cs-debating-the-nuts-and-bolts_b_1914307.html
The results were clear. As described in a forthcoming issue of the journalPsychological Science, those who simply listed reasons for their positions -- articulating their values -- were less shaken in their views. They continued to think they understood the policies in their complexity, and, notably, they remained extreme in their passion for their positions. In a final version of the study, volunteers who were forced to confront their inadequate knowledge actually gave less money to the cause, suggesting that with their extremism attenuated, they actually acted more moderately.

FYI, that had nothing to do with your point (or my response to same).
 
Only to a political extremist.

From a Left Wing source:
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/wray-...cs-debating-the-nuts-and-bolts_b_1914307.html
The results were clear. As described in a forthcoming issue of the journalPsychological Science, those who simply listed reasons for their positions -- articulating their values -- were less shaken in their views. They continued to think they understood the policies in their complexity, and, notably, they remained extreme in their passion for their positions. In a final version of the study, volunteers who were forced to confront their inadequate knowledge actually gave less money to the cause, suggesting that with their extremism attenuated, they actually acted more moderately.
Only a pysch wannabe would put up the huffpuff as a source on profiling.
 
Only a pysch wannabe would put up the huffpuff as a source on profiling.
Clearly you are so pissed off at me, you are reduced to taking low-minded jabs and incapable of intellectual discourse.

It's clear to all the sane and rational people on the forum that using a RW source in response to a LWL will only result in denials of the source not the content. You should know, you are guilty of the same and, in fact, are essentially doing it now by commenting on the source, not the content.
 
FYI, that had nothing to do with your point (or my response to same).
Denial is an indicator of your problem. You do not say why it has nothing to do with my post for the simple reason that if you did, you'd easily be proved wrong.

As the article points out, when political extremists articulate their values, they became more moderate. You have failed to articulate both your values and why you think I'm wrong; evidence you are simply running from the obvious truth like your polar-opposite brother-in-extremism.
 
Denial is an indicator of your problem. You do not say why it has nothing to do with my post for the simple reason that if you did, you'd easily be proved wrong.

As the article points out, when political extremists articulate their values, they became more moderate. You have failed to articulate both your values and why you think I'm wrong; evidence you are simply running from the obvious truth like your polar-opposite brother-in-extremism.

Crikey. You seem to have forgotten what your point was.

It was a ridiculous, overbroad statement that "political extremists" (whatever they are) are most dishonest and never admit mistakes. That piece you linked does not support your premise.
 
Nah, you're just more interested in dissembling than having an honest debate.

You ignored what I said about diplomats, and make no point about Indians, while pretending that you have one. Your taste for dissembling makes you right at home in the GOP.

You are the one dissembling. It's obvious from the native American experience what the language in the 14th Amendment was intended to mean. If you are on American soil but your citizenship (loyalty) is to another government entity (jurisdiction), whether you are an Indian, a foreign emissary or just a visitor from another land with no intention to settle here and become a fully assimilated permanent resident in the USA, then any baby born to you while you are here is an exception to the birth right citizenship under the 14th Amendment. One glance at all the Mexican flags being flown at the si se pulde events shows the wisdom of putting that language in the 14th Amendment - which you are mis-interpreting in an effort to increase the number of anti-Americans (like yourself) seeking to overthrow the US government and implement a communist system.
 
Back
Top