New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

SNOPES

Yes there is ... the principle of supply and demand.

I want to take this opportunity to thank you from the bottom of my heart for your posts in this thread. I really can't think of anything any poster could say in support of my argument that would help make it stronger than does your (Marxist ideological) support for my opponent's viewpoint.
 
By the time the Depression brought Hitler to power in 1933 ... FDR was not even president yet. The Depression was 4 years old and deepening ... the recovery started with the New Deal.

Obama had one of the least interventionist responses to an economic downturn in recent decades ... very small spending increases, low deficits, no major expansion of government programs except for Obamacare. If anything, his conservatism (and the underlying seriousness of the crisis) helps explain why the recovery was slow.

Few objective economic analyses (you know, ones that use actual numbers) blame Roosevelt's policies for the depth of the Depression.

It's not the depth of a downturn that marks it as a "depression," it's the length. If Roosevelt's "New Deal" policy agenda "started the recovery," why is it that economic historians mark the end of the Great Depression as the "US entrance into WWII?" I find it extremely comforting that so many left wing arguments refute themselves...
 
I want to take this opportunity to thank you from the bottom of my heart for your posts in this thread. I really can't think of anything any poster could say in support of my argument that would help make it stronger than does your (Marxist ideological) support for my opponent's viewpoint.

That you think he and I share the same viewpoint is laughable.
 
It's not the depth of a downturn that marks it as a "depression," it's the length. If Roosevelt's "New Deal" policy agenda "started the recovery," why is it that economic historians mark the end of the Great Depression as the "US entrance into WWII?" I find it extremely comforting that so many left wing arguments refute themselves...

Um, because that's when the recovery which started in 1933 ended? The point is that (except for the 1937 austerity-driven crash) things got steadily better from 1933 on, even if there was a very deep hole to climb out of and eventually it took a war to get capitalism's heart beating steadily again.
 
Um, because that's when the recovery which started in 1933 ended? The point is that (except for the 1937 austerity-driven crash) things got steadily better from 1933 on, even if there was a very deep hole to climb out of and eventually it took a war to get capitalism's heart beating steadily again.

LOL! Then that's not a "recovery" at all, is it? Not getting worse is not the same as "getting better." And thanks for the (Marxist) endorsement of "military Keynesianism" as a "successful" (if anti-capitalist) economic policy. The idea that the economy was incapable of recovering (after, according to you eight years of, well, "recovery") without the assistance of a world war is about as morally and intellectually bankrupt a "viewpoint" as I can imagine. And, as far as I can tell, that ridiculous notion is at the heart of both of your "arguments" here.
 
That you think he and I share the same viewpoint is laughable.

That you think you two aren't in pretty much complete agreement on this thread is laughable. But thanks for giving me yet another opportunity to point out how simpatico democrats and communists are on these (pro-Keynesian) economic beliefs.
 
LOL! Then that's not a "recovery" at all, is it? Not getting worse is not the same as "getting better." And thanks for the (Marxist) endorsement of "military Keynesianism" as a "successful" (if anti-capitalist) economic policy. The idea that the economy was incapable of recovering (after, according to you eight years of, well, "recovery") without the assistance of a world war is about as morally and intellectually bankrupt a "viewpoint" as I can imagine. And, as far as I can tell, that ridiculous notion is at the heart of both of your "arguments" here.

There is nothing "anti-capitalist" about "military Keynesianism." In fact, it is the only capitalist alternative to socialism as the answer to the long-term crisis built into capitalism.
 
That you think you two aren't in pretty much complete agreement on this thread is laughable. But thanks for giving me yet another opportunity to point out how simpatico democrats and communists are on these (pro-Keynesian) economic beliefs.

You could claim the moon is made of green cheese...he and I would agree that you are wrong. You've conjured up a bizarre version of history that states FDR started WWII...then you dismiss the facts that show the war started in various places, involving first China, Ethiopia, Spain against German, Japan and Italy...long before FDR had made any kind of real policy changes in the US. You claim that FDR's policies prevented the European nations from becoming strong enough to stand up to Hitler...which is also idiotic, since France had a larger army than Germany and Britain certainly had the strongest navy in the world. You pretend that it didn't matter that Hitler solidified his gains on power in 1934 with the death of Von Hindenburg and his "Night of the Long Knives" purge of the Nazi party...What could FDR possibly have done to bring 25% unemployment down to 5% or 6% or to have gotten to a meaningful recovery in one or two years?

You keep pretending that all depressions are the same, but they aren't by a long shot. There were a number of recessions in the 1920s...and there causes were substantially different...and their recoveries were as well. The 1920 depression was caused by major manufacturers shutting down to retool from military production...and the recovery of European agriculture bringing major competition to the market...as well as the massive demobilization of the military.

None of those were factors in the 1929 depression. Reagan's recession was largely caused by the oil shocks brought on by Opec and their cut backs in production and resulting jumps in the price of oil as well as the Fed's attempts to reign in soaring interest rates....which were very different from the 2007/2009 recession caused by the surge in home building and the practices the mortgage industry indulged in which created value from nothing at all....( very much like the Tulip craze in Holland )....eventually home building halted, the astronomical debt associated with mortgage backed securities and the fraud that banks and lenders allowed to happen put a halt to most lending....the S&L crisis of Regan's administration was much the same, but on a smaller scale. It also brought on a recession.

You engage in your fantasy version of the economy solely because you hope to gain points for the right wing of the republican party.
 
That you think you two aren't in pretty much complete agreement on this thread is laughable. But thanks for giving me yet another opportunity to point out how simpatico democrats and communists are on these (pro-Keynesian) economic beliefs.

What does it mean that Queenie agrees with you that WWII was FDR's fault and not Hitler's?
 
There is nothing "anti-capitalist" about "military Keynesianism." In fact, it is the only capitalist alternative to socialism as the answer to the long-term crisis built into capitalism.

Then why is it that it was the heart and soul of the USSR's economic "success?"
 
You could claim the moon is made of green cheese...he and I would agree that you are wrong. You've conjured up a bizarre version of history that states FDR started WWII...then you dismiss the facts that show the war started in various places, involving first China, Ethiopia, Spain against German, Japan and Italy...long before FDR had made any kind of real policy changes in the US. You claim that FDR's policies prevented the European nations from becoming strong enough to stand up to Hitler...which is also idiotic, since France had a larger army than Germany and Britain certainly had the strongest navy in the world. You pretend that it didn't matter that Hitler solidified his gains on power in 1934 with the death of Von Hindenburg and his "Night of the Long Knives" purge of the Nazi party...What could FDR possibly have done to bring 25% unemployment down to 5% or 6% or to have gotten to a meaningful recovery in one or two years?

You keep pretending that all depressions are the same, but they aren't by a long shot. There were a number of recessions in the 1920s...and there causes were substantially different...and their recoveries were as well. The 1920 depression was caused by major manufacturers shutting down to retool from military production...and the recovery of European agriculture bringing major competition to the market...as well as the massive demobilization of the military.

None of those were factors in the 1929 depression. Reagan's recession was largely caused by the oil shocks brought on by Opec and their cut backs in production and resulting jumps in the price of oil as well as the Fed's attempts to reign in soaring interest rates....which were very different from the 2007/2009 recession caused by the surge in home building and the practices the mortgage industry indulged in which created value from nothing at all....( very much like the Tulip craze in Holland )....eventually home building halted, the astronomical debt associated with mortgage backed securities and the fraud that banks and lenders allowed to happen put a halt to most lending....the S&L crisis of Regan's administration was much the same, but on a smaller scale. It also brought on a recession.

You engage in your fantasy version of the economy solely because you hope to gain points for the right wing of the republican party.

The idea that the moon is "made of green cheese" isn't supported by logic, the way my argument here is. So that is what we refer to as a "straw man." I have linked repeatedly to historical accounts that recount how the depression contributed to the tensions that boiled over into war in the 1930s. And I also linked the study that illustrates how Roosevelt was responsible for extending the length of the Great Depression (an argument that is abundantly supported by the fact that the economy, which always recovers fully and quickly after downturns, failed to do so during the decade after he first won election). And then, the coup de grace is the credible accounts that FDR, at the end of the decade, as the reality that his economic policies were not ever going to engender an economic recovery sunk in :

http://dailysignal.com/2009/01/14/were-spending-more-than-ever-and-it-doesnt-work/

That he engineered the US entrance into the global contagion that ongoing economic malaise had produced:

http://www.independent.org/issues/article.asp?id=408

Effectively engineering the beginning if WWII.

So I'm in no way making a "moon is green cheese" argument here, but rather merely interpreting the historical facts in a way that is inconvenient for left wing FDR sycophants to digest, in that it indicts their demigod of big government anti-capitalism as a complete failure, albeit in opposition to the conventional narrative that he somehow "fixed" the depression and "saved the world."

FDR was a powerful man, but a complete loser of a President; one whose economic policies failed miserably (as the length of the Great Depression shows) and, rather than "saving" the world, actually played a large role in the events that precipitated WWII. It is simply because of the (misplaced) hero worship of people like you, who let their ideology determine who is worthy of honor, rather than results (see Barack Obama for reference), that our historical narrative paints FDR in such a glowing historical light.

Your entire argument here boils down to "na nanana na na, I can't hear you." Instead of lifting a finger to refute any of the points I have made, you prefer to hide behind this fake argument that my argument has no facts underpinning it so you can simply dismiss it out of hand. As I have repeatedly shown, there are facts that underpin every step of my process that lead to my position. That's called logic, not "green cheese." You should try some.

As for your position on recession/depression, they ARE all the same - dislocation in one or more (sub)markets in an economy, leading to idled productive capacity and workers (unemployment). It is not ever, as the Keynesians would have it, a "lack of demand" (demand is infinite) that causes them, so lets dispense with that up front. Then there is difference in the depth and length of the downturns that result from these (various) market dislocations. To some minor extent, that might have some effect from which of the tens of thousands (if not hundreds of thousands) of (sub)markets that make up an economy, are involved (housing being perhaps more difficult to clear than autos) in the initial downturn. And, of course, how many other markets are brought into dislocation as a result of the initial market(s) that dislocate to cause the initial downturn. But on the margin, the length and depth is a function of the policy response of government officials - put government in the way, the downturn endures; get it out of the way, and the economy begins to heal almost immediately:

https://mises.org/library/forgotten-depression-1920

The sooner you let the markets clear, the fewer other (sub)markets get dragged into the downturn, and the sooner the recovery can begin. Lefties like you seek to perpetuate the narrative that these matters are more complicated than they are for the simple purpose of supporting their big government (anti-market) bias. If all recessions/depressions are "different" well then "we better have a legion of lefty propeller heads in charge to diagnose and implement interventions that will 'fix' these pesky markets that can't figure this stuff out on their own, and allow them to overcome their own innate inability to understand what is in their own best interests." Sound familiar? It should - that's your idiotic Keynesianism in a nutshell. You probably can't even see the inherent anti-capitalism in that viewpoint. "Why I'm an entrepreneur, I own a restaurant, so that makes me automatically a capitalist" you might be thinking. But, unfortunately, you are wrong. It is a belief in markets that makes you a capitalist, not simply a willingness to engage in them while supporting efforts to place government in control of them. But, back to my point, the actual historical records show that the more interventionist the government (think FDR, Barack Obama) the longer the downturn. This isn't the result of these downturns being somehow "different," but rather how different the political response was. The more the government interferes to "fix" the economic problems, the less robust the recovery. You may not like the fact that history proves this correct, but it is in fact, a fact.

You engage in your fantasy version of the economy solely because you hope to gain points for the left wing of the democratic party.
 
Last edited:
It means she understands a good argument.

Sure thing...couldn't be due to the fact that she denies the holocaust happened, pretends that the Jews deserved to be rounded up and sent to camps and claims Hitler wasn't such a bad guy.

She's on your side....be proud of having her support.
 
Daily Caller is your credible source to debunk Snopes? Now that is funny. The Day Tucker Carlson can be trusted will be a historic event.

Remember the Daily Caller saying there had been no American Flags on stage for the first day of the DNC convention?

https://www.bing.com/videos/search?...2A62FD916C6155DE60DD2A62FD916C6155D&FORM=VIRE

What's funny...no make that hilarious, is after all Dino had in his post about this Kim Lacapria you strike back hard with nothing but a personal opinion about Tucker Carlson.

You must have been a real terror at recess.
 
The idea that the moon is "made of green cheese" isn't supported by logic, the way my argument here is. So that is what we refer to as a "straw man." I have linked repeatedly to historical accounts that recount how the depression contributed to the tensions that boiled over into war in the 1930s. And I also linked the study that illustrates how Roosevelt was responsible for extending the length of the Great Depression (an argument that is abundantly supported by the fact that the economy, which always recovers fully and quickly after downturns, failed to do so during the decade after he first won election). And then, the coup de grace is the credible accounts that FDR, at the end of the decade, as the reality that his economic policies were not ever going to engender an economic recovery sunk in :

http://dailysignal.com/2009/01/14/were-spending-more-than-ever-and-it-doesnt-work/

That he engineered the US entrance into the global contagion that ongoing economic malaise had produced:

http://www.independent.org/issues/article.asp?id=408

Effectively engineering the beginning if WWII.

So I'm in no way making a "moon is green cheese" argument here, but rather merely interpreting the historical facts in a way that is inconvenient for left wing FDR sycophants to digest, in that it indicts their demigod of big government anti-capitalism as a complete failure, albeit in opposition to the conventional narrative that he somehow "fixed" the depression and "saved the world."

FDR was a powerful man, but a complete loser of a President; one whose economic policies failed miserably (as the length of the Great Depression shows) and, rather than "saving" the world, actually played a large role in the events that precipitated WWII. It is simply because of the (misplaced) hero worship of people like you, who let their ideology determine who is worthy of honor, rather than results (see Barack Obama for reference), that our historical narrative paints FDR in such a glowing historical light.

Your entire argument here boils down to "na nanana na na, I can't hear you." Instead of lifting a finger to refute any of the points I have made, you prefer to hide behind this fake argument that my argument has no facts underpinning it so you can simply dismiss it out of hand. As I have repeatedly shown, there are facts that underpin every step of my process that lead to my position. That's called logic, not "green cheese." You should try some.

As for your position on recession/depression, they ARE all the same - dislocation in one or more (sub)markets in an economy, leading to idled productive capacity and workers (unemployment). It is not ever, as the Keynesians would have it, a "lack of demand" (demand is infinite) that causes them, so lets dispense with that up front. Then there is difference in the depth and length of the downturns that result from these (various) market dislocations. To some minor extent, that might have some effect from which of the tens of thousands (if not hundreds of thousands) of (sub)markets that make up an economy, are involved (housing being perhaps more difficult to clear than autos) in the initial downturn. And, of course, how many other markets are brought into dislocation as a result of the initial market(s) that dislocate to cause the initial downturn. But on the margin, the length and depth is a function of the policy response of government officials - put government in the way, the downturn endures; get it out of the way, and the economy begins to heal almost immediately:

https://mises.org/library/forgotten-depression-1920

The sooner you let the markets clear, the fewer other (sub)markets get dragged into the downturn, and the sooner the recovery can begin. Lefties like you seek to perpetuate the narrative that these matters are more complicated than they are for the simple purpose of supporting their big government (anti-market) bias. If all recessions/depressions are "different" well then "we better have a legion of lefty propeller heads in charge to diagnose and implement interventions that will 'fix' these pesky markets that can't figure this stuff out on their own, and allow them to overcome their own innate inability to understand what is in their own best interests." Sound familiar? It should - that's your idiotic Keynesianism in a nutshell. You probably can't even see the inherent anti-capitalism in that viewpoint. "Why I'm an entrepreneur, I own a restaurant, so that makes me automatically a capitalist" you might be thinking. But, unfortunately, you are wrong. It is a belief in markets that makes you a capitalist, not simply a willingness to engage in them while supporting efforts to place government in control of them. But, back to my point, the actual historical records show that the more interventionist the government (think FDR, Barack Obama) the longer the downturn. This isn't the result of these downturns being somehow "different," but rather how different the political response was. The more the government interferes to "fix" the economic problems, the less robust the recovery. You may not like the fact that history proves this correct, but it is in fact, a fact.

You engage in your fantasy version of the economy solely because you hope to gain points for the left wing of the democratic party.

The comment about green cheese was related to your linking someone else's opinions to mine. Funny that you blow off the fact that Queenie likes your anti-FDR rant. She just wants Hitler to be off the hook for starting WWII...just like you do.

So your attempting to claim WWII started on December 7th, 1941? It didn't. The US was the very last major power to join the war. You seem to be saying the US would have been better off letting Britain fall. That, all by itself, is one of the more amazing things you have posted. It is certain that would have happened if the US had stayed out.
All of Europe was at war by 1940 or had been conquered. Asia was likewise at war long before the US entered the war.

Your idea that all recessions/depressions are the same is idiotic at best. Saying that they are all related to "market dislocations" is the same as saying they were caused by something going wrong. DUH. The depression of 1920/1921 was caused by a halt in military spending, the sudden jump in unemployment when active duty soldiers came home and were mustered out and the surge in European production competing with US products. GDP dropped 7%. In 1929/1930 the GDP dropped 9% and in 1930/1931 another 6.5% and in 1931/1932 a whopping 13%. You praise Harding for his policies during the 1920 depression, but did you also approve of the Emergency Tarriff of 1921 and the Fordney-McCumber Tariff act? Did you know that Harding was sworn in on March 5th, 1921....and you claim his policies made the recovery happen quickly....His tax cuts didn't take effect until 1922 and Harding died in august 1923.

Did FDR get the US involved in WWII to help fix the economy? That is what you have not proven and is simply an unfounded and unsupported attempt to discount the contribution FDR made to improve the economy, prepare the country for the certain involvement in the war and keep the US from becoming a right wing fascist state like others had.

1. Did Hitler come to power due to anything FDR had done? No.
2. Did Hitler solidify his control of the country due to anything FDR did or didn't do? No.
3. Did FDR do anything to make the depression worse? Not if you were unemployed in 1933 and were then to find a job due to FDR's programs or the improving economy. Your opinion not withstanding, every industrial economy...Germany, Canada, the UK, the US..all began to see improvement starting in 1935. Japan suffered the least of the major nations in the depression. Is that because they were such great capitalists?
 
What's funny...no make that hilarious, is after all Dino had in his post about this Kim Lacapria you strike back hard with nothing but a personal opinion about Tucker Carlson.

You must have been a terror at recess.

Are you actually saying Tucker Carlson is a non-partisan source of info and Kim Lacapria can't be trusted? Now that is funny.

Dino had nothing at all that showed Lacapria had produced false data while at Snopes. He actually wrote nothing at all about anything she'd written while at Snopes.

Carlson's rationalization of slavery still stands as the most amazing bit of partisan bullshit I've ever read....
 
I want to take this opportunity to thank you from the bottom of my heart for your posts in this thread. I really can't think of anything any poster could say in support of my argument that would help make it stronger than does your (Marxist ideological) support for my opponent's viewpoint.

This would be your own straw man diversion from the facts....
 
It's not the depth of a downturn that marks it as a "depression," it's the length. If Roosevelt's "New Deal" policy agenda "started the recovery," why is it that economic historians mark the end of the Great Depression as the "US entrance into WWII?" I find it extremely comforting that so many left wing arguments refute themselves...

NBER says the great depression lasted from Aug 1929 to March of 1933.
 
It's not the depth of a downturn that marks it as a "depression," it's the length. If Roosevelt's "New Deal" policy agenda "started the recovery," why is it that economic historians mark the end of the Great Depression as the "US entrance into WWII?" I find it extremely comforting that so many left wing arguments refute themselves...

A recession is two consecutive quarters of GDP decline. A depression is a decline of more than 10%...
 
Sure thing...couldn't be due to the fact that she denies the holocaust happened, pretends that the Jews deserved to be rounded up and sent to camps and claims Hitler wasn't such a bad guy.

She's on your side....be proud of having her support.

None of that is part of my argument here. My argument is anti-government pro-capitalism. The fact that she shares those economic policy views is inconsequential to the argument in which we are currently engaged. ETR may well be kind to animals, but that has no bearing on the argument at hand (either). I like ETR. He is at least unabashed about his disdain for capitalism. You, on the other hand, couch yours in terms of "I love capitalism, but…" What comes after the but is always a betrayal of your "middle view."
 
Back
Top